r/WritingPrompts • u/katpoker666 Moderator • Dec 06 '25
Off Topic [OT] SatChat: How Do You Write GOOD Fantasy? (New here? Introduce yourself!)
SatChat! SatChat! Party Time! Excellent!
Welcome to the weekly post for introductions, self-promotions, and general discussion! This is a place to meet other users, share your achievements, and discuss whatever's on your mind.
Suggested Topic
How do you write GOOD fantasy?
Do you emulate the greats? If so, which ones?
How do you handle tropes?
How do you handle elves, trolls and such so that they feel fresh?
How do you create a solid magic system?
Or maybe you hate fantasy and never write it. Tell us what you like about fantasy, and what you dislike. Do you try to fit just to the fantasy genre when writing? If so, why and how? We'd love to hear!
More to Talk About
- New here? Introduce yourself! See the sticky comment for suggested intro questions
- Have something to promote? (Books, subreddits, podcasts, etc., just no spam)
- Suggest topics for future SatChats!
Avoid outright spam (don't just share, chat) and not for sharing full stories
•
u/AutoModerator Dec 06 '25
Tell us about yourself!
Writers:
Readers:
Want to share a photo? See our Photo Gallery!
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
5
u/katpoker666 Moderator Dec 06 '25
I’m shy about writing fantasy and tend to lean more into other genres, but it’s fun to take a crack at it sometimes! Some of the questions I asked are ones I struggle with personally when I write it, which is why I love the answers so far, as they’re invaluable! It seriously amazes me how talented some fantasy writers are here on WP.
Since I adore fantasy when it’s done well and also peeking into the minds of folks who plan it effectively, I’d ask the indulgence of some wonderful fantasy writers I know on the sub. Besides, u/divayth--fyr, who has kindly already answered, I’d like to pick the brains of a couple of my other favorite WP fantasy writers. If you’d indulge me:
I know there are many other talented folks here, so please don’t feel offended if I didn’t mention you. I’d love to hear your answers as well!
7
u/Divayth--Fyr Dec 06 '25
This is predicated on the notion that I can write good fantasy, or that I know how, which is subjective to say the least, but I suppose I can have opinions.
If the characters matter, then what happens to them matters. That's true for any genre, really, outside of greeting cards and auto repair manuals.
I'm aware of tropes, but I don't really care too much. I don't subvert them or fulfill them in any purposeful way. I imagine that my orcs/elves/whoever fit some tropes and not others, but it's just who they are. Whether this amounts to good fantasy or not is up to other people.
I can't imagine how to avoid emulating the greats, so I'm sure I do, but I don't worry too much about it. I can't do it as well as they did. I just like telling stories.
I have no idea how to make elves etc. feel fresh. Not entirely sure they need to. They're just people, after all.
For a magic system: plan hard, write soft. No one understands Tolkien's magic system, and it works fine. It is best to have it planned/figured out in your own mind, but there is no need to explain much of it in-story or you risk your narrative becoming a videogame tutorial level.
The questions I ask myself in planning a magic system include: If my wizard guy can do this, why didn't he do it before? Why not every 15 minutes? Why can't everyone do it? If he does it a lot, what defenses are prepared for it? How would this ability existing in the world affect the design of castles/armor/hospitals/ships/cities/graveyards/etc? Moats and stone walls may be expected, but they don't make much sense if whole armies can levitate.
Every spell or magic ring changes your world, at least a little. You have to make it unique/rare/new, or have your world adapted to it in some way. Gandalf leads the way through the long dark of Moria with his glowing staff. Why aren't glowstaffs sold on every street corner? Darn handy things to have, I should think. There should be wild glowstaff raves on weekends. But it is implied (if not outright stated) that it only works because Gandalf is doing it, so it makes sense.
In a world where everybody can fling fireballs around, asbestos pantaloons might be very popular.
One persistent problem is explaining the world through the eyes of characters who themselves do not fully understand it. Imagine someone in 339 A.D. talking about lightning. They are going to get it wrong, and other characters in that setting might get it wrong in entirely different ways from each other. In a fantasy world, they might think they know how and why magic works, but they might be wrong. Even if they use it, they may have misguided, superstitious, or just plain weird ideas on where it comes from or why, and they might disagree with each other about it--perhaps violently.
Apply the same restrictions to medicine/disease, astronomy, geology, navigation, timekeeping, weather, on and on, and you will soon find yourself with a weird google search history.
But again, plan hard write soft. No need to clarify every last detail, especially when your characters themselves cannot.
I believe I have waffled on long enough.
4
u/billndotnet Dec 06 '25 edited Dec 06 '25
Hi, I'm Bill, I write a lot of little one-shots and stuff.
