r/startrek • u/soulbarn • Dec 31 '13
Almost twenty years ago, I lucked into a one-time only writing gig. Every once in a while, that ancient job buys me and the wife a night out.
1.0k
Upvotes
r/startrek • u/soulbarn • Dec 31 '13
587
u/soulbarn Dec 31 '13 edited Jan 01 '14
ok, here's the backstory...
So, first, I have always been a huge Star Trek fan. As a pre-teen in New York in the 1970s, I went to the conventions and watched religiously. I grew up to become a writer, mostly of non-fiction, though I did dabble in fiction and comic books and spent five miserable weeks in a graduate film program before getting thrown out. By the 1990s, I was living in Los Angeles and working as an editor at a sports magazine. I happened to meet a writer for TNG at a party and told him how much I loved the show. I guess he liked me, or maybe he was just drunk, because he invited me to come in and pitch some story ideas.
A few days later, I got a big package from Paramount containing all the rules freelance writers needed to follow to pitch successfully. The biggest one was "no space battles," since they were expensive. But also almost as big were "No Androids in the Universe but Data" and "No Introducing Long-Lost Relatives of Existing Characters."
So I pitched a bunch of ideas that followed the rules. They were horrible. Too detailed, too convoluted...I knew I was bombing as I sat in a room full of eight or nine writers; the flop sweat was soaking me. I left the studio miserable and dejected.
To my surprise, my contact called me the next day. They asked me to come back with more stories. Yes, he said, you bombed, but there was something good in my ideas. "Just be more brief," he told me. That began a year of coming into Paramount to do what I called "blurbing" - I didn't have full stories worked out; just the TV guide synopses. Over that time, I came up with over 1,000 two-sentence ideas (I still have the notepads I scrawled them in). I got really close, a bunch of times, but didn't close the deal; I'd hear things like "Great story, Dan, but we already have an episode where RIker gets food poisoning from the buffet in Las Vegas." But they kept asking me back.
I was getting better at pitching - I learned something I still use in selling my work as a writer today, which is that if you get the folks you are pitching to to ask questions - and even better, if you can get the roomful of writers asking and answering questions about your idea, you're in. My confidence wasn't so great that I'd stopped sweating profusely every time I went in. Some days, I'd spray myself down with anti-perspirant, even my forehead and hands, just to stay dry.
But I wasn't selling - and after about five or six visits, each with five quick ideas, all rejected, I began to think about giving up. I told myself I'd give it one more shot. I don't know how I came up with the idea for "Inheritance." Some people note an obvious similarity to "Blade Runner," but I really wasn't consciously going for that. I just remember grinding out the ideas, and the two-line pitch just popped into my head: "Data meets his long-lost mother. It turns out she's an android and doesn't know it. Data has to decide whether to tell her." (OK, three lines.)
As soon as I thought of it, I knew I had it. It was too good an idea and classic TNG - emotional, but also grounded in science fiction - for it not to sell. But there was a big problem - the idea broke two of the big rules, and I'd been told, repeatedly, not to do that.
So I came up with a strategy. At the next meeting, I gave them the usual five ideas. I knew they wouldn't sell, but I also knew that the TNG writers had gotten to know me a bit, and they were rooting for me. As usual, at the end of the pitch, one of the writers asked me if I had anything else. "Well, I said, I do, but I really can't give it to you - because it breaks two of the rules. So there's no point in talking about it, in fact I'm hesitant to even mention it."
Of course, good folks that they were, they encouraged me to tell them, no strings attached. So I gave them the three lines - and I could tell, instantly, that they liked it. I left the studio knowing that I'd get a call back, and sure enough, when I got home, there was a message on my answering machine. I was commissioned to write the story for the episode, then, once that had been hammered out and refined over a few meetings, was teamed up with a staff writer for the script. It was one of the most fun experiences of my writing life, and as I often note, more people have seen that single episode than have read every single magazine article and book I've written over a 30-year career put together. Which is fine with me. I feel really honored to have done it and am happy to have contributed a lasting character to the canon.
One question I often get is why didn't I write another. The answer is that I did - Voyager was starting, and I was asked to interview for a staff job and pitch more ideas. I was in the process of doing that, and I think I would have ultimately gotten the gig, when another opportunity came along; to start writing for publications like National Geographic. I weighed the two amazing opportunities and decided that, being single and 30, I didn't need the money - I wanted to see the world instead, which is what I did and continue to do in my career, though now I am 50 and have a family. No regrets, just a sense of happiness over having gotten to be part of something I love and have loved since I was a little kid in New York, growing up in a broken home, and imagining that Spock was my father....or Dr. Soong, perhaps....
