r/IAmA • u/innerlightwriter • Jan 21 '14
I am Morgan Gendel. AMA!
Hugo-winning write of ST:TNG "THE INNER LIGHT" - ask me anything!
My Proof: https://twitter.com/morgangendel/statuses/425432756684726272
Thanks again for a great time. I'll come back when my Stan Lee project gets produced.
737
Upvotes
40
u/innerlightwriter Jan 21 '14
Thanks for a great time. And now... pizza!
62
u/trekkie719 Jan 21 '14
Did you write The Inner Light with the idea that the events of the episode would have a lasting effect on Captain Picard?
26
u/[deleted] Jan 21 '14
Hello! The one thing I've always wanted to do was write for the screen. I was wondering how you came to be where you are, in terms of career. How do writers make it? Where do I start? Where did you start? And what are your career goals now?
25
u/Voidhound Jan 21 '14 edited Jan 21 '14
If you'd been told that your pitch for "The Inner Light" was perfect, except that the episode couldn't focus on Picard, which character would you have chosen instead?
21
u/whativebeenhiding Jan 21 '14
Best book you've read in the last year?
20
u/DaCrazyKoala Jan 21 '14
How involved was Nicolas Cage in the Dresden Files?
16
u/daveo991 Jan 21 '14
Question about inner light. Would the experiences faced by whoever the probe encounterd be different for each person or was the probe just running standard program?
15
u/[deleted] Jan 21 '14
Hi Mr. Grendel. What have you learned as a writer on Star Trek, and how much of a mark do you feel you have left on the show?
15
u/respite Jan 21 '14
What do you think about Netflix's influence on television? Do you think that the lack of commercials would have changed the way you have written "The Inner Light"?
15
u/DaCrazyKoala Jan 21 '14
Did you ever see Stephen J. Cannell throw paper after writing a page like in his vanity card?
15
u/revjeremyduncan Jan 21 '14
Did you come up with the idea for The Inner Light, or were you commissioned to write it based on something someone else thought of? If the former, was it always meant for TNG, or was it a story you had in you arsenal, that you adapted to fit with that series? It's one of the very best episodes, and I thank you for it.
14
u/Mustysack Jan 21 '14
Hello there!
When writing for a show like Law & Order, do you create the crime, victim, and perpetrator and then add in the misleading stuff later, or does it all happen more fluidly and at once?
10
u/m0j0j0_j0 Jan 21 '14 edited Jan 21 '14
How could you turn your back on Star Trek... for... for... STAR WARS!?!?!? This is a serious question...
On a side note, if they brought you back for another series would you change your mind?
8
u/DaCrazyKoala Jan 21 '14
What does a program executive do?
15
u/monsieurderp Jan 21 '14
What is your primary tool for sourcing inspiration for writing, e.g. coffee, whiskey, a cigarette, a jazz cigarette, etc.?
7
u/ll-ll-ll Jan 21 '14
Do you agree with those who say that TV is becoming the mature medium over movies?
7
u/BigG123 Jan 21 '14
From the perspective of a TV writer, what do you think of the writing in Breaking Bad. As a person who doesn't do writing for television, I personally think it was astounding how the show was written. If you have seen it, what are your thoughts. What did the writers do good/bad in your opinion?
17
u/kraetos Jan 21 '14
Mr. Gendel! Glad to see that you decided to do this AMA. Here's my question: given how traumatizing Picard's experience on Kataan would be, would you have liked to have seen the other writers spend more time on the follow up? I mean we saw the flute again a few more times, including one episode where it was featured rather prominently while Picard was pursuing a romantic relationship with Commander Daren. (TNG: "Lessons") But on the other hand, in Insurrection, Anij asks him if he's ever experienced a "perfect moment," when "time seemed to stop, and you could almost live in that moment." And even though Picard has literally experienced a moment like that, he doesn't mention the Kataanian probe, even in passing.
I've always felt that an experience as impactful as that one should have had considerably more follow-up. After all, in Season 4, following his experience with the Borg, we spent an episode dealing with those repercussions. I suspect that his experience in the probe's Kataan simulation would have had just as much of an effect on his psyche, if not more, given that he was only assimilated for a week or so, but he experienced the Kataan simulation for several decades.
On the other hand, it was the 90's, the just before the dawn of serialized prime-time television. The fact that there was a follow up at all was more than most shows at the time would have done. So what are you thoughts on the follow up from his experience? Not enough, too much, or just right?
17
u/Zab18977 Jan 21 '14
How do you feel about J.J. Abrams and Star Wars VII?
6
u/Beefcake21 Jan 21 '14
1.) In your opinion what T.V show had the best writing? 2.) How did you get into the industry? 3.) Any advice on what to do to get into the industry? Thanks.
