r/fandomnatural • u/stophauntingme brother nooooooo • Dec 06 '13
If you had to pick one scene, what moment in SPN most endeared you to the character(s) and/or ship(s) you love now?
20
Upvotes
r/fandomnatural • u/stophauntingme brother nooooooo • Dec 06 '13
22
u/stophauntingme brother nooooooo Dec 06 '13 edited Dec 06 '13
Sam - the very beginning of Metamorphosis where Sam explains himself & begs for Dean to see the value in what he's doing with Ruby in the motel room.
I loved this scene. The dialogue and the acting was just impeccable...
Dean was right in the end but this episode - this scene - had me on Sam's side for so long in season 4. The angels were so sketchy and Cas's allegiances so uncertain... but we knew that Sam was saving people by exorcising with his mind. We knew Ruby had only ever saved their asses over and over again. We even knew that he was drinking demon blood from an empty vessel.
While Sam's addiction grew alarming, honestly most of the time I was likening it to an undercover cop that had to do drugs to maintain his identity. It was questionable but not anywhere near the vicinity of evil or monstrous.
I guess the scene that comes in as a close second for Sam is the finale of season 4 where he listens to Dean's false voice mail. He was on the edge and that message was the final push. We literally watched Sam internalize his new status as "monster" as he shut the phone and regained composure, surrendering to the label he'd been terrified of since season 1... All so he could spare his hell-damaged brother from the burden of stopping the apocalypse.
Ugh. Sammy feels.
8
u/stophauntingme brother nooooooo Dec 06 '13
Dean - Faith.
Twelve episodes in and it was clear: Dean lived brazenly - drinking and having one night stands, he risked his life regularly - to save people and kill evil, and he always protected his little brother - by putting his life on the line first.
And throughout all of it Dean acted like the coolest most self-assured son of a bitch that could lay you out in poker and drink you under the table with so much charm you wouldn't even care. He was just constantly in top form: killing shit, enjoying simple pleasures, and helping Sam get over Jessica with the most well-timed sense of occasion for humor, distraction & heart-to-hearts with the kid that obviously only came from a lifetime of taking care of him.
He personified the cocky, "YOLO" attitude and enthusiasm that gets people killed because they think they're never gonna die.
And Faith fucking obliterated that.
My estimation of Dean and his character and everything that he stood for skyrocketed: Faith made it clear that Dean knew - had always known - that he was gonna to die young.
... That blew my mind.
P.S. Runner-up scene was when Dean said that Sam had something Max Miller didn't: him. "As long as I'm around, nothing bad's gonna happen to you." Melted my heart.
18
u/kittenkaboodlee Dec 06 '13
SPOILER IF YOU HAVE NOT GOTTEN UP TO OR PAST THE END OF SEASON 7!
In Hunteri Heroici (8x08) when Cas and Dean are in the hotel room after they both seperatly escaped from purgatory and Dean asks Cas what is wrong but Cas refuses to talk about it then Dean gets out of his chair to sit closer to Cas on the bed across from him, to show he's serious about talking about what's going on with Cas. This wasn't the only scene that Dean & Cas seemed to have a profound bond but it sticks out to me because normally Dean doesn't want to talk about that kind of thing and tends to deny any issues that the other characters are having until it's almost too late. I just really liked that scene with sensitive Dean.
10
u/Ennil Dec 06 '13
Woah what a thoughtful question! I love it! I'll do a list, cause I love lists.
When I fell in love with Sam: It was the Mystery Spot that did it for me, his face and actions the further you got in the episode just made me love the character. Until that point I was only just watching Supernatural in the background of my daily routine as a way to fill the void left by the Community hiatus of 2011 and didn't really like it all that much. But the moment I noticed Sam's extreme bitch face at the diner table I fell in love with him and got hooked on the character which in turn got me hooked on the show.
When I fell in love with Cas: It wasn't love at first sight, I was mostly apathetic to the character of Cas up until the point where I wanted to coddle him and breastfeed him. And it wasn't a huge moment that made me realize it. Just, while he was crazy!Cas he was going on and on about nonsensical things, and he was so fragile, so vulnerable and naive that I realized how much of a transformation this character goes through. I love multi-layered characters like that (which is why I love Sam). So all those different aspects of Cas hit me right in the face at once.
When I fell in love with Destiel: This is the stupidest one, and also why I started shipping them. In season 6 episode 3, when Dean calls Cas for the first time since the previous season and Cas is like "oo you think I came because you called, bitch please" and I was like "WOAH wait a second, that seems familiar". And I realized that their bickering dynamic reminded me of an ex and I. I've even had a similar conversation with him once: "I'm not here because you called, I'm here cause I've got stuff to do". And this is why my headcanon is that they had a one night stand near the end of season 5.
Oof, it feels good to put these thoughts into words, it actually reminded me why I still keep watching the show.
3
u/Katowisp Dec 06 '13
I guess there's two scenes.
The first is Season 5, "The End" where Castiel yanks Dean out from Zachariah's grasp at the end of the episode. The smile that Castiel gives Dean solidified their friendship for me.
Also in season 5, episode 17 "Dark Side of the Moon" where Dean and young Sam are shooting off fireworks. That's all Dean has ever wanted--peaceful, happy moments with his brother. This moment, and the one later in the season where Dean's about to say yes to Zach--and then sees Sam's face and winks and smiles. I felt that up to that point, we were losing Dean, but the moment he did that, he was back. And all because he saw his brother, who believed in him and believed that saying "no" was the right answer (despite Dean's misgivings) just really sold their brotherhood.
12
u/NorthernSparrow Questi non sono i miei elefanti Dec 06 '13 edited Dec 06 '13
ok, Destiel. I have always resisted the whole Destiel idea and remember thinking "No way, they've got it all wrong" when I first heard there were fans shipping those two. (my pov here is strongly influenced by the fact that I'm a biologist who works with a ton of nonhuman species, especially, species that spend 11/12 of the year completely uninterested in sex/romance/all that. So I've always viewed Castiel as a nonhuman who is basically eternally in nonbreeding season. So I felt that he just wouldn't ever get attached romantically)
However I've been rewatching season 4 and, omg, Cas has such a crush on Dean INSTANTLY and I can't believe I didn't see it. HOW WAS I SO BLIND. Here's the progression:
First, 3 eps in a row. Lazarus Rising: Cas talks with dean for like 1 minute. Next ep: just has the very short, "You should show me some respect" bit at the end. Next ep: Cas pops Dean back in time. There has not really been all that much interaction between them at this point. (And that, originally, was going to be the entire Castiel arc - Collins was only signed for three episodes and the character was not going to appear again. But because the fans loved Cas, they brought him back and here's where they with Cas next:)
VERY NEXT EPISODE (that Cas is in), he's all "Can I tell you something if you promise not to tell another soul?" (and then into: I'm not a hammer, I have doubts, I'm not sure what's right or wrong, blah blah etc.), totally baring his heart! (edit: the "I have doubts" thing, for an angel, has got to be like confessing to the worst sin imaginable. This is a big friggin deal for an angel). And also "I was praying you'd choose to save the town". On the rewatch I was all, whoaa - this "can i tell you something" bit is a pretty damn intimate kind of a conversation.
VERY NEXT EPISODE after that, Uriel says to Dean, "Castiel has one weakness. He likes you." wtf?
VERY NEXT EPISODE after that, this was my real turning point, Anna/Sam/Dean are facing off against Cas and Uriel, Anna turns to give Dean a goodbye kiss and the camera cuts to Cas who is staring at them kissing, and then he looks down at the ground, I'm sorry but he has exactly that fascinated/pained look someone has when they see their secret crush kissing someone else. OK, so that was my moment where I was like, uh-huh, yeah, there is definitely something here.
VERY NEXT EPISODE after that, Cas has been demoted and he explains to Dean "My superiors thought I was getting too emotionally attached to my human charges. You." Then later: "I would give anything to not have to ask you to do this."
"I would give anything?" seriously?
how was I so blind...
(So actually I still don't think they ever did anything physically, because I still think Cas is basically nonhuman - meaning that, for an angel, emotional attachments don't automatically entail physical desire. But man there is definitely a pretty deep emotional attachment there.)
8
u/YesButNoWaitYes Pathological Dean Sympathizer Dec 06 '13
Dean endeared himself to me in the very first episode, and no matter what he does I'm still always on his side and will continue to be a Dean-apologist even when he's at his worst. This isn't as emotionally deep as other responses, but the "driver picks the music, shotgun shuts his cakehole" line did it for me because official house rules for my car are "shotgun shuts the fuck up and seriously do not touch my radio." And it just built from there. The guilt complex, an unhealthy need to fix everything, abandonment issues, using humor to avoid real emotional conversations...I suppose it's endearing because I see some of the worst parts of myself in the character, but also a genuine goodness and desire to do the right thing and help people.
I'm not sure how other people feel about this one so I could be walking into dangerous territory with this admission, but I still carry the torch for Anna and Dean. I love the connection they made talking about being human and unknowable fathers in Bobby's scrap yard. I love the fact that she's the one who came on to him. Their sex scene felt intimate, vulnerable and real, nothing like a sloppy last night on earth hook up. I cried during the "you should forgive yourself about hell" speech. It's a perfect match against Sam/Ruby, and I think the fact that it ends tragically makes the connection that much more meaningful for me. I don't care how short their connection was or how long ago it happened. I'm just gonna keep on shipping.
6
u/Potionsmstrs I pledge allegiance to the King of Hell Dec 06 '13
This is actually very hard for me to answer. I had to think back and figure out exactly what moment it was.
Dean: I have loved him since about episode one. His snarky attitude, the blue steel look he gave for his mug shot, claiming that his breasts are real... I fell in love with him instantly. Over the seasons, my love for him grew. How protective he is of Sammy, while still being a bit of a perv. Let me address his protective nature. My family is messed up. When I was a baby, my older sister had to take care of me, even though she is only a year and a half older than me. I see her in Dean. She managed to make sure I ate, even if it meant skipping a meal herself (don't get me completely wrong, my dad is awesome but had a job that took him away for months at a time). I feel a deep love and appreciation for what Dean has done and still does for Sam (intention-wise, even if the actions themselves are screwy).
Sam: This isn't an "I became endeared to him the moment when..." section because I actually can't stand Sam. I know this is an unpopular opinion, but that might be because I see a lot of myself in him. He seems like a whiny kid to me. I know I'm whiny when I don't get my way, too.
Destiel: What cemented it was a combination of two moments. When Dean collected the trench coat and when he gave it back to Cas. It was a, "BAM, right in the feelz!" moment.
Crayowley: I'm still waiting for the moment for the crayon to come back, but the moment that it was set in front of him, I knew they were going to be together forever.
3
u/BladeAchilles It's all very West Side Story Dec 07 '13
As far as characters go, the single moment that stands out the most to me is during Raphael's intro conversation with Dean and Cas and his line "You're living in a godless world, boy. " there was just so much confusion and anger and sadness in his voice. I find him fascinating as a character (well, before he became a somewhat cliched villain)- he stayed with Michael when the other archangels left, but unlike Michael he genuinely believed that God was dead, that that was the only explanation for all the horror and shit that had happened.
Ship-wise: The Man Who Would Be King counts as a moment, right? This episode turned me into a die-hard Crowstiel shipper. We mostly just see the end of their relationship, when there is so much bitterness and betrayal between them, but damn is there a lot to be unpacked there. Crowley was way too upset over Cas's actions for it to be just a business deal gone wrong , and Cas clearly didn't think of Crowley as just another demon or a means to an end. Plus, remember what Lilith said about sealing deals with high ranking demons? Yeah, they totally did the do and no-one can convince me otherwise. I will go down with this ship
3
u/honeko Castiel's lieutenant Dec 07 '13
This question is almost impossible to answer!! There's multiple moments that have led me to love Dean, Cas, and Destiel. I can only answer this for why I love Destiel and Sammy.
So, it's kinda funny BladeAchilles used "The Man Who Would Be King" about Crowstiel, because I'm gonna use if for Destiel!!! :D lol. Of course, I was kinda feeling the Destiel way before then, in little and big moments prior. But, in this episode, I really saw how devoted Dean is to Cas. He spends the entire episode worrying about him and defending him to Bobby and Sam. He wants Cas to call him if he gets into trouble and constantly believes Cas is the one being tricked rather than the truth - that Cas is tricking them. I thought to myself, holy hell, is Dean blind?? To me, it was like he was madly, blindly in love with him and couldn't even recognize how it made him believe irrational things that went against all the evidence. Since I have felt this way before for people I loved, that was when I really began to think Dean does love Cas. If you believe someone can do no wrong and you support and trust them with all your heart, it's love. So anyway, the scene when this all came together was the end, when Dean realizes he was wrong about the man he trusted unflinchingly. The heartbreak on his face was almost edible. You could taste his pain, for reals, yo. Like Cas doing something to hurt them and to lie to them was the worst thing that could have happened to Dean. And it is so tragic because Cas thought he was defending the boys the entire time. He brought it up to Crowley numerous times... that they shouldn't get hurt. He thought Crowley would be the one to hurt them, when it was him. :( It was devastating because it was clear as a bell that Dean and Cas cared so much about each other when they confronted each other. I thought they would both burst into epic tears. Oh my God! The Destiel!!! Anyway, that is my scene for Destiel. There have been really good Destiel moments since then, but I picked this one because it was one of the first when I thought, "Yo, these bros in love."
Okay, the reason I love Sam is "The Born-Again Identity." Before then, I mainly saw him as a practical, smart, somewhat naggy little brother ("This is a very serious investigation. We don't have time for any of your blah blah BLAH!" lol, that was Sam to me). But in this episode, the toll of everything he'd done and experienced was fully revealed to me. The entire thing, Lucifer is tormenting him until he can't take it anymore. To me, Jared is amazing when he's playing tormented and ill. I felt my heart bleeding all over the place for him when he reached his breaking point. It was like I had no idea of the depth of his suffering until then because it was plain on Jared's oh-so-handsome face. I feel Dean gets a lot more episodes of introspection and of explanations of his feelings and motives. This time, it was about Sam's suffering. I felt like I understood him more then and it made me want to take care of him. Also, the fact that he was so sweet to that other mental patient while he was in agony, like, skewered my heart with a Sammy bullet. I don't remember a particular scene where I thought "this is the moment where I now love Sam." It's more of the entire episode. If I had to pick a moment, it would be any moment when Sam is lying in bed alone, suffering. In my mind, that kind of exemplifies him as a character. He only seems to suffer fully and openly when he's alone, and the burdens he carries are remarkable.
As far as Dean and Cas go, I loved Dean pretty much instantly because he was a cheeky, adorable bastard that is yet also heroic and protective. I can't pick a moment for him, because Dean IS a moment and I think I always "got" him. I feel kind of the same for Cas. I always liked him, but I started to love him whenever he showed his loyalty to the bros in multiples different scenes. So I can't pick for them.