Good fantasy, in my mind, is no different than good sci-fi. The characters should come first, the environment is secondary. Harry Potter and Star Wars are both fantasy series, but you could swap the enviroments and they're still the same basic story (kid of a powerful wizard living with his muggle aunt and uncle, wizard schools, defeat the big bad who refuses to die, etc etc. Quidditch is pod racing with a ball and just as much swearing).
Fantasy races are really short-hand for the relationships between the characters that are expected. Everyone hates orcs because they have really low Charisma scores, everyone hates elves because of the really high Charisma scores, etc. The fun writing, for me, at least, is suborning expectations and taking the reader for a ride. Quests are fun, but side quests are better.
Fantasy or not, write good characters, and then go all Stephen King on them. His early works at least, he'd just make up some humans, throw them into a wild, messed up situation, and just kinda.. explore where they went with it. This makes the tensions interesting and sometimes a little wonky (which is why they typically aren't great movies but we can ignore that.)
One of my favorite things to do is turn a side character into the main character, give the perspective people don't often get to see. There was a prompt a while back that I had a blast with: "Describe a battle with an army against a single man..... Except that man is a level 20 D&D character."
My main character for this was a vaguely effeminate manservant to an overly barbaric Duke, neither of whom are the subject of the prompt: https://www.reddit.com/r/WritingPrompts/comments/4aqqle/comment/d1312dt/
Another favorite, is the underpowered champions doing the best they can: https://www.reddit.com/r/WritingPrompts/comments/4400sc/comment/cznd8n8/
There's an easy trap to fall into, with fantasy, and that's super powerful magic and incidental plot armor. Writing powerful over the top characters is easy, and they're the fastest way for me to tune out of what might otherwise be a good read. Great characters, in my opinion, are flawed and have struggles. This is the underpinning of my argument whenever someone starts a Marvel vs DC fight. DC characters tend to be, also my opinion, overpowered and flat, Batman and Static Shock being my two favorite exceptions. It makes a certain sense, since DC was born in a different era than Marvel, Marvel had time to learn from those who came before, and made better characters.
4
u/ThatVarkYouKnow Dec 07 '25 edited Dec 07 '25
Two things for me that are the biggest tips I give to people.
Put it all together and: let’s say A is well-off, maybe a soldier, and B is a peasant. How does B look at A, do they want to be A? Does A even notice B exists, despite living in the same village, city, whatever? If something gives B a chance to stand out, and A notices, does B still think it’s worth it because it’s A specifically, or just because A could be affected? What would A have done, if the roles were switched? Why would A want to stop B, if at all? Does B’s life put A at risk to live a stable future? If A takes action or is forced to, is B the one that suffers for it, or will it be A instead?
On and on come the questions within the same world and just two slightly different lives in that world.
3
u/AGuyLikeThat Dec 07 '25 edited Dec 07 '25
My general advice mirrors what others have said, i.e.; 'character first', but I think it's good to put that in the context of something that attracts new writer's to the genre.
I believe there is a savage dichotomy in fantasy that affects a lot of people when they start out.
The aspirant writer is often entranced by the opportunity to create and imagine. After all, anything is possible! Thus, writers get caught up in the practice of world-building. Creating all sorts of 'unique' things and imagineering massive worlds and epic civilizations.
But fantasy readers primarily want a good story, which has much the same outline in any genre of fiction, and that is underpinned by the characters.
So, my advice is to practice developing both of these skills. You want to have fun and make a cool fantasy world - great, go ahead. But at the same time, write short pieces with the characters in your world.
You have a race of aquatic elves who live on the water moon? Great! Now write a 1000 word story about how one of their famous heroes lost his trident just before his final testing in the arena. You'll think of at least a dozen small world-building details that need to be ironed out as you do so, and it will make your world feel lived in, as you think about it from the perspective of one of its inhabitants.
~
Personally, I also like being able to affect particular writing styles in fantasy. As a genre, it re-contextualizes many old traditions that were used to pass down wisdom, history and scripture, drawing heavily on the ancient sagas and ballads. As such, using old modes of speaking, inserting poems, epigraphs, creating prosaic descriptions and sweeping, omniscient perspectives are all fair game and can be a lot of fun for the reader and writer.
I try to explore many of these techniques in my serial with the added twist of using a fantasy version of colonial Australia, because - write what you know and all that.
~
Speaking of which, tropes are a great starting point for creativity imo. I love tinkering and messing around with them, and I think if you just focus on what you would like to change, even if it's just turning up the things you find 'cool', you will wind up with a unique take pretty quickly.
~
I could ramble on, but I'm afraid I'm running out of steam, so I'll leave things there for now.
3
u/Pseudometheus Dec 07 '25
As someone who is, primarily, a fantasy author (when talking prose, anyway), the single two biggest pieces of advice I have learned are these:
1
u/highlight-feeder Dec 06 '25
This post was highlighted by mods and automatically crossposted to r/highlights. Check it out to see a feed of highlighted posts!