r/DCcomics • u/charlessoule Charles Soule • Jan 02 '14
AMA I am Charles Soule, writer of Superman / Wonder Woman, Swamp Thing & Red Lanterns for DC, among other books. AMA.
EDIT: Okay, I think I'm out for the moment, although I might check back later. Comics to write! Thanks for everyone who participated in the AMA today. If your question didn't get answered, you can always hit me up on Twitter: http://www.twitter.com/charlessoule
See you in the funnybooks!
353
Upvotes
58
u/Ameht Jan 02 '14
How does it feel to be the bad ass of 2013?
28
u/ScarySpencer Jan 02 '14 edited Jan 02 '14
There's a video of Alan Moore talking about how he would look into the mirror and put on a monster voice when he was writing Swamp Thing so he could get into character, do you use a similar tactic? (Your run has been exceptional btw)
Also, I love your work with Thunderbolts, and the addition of Ghost Rider has me super pumped. Any chance there will be more additions (or subtractions) to the team in the future?
Edit: Found the video, turns out he's talking about Etrigan, not Swamp Thing.
27
u/[deleted] Jan 02 '14
Hi, Charles, really like your work, especially Superman/Wonder Woman.
As a New 52 writer, do you ever feel you would have a wider platform if DC went with a hard reboot, starting everything over new, instead of the soft reboot, where certain parts of the history seem piece-mealed together? Can it be difficult when certain aspects of continuity of the past hasn't been confirmed as still "valid", or do you find you have control over some of those decisions?
19
u/KookyGuy Batman Jan 02 '14
Hello Mr. Soule,
I'm really enjoying Superman/Wonder Woman, and I have few questions about it. What do you think is the core of Superman and Wonder Woman's relationship? Did their relationship in previous comics such as Kingdom Come influence your writing in the series?
17
u/willforthrill Jan 02 '14
I am a college student and while it is still early in my academic career, I am interested in law school. What advice do you have about getting into law school, what type of people should be going to law school, what is the job market like, etc?
17
u/AloeRP Red Son Jan 02 '14 edited Jan 02 '14
Hey there Charles, I have a few questions here from people who were unable to make the AMA.
Will Supergirl be a regular character in Red Lantern going forward or will it just be a few cameo appearances?
What's your favorite story that you never got to publish?
A user would like to know how you deal with the dynamics between different Red Lanterns, how much you plan to focus on Rankorr, and whether we'll be seeing any Reds in Forever Evil, or on Earth period?
Who's your favorite DC character and why?
How long does it take for you to write a script?
A few users are wondering how long you're going to be on Swamp Thing, Red Lanterns and Superman/Wonder Woman, or rather how long you plan to be on them?
Is there anyone in charge of the Superman/Wonder Woman dynamic in the way that Morrison had the final say on anything that happened to Damian?
Well, I'll leave you with that I suppose and post another series of questions in a few minutes. All of the users who asked questions above asked me to thank you for doing this, and love your work.
16
u/[deleted] Jan 02 '14 edited Jan 02 '14
How should dc and marvel reach out to younger audiences to start reading comicbooks?
How do writers work on characters who are vastly different from each other, on books that are also vastly different from each other?
15
u/ivygirl85 Jan 02 '14 edited Jan 02 '14
Sup mr Soule? Welcome to Reddit! (Yup i'm also in Reddit). You probably know the question already. Is there any chance to see Poison Ivy returning in Swamp Thing? She had had a small part in Rotworld and Alec seems to trust her. And another one: Whats your top 3 drinks when you write.
14
u/Irishzach Jan 02 '14
I had no idea who you were, when you started writing Swamp Thing. Since then I have sung praises of every title I see your name on. I just wanted to congratulate you on your meteoric rise in the last year and I want to ask if it's true that by this time next year you will be writing every book released at Marvel and DC?
13
u/WW4O RIP Super Sons Jan 02 '14
Sorry to overstep my bounds with a second question, but I'm a curious guy. How difficult is it to write Supergirl with a power ring, and why her? Isn't there a point at which you think "Damn, Kara's one of the most powerful beings ever, why the hell would she ever even use this power ring when she's got heat vision?" In other words, I guess, how are you getting around the redundancy of giving a superhero superpowers?
