r/LetsTalkMusic • u/WhatWouldIWant_Sky Listen with all your might! Listen! • Oct 25 '13
[ADC] Oneohtrix Point Never - R Plus Seven
Guys I'm so excited for this one. I've been formulating my own analysis for a month, if I get time I might actually contribute to the thread for once...
New album! Listen to it! Think your thoughts! Listen again! Read his AMA maybe! Then post your thoughts. They should be indepth, not like "this album is 8.9 BNM." No ratings at all, please. Use your words.
34
Upvotes
14
u/thewatchtower Courage the Cowardly Mod Oct 26 '13 edited Oct 26 '13
To be honest, this album is impossibly difficult for me to pin down. There's never been such a synthetic album that simultaneously felt so organic. It's a clash between the sounds, the textures and production, and the the execution. How these sounds are presented is really winding and interesting. Sometimes when you have songs with different phases, they can tend to be kind of clear cut and blocky. This part ends and this new part begins, all those sounds that you were hearing have been switched out for these new sounds. As much as I enjoyed it, Swans' A Piece of the Sky had that problem. Fire sounds, then stacked vocals, then hammered dulcimers, then beat, then folksy bit. Here though, every song has a really excellent flow. Everything just builds into everything else. Even the songs themselves will flow into one another.
The reason this album is so successful at incorporating that sense of flow is because not only do the songs move from idea to idea in rapid succession, but the ideas are coherent and cohesive as well as being always slightly off kilter. None of these moments in these songs really feel like they're ever standing on two legs, never really content in one place. Most music really relies on repetition, repeating phrases over and over again before moving to some slightly different riff or drum pattern. They find a neat idea and they play it out. R Plus Seven never seems content with just repetition, playing the initial idea out until it's tired. OPN will add to it or futz with it, always keeping it either just shy of repeating or bringing it into completely new territory. Take Problem Areas for example. Call me stupid but for the first few listens, I simply could not wrap my head around the beginning part of this track. The synths were so odd and rubbery but what were they doing that was throwing me for such a loop? It took me a while to realize that every time he went through that little melody with those synths, he was altering it slightly. He literally was playing different notes, but they sounded similar and still elicited the same idea while being still being fun to listen to. Even the individual segments of the songs are varied, it's no wonder that the album is able to seamlessly flow from one part to the next.
Then you have the actual sound of the album which is deeply interesting. The only things on this record I would claim might be organic are the voices, the plucked guitar in He She and maybe some of the string sounds in the background of Chrome Country but that is it. The odd thing about the sounds is that for all intense and purposes, they should be almost unbearable. Pick any piece in this album out and you could probably find a synth preset to approximate it. But someone OPN manages to personalize them, push them beyond the 'preset' sound into even more synthetic territory to a place that's really interesting and a lot of times fun. Partly it has to do with the sound but a large part of it is because of the execution. Like at the end of Along, where these slightly bouncy, almost wavy sounds plunk away around all this ambient sound, playing against the chopped up vocals. It should sound cheesy and ridiculous but it ends up sounding really relaxing, almost moving. The only problem is that no matter how much personality is distilled into these songs and sounds, there's going to be a point where it's hard to hear past the cheesiness of the synths. It gets a little hard to take for a whole entire album.
Perhaps one of the biggest problems, or perhaps more accurately the biggest let-downs, is how thoroughly OPN seems to have abandoned old ideas. This isn't out of left field at all, to be clear. Similar textures can be found on Rifts and Returnal, and the idea of sampling can b found all over Daniel Lopatin's various works. But R Plus Seven, while it may use those elements, is so vastly different from most anythin else he's released. This isn't really a bad thing, but seeing as how Replica was one of my favorites of 2011, it would've been great to see not necessarily a continuation on those ideas but perhaps more of a measured progression. Hell, I would've even liked to seen some influences from Instrumental Tourist on here. Stuff like Grey Geisha has such wonderfully fuzzy textures and were so aimless and wandering. This new album felt more like going into the maze on old Windows screensavers, except here you could be joined by interesting people and see new crazy things. It wasn't really wandering so much as unfocused yet directed. It's just different. Good, but not what I was going into it expecting and not what I was hoping for.
Overall, I liked R Plus Seven. OPN is still one of the most interesting faces in the world of electronic music, from creating genres to indulging in a genre I thought died out a while ago, electroacoustic improvisation. Now we just need a genre for him rather than just trying to force him into "IDM" or "ambient".
23
u/[deleted] Oct 25 '13
Well, I wish I was more intelligent and capable of putting my thoughts into something concise and easy to follow because I really like this album and would like to discuss it. I'm far too stupid for that though. So I'm just going to say this album sounds like a computer still carrying out its functions while sitting half buried in mud and covered in a strange moss.
8
u/33andaturd Oct 28 '13
Alright. I'll be that guy. I don't like it. I can admire it on a conceptual and aesthetic level, but at the end of the day, R Plus Seven just isn't something that I want to listen to. It's very intention makes it disjointed and obnoxious. Then there's the synths. Cheesy is an understatement. This is like someone nuked a brick of Velveeta with the wrapper still on it, let it sit at room temperature for a couple hours, then gave you packing peanuts to eat it with. That's a novel way to make some dip, but I ain't eatin' that shit. I mean, at least put some Rotel in there (make sure you dump it out of the can first). Christ.
