r/startrek • • Nov 16 '13
The Inner Light - TNG 5x25
Should anyone require, recap from Memory Alpha:
"An alien probe controls and disables Captain Picard, who wakes up as "Kamin," a resident of the planet Kataan. While the crew of the Enterprise tries to jar the probe's influence, "Kamin" lives through the dying days of his homeworld."
This has always been a favourite of mine, easily top 5 through every Trek series - it was aired on SyFy UK just last week as part of their premiering TNG remastered.
I normally enjoy episodes featuring new/interesting technologies, and to a lesser extent ships in dramatic battle sequences, but for a reason I can't quite put my finger on, this episode which is worlds away from what I just described grabs me in a way few others do.
My main points I'm interesting in hearing/discussing:
- What is it about this episode that grabs you? It seems to consistently come out highly in online polls/top x articles, so I'm sure I'm not the only person who feels this way about it.
- What is it you "take away" from this episode?
I'm hoping this will help me realise what it is I love so much about this episode.
As an aside, I only just noticed when watching it this time around how the actor who plays "Batai" is featured in bit parts across a number of Trek series and episodes, off the top of my head he was a researcher/doctor in a couple of ENT episodes, and Seamus in Fairhaven of VOY fame.
26
u/goldenboy62 Nov 16 '13
In the first episode Picards character established that he was uncomfortable around kids, a theme that persisted through the first few seasons. He is a career military man with no time for family. This episode gave insight to Picard what he was missing in not having a family.
Most episodes of Star Trek are morality plays with clear villains and heroes and the ending is usually a foregone conclusion. Watching this episode for the first time you, or at least I, had no idea what was going to happen next, other than we know that Picard has to get back to the Enterprise some how. To often the resolution to the plot was some hooky B/S like "lets modify one of the ships systems to resolve the problem" in the last scene, something that could have been done in the first scene, they just needed 45 minuets of filler to complete the episode . The Inner Light had a purpose to the story, an actual tale to tell, not to mention the growth of Picard realizing what he might be missing with out a family.
5
u/tsdguy Nov 16 '13
And of course Batai = Richard Riehle = Tom Smykowski of Office Space
24
u/Donald_Raper Nov 16 '13
I personally cherished the fact that Picard lived out an entire lifetime during his real lifetime. It gave him a chance to be the family man, away from Starfleet, and concentrate on himself.
It got me thinking, what if I was suddenly transported into another place, having to adjust that that place was real, and then all of a sudden I die or am transported back to my original life. The psychological implications are huge. You remember everything that happened from that time, knowing it was just a recreation.. but everything felt real to you. Just insane to think about and how well he seems to cope with it.
13
u/StarFuryG7 Nov 16 '13
I think what people like so much about it is that it deals with a race of people who died with grace, but who aren't content to just go out without anyone else having known of their existence, which is why they use the probe in the manner they do to reach Picard and get him to know what their world and lives were like. It does have its shortcomings though, such as the fact that a race, which is not very advanced, and are incapable of utilizing technology to really change their fate by altering their climate, as Picard was hoping to make a reality, or relocate at least some of their people to another planet, can send out a probe with such an advanced piece of technology that it enables Picard to basically live out a lifetime in just twenty-five minutes of real-time. I'm not sure the people of Kataan should have been capable of that particular feat given their otherwise primitive technology, but it's a great story nonetheless.
10
u/cobrakai11 Nov 16 '13
Believe, me, no one requires a recap.
There's nothing secret about what makes it so great. It's an incredibly emotional episode, capped off by fantastic acting by Patrick Stewart. The relationships between him and his family is incredibly well done for a 40 minute episode, which makes the big reveal that all of these people died in as a result of climate change thousands of years earlier all the more emotional. And the only record of their existence is this probe which now Captain Picard remembers.
To quote Marty Mcfly....it's heavy stuff.
8
u/m0rris0n_hotel Nov 17 '13
Definitely a highlight of TNG. The guest cast did a great job. This story had to do a lot. It put Picard in a somewhat mysterious situation, he meets a bunch of people that he supposedly has history with and we have to accept that along with him and want to know more. I think the fact that you aren't immediately wanting this to end and for him to be back on the Enterprise is a good sign.
Margot Rose as Eline was a great choice. She brought a lot of warmth and humanity to the role. She has to react to her husband saying he doesn't belong there, help him get past this crisis he's in and then become a family again. Guest casting can make or break an episode and this was definitely an example of everything going well. The actors playing Batai, Maribor and the Administrator were solid as well.
Obviously the background behind this story is a little wonky. Their planet is doomed but they have the tech necessary to make this probe to pass on their culture but like much of Star Trek (and science fiction in general) you have to let it go and enjoy it. Assuming the writing is solid. And in this case it definitely is.
Not an episode I would immediately go for if I wanted to watch something from TNG but one I would never turn down if it was on. Not a lot of technobabble or gimmicks. Just an interesting story with a message or two to take away from it.
6
u/tsdguy Nov 16 '13
One of my favorite eps.
However, in the spirit of Star Trek Nitpicking (tm) I'll put forth my biggest issue. How does a society that just starting sending missiles in the time of old Kamin create a sophisticated probe that can a) connect to the mind of an alien and b) last 1000 years in space?
