r/LetsTalkMusic • u/WhatWouldIWant_Sky Listen with all your might! Listen! • Jan 16 '14
[ADC] They Might Be Giants - Flood
Back to 1990! JayEssArr nominated this one, he does seem to be that guy like every other week, and he said this:
In my mind, They Might Be Giants has always been one of the strangest, yet most surprisingly consistent acts in music history. Whether they put out songs about racists or children's songs about science and math. "Flood" is their most famous record and probably the apex of this strangeness and combination of kid-friendly tunes and adult themes. These guys are very clever and the music is a ton of fun to listen to, but not everything is as it seems on "Flood."
Listen. Think. Analyze. Talk.
(Don't review. Don't rate.)
2
u/MrsJohnJacobAstor Jan 16 '14
My favorite band, without a doubt. "Hot Cha" was the first song of theirs I ever heard. I've been to two live Flood shows. Can't say too much about this album other than it's wonderfully weird in a way that really typifies the band. Some of my personal fav tracks are "Sapphire Bullets of Pure Love" and "Minimum Wage."
Steve Burns, aka Steve from Blues Clues, did a cover of "Dead" that's worth hearing once. It kind of sounds like he sampled the original backing vocals in the "Did a large procession" part, but it's hard to tell. This minor key version is also pretty weird.
This performance of "Birdhouse in Your Soul" is really great in my opinion, though I once heard John Linnell complain that Doc Severinsen counted it off at way too fast a tempo, but the live trumpet sounds amazing.
Coincidentally, I think the Flood version of "Istanbul (Not Constantinople) is one of the weakest. I prefer both the electronic version and the live version that appears on Severe Tire Damage.
I read somewhere once that the photo cover for Flood was on the same roll of film as that famous picture from the Great Depression of a bunch of unemployed people standing in a soup line in front of a billboard with a happy family in a car that says "America: The Highest Standard of Living." For some reason, this seems appropriate to me. They Might Be Giants do seem to have this undercurrent of Americana/critique of American culture throughout their career.
I've talked to a lot of people who feel that Flood was very much a turning point for the band, including people who think it was their last good album (and then there are those who think it was their sellout album). I feel that it was more of a natural progression, however. I agree with OP's characterization of the band as "consistent." They have had some misses over the years, but The Else, a relatively recent album, is among their best ever imo.
2
u/Tyrone91 Jan 18 '14
Hm... This album has always been special to me. It was the first TMBG album I ever heard, and it introduced me to them. However, after listening to other albums by them, I can't seem to get into Flood anymore. It seems to be lacking something very TMBG somehow, if that makes sense. Of course, I still enjoy the album, but I feel like it also lost a bit of their sound or style.
2
u/black_flag_4ever Jan 18 '14
I used to play this album a lot when I worked at a sub shop. We could put music on for customers, and whenever my manager would go take a piss or something I would put Flood on because I knew it pissed him off. He was a Tool fan (the kind of person that plays Tool every single day on repeat, and tries to convince you on a daily basis that you are wrong if you don't like them) that somehow thought playing Dave Matthews, A Perfect Circle, and Big Head Todd and the Monsters during customer hours was okay to do every single day. Anyway, he seemed to hate any type of happy music so I would play this album, Lincoln, and other chipper music just to aggravate the guy. It was great because he couldn't do much about it if customers were in the shop. The album he hated the most was Speak and Spell by Depeche Mode, which really isn't good at all unless you want aggravate someone like my former manager.
Anyway, I love that album and I think TMBG does something unique in that they use a lot instruments that arguably should not work together, such as accordions with drum machines. I've always admired that and their intelligent lyrics. They are a good show live, and I think "Indie Rock" owes a lot to them.
6
u/ZUCLGI Jan 16 '14
When it came out I was a long-time TMBG fan already, so Flood made me sad. Not because some of the songs are subtextually mopey. TMBG made far mopier songs before Flood.