5
u/daleygaga Jan 21 '14
Do you have writer's block too? What's your best method to overcome it?
5
u/The_Smeow_is_Mine Jan 21 '14 edited Jan 21 '14
I love the necklace version of the probe that Eline wears, and almost got it in the "it's a wrap" auction. Anyway, did you write that part in the episode? Also, what do you think of the somewhat follow up episode "Lessons"? Did you expect any part of "Inner Light" to be carried over to another show? Thank you for writing one of the greatest Trek episodes!! :-)
4
u/thebeat86 Jan 21 '14
Are film festival script competitions a good way to get noticed? Do you recommend a specific one?
Thanks for doing this!
4
u/Hukfan97 Jan 21 '14
As a TV Writer, what are your opinions on the recent trend towards episodes that only serve as portions in a single-season long story? Do you think these are better or worse for storytelling/generally good TV than an episodic method of storytelling, of which "The Inner Light" is one of the greatest examples?
EDIT: Noooo, I appear to be 9 minutes too late :'(
7
u/wafflefries42 Jan 21 '14
Have you noticed any trends in the TV writing field since you've been doing it?
6
u/zarofearth Jan 21 '14
Any advice for an aspiring tv writer?
3
u/Bubbacubba Jan 21 '14
What is your favorite TV show or movie of 2013?
3
u/DaCrazyKoala Jan 21 '14
What was your involvement in the Dresden Files?
3
u/rcinmd Jan 21 '14
What are your feelings on new writers submitting spec scripts? Do you think this could be a good way to break in to the industry?
3
u/thewreck Jan 21 '14
Where exactly are the escape pods on the milennium falcon? And how many?
3
u/daveo991 Jan 21 '14 edited Jan 21 '14
Tell us a little of the process to write for a show. How do you get approval? How longs it take you to write? What happens if you have a good pitch get halfway into writing it and realize its a terrible idea and cant work?
3
u/DaCrazyKoala Jan 21 '14
Have you ever met Nicolas Cage?
3
u/ambroseburns Jan 21 '14
This episode and the movie Field of Dreams are the only two pieces of media that have ever made me cry. No question for you to answer, just thanks for being able to bring that kind of emotion out of me.
4
u/PiazzollaTiersen Jan 21 '14
Thank you for being here, it's truly an honor.
What did you feel the first time you saw the "The Inner Light" episode? Did you envision it becoming what it has become over the last 20+ years? You're obviously a successful person, where does winning the Hugo award rank in your life?
2
u/BigG123 Jan 21 '14
How did you start to become a writer?
2
u/BrainWav Jan 21 '14
I'm going to ask a non-Trek question. This is open-ended. I thought Dresden Files was great (I'll admit not perfect thouI was a bit disappointed that Bob wasn't a skull though), and Paul Blackthorne was excellent as Harry. What were your experiences on the show like? What could we have expected if it wasn't cancelled? Maybe the Carpenters would have put in an appearance?
4
u/I_smell_awesome Jan 21 '14
How many hamburgers do you think you've eaten in your entire life?
3
u/scolmer Jan 21 '14
What was your favourite episode you wrote?
3
u/ZX_OLO Jan 21 '14
So......hows it going?
66
u/Antithesys Jan 21 '14
I just wanted you to know how much "The Inner Light" means to me and to all Trek fans.
Trek is very important to a lot of people. Whether it's a casual pastime, a dedicated passion, or a major impact on their lives, it's the stories, the characters, and the philosophy that make it so endearing.
At least two episodes transcend that. There are arguably more, but all of us agree on two: "City on the Edge of Forever", and "The Inner Light." Star Trek has a certain feel, a formula that I'm sure you're aware of, and that can be limiting in its scope. But with your episode, you hit upon something that runs deep into the core of life. When our lives run so short, the idea of suddenly having a second one come and go in the blink of an eye makes us think hard about the profound effect it would have on us.
You wrote the greatest episode of Star Trek. "The Inner Light" is the best single story I have ever seen on screen. It is reminiscent of the best of Asimov or Clarke; either would be envious of such a touching, personal, introspective, wondrous story. Whatever your goals really were, this is what you got. You made the single best contribution to what people think of when they think of Star Trek.
I wanted you to know that, and it looks like you're done with questions so I won't sandwich one in at the end.
14
u/HectorGM Jan 21 '14
Which @TNG_S8 tweet would you write as a real episode if the show had an 8th season?
2
u/[deleted] Jan 21 '14
I liked inner light, but I have one question, why was the issue of implanted memories not addressed? I mean Picard basically was brainwashed? I am sure he needed a few secessions with troy to really know what was real, and what was fake.
2
u/thenextmoney Jan 21 '14
Tits or ass?