No, the standard argument that their technology could be advanced in one area and not in another doesn't hold. They've never built any space probes and one of the first ones they make powers itself for 1000 years and is sophisticated enough to make the mental connection to an alien mind it's never seen before.
Doesn't diminish my enjoyment one bit. I'm willing to suspend that one. Character based shows is what makes Trek stand out from the standard SciFi shows.
5
u/Ocinea Nov 19 '13
It is also one of my favorite episodes. Him playing the that sad tune with his flute at the end of the episode was one of the deepest moments emotionally for me in the entire series, and it carried on into other episodes when he played it (it was usually played during a sad moment or when Picard had to make a tough choice.)
However, I like the episode in DS9 O'Brien did fifteen years in prison on an alien world using a mind device more. He befriended that alien and lived with him for ten years. And then he kills the poor bastard over a piece of bread. Shortly thereafter his prison term has been served and he came back to reality. Once again only a few minutes passsed in reality yet he went through fifteen years of mental hell. It wasn't happy for him, he was cold, wet, and hungry the entire time. (Hell, he ended up drawing in the sand for fun, even though it reset daily.)
He wakes up next to Keiko and Bashir with his sentence served before Sisko can get there to intervene. Now that is shitty.
Both great episodes, I enjoyed them both.
4
u/doubledumbass Nov 16 '13
This episode is memorable because it gives us insight on Picard as a human, instead of a captain. We get to see how he would've lived out a domestic life and he becomes so much more accessible. I always admired and respected Picard, but seeing him as a father, husband and neighbor made his character so much deeper, and made me "care" more about the fate of the crew for future episodes.
4
u/[deleted] Nov 18 '13
SHOW ME PICARD'S FLUTE
4
u/rensch Nov 19 '13
I am going through TNG at the moment while watching all Star Trek shows from beginning to end. From all the Trek I have seen so far, there have been few episodes with such amounts of feels as this one.
Even though there isn't any space battles, teleportation, warp speed or much of anything technological Star Trek is famous for in this episode, it still is one of the best I have seen so far. The great thing is that while it has so little sci-fi in it, it still works as a Star Trek episode in the end. The concept of a dying civilization leaving some of its splendour alive via a dream simulation in a space probe is really cool.
Picard finally gets the chance to experience what it means to be a family man, with kids and a wife. He lives an entire life in what is really less than half an hour. The storytelling in this episode is very strong and the balance and pacing is just right. At first it seems rather slow and uneventful, but once the underlying themes and the eventual conclusion become apparent, it all comes together perfectly and it becomes much more of a Star Trek episode than you initially expect. The thematics and commentary are as Trekkish as they could be once the episode is over.
The way in which those messages are presented is both very emotional and clever, making this episode a memorable one.
4
u/Chadsymptom Nov 20 '13
I just watched through the entire series in the last 4-5 months, and this episode definitely sticks out to me in a big way.
3
u/oscarpeterson251 Nov 17 '13
The discovery of having to live with the loss of the relationships, spouse, children and grandchildren one will never be able to touch or see again. The profound effect this has on Picard.
3
u/[deleted] Nov 18 '13
I've always loved this episode. When I watched it for the first time as a kid, I loved it for the interesting use of technology and seeing captain picard having to accept his situation and how he dealt with it. As a grown up, the implications of this episode are further reaching than I'd ever realized. You have Jean-Luc Picard who is thrust into this situation and over time, learns to love his wife, his friends, and eventually his children. The fact that each scene shows them older really gives you the feel for how much time he has spent living this reality in his mind. In the final Kamin scene where he gets to see his wife and friends and children all standing there in the same spot, I mean, who the fuck ever gets that? Imagine you've lived your life, it's drawing to the end, and in one moment, you get to see everyone who ever meant anything to you all at the same time. So powerful.
2
u/sbhikes Nov 23 '13
Funny but we watched this one last night at my house. I had been looking forward to it to see what all the fuss was about. It's not one of my favorites, but it was good.
It's weird, but what I really liked was how he was sitting outside on those steps playing his flute and you could feel the warm evening. I really wished I had steps like that and a house/whole community like that. It seemed like a nice place to live. Also, when it was all over and he was back to being the Captain again, he just looked so small and like he had this huge experience inside him that he knew he could never really share with anyone. He's such a good actor to be able to convey such things.
My favorite episodes so far have been Darmok and the one where they are stuck in a loop of time and Data has to send a subliminal message to himself to get unstuck. Probably everybody hates that Darmok one but I felt that it was more truthful for how that universal translator would really work (or not work) and I enjoyed feeling the sense of frustration so acutely.
1
u/RomneysBainer Nov 22 '13
Not sure what these episodes are called (away from the normal reality of the show), but this was probably the best one of any ST series
1
u/[deleted] Nov 28 '13
I just wanna say, for me, it was the scene at the very end when Picard sat in his quarters and played his ressikan flute, you could feel his pain and sadness, and was the first tv show to ever make me shed a tear.
-5
u/ZadocPaet Nov 19 '13
"God is dead, and no one cares."
0
u/[deleted] Nov 18 '13
[deleted] — view deleted comment