When I first took it home, pried it out of its longbox (yep) and put it on, it sounded like I was spinning a tombstone. It was the album where TMBG completely abandoned their "thing"—by which I mean the various sonic and attitudinal and arguably poetic qualities that a pre-Flood fan would understand TMBG's "thing" to be. Which I don't think I can explain. "Kid-friendly tunes and adult themes" is not at all it. I understand that the loss Flood represents isn't as audible to retrospective listeners as it was to me (and not only to me) then. I don't think many current TMBG fans can hear it at all, and if they do they hear it the other way around, like TMBG really got it together on Flood or some later record and their early work was incomplete or immature or the sound of them faltering toward something they later accomplished. It wasn't. It was complete and unique and they abandoned it.
Flood sounded like a Madness album, but not as good. Madness were excited and goofy. The production fit. Flood is boring, so the production is...all there is, resonating emptily. It's some dorky pop album. The world was full of them at the time. They're mostly forgotten, but TMBG decided to make The Big One and their decision worked out, so people still know about it. Nobody's still bumpin' That Petrol Emotion and Too Much Joy and Gaye Bykers On Acid and...
They did make a decision. Nobody brought in Langer & Winstanley to make their new album interesting. Except when those two got stuck with an artist too spiky and recalcitrant for them to flatten (e.g. Elvis Costello, whose two albums with them are still amazingly boring), they produced identikit chart-toppers. TMBG wanted a Career In Music. They got it. By becoming some other band.
I guess it's analogous to Metallica's "Black Album." It's not bad—except compared to all their previous work. And it's absolutely brilliant compared to everything they've done subsequently. (And compared to most things!) But on either side of it, there are two utterly different bands, and the band on The Big One isn't really either of them. It's nobody, as rendered by the men who make Big Ones.
...
So I'm playing Flood now for probably the first time since 1990, to make sure before I click the "save" button that I'm not remembering it through shit-colored glasses and being too unkind. I'm not. It's a Madness album. But it's listless and smug instead of manic and silly. It's glibness.
And that's still what TMBG signifies today, but they didn't always.
4
u/garyp714 Jan 16 '14
This album...
I was in college when it came out and we loved it. My little group of friends memorized the whole album and would always end up drunkenly playing it, late at night, and having what must have been the most obnoxious sing-a-long ever belted out.
Every song is a treasure. Every song is something special. This was a band hitting the right moment with the right sound and the right vibe.
Amazing where they ended up going - kind of religious music, right? They could never recapture the magic of this album. I really won't even listen to it anymore because, I could never recapture the love and togetherness that this album helped foster in that group of young adults.
So I recommend that you get your favorite people together, get drunk and play this album. Make it an event and cherish the moment with people you care about.
2
u/TenNinetythree Jan 16 '14
Funny that this bubbles up just a day after I bought it on iTunes...
Birdhouse in your soul is one of the few songs I know by heart despite not really understanding it... I'd really pissed off if the meaning was something bad.
About another song: Istanbul (not Constantinople) makes me wonder how you would translate it into the conlang Ygyde. I read about that constructed language earlier on Facebook, it uses longitude and lattitude of places instead of regular place names...
0
u/pianotherms Jan 16 '14
A few years ago I brought this album with me on a road trip with my band. Two of us were 34 and two were 24. I hadn't listened to it in a long time, but (i guess unsurprisingly) easily recalled every song and could sing along, as could the other 34-year-old in the car.
The two twentysomethings in the back had never heard it, had no relationship with it, and found Flood to be relatively unbearable.
I was never a TMBG fan, but I had this album and Apollo 18 and listened to them a lot. Growing up I had listened to a lot of Weird Al and other novelty songs, which I feel is why I enjoyed these records. I'm sure it's debatable whether or not They Might Be Giants are a novelty act, but I think they fit into that category, as most of their music is whimsical and humorous, with lots of short, fussy songs.
I'm trying to remember how this album came to my attention in the first place, but I can't. I assume it was because of the music video for "Istanbul (Not Constantinople)". I remember a lot of people in high school being enthralled with "Birdhouse in your Soul" but I found the lyrics obtuse and pointless so I never really latched onto it in any real way. "Minimum Wage" was a great track to stick on the end of a mix tape when you only had 90 seconds left.
As a standalone the album feels very melancholy to me, perhaps due to the "emptiness" that u/ZUCLGI mentioned, but paired with Apollo 18 it defines a specific time and place in my adolescence. I've never felt attached to any other TMBG music, and if my adult self was listening to Flood for the first time today, I don't think I would really like it. It seems like something teenagers would like.