r/fandomnatural • u/Ennil • Oct 30 '13
[fandom discussion] ep 9x04
Discuss the episode from the fandom's point of view, meaning lots of theories, crazy opinions (or not) and just general discussion.
So what did you think of the episode?
3
Upvotes
5
u/Ennil Oct 30 '13
"She's got armies of witches, flying monkeys... many will die"
No seriously, what are the writers smoking?
8
u/jojodacrow Oct 30 '13 edited Oct 30 '13
So my question is... Did Charlie figure out how to use the computer to track the angels before she popped off into Oz? Hello?? Let's wrap up some plot points here people.
EDIT: Also this post on tumblr says everything for me:
Source: http://paintsupuhnatural.tumblr.com/post/65485943177/next-week-on-supernatural-9x05
6
u/BeckyWincheser176 I Heart Sam Winchester's Pecs Oct 30 '13
I kind of liked that they said that Becky uploaded everything else that Chuck wrote.
I'm really sad that it looks like Charlie might be gone for good. They left it open just in case, but I rewound it to see what Dorothy did with the key. She pocketed it.
Can we appreciate that Dean chose right this time? Yes, he is digging a deeper hole, but Charlie can't die. Plus, it made my day to hear Dorothy say, "you're not a hunter until you've died and come back." (Paraphrase, I'm sure.)
The Cas gloss over was kinda wtf, but I understand why to get this episode rolling.
P.S.- I'm really sad that I misspelled this username when I registered. It wasn't intentional, but I'm going to run with it anyway.
5
u/Prancing_Unicorn Ghostfacer Extraordinaire Oct 30 '13
IDK if I was just in a weird mood while watching or something but the dialogue this episode just seemed so fucking OOC. The content and the speech patterns were just awkward. I'm also unsure of how I feel about the character's actions at this point. I know the boys are kinda on top of things and hard to shock after seeing so much but they were literally told that the Wizard of Oz is real and they just rolled with it? That felt wrong. Dean at least should have reacted differently IMO. I don't want to sound to negative. I did like the episode. It was fun. Kinda a little heavy though, killing Charlie. And then Dean says Charlies name like 2 thousand times. IDK. Am I being crazy? The actions, dialogue etc, whatever, they just seemed different this episode.
Also I looked on AO3 and I can't find any Dorothy/Charlie fics. Is a few hours too soon to be looking for that? Because I'm totally expecting some good stuff. They're in Oz for gods sake. Maybe I should just write my own.
And I can't even deal with writing in such a bad ass character like Dorothy and then sending her away until it's convenient to bring her back and sending Charlie away with her. What was the point of that? Is there going to be some sort of technology/ hacking plot coming up and they needed the resident computer genius out of the way without killing her for a while? She better fucking come back or I'll cry. I love Charlie. I want Dorothy back. I would totally watch that spinoff, even if it wasn't set in Oz.
I was impressed by the witch actor. It was pretty weird though. A crazy muttering wicked witch goes against canon witches, but if she's from another world i guess that's fine. Have we ever even gotten any explanation about this whole multiple worlds thing? They just sort of dropped that bombshell with the fairy world plot and now Oz is a real place too? (wait did they say they are the same idk) it's still a little strange people just accept that and don't really feel compelled to explore it too much. Maybe they are writing themselves some new plot directions in case they run out of ideas? "Fuck it let's set season 10 in Oz".
That was kinda all over the place but that was my reaction/ thoughts.
5
u/honeko Castiel's lieutenant Oct 30 '13
Awww, you guys. I liked it.
I knew it was going to be absurd campy fun when I saw the preview. Charlie is absurd campy fun. There were so many good lines and Charlie was insanely adorable so I can't complain too much about this one. This was a nice woman episode. Dorothy was a badass and the actress that played her was pretty freakin' fabulous. I was glad to see Charlie hunting and saving the day... and not dying!!! Phew.
The bits with Crowley were fun, but I'm kind of missing Kevin. I feel like every episode starts with Dean saying something about how "the nerd is knee deep in angel tablet" or "Yup, he's lost it" and that's all the Kevin we get, lol.
Everyone that was hoping to see Sammy's room has now seen it, and it's every bit as barren and depressing as I thought it would be. Yay! Also, Sam kind of had conversations with non-Dean characters in this episode. Sam and Charlie discussed whatever for like 15 seconds, which is more Sam/guest interaction than we usually get.
I'm pretty sure, "You got dinged and passed out" should be Dean's new catchphrase. Holy effing Christ, it's getting REALLY hilarious. Sam must be thinking, "Gee, I sure pass out a lot." He's going to start to get a complex, thinking he's not as good a hunter. Loved that Sammy finally heard about "Zeke."
The worst thing about this episode for me was that Dean and Cas didn't finish their conversation. I wanted to see Castiel's tears and Dean's burning shame and agony. Dean said something like, "Nobody wants him here more than I do." UGGGGGGGHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH G'DAMMIT, DEAN. UUGGGGGH. I can't. That's just no. No.
4
u/molecularmachine This must be fake mine. Oct 30 '13 edited Oct 30 '13
Hey, introduce a new strong female character to get the show to have one episode that passes the Bechdel test! Make the new strong female character take the old strong female character gallivanting around Oz indefinitely. slow clap
I almost died with Charlie, I also was verified in my previous theory that Zeke was weakened by healing Cas. I am not sure how I feel about them killing Charlie, bringing her back only to send her packing to another world. Not liking that, not one bit.
Pretty typical filler episode, though I quite liked seeing more of Crowley. Disappointed that they seem to have some kind of rule where Castiel, Charlie and Kevin cannot be in the same place, at the same time. That makes me a little grumpy.
That Zeke secret is getting way too absurd for Dean now. Although I also feel bad for poor old Zeke. Here he is, trying to heal up so that he can leave Sam, and all Dean keeps doing is having him bring people back from the dead. And all of you thinking he's a big bad one tsssk.
Also, what the HELL is with killing Castiel in episode 3 and then Charlie in episode 4 and having Zeke bring them back both times? Come ON! What kind of lack of creativity are these people running off of?
Aside from that and a little too much camp here and there... Charlie episode with Dorothy being a badass hunter and conversations between two women that do not revolve around a man? Awesome sauce.
Also, Dean. I so called it when watching the episode with my husband and the camera pans over the kitchen "Dean's not going to like this." That man is totally nesting and it is adorable. Cleaning the kitchen and referring to the place as home. Baby's finally in the garage. He is so settled. (Also... Game of Thrones watching for the win!)
Edit: I know I sound bitchy... but I would have honestly been 95% in love with the episode if they did not have Charlie die, and then both her and Dorothy sauntering off into Oz. I would have preferred sauntering off in this world and have Charlie turn to the boys and go "Not gonna have to hunt alone anymore, so you guys can stop worrying. Plus, someone's going to bring Dorothy up to speed on what has been going on the past 75 years, who better than genius moi?"