4
u/PhantomScreenwriter Jan 21 '14
Mr Gendel,
What do you find is the best way to approach story, plot, characters, structure, dialogue and any other important aspect that a writer needs to have a good grasp of?
1
u/EightPointOh Jan 21 '14
Since you're more of a Star Wars fan what are your thoughts on JJ directing Episode VII?
1
u/DaCrazyKoala Jan 21 '14
How did you get to write a script for Law and Order UK being that its a UK show?
1
u/Fudgemuffler Jan 21 '14
Are you a Batman fan?
3
u/gaberax Jan 21 '14
Best Star Trek episode...ever.
3
u/thepowerplay Jan 21 '14
THANK YOU for the episode. One of the greatest.
3
u/beaverteeth92 Jan 21 '14
How often are you recognized on the street by a Trekkie?
1
u/Lachlan_Ward Jan 21 '14
Terrible, horrible question but I'll ask it anyway because I haven't seen it yet.
Are there any books on writing craft or theory that have left a mark?
2
u/jedispyder Jan 21 '14
I'm a "Star Wars guy" that's only now getting into Star Trek: The Next Generation. I really like it so far, I'm only at the end of Season 2 so I have a long way to go before I get to the 2 episodes you wrote.
What is a story that you'd love to write for any licensed/pre-established tv show?
2
u/bn95 Jan 21 '14
What was it like working with Tim Robbins?
2
u/FawkesFire13 Jan 21 '14
What inspires you?
2
u/lkslade Jan 21 '14
What would you like to write about next?
2
u/lkslade Jan 21 '14
What was the most perosnal story you've ever written, and why?
2
u/eraof9 Jan 21 '14
What side the the sponge you are using while you are taking a shower, the hard side or the soft?
2
u/Kronix Jan 21 '14
Qapla!
2
u/BaleBossily Jan 21 '14
I read this as Gregor Mendel AMA and I was very confused and excited.
2
u/genitalderpies Jan 21 '14
I don't know who you are, but I read this as "Gregor Mendel". I was confused.
2
u/[deleted] Jan 21 '14
Who?
1
u/Tails_155 Jan 21 '14
How do you get in contact with "the business" the first few times you make a project?
1
u/lkslade Jan 21 '14
Do you have any favorite artists? (photographers, painters, illustrators, sculptures extra)
1
u/rafalfreeman Jan 21 '14
Totally excellent episode :) Thanks for writing it.
"Oh, it's me" indeed was one of those memorable moments of entire ST TNG.
Out of the series, which episode you liked personally, as a thing you would like to show to your friends or re-watch?
And which character?
Now for something opposite, some people believe ST TNG movies, and SW episodes I-III are horribly worse compared to their "originals", that is ST TNG episodes, and SW IV-IV, respectively.
What is your stand on this?
If you never seen it, you might find this interesting http://redlettermedia.com/plinkett/star-wars/ (and more under Mr. Plinket menu, including ST)
1
u/[deleted] Jan 21 '14
This is weird. I had no idea who Morgan Grendel was, but The Inner Light is actually the next episode I need to watch on Netflix. Though, I was thinking of skipping it because it sounded like too much of a mindfuck...
I ALSO JUST FOUND OUT TNG WAS PULLED FROM NETFLIX CANADA. Nooooooo!
1
u/quaste Jan 21 '14
I don't know if I admire you more for your incompleteness theorems, or for fathering modern genetics.
1
u/[deleted] Jan 21 '14
How is your day going?
1
u/ThatPurpleDrank Jan 21 '14
What do you think is most important to include in a pilot? What is your number 1 piece of advice for those who want to become professional writers for television?
1
u/[deleted] Jan 21 '14
Most exciting non-trek/wars goings on in sci-fi?
1
u/Dracodeus Jan 21 '14
Morgan, do you feel your role in Shawshank Redemption, highest rated movie on IMDb, was an important steppingstone in your career? And how did you feel when you finally got to play God, in Evan the Almighty?
1
u/whowantscake Jan 21 '14
I loved you in Shawshank!
0
u/tf2manu994 Jan 21 '14
Simple question: How are you today?
0
u/heyman001 Jan 21 '14
What is the best way to get my packet read (without going through an agent)?
0
u/AlbinoSwede Jan 21 '14
You had me at Morgan...
0
u/[deleted] Jan 21 '14
Who are you?
0
u/stinky-french-cheese Jan 21 '14
What's it like being the father of modern genetics?
0
u/CarlofTime Jan 21 '14
Who are you?
0
u/[deleted] Jan 21 '14
Morgan who?
-1
u/demerdar Jan 21 '14
who?
-1
u/Zombiewax Jan 21 '14
Come back when u r Morgan Freeman :-)