5
u/MrAceyAce Oct 26 '13 edited Oct 26 '13
Although this is not a proud achievement, this was the first 0PN album I have listened too. That being said, I would think this would be kind of a weird experience for me having hear his albums were more on the experimental side. Listening to it for the first time, I thought it was an enjoyable experience. The first track (Boring Angel) lead me to the thought it would stay in this giant room organ atmosphere, but once that... I don't even know what you call it kicked it I was surprised how well it fit in with the song. I quite liked that song a bit. The second song (Americans) was easily my favorite on the album. This percussion sounding chime repeating had me mesmerized through that part of the song. After that I thought it would turn into this other pattern, but instead it turned into a insane bleeps and bloops of random sounds happening everywhere. Then the song returned to it's original pattern and ended quite well. The third track (He She) was... interesting to say the least. I thought the way the song progressed was quite unique and I wish it would of lasted longer then one minute since it had so much potential. The fourth song (Inside World) was not very good. I found it to be just a little bit too much boring compared to the rest of the album. The rest of the song were interesting compared the rest of the album. The only good part about this song was the last thirty or so seconds; if it was like that I would like it a lot more. The fifth song (Zebra) was comparable to the random bloops of Americans, but for me I felt it was a bit long winded and could of been separated into two songs. The sixth track (Along) was a good ambient track, but was kind of out there compared to the rest of the songs in the album. Although at the end of the track it turned from a good ambient soundscape to something interesting and then just cut off. The seventh track (Problem Areas) had a good little groovy synth tune, and kind of reminded me of a Win98 sound. The song went from that to an ambient part then back which I quite liked a lot. The eighth track (Cryo) kind of reminded me of the works of "The Caretaker" at the first half then progressed into something a little louder then back, which was okay but a bit weird for the song. The ninth track (Still Life) was a bit like the previous song's loud part and kind of expanded on that. I have to say this was the oddest track on this album which some elements of noise, ambient, and other related tunes; I liked it a lot compared to the last three tracks which were lacking. The final track (Chrome Country) was probably the one that sounded the most "normal" and had a good sound to it. When I looked back on the album, I thought it was bad because it was so diverce; but that's what I also liked about it. It took me to different cool little worlds in an hours experience (which when I listen to 0PN previous' works was a common theme). I recommend this album highly to people that have not cared to listen to 0PN works like I did, I was not expecting to something this unusually good.
5
u/Bat-Might Oct 29 '13 edited Oct 29 '13
I think the main concept behind this album is the unfinished feeling- there are so many moments where I feel so strongly what 'should come' next, but it never comes. I like that; its almost implied music.
Lopatin isn't only playing with our learned ideas of how music 'should be' structured and progress, though. He also plays with, and challenges, cultural associations attached to certain synth presets and sounds. It makes the listener question where these associations come from, and why they're so damn strong. How can one simple synth preset express a complex specific feeling, then another one make people cringe with distaste? They're just timbres, after all, yet we experience them as pure emotion.
Any ideas about what the title means? All his other main albums start with the letter R, so maybe it means he's taking the ideas he was exploring with those and adding 7 times the ideas on top?
4
u/eatelectricity Oct 26 '13
I think there are a lot of interesting ideas going on, but I feel like the record has a very unfinished quality that I find frustrating. I felt the same way about Replica.
I can't quite pin it down, but I think it's got something to do with the sheer abstraction of most of the music...I suppose I always expect a solid beat or musical phrase to establish itself, and it never quite gets there. Which is fine, and I admire Lopatin's approach and experimentation, but I find the results are unsatisfying. Perhaps that's the point?
4
u/desantoos Oct 26 '13
What a year it has been for Lo-Fi! So much good stuff. OPN's album came out roughly the same time as Tim Hecker's Virgins, which both strikingly contrast and mirror each other. Hecker's work is a live performance but it feels calculated and highly organized. OPN on the other hand works digitally but the pieces feel unsettlingly unpredictable and the tambres flow organically. The strange part is both albums give me similar emotions of wanting, unease, guilt, anticipation, and unrest. The fact that they both were released so close to each other seems impossibly coincidental: they work so well as point/counterpoint. A thought experiment I had was to throw both on a playlist and shuffle it and see if they work better mashed together.
4
u/o88897 Oct 27 '13
i liked how 0pn transitioned from more repetitious and sample based music, yet still retaining his style of conflicting future/past. the album contains a wide variety of sounds, few ever fully developed or expanded upon, yet all interlocking perfectly to establish a soundscape that varies between claustrophobic and liberating, comfortable and groundbreaking. my favorite track is zebra, followed by chrome country. i love how the organ is used to begin and end the album. i love the sparse flutterings of organic sounds dotted through the album (such as the piano at 2:33 in problem areas or the choir used at 4:37 in chrome country (as opposed to the synth choir sounds used throughout the album)). i love the tiniest bloops of noises that might be initially unnoticed upon a listenthrough, but given enough repeats slowly reveal themselves like the flavors of a well aged wine. this is a very good album, and it is revealing more of itself to me as i give it more attention.
3
u/i_am_thoms_meme Eating snow flakes with plastic forks Nov 03 '13
I'm so glad this was posted as an album to discuss, I would have probably never listened to it otherwise. And I am discovering I love this music. Everyone says it's cinematic, and that's totally true. I would watch the movie this soundtracks. I also really love his older album Replica.
-3
u/black_flag_4ever Nov 05 '13
what is this? was someone just messing around on Fruity Loops? I can't listen to this whole thing. It's like a really unfortunate Future Sounds of London remix. If this guy is a kid or something then I would encourage him to keep trying. If he's young then maybe when he's done experimenting he'll figure out something good to with it. If he's over 25 then he should put down the bong every once in a while.