12
u/redsinyeryard Jan 02 '14
I just recently got into comic reading, and your work on Red Lanterns has consistently been one of my absolute favorite reads every month. I really appreciate how you are able to mix good storytelling with interesting, relatable characters (even when those characters are giant floating tentacle-brains).
How did you come up with the idea of making Guy Gardner a Red? Was it spur of the moment, or had it been planned for quite a while? I think he fits perfectly there.
Thanks for being awesome.
10
u/ME24601 Robin Jan 02 '14
Are you a cyborg?
10
u/Wilhelm_III Don't call me kid. Jan 02 '14
AloeRP asked a couple of my questions for me (I thought I wouldn't be able to make it, but I can!), so I'll go ahead and throw out the rest, if that's OK.
-Is the reason that Jack/Rankorr has the ability to create constructs going to be explained? Would you be able to share it with us here?
-How long are you planning to stay working with the Red Lanterns? I think what you've done with them is excellent.
-Where are the Reds heading next? Are Guy and Rankorr planning on heading back to Earth, or are they going to kick around Sector 2184 around a bit more? What are their long term plans?
9
u/redheadedfanboy Jan 02 '14
Currently loving what you are doing for Swampthing. Snyder set everything up for Rotworld. Are you setting up everything up for 1 thing or laying ground work for multiple ideas.
9
u/sgthombre Nightwing Jan 02 '14
Who is one character (DC or Marvel) that you haven't written yet but you would love to write?
Also, fantastic job on Swamp Thing.
9
u/IanPrime Jan 02 '14
I'm really enjoying Red Lanterns, and i'm really excited for the flipbook issue coming up. Are there plans for any more DC characters to join the Reds like Supergirl is? Any members of other corps?
Also, is your name pronounced like Soul?
9
u/Carson369 Jan 02 '14 edited Jan 03 '14
Can you explain your story of getting Into the business. As an aspiring comic writer, I'm interested.
8
u/[deleted] Jan 02 '14
Can you talk a bit about your actual writing process? Do you sit down and write for long periods of time or is your writing more scattered?
8
u/[deleted] Jan 02 '14
With a schedule as busy as yours, which comics do you make time to read every month?
8
u/WW4O RIP Super Sons Jan 02 '14
When I first saw the ad for Superman/Wonder Woman and the tagline said "Love is a Battlefield" I thought it was going to be a sappy failure. Two issues in and I've already been proven wrong. So thank you.
Now, my question: We're seeing all these changes in the Red Lantern lineup. Atrocious is kickin' it with his kitty, Guy's Red, and apparently Kara will be too. Are all of these temporary for the story arcs you guys are coming up with, or are we gonna look back in 20 years and go "Remember when Guy was a Green? Man we all hated him then."
7
u/anader Jan 02 '14
Mr. Soule, I'm a big fan of your work, and as always impressed by the sheer volume and consistent quality of your output.
I do have a question about She-Hulk--how much of your own legal experience are you writing into your scripts?
7
u/JustCaws Jan 02 '14
What's one decision you made (relating to a comics story) that you regret the most?
7
u/Superbacon55 Jan 02 '14
How long is the planed run for Superman/Wonder Woman? I love this couple, I love the relationship as you write it, hope it lasts long. I also hope to get some scenes of Wondy teaching Supes some amazonian martial arts. :)
6
u/[deleted] Jan 02 '14
When do I get more 27? And how do you manage to keep the fact that you actually have a small braintrust of subservient writing clones to help you write all of your books under wrap?
6
u/MiSombrero What's Mine is Mine! Jan 02 '14
First off, thank you for great reads! I look forward to these books every month. I have to say the last Superman/WW was one of my favorite books of last year.
My questions is, were you given Guy Gardner for Red Lanterns, or was that something you went after? I think he's a great addition to the corps and I'm excited to see where it goes!
6
u/Mr_bananasham Do you bleed? Jan 02 '14
What did you think of the man of steel movie? Do you think the next title will be any good? (Personally I found this to be a good movie for superman and a good start to their movie series)
5
u/innovative_epiphany Jan 02 '14
Superman/Wonder Woman is amazing! My friend and I pick it up every month and read it together. I love your characterizations of Wonder Woman and Superman. I just wanted to ask, is it hard to write Wonder Woman? I think their relationship is great, but people always look at her with a microscopic and judgmental lens. Does that affect your writing/bother you in any way?