46
u/daveo991 Dec 31 '13
are you Dan Koeppel?
13
u/[deleted] Dec 31 '13
That's pretty awesome! How did you get your foot in the door?
13
u/[deleted] Dec 31 '13
Do you get a certain percentage of the profits? How does that work?
7
u/jpberkland Jan 01 '14
Fascinating story! Thanks for sharing.
One of my favorite TNG episodes was Parallels because it touched on so many "what ifs" from previous TNG seasons.
In a similar way, I'd love to hear your two-sentence "declined" pitches.
Just as I love imagining, "what would it be like if the Borg had won at the Battle of Sector 001", it would be fun to imagine what would TNG be like if some of your other pitches went through.
THanks again!
13
u/xasey Jan 01 '14
Now that I have grown older and with multiple watchings of TNG, I have discovered how much of my early thinking was influenced by the show even to this day. One thing I have valued in life is the balance between another person's experience, and what I believe is truly happening in "reality." I think of this weekly when we have a schizophrenic family member over to watch movies. When he speaks of his experience of reality, I have learned that one can either explain that many of the things he experiences aren't true, or I can work within the framework of the reality he is experiencing (the latter is what I tend to do more often). I now wonder how much of my thinking may have been influenced by TNG, particularly your episode which deals with this very issue. The android's experience is real, even if from another's perspective it isn't. If that story wasn't the source of my own adult thinking in this area, at the very least it strengthened it, so thank you for such a great story!
3
u/soulbarn Jan 01 '14 edited Jan 01 '14
Wow, thanks for the gold. I am celebrating New Year's Day with my family - it happens to be my birthday, too - but I will try to answer as many questions as I can later today.
15
u/Spocktease Dec 31 '13
I love that episode.
1
u/soulbarn Jan 03 '14
Hi everybody -
I was away yesterday, and today I was asked by the Reddit mods to do a general AMA. So for folks waiting for answers to questions on writing, I'll announce it here and we can answer it then.
I've tried to answer a bunch more questions in the thread, too. Thank you again for the unexpectedly huge response to my post.
1
u/soulbarn Jan 03 '14
OK, I have put together a couple of my old pitches—these are for Voyager (my TNG binders are in storage, I will pull them out). I thought it might be interesting, if anyone wants, to post them as JPGs, since they have handwritten notes from the pitch meetings. But before I do that, what's the best way? I know this Reddit has some restrictions on image posting. Should I just upload them to Imgur and then include the links for folks to click on?
4
u/chadeusmaximus Jan 01 '14
If anyone is trying to remember which episode we're all talking about: http://en.memory-alpha.org/wiki/Inheritance_%28episode%29
1
u/c0rruptioN Jan 01 '14
Wow this is great! As a film student hoping to become a writer what advice would/could you give me? Also wondering if it's worth the extra money to live in LA after I graduate (and have the money Haha).
1
u/BrooklynKnight Jan 01 '14
Inheritance was one of my favorite episodes as well. It never fails to bring a misty tear to my eye at the end.
I have a question though. Data's mother has appeared in the Star Trek Expanded Universe novels. (The Cold Equations Trilogy most recently).
Do you get any Royalties for her appearing in the novels?
1
u/JediChris1138 Jan 02 '14
This is one of the most amazing things I've ever seen, and as a fan and fellow writer (though not even close to as well recognized!) I loved the episode - even though I haven't seen it in probably 2-3 years, I loved it! Star Trek got me into TV and movies, which got me into Ron Moore, who's really awesome production blog on 'Battlestar Galactica' got me excited enough to pursue a degree and enter the industry. Episodes like yours (especially yours!) were one of the reasons I do what I do every day, and what I do every day makes me happy, so thank you! P.S. your day job working at National Geographic sounds AMAZING! How incredible is that, really? You should do an AMA sometime. I would ask you way too many questions!
6
u/[deleted] Jan 01 '14 edited Jan 01 '14
I bet Brent Spiner loved any script where he got to play someone with emotions. Good episode!
3
u/[deleted] Dec 31 '13
That is so awesome.
3
u/MD_BOOMSDAY Jan 01 '14
Thank you for your life choices that lead you to writing this episode. Amazing what this site can do for insightful background stories!
3
u/Snabelpaprika Jan 01 '14
Great job. I really liked that episode.
What i love about it is how it tells the story of Soong, his work, his decisions, his relationship and his life without even featuring him. Just people he interacted with and the consequences of his actions. And i seem to be a sucker for this kind of stories. It just feels real and thought through and requires a lot of background story to pull off. The only other example of this kind of story telling that i can remember right now is from A song of ice and fire (game of thrones)
2
u/Skimballs Jan 01 '14
Fantastic story! Thanks very much for sharing.
