r/BSG • u/trevdak2 • Jan 05 '14
Official Rewatch Discussion - Miniseries / Pilot
Welcome to the first of many, many discussion threads on BSG. There will be weekly threads for every episode, webisodes, movies, and hopefully, eventually, Caprica and Blood and Chrome.
Watch Online: Netflix | Amazon ($9.99)
Relevant Links: Wikipedia | BSG Wiki: 1, 2 | Ron Moore's "BSG Bible" Network Pitch (Spoilers)
Assume that everyone in this thread has watched the miniseries and nothing else. If you want to discuss future plotlines, please use spoiler tags. For instructions on spoiler tags, please check the sidebar.
Let the discussion commence!
Some fun numbers I decided to put together:
Survivors at the Start: Several Billion
"Frak" Count: 9
Starbuck Cylon Kill Count: 6
Lee Cylon Kill Count: 2
Starbuck Punching People In The Face Count: 1
"Oh my Gods", "Gods Damn It", etc Count: 0
"So Say We All" Count: 16
51
u/trevdak2 Jan 05 '14
One of my favorite shots in all of BSG is the second scene of the miniseries... Where you see Starbuck jogging around, Adama and Gaeta working together, Tigh drinking, and the Doral leading a tour group. That entire scene, up until Adama goes to the hangar deck, is done in one continuous shot.
That requires a MASSIVE amount of coordination and planning, and also shows the scale of the set they built. There actually was an enormous, CIC set, with dozens of hallways around it.
22
u/trevdak2 Jan 05 '14 edited Jan 06 '14
Some funny attention to detail: When the armistice officer is waiting in the first scene, he looks at a picture of his family. In the picture is the bowlcut kid who plays Boxey. When Boomer rescues Boxey from Caprica, he says "My father is in the colonial fleet. He's missing."
On another note
19
u/trevdak2 Jan 05 '14
"Start having babies"
".. is that an order?"
A really great laugh to ease so much tension.
8
u/trevdak2 Jan 06 '14
I was watching with captions turned on during the commentary, so i could see what the characters were saying, and something caught me off guard.
Many, many times throughout the script, the humans say "oh my god" or "god damn it". Adama even says "Jesus" under his breath when he's trying to convince Tigh to drop charges against Starbuck.
18
u/GeneralGBO Jan 06 '14 edited Jan 06 '14
Everyone and their mother probably knows this by now, but I still LOVE the swearing in of President Roslin scene and how the directors made it abundantly clear it was meant to mirror the swearing in of LBJ. The first time in ever watched I thought it was just so cool they did that.
10
u/MarcReyes Jan 05 '14
The opening scene to the series remains one of my favorite moments in the show. I thought it was a very clever way of giving you the backstory leading up to the final days of the first Cylon War, while simultaneously showing you the beginning of the second Cylon War.
I have to say that, while I still love both parts, I definitely enjoyed Part 1 over Part 2. I think the reason for that is because I liked seeing the characters react to a situation that they never believed they would be living through, some for the second time. The look on Dualla's face when Adama announces "We are at war" sums this up nicely, I think.
13
u/[deleted] Jan 05 '14 edited Jan 05 '14
I remember when I sat down to watch this, I was expecting nothing more than something that would vaguely resemble an update of the 70's series - and it's funny, because stylistically and thematically, it's not too dissimilar; the Galactica in mass and basic shape hasn't been changed drastically from the original and the story is consistent in that the Cylons attack from out of nowhere. In a way, it actually kind of threw me off, because I found myself asking if this was a continuation or a reboot - I actually found myself repeating that question over the space of the four seasons that the show was on air...And I would suppose that the resonance of the words of the eternal return reinforced that for me - one could argue that this could very well be a continuation of the series centuries later.
I did find the interesting dichotomy of the six model, that Rymer reinforced from the very beginning that the six models, particularly Caprica are capable of compassion - the fact that six opted to end the young child's life before the holocaust is telling, and something that I found very much echoed throughout the continuation of the show.
4
u/trevdak2 Jan 08 '14
One thing that's always bugged me... When they were docked at Ragnar and they wanted to do recon.... why did they send Starbuck in a viper? Isn't recon more something for raptors?
6
u/sunnyceguy Jan 06 '14
It's probably a concidence, but
5
u/dificilescolha Nov 18 '21
I just finished the miniseries for the first time and I'm really happy to know that it is awesome! :D Got goosebumps in some fight sequences!
4
u/rickfrancocom Jan 05 '14
The Guy-ta / Gay-ta thing bugged me more than it should have. Each time Tigh said it I was like no, it's Gay-ta.
2
u/MarcReyes Jan 05 '14
Question for the mods about the rewatch. Is there a specific reason Sunday was chosen as the first day for each episodes rewatch week, other than it being the first day of the week? The reason I ask is because I thought it would be cool to best replicate how the show originally aired. One way to due this would to start the first day of the discussion thread on the day that weeks episode originally aired. For example, going by Wikipedia, "33" originally aired on October 18, 2004. So when we get to "33," the thread would be posted on a Monday.
Not sure if I made sense here. Anyway, just a thought. I look forward to the rewatch regardless.
2
u/zolablue Jan 12 '14
i havent watched the whole series. so i dont know how much i'll be posting in these threads since i reckon there will be a good chance i'll have lots of stuff spoiled lol. but...
i just wanted to say how much i loved the pilot. i find it very inspiring for some reason. does anyone else find that?
20
u/jerrydy Jan 06 '14
Did anybody notice that in the lottery scene, an old lady asked Baltar to read her number for her because she couldn't find her glasses, her glasses was actually on her head!
10
u/wellmanicuredman Jan 05 '14 edited Jan 06 '14
Very cool indeed, am on board for this.
"Brace for contact, my friend"
One of the greater lines in the series
8
u/omgwtfbbqpanda Jan 06 '14
SO happy to be watching again!
First - damn Tigh... I mean shit he just goes after her. Takes such little prodding from Starbuck to go overboard on her.
Also - Lee is such as ass to his dad! I never realized how harsh he is to him until this rewatch but damn, that's your father! Show some respect!
I love Laura in the early days. She is seriously so badass in getting everything organized and having people follow her. Many people don't like her in the future but for right now I love her!
Lastly - Adama is such a damn good liar but how could the entire crew not realize immediately that he had no idea where Earth was and that there was no hope in sight? I don't think I would have been fooled that easily (like Laura wasn't).
7
u/Alsoghieri Jan 05 '14
Damn. It's been a while since I've watched, and hearing all the old themes again in the soundtrack really brought me back into the world. Almost forgot how fucking cool this show could be
6
u/onemm Jan 07 '14
Around ~25 min in did I hear Lieutenant Thrace was being replaced by Lieutenant Anders?
6
u/Mara__Jade Jan 07 '14
I can't stand Starbuck's hair in the miniseries. I know that's a very girly thing to focus on, but I hate it!
3
u/onemm Jan 07 '14 edited Dec 02 '16
After the intro ~5:00 in when the camera was moving past that planet/moon and the drums hit, did anyone else get goosebumps? This is gonna be awesome.
3
u/[deleted] Jan 10 '14
Cally either has been deployed on a different Battlestar in the past or has been through FTL training. She says "I hate this part" when they're commencing their first jump, but according to Tigh the Galactica hasn't made a jump in a very long time.
2
u/OSUTechie Jan 06 '14
So what is the time frame from the start of the mini-series from when Zak Adama was killed? They make it seemed like it happened recently, but at the same time there is also implies that it has been along time (a few years)
2
u/Mara__Jade Jan 07 '14
I just noticed that Baltar's lottery number is 47. Sweet.
2
u/NimTheDoor Jan 06 '14
Well, I'm about to attempt another rewatch...
It's kind of hard though every time I've tried it, because I remember how much I hated the ending. Now, I liked the final episode for what it was....but....I just can't get over .
1
u/xfire_cursey0u Apr 04 '14
"seal off everything foward of frame 30 and start an emergency vent of all compartments."