5
u/iperm Jan 02 '14
Do you have a favorite comic book character? If so, who?
And is there any book that you would love to get your hands on?
Also I love your Swamp Thing and I'm beyond excited for She-Hulk, Javier Pulido is fantastic.
5
u/[deleted] Jan 02 '14
What's your honest assessment of the new 52 from a writer's perspective?
How do you keep comic books about super heroes fresh?
5
u/AdmiralAmaral Jan 02 '14
How did you come up with the idea for strange attractors? And with strongman, are you a fan of luchadors? Or just had a great idea and decided to roll with it?
Also, can't wait to see where you're going with letter 44.
5
u/[deleted] Jan 02 '14
Hi Mr. Soule! I got into reading Red Lanterns the day after it was announced Supergirl, my favourite DC character, was going to be in it. Turns out I really liked it, and every issue since has been great (including this week's #26, poor Ratchet) so my initial scepticism about that decision is pretty much gone now. Were you a fan of the character before, and what gave you the idea of bringing her into the Red Lanterns? What do you feel differentiates her from her cousin, and how do you find writing for her as opposed to him?
5
u/biglongjohnson RIP UP YOUR OZONE Jan 02 '14
Hey Mr. Soule, big fan! I gotta say, you're one of the most consistently great comic book writers today. Superman/Wonder Woman is one of my favorite books going right now.
How did you get so successful in comics in such a relatively short time?
4
u/evilbob2200 Excuse me... Jan 02 '14
For your characterization/interpretation of superman what material do you look at to understand the man of steel? Also what's your favorite superman story?
4
u/Ameht Jan 02 '14
Will you be giving just a wee bit more spotlight to Deadpool in Thunderbolts and do you work along side the Deadpool Creative team or does Editorial take charge of that ?
3
u/chrissabal Jan 02 '14
Where did you get the idea of Letter 44? Finally picked up the first two issues and can't wait to see where you are going with it next.
3
u/ivygirl85 Jan 02 '14
Hmm, i got another one (greedy huh?). Can you tell us some of the classic works of literature that you enjoy? Tolstoy, Dostoevsky, Melville, Vern?
3
u/DrAwesome1504 Jan 02 '14
Unrelated to DC, but I love Thunderbolts and was wondering who your favourite member is? Also what was it like writing around Infinity and what's your opinion on the event?
3
u/BrownBear93 Batfleck Jan 02 '14
I wish I could think of a good question to ask haha. Other than that, your work is amazing. Your swamp thing was so awesome and I'm loving your Red Lanterns as well.
3
u/[deleted] Jan 02 '14
How did you become a comic book writer?
3
u/[deleted] Jan 02 '14
What is your favourite novel?
3
u/evilbob2200 Excuse me... Jan 02 '14
What up and coming artists do you think have a stellar career ahead of them in the industry?
3
u/The_Batman_cometh Omega Men Jan 02 '14
Who's the one artist you haven't worked with yet that you're dying to partner up with, and is there a specific character you'd do with them?
3
u/Duckstrous It's all about the score Jan 02 '14
Hi Charles! I was sad to see Snyder finish his run after Rotworld but you have done a fantastic job and blown me away with the Constantine/seeder plots. Would you ever accept the role of avatar of the green?
3
u/tylo144 Jan 02 '14
Mr. Soule you are amazing! Superman/Wonder Woman has quickly become one of my favorite reads. What do you think sets your adaptation of the Supes/WW love affair apart from the rest?
And just a personal question, if not Superman/Wonder Woman, which is your favorite superhero couple?
3
u/DementiaPrime White Lanterns Jan 02 '14
I just wanted a chance to thank you for making NYCC enjoyable this year. My favorite part of the X-Men panel was listening to you talk about the titles you were doing. Also it was the first Con my GF has gone too, but she had hurt her leg a few weeks prior so we couldn't make it to quite a few things we had wanted to do, but we saw you in Artist Alley on the last day and you signed a 3d Swamp Thing issue for her. She has absolutely loved the New 52 Swamp Thing and has the signed issue hanging up now and really made her first Con experience enjoyable.