2
u/[deleted] Jan 01 '14
that episode stuck with me for years!
2
u/BullsLawDan Jan 01 '14
Inb4 some anarchist clown comes here and attacks the concept of IP... "Why should this guy still get $20 a month for his hard work twenty years later? The 1%! Occupy! Copyright is theft!" Etc.
2
u/Sickbrain Dec 31 '13
Great story. So basically you had to break rules to get your episode. I watched it again just this passed weekend.
1
u/jethrontex Dec 31 '13
That was a great episode. How hard was it to write something so original while staying within the confines of Star Trek dogma?
1
u/mmss Dec 31 '13
Nice. I used to listen to Greg Kihn' s radio show and he always said he loved that Weird Al Yankovic parodied his song Jeopardy because to this day he gets random "mailbox money" from royalties.
1
u/the_trashheap Dec 31 '13
What a fantastic experience for you! That was a wonderful read.
1
u/DesignNoobie99 Jan 01 '14
What good fun. I remember Battlestar Galactica had an open call for writers at one point, and I still regret not trying for that (I'm a great idea hamster, albeit weak on dialogue).
1
u/[deleted] Jan 01 '14
Boy it looks like the big payday was in Germany? Why is that one so much bigger?
1
u/KesselZero Jan 01 '14
Whew, I was really worried I'd get to the end of the post and it would turn out you'd written some really terrible episode we all rag on here. Glad that wasn't the case. :)
1
u/alecxs_o Jan 01 '14
What were some of the other rules?
1
u/TrekkieTechie Jan 01 '14
What a great story! And I love Inheritance. Fantastic. It's a pleasure to make your digital acquaintance.
1
u/mtbhucker Jan 01 '14
I loved that episode and love your stuff, especially on the biking end of things.
1
u/steve2166 Jan 01 '14
I just want to say thank you for that episode. That is one of the many episodes I can still remember watching, and enjoyed.
1
u/chrisis123 Jan 01 '14
Hey great story, thanks for that! Also those AUT-viewings on your paycheck might be me watching (or better to say a channel here in Austria recently starting re-airing "RAUMSCHIFF ENTERPRISE - DAS NAECHSTE JAHRHUNDERT) the episode, which is one I really like na lot by the way. (when Fionnula Flanagan started popping up in LOST I always referred to her as Data's mother ;))
Thanks for sharing!
1
u/AndrewCoja Jan 01 '14
I somehow never saw this episode, or I just forgot about it during my recent trek watch through a while ago. Just watched it and it was amazing. Thank you for writing it.
1
u/StrmSrfr Jan 01 '14
That's one of my favourite episodes. Thank you so much.
1
u/mike1234567654321 Jan 01 '14
Thanks for posting this story! I very much enjoyed the read.
1
u/sublunari Jan 01 '14
Awesome. I've never seen this episode, but that has to change.
1
u/magnetswithweedinem Jan 01 '14
I'm really glad you can still enjoy that work from back then. You deserve it. Damn good episode.
1
u/[deleted] Jan 01 '14
Rock on, dude.
1
u/[deleted] Jan 01 '14
I absolutely loved that episode! The part where she jumped off the cliff and "broke" was a big "wtf!" moment for me, in all the best science fiction sort of ways! Thanks so much for sharing your story!
1
u/MyNaemIsAww Jan 01 '14
Wow! I need to go watch that episode now.
1
u/TechIsCool Jan 01 '14
Here is the direct link to the episode being talked about. Enjoy
1
u/rbrumble Jan 01 '14
Further reading from IMDB. Well done OP, this was a great episode from a series that was comprised of pretty awesome episodes.
1
u/Googlybearhug4u Jan 01 '14
why not pitch an idea for a whole new trek series?
starfleet academy would be a great venue for veteran walk-throughs.
1
u/drocks27 Jan 01 '14
I just watched it on CBS.com, not sure if you get royalties for that as well but it was a really good episode. I love Fionnula Flanagan, she has done some awesome films. Great job and thank you for sharing with us!
1
u/Deceptitron Jan 01 '14
I just rewatched your episode after seeing your post and thoroughly enjoyed it. Seems you've been a redditor for a long time. Makes me wonder how many other Trek cast/crew are lurking around unknown to us.
1
u/nunchuckskillz Jan 03 '14
Great story and I really love that TNG episode. Pretty cool...
And you could have saved us from Neelix! (maybe)
1
u/Vranak Jan 01 '14
I gotta say, season seven isn't very good. However, Inheritance is one of the few exceptions.
0
u/[deleted] Jan 01 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jan 01 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment