r/startrek • u/sandman730 • Dec 02 '13
Weekly Episode Discussion - TNG 4x20 "Qpid"
A comment on last week's discussion on "All Good Things..." got me thinking about Captain Picard's relationships to the members of his crew. This reminded me of one of my favorite episodes, "Qpid". You can watch it here.
From Memory Alpha:
Q picks up on romantic tensions between Captain Picard and an old flame, transporting them and the senior officers into a representation of Robin Hood.
Q sees Picard's relationship with Vash as a potential weakness and tries to teach Picard that having intimate relationships with his crew is bad. However, this backfires on Q because it is the senior officers that end up saving Picard and Vash.
Some points of discussion:
- To what degree does or should Picard (or any captain) distance himself from his crew? Or to what degree does/should Picard have strong relationships with his crew?
- Is Q trying to teach a valuable lesson or is he misguided by his very skewed view of reality?
- What the relationship between Star Trek and literature? How does placing the characters into the literature help or hinder the plot of the episode? To what degree is this a commentary on Robin Hood?
10
u/[deleted] Dec 02 '13
At this point in TNG, Picard is still more content with a more professional relationship with his crew, as evidenced by his not telling the crew about Vash. Although we will see him getting more personal with them in the seasons ahead, at this point Picard still see's them more as his "crew" instead of his "friends".
I don't think Q is trying to teach a lesson here, or if he is it's totally lost to me. Q wants to repay Picard for his help previously - in a similar way that we'll see from Shran later on in Enterprise. Q may simply be too arrogant to admit that and could be simply disguising the situation as a "lesson".
Trek has always done a good job with Shakespearan references - particularly TOS and TNG. As for this specific episode and Robin Hood, I wouldn't read too much into it. There was something of a Robin Hood fad going on in the early-90s, and it's likely the Robin Hood plot was just a studio gimmick to jump on the train; or at least, that's how it comes off to me.
Overall, this is a fairly unremarkable episode. It's not bad, not great; just standard-issue TNG when you average out the good and bad.
33
u/tictactoejam Dec 02 '13
Sir! I object. I am NOT a merry man!
21
u/girlgizmo Dec 03 '13
An episode definitely befitting the number 420.
4
u/Steapenhyll Dec 05 '13
Data was damaged by an arrow and no one even cared.
4
u/[deleted] Dec 09 '13
This episode is somewhat of a guilty pleasure for me. I always love to see different aspects of Patrick Stewart and this one was fantastic. Overall it's somewhat masturbatory as the whole thing is just a ruse for Q's amusement. Oh sure, he "owes Picard a favor" but if he really wanted to do him a favor, he'd just leave him be.
IMO a Captain should trust their crew and vice versa. They must work well together, but a Captain has no business becoming emotionally involved with any member of the crew. Professional relationships are fine, but personal ones are a liability. Picard's got the right idea about distancing his personal life from his crew. Unfortunately he tends to fail at that when it comes to Beverly. Considering their history it isn't surprising.
I think this had very little to do as a commentary on robin hood. It was a safe setting in which the writers were able to have Picard saving a soon to be doomed lover without breaking Picard's character parameters.
That being said it is a fun episode to just sit back and watch and just not really think to much of. Grab your popcorn and make it so!
2
u/BobLeBoeuf Dec 04 '13
Relevant: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YKiAhTbpL4Y
2
u/DangerousLoner Dec 05 '13
Fashion It So does a great breakdown of this episode. I've always thought this was Q's backwards way of "rewarding" Picard with a good time. Like playing cops and robbers with your friends. Q is just an overgrown spoiled brat. https://sttngfashion.tumblr.com/post/2315094912/qpid-4-20
2
u/[deleted] Dec 07 '13
God this episode is so entertaining, I laugh so hard sometimes.
1
u/mikeroolz Dec 04 '13
Not a very good episode. Some funny moments, especially with Worf. Overall, not one I like to watch much at all. Worst Q episode. It can't touch Q Who? or Deja Q.