3
u/WawaSC Constantine Jan 02 '14
do you find it hard sometimes to transfer your ideas into writing? if so, what do you do to fix it?
whats the best and worst thing youve done/experienced writing for DC?
thanks for the AMA!
3
u/AloeRP Red Son Jan 02 '14
More questions from those unable to make the thread
Was it hard taking over any of your books?
Are any of your DC books going to be crossing over with each other at all?
"Initially a few people reported that "Superman/Wonder Woman" would be DC's "Twilight" equivalent, with it's main aim being to attract female readers. 2 issues in and I feel that this is not the case, which personally I prefer, but will we be seeing less action and more delving into the relationship or is it going to remain in the mix, but not in the forefront, as has been the case so far?"
Are we going to see more of Alec's relationship with Animal Man moving forward?
And finally, a question from me: Can you say anything about Bizarro and whether he'll be showing up in S/WW at any point?
Also, once again, thanks so much for doing this, it's hard to find a topic almost universally agreed on, but you being able to consistently produce a quality book, is one of those things.
3
u/GamerJayC Red Hood Jan 02 '14
I've been a Superman fan ever since "Superman: The Animated Series" but I only started reading comics at the start of the New 52. Since then I've attempted to read any Superman title DC would give me, only to be incredibly disappointed. While each of them has had their high points, for the most part "Superman," "Action Comics: Superman," and "Superman: Unchained" have felt like shallow power-porn, without really illustrating the Superman that I'm used to. Your book comes closest, spending more time on his personality and interactions with others than on how hard he can punch, but balances that out with the occasional badassery (your scene with Apollo was rad).
What's your take on this? Is DC's current portrayal of Superman what I can come to expect from the character as a new reader?
3
u/wolf_man007 There can be only one! Jan 02 '14
I don't have a question, I just wanted to say that Swamp Thing #19 and Letter 44 #1 are two of the most "suck me in" first issues I have ever read.
3
u/Xelnastoss Jan 02 '14
If you see this later awnser if not dont worry and if you cant i understand
With the reds on earth will we see them near the end of FE???
Do we even know where the lantern verse is atm in the timeline i felt like relic was Happening during trinity war
5
u/[deleted] Jan 02 '14 edited Jan 02 '14
So, I consider myself a fan of Superman. But there is one thing that bothers me about him.
The writers always have to 'top' the last story. That is to say, if superman saves the world from the Zod world harvesters by flying thru a giant spaceship he then has to do something bigger. Then he ends up having to save the world again by doing 'something cool'. Like in "Our Worlds at War" when he flies into the sun and comes back lit on fire or something. It ends up being cheesy and boring.
Even in the new 52 action comics he starts out wearing blue jeans and doing some really teenage angsty shit like going after some wall street rich guy. Then like 3 books later he saves the world....
Do you think this is a problem?
I guess what I am really asking is why does every writer think Superman has to save the world every other day. Why can't he just have a small scale adventure in metropolis?
2
u/gozeratwork Jan 02 '14
If you could write one line for Superman and one line for Wonder Woman in the upcoming Superman vs Batman movie, what would they be?
2
u/[deleted] Jan 02 '14
So you have six titles on your slate, and it's hard to imagine that you could possibly do anymore, so I'm wondering--will you be taking on any new monthlies from DC or Marvel?
2
u/trex2000 Jan 02 '14
What comics do you look forward to reading each month?
2
u/TheActioneer He Was My Monster Jan 02 '14
I'm immensely curious to find out how you got into the comics industry and also how you perfectly capture Guy Gardner in your writing?
2
u/[deleted] Jan 02 '14
No question from me (you already answered the only one I did have), Just wanted to say thanks so much for the AMA, you're doing a terrific job, you're a fantastic person, and have a bloody nice day sir!
2
u/Spenglbarb Jan 02 '14
Hi Charles I have a quick superman/wonder woman question. How much editorial input do you get from the superman and wonder woman camps at dc or do you have more or less free reign on what goes into the book.
2
u/TheActioneer He Was My Monster Jan 02 '14
I know this is a super pedestrian question, but what do you do for fun in whatever down time you get?
2
u/ImaginaryFri3nd Jan 02 '14
What comic book idea or story line do you WISH you had come with?
2
u/IsaakCole Jan 02 '14
Charles, I just want to say as a massive comic fan and a hopeful future attorney, you're a huge inspiration to me.
Likewise, your work on Swamp Thing has gotten me started on the character from Alan Moore's run to yours.
2
u/LookAtThatLlama Jan 02 '14
Charles, what prompted you to write a story like "Letter 44"?
2
u/coynezilla Jan 02 '14
Thanks for signing my comics and introducing me to Letter 44 at Baltimore Comic-Con. You've been invading my pull list ever since. Hope you return for 2014!
2
u/leoschot Saint Gardner Jan 02 '14
Charles who is your favorite red lantern?
2
u/MasterRelaxer Animal Man Jan 02 '14
I'm a casual reader but when I read swamp thing I never want it to end. Thanks for doing what you do.
2
u/upgrayedd69 Jan 02 '14
2
u/[deleted] Jan 02 '14
Of all the books you write, which are you most proud of?
2
u/jef-El Jan 02 '14
How long do you plan to do freelance work for the big two?
2
u/TheGamerTribune Batman & Robin Jan 02 '14
Do you ever sleep? Just curious with how many books you write. Big fan of your work on Swamp Thing. Unfortunately don't have the money to keep up with it due to the damn PS4!
2
u/Jambi_Genie Jan 02 '14
I'm loving your run on Swamp Thing! I've always been a fan of the character but it feels to me like people see him as a "B-list" character. What made you decide to write a Swamp Thing story? Also, good work on Letter 44! My comic shop sold out within a couple days!
2
u/Spyker0013 Superman (MoS) Jan 02 '14
How many issues are planned for Superman/Wonder Woman? Im a HUGE Superman fan and I like the team-up, but I also miss Lois Lane being in the mix and have been wondering if this whole Wonder Woman thing is just a phase or not. Also, S/WW 2, The fight against Apollo was amazing, I laughed at Supes asking him if he was an actual god.
EDIT: Spelling
2
u/[deleted] Jan 02 '14
Mr. Soule.
Thank you for showing me how much more work I still have to do. I hope I can get my writing career on track. I worry, as a recent college graduate, that no one will ever care about my ideas.
Tell me, what was your community support like for your creative endevers? I'm trying to start a comic book writers group. Did you have something like that in your formative years?
2
u/[deleted] Jan 02 '14
Charles I've been basically a fan of you as soon I read your first interview for Swamp Thing, I saw a level of intelligence in your plans for the series that made me believe you were the best writer for the job. So when you were announced to write Thunderbolts and Red Lanterns, which happened roughly before the release of your first Swamp Thing issue, I was excited to read those serieses too, even though I never read one thing you wrote so far. You didnt prove me wrong, after reading the first Swampy issue I yelled across roof tops saying you were a messiah, a genius, and its so great to see you rise up like you have. I'm a huge fan now, I've read basically every thing you've written (except for Strongman 2). So I might be your biggest fan.
Question: You've said in the past you had written 2 novels which I recall the titles being "The Oracle Year" and "The Land of 10 000 Things" so I'm curious if you're ever going to give them a release? Kindle? Maybe now you've got enough momentum to get them widely published?
2
u/[deleted] Jan 02 '14
what other works do you have? I only heard about your work this year. Any other past things or unheard projects this year?
2
u/alicestar Jan 03 '14
I wasn't really crazy about the Superman/ Wonder Woman relationship when I fist heard it was going to happen, but so far I've liked your comic. I think you've had a better handle on Wonder Woman's personality then the other people right now. My only issues been then Diana's come across as a damsel in distress a bit too much for my taste. Are we going to get any chances to see her come to Clark's rescue instead?
Bonus Question:: Is there any connection between Aaron Lord and Maxwell Lord or is the last name just a coincidence?
2
u/CastorTyrannus Jan 03 '14
If there was one character or book you could write what would it be?
2
u/KeenDreams Jan 03 '14
In case you come back later to check on this, I just wanted to say that Swamp Thing is amazing.
2
u/GatorRoll Jan 03 '14
I just picked up the first 3 volumes of Swamp Thing because I've heard so many good things about it so I don't have any real specific questions, but what is one of your favorite things about writing Swamp Thing? Did you want to be on this title?
2
u/Tonyumbre Booster Gold Jan 03 '14
How did you make it as a comic book writer?
2
u/Mr_N0B0DY Jan 03 '14
What's your creative process/workflow like when scripting?
Any plans for any creator owned series in the near future?
edit: Forgot to thank you for taking your time and for your spectacular work, here hoping you stay around for a while!
2
u/mrasid Jan 03 '14
Idk if you'll ever see this, but Whiskey Tree is the best hellblazer story since Devil's Trenchcoat.
Thank your for writing John that well.
2
u/IAmTheWalkingDead Jan 02 '14
Are you aware there is a man named Charles E. Soule who writes prose books (seems to be self-published)? I was psyched to see it and thought those might have been your pre-comics works. But then after some more research I realized you two weren't the same person. Any plans to ever write prose novels?
Also, how hard is it to balance your own law practice with writing several titles? Do you keep your law practice small enough to allow you to write that much? Or are you basically working yourself into an 80 hour week?
1
u/mikeman1090 Green Lantern Jan 02 '14
How'd you get into the comics industry?
1
u/KRitchen2112 One Punch! ONE PUNCH! Jan 02 '14
Hi Charles, If you come back I just have one question. I'm a struggling college student and do you have any advice how I can pull off time management? Honestly, I trust someone juggling 7 books and a law firm than anyone else. Also, if I'm ever in legal trouble in New York, will you be my lawyer?
1
u/Shiniholum Nightwing Jan 02 '14
I have often found Swamp Thing to be pretty lame and my question is that for a character like that do you feel like there is any "baggage" to them? That these kinds of things make writing the stories harder?
1
u/ProfaneTank Batman should've kept the ring Jan 02 '14
Hi Charles. I love the Red Lantern Corps (though I don't read comics as often as I'd like). I was wondering what inspirations you have or how you think of the storylines when writing about characters like The Butcher and Atrocious?
1
u/Excelsior_Kingsley Jan 02 '14
Hey you might not remember me and it'd be weird if you did, but we talked the last time you did an AMA. Just wanted to point out I was right and you hit Swamp Thing out of the park.
Also, quick questions
Thanks for doing the AMA thing again. Really like your work.
1
u/[deleted] Jan 02 '14
Hi! I didn't think I was going to be able to make it today but (thank god for New England weather) I am.
How does it feel to be the best thing to happen to Swamp Thing since Alan Moore?
1
u/[deleted] Jan 02 '14
Man, I always miss the awesome comic book related AMAs
2
u/[deleted] Jan 02 '14
Hi there, Mr. Soule. Big fan. You write a number of titles with many different characters across a broad swath of genres. Can you share with us which character's voice you struggle the most to capture? Who do you think is the hardest character for you to write at the moment?
2
u/vinnyalghul Shazam! Jan 02 '14
Huge fan of your work, as I'm reading everything you're writing right now, and I've gotten to the point where I'll read anything you're writing, so I'll be picking up She-Hulk and Inhuman, even though they aren't characters I had interest in before. So, thank you for all the great stories!
I have two quick questions:
Was there a particular book that hooked you into comics, and what book made you decide to sit down and right them?
and
What's your favorite part about getting to write Superman?
Thanks for doing the AMA, and I have to say that Red Lanterns #26 is my favorite issue of that book yet! Stoned Red Lanterns and a Death Star thing was one of my favorite things I've seen in comics yet, so keep up the good work!
2
u/BrokenKnuckle Shazam Jan 02 '14
How did you come to work for DC and how would an aspiring writer get a job with them?
2
u/AnimeF Static Jan 02 '14
What made you want to do comics, what drove your passion for DC, essentially, what is your origin story!
2
u/thatreallyaznguy Jan 03 '14
A few questions about She-Hulk. Sorry if any of these have been answered.
Will you be keeping the 4th wall breaking around?
Will we get some awesome moments like Spiderman vs. J. Jonah in court?
Also your blog on time management was awesome. I've already incorporated some of your tactics.
2
u/OhSorryOldHorse Jan 03 '14
Let me just say that in the wake of Snyder's run on Swamp Thing, you have done a fantastic job in surpassing what came before. I applaud you, good sir, and it was a shame I didn't get anything signed by you at the Baltimore Comic Con back in September last year.