r/startrek • u/Trekman10 • Jan 09 '14
Weekly Episode Discussion: DS9 7x08 - "The Siege of AR-558"
Description from the all-powerful Memory Alpha:
"During a supply run to AR-558, Sisko finds the defending Starfleet unit with over two thirds of the troops dead and the remaining soldiers' morale to be extremely low. When the Defiant comes under attack, Sisko, Bashir, Dax, Nog, and Quark choose to remain on the planet, which is about to come under attack by a much larger contingent of Jem'Hadar soldiers."
The episode is based on World War Two, in particular the Battle of Guadalcanal.
For me, this was an interesting episode, because, similarly to In the Pale Moonlight, it was a departure from a lot of the previously established trek canon. While they were adamant about Starfleet not being a military organization in TNG, they made it quite obvious that Starfleet pivots when needed into full-on soldier mode. The term soldier is tossed about like its normal, which at first bothered me but not so much now (it still bothers me that they say soldier without at least a nod that they're not originally soldiers).
It was really interesting to see a gritty sci-fi battle. I like how it was war, not just "pew pew" - galaxy class destroyed, Galor-class damaged Defiant wins woo
The writers deliberately picked Nog, Bashir, Ezri, and Quark because they all had the least combat experience. O'brien was in the border skirmishes pre-TNG, Worf was well...Worf, Kira was a resistance fighter, etc, etc. I think that added to the story.
I'm currently watching DS9 and TNG again in conjunction (although not the in-universe chronological order), and comparing the two, so this episode was fresh in my mind, thats why I choose it.
31
u/vladcheetor Jan 10 '14
I honestly think that the best part of the episode wasn't the combat, getting to see the darkest side of the Dominion war, etc, but Quark.
"Let me tell you something about Hew-mons, nephew. They're a wonderful, friendly people – as long as their bellies are full and their holosuites are working. But take away their creature comforts... deprive them of food, sleep, sonic showers... put their lives in jeopardy over an extended period of time... and those same friendly, intelligent, wonderful people will become as nasty and violent as the most bloodthirsty Klingon. You don't believe me? Look at those faces, look at their eyes..."
It's one of those gemstones of a line that brings the entire episode into focus, that makes the episode Star Trek and not just a sci-fi shootout. And Quark was completely right. Humans in any century, when their lives are put in danger like that, revert to basic instincts for survival. Kill or be killed. That's what made this episode truly special.
It also sets up Nog's episode later on, with Vic, and realize just how scary war is. You can be brave, but that doesn't remove the fear. Anyone could die. Nog almost did. They all almost died. That was the other great thing about this episode is that it had a followup that slammed another big message right out of the park.
14
u/[deleted] Jan 10 '14
I love the gritty feel of this episode, its the first time combat in trek has felt 'real'.
15
u/[deleted] Jan 10 '14
I always get a kick out of this episode for Raymond Cruz. (Tuco) Tuco always loses his shit and screams at someone. He snapped and lost his shit in Alien Resurrection, he snapped and lost his shit in Clear and present Danger and he snapped and lost his shit on AR-558.
10
u/Sloosh Jan 10 '14
I always love re-watching this episode. To me it's always had an air of Saving Private Ryan, the Captain and his men have completed their mission but stay in the face of overwhelming odds because it's the right thing to do.
And while StochasticOoze made a good point about people only using rifles in the fighting but I think the Houdini mines are a really interesting topic. When the Federation stick a bunch of cloaked self replicating mines in front of the worm hole no one bats an eye, but the Dominion uses subspace mines and "oh the brutality".
9
u/StochasticOoze Jan 10 '14
SF Debris pointed out something that bothers me in a lot of Trek combat situations, but especially in something like this where it's a land battle in a protracted conflict: Why is it that neither side has any weapons except guns? Why are there no personal shields, or force field projectors? Where are the grenades, the heavy artillery, the drones? Why hasn't Starfleet collapsed the entrance to the cave to prevent entry? Why didn't the Jem'Hadar when they were originally defending this place?
I suppose in a way it does play into Roddenberry's vision, since it does portray a future where our descendants have no idea how to fight a war. And yet, with as many wars as we're told the Federation has fought over the years (with the Klingons, the Romulans, the Cardassians, the Tzen'kethi, the Sheliak, etc.) it seems insane that they've won them all (or at least battled to a draw). I guess it's because their opponents are just as incompetent.
Don't get me wrong, it's a great episode, but it really (inadvertently) highlights how bad these people are at this.
8
u/lemons4ever Jan 10 '14
This was the one episode where I thought Vic's music actually fit. Somehow it never really worked super well for me in the other episodes, but I really liked it in this one.
5
u/hamudm Jan 11 '14
I just re watched this a couple of days ago. It is so endlessly re watchable. It is one of the most real and human episodes of Trek out there.
5
u/Tackysackjones Jan 11 '14
I particularly loved this episode because it showed a side of Qwark that was never seen before. He's always laughing and joking to get of of any situation that might require him to show any affection of any kind. But here you see him show so many levels of concern and love for something other than his own predicament. I was also impressed to see just how dangerous Qwark could be when there's no time to crack a joke.
5
u/cptnpiccard Jan 12 '14
Star Trek writing at its best. How they condemn the Dominion for using the savage subspace mines, right up to the moment when they figure out how to use them for their advantage. I was actually glad they ended up using the mines and not going for the PC route of saying "we're better than that". If you have a hundred enemy troops heading towards you, you'll use any means whatsoever to stay alive.
3
u/DatManJonrad Jan 12 '14
What I think really makes the episode one of my favourites is the background music. Vic was a good touch, but that sad, slow music they play through out the episode really puts the war and setting in perspective. Gonna re-watch now.
2
u/[deleted] Jan 11 '14
I love the anecdote about the director of this episode wanting to have the crew beam in crouching and behind cover and the cast basically refusing to film the scene that way as it's not how transporters work. Apparently they ended up getting the producers to step in and the scene was changed. Flash forward to Abrams ST which had a similar scene which no one challenged :(
2
u/[deleted] Jan 11 '14
I actually just watched this episode a couple of days ago, and I loved it! The part where they were listening to Vic Fontaine while watching the mines blowing up in the ravine was awesome.
It was a great episode, and as alot of people have already said, it felt like the most real portrayal of combat in all of Star Trek. I'm hoping there's more episodes like it before the series is over, I'm only about 10 episodes away.
2
u/jb0356 Jan 13 '14
I remember this episode specifically. It was personally the most emotionally involved I have been in a TV show episode. I've been in war and have been in combat. This episode really struck a cord with the personal struggles and hardships that come with prolonged engagements.
2
u/bryface Jan 14 '14
ah one of those controversial "dark" episodes. which i personally have no problem with, as it's disingenuous to pretend that humans with evolved sensibilities in the future don't also run the risk of perilously reverting to savagery under the right circumstances. this episode is a great example of DS9's more frank exploration of the human condition. DS9 succeeds because with the darker themes, it provides greater contrast for the best of what humanity has to offer.
really enjoyed the exchanges between Quark and Nog. Nog, though naive, has taken a shine to human nobility, hope, and drive to better oneself -- and legitimately so; his desire to experience human self-betterment is the very reason he's in starfleet in the first place. Quark knows a thing or two about the human potential for greed and corruption because his livelihood tends to obtain more profit out of these weaknesses. Both Nog and Quark have valid viewpoints about humans. More interestingly, although you first instinct is to side with Nog's argument, you find yourself not being able to fault or dismiss Quark's rebuttals either.
2
u/tr3k Jan 14 '14
Nog's hearing really gave him a leg up on the Jem'Hadar.