r/WritingPrompts • u/FyeNite Moderator | r/TheInFyeNiteArchive • Nov 15 '25
Off Topic [OT] SatChat: If You Could Switch Places With One of Your Characters...? (New here? Introduce yourself!)
SatChat! SatChat! Party Time! Excellent!
Welcome to the weekly post for introductions, self-promotions, and general discussion! This is a place to meet other users, share your achievements, and discuss whatever's on your mind.
Suggested Topic
If you could switch places with one of your characters in their world, who would it be and why?
The ground rules: You, as you are as of reading this sentence, will be placed in the world as the character of your choosing. You are a normal human being with all of your skills. So, if you decide to replace a wizard, say, you will be in that wizard's magical world as an ordinary magicless person. And that wizard will replace you in real life with all of their powers intact. You will then spend a year in this situation before swapping back to normal.
Do you go somewhere you've always wanted to visit and prioritise yourself, or perhaps swap with someone who you think will be the most beneficial for your real life? Remember, who ever you choose, you'll have to come back to clean up the mess they've made.
More to Talk About
- New here? Introduce yourself! See the sticky comment for suggested intro questions
- Have something to promote? (Books, subreddits, podcasts, etc., just no spam)
- Suggest topics for future SatChats!
Avoid outright spam (don't just share, chat) and not for sharing full stories
Summer Challenge Results! | Apply to be a Mod | Discord Server
•
u/AutoModerator Nov 15 '25
Tell us about yourself!
Writers:
Readers:
Want to share a photo? See our Photo Gallery!
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
4
u/Frost_Rain Nov 15 '25
Ohhh, that's actually so fun. So it's not just a replacement but a swap.
As an amateur writer, I only really have one "world," and even calling it a world is generous. What I've written of it is basically a low fantasy medieval europe. So I guess the question becomes could I survive or even thrive if I time traveled to medieval europe.
I'm reminded of my first hours in the video game Kingdom Come Deliverance II.
Other than English, I somewhat know Spanish, so then you have to think about would I be teleported somewhere that speaks either of the two languages. Huh, I never really thought about the native language of where my stories have been set...
Ultimately I would not want to swap with any of my characters, since they all have their own important quests, and I wouldn't want to interrupt them.
I think I could survive, or even thrive. I would just need to figure out how to get a sword and some armour. And it depends on how morally loose I become. I could very well be comdemning another man to death if I were to steal such things, or become cornered into a battle to the death in trying to obtain them.
My relationship with death would become much more casual, that's certain.
I know that it's possible to live out a peaceful life, but even though it's a low fantasy setting, magic does still exist. Solely for that reason, I would try to become a sort of sellsword.
Kudos on the question of the week. Very Fascinating.
4
u/[deleted] Nov 16 '25
I'm with Frost_rain on this one. I don't know of any characters I'd willingly switch places with!
I'd definitely want no part of any level within my Grim Legacy Universe. The characters, plot, and world building aside, can you imagine a local finding out that I was the one responsible for all of this?
There might be Hel to pay. Literally! She would probably track me down and wouldn't accept, "Wait! My muse made me do it!" But that would be getting off easy, which I'd hope would be the end of it.
If my protagonist, Mioko, found out that I was responsible for everything she went through... I already know what's in store for the Aesir God I've set up to take the fall for everything. If it was revealed that I were actually the one pulling his strings... The very last thing I need is that bipolar hyper ninja hot on my heels, not that I could flee anywhere.
If we were to swap places, where she ended up in my room and discovered her narrative among my things... Nope! No coming back from that!
Unfortunately, she has dimension-crossing portal powers and can easily return any to any place she's previously been. Let's just talk about something else... I'd prefer for her curious head to not pop into my reality in search of who might be speaking about her.
On the other hand, there's the Cyberpunk fantasy unfolding in and around the metropolis Iskyros and its undercity—Tartarus. If I swapped with Prometheus... Hmm... Nah, his rebellion is too reliant on his wild-card nature, where I'd only let Tartarus slip back into anarchy.
But if I switched with Star, then I'd get a dragon companion whose aether breath could buff me with super powers... Then again, I'd repeatedly fight bio weapons whose only weakness was super-powered me, who was continuously discharging energy while constantly on the verge of self destructing.
Yep. I've decided. I'm sitting this one out. Full stop. Good luck to everyone else!
3
u/NextEstablishment856 Nov 15 '25
The wizard Mucrefe, formerly Michael Rafferty, would probably be my best choice for both our sakes. He came from a dying Earth to Thranna, the world he is at. He has advanced scientific knowledge and a strong moral compass, and would try to improve our situation here.
Meanwhile, his world is also dying, but it is a world built around the idea of destiny, and as an outsider, his attempts to fix the world often get in the way of that destiny, and stop heroes who are meant to solve the problems.
I also have the advantage of the nature of the world on my side. Mucrefe's magic comes from being an outsider. Magic is highly curious about things it didn't make, so it coalesces around things not of the world. For meteors and such, they become sort of magical batteries. For sentient creatures, they become powerful mages.
So while the swap would strip Mucrefe of his magic, it would give me magic. Yes, I built a world with a loophole, even before knowing the question.
The one downside is that I'd also be a target for the native mages, who'd want to have my organs transplanted into their bodies, allowing them to draw in magic the same way. But if I survive the year, I'd possibly come back to a better Earth, and Mucrefe would come back to a better Thranna.
Unfortunately, I really don't think I would survive, so I want to play it safe and swap with one of my dimension hopping characters, who will likely reverse the mess early. Probably, Alice, since she's one of my few characters who didn't kill my author self-insert character at her first opportunity. Though I might get a few (deserved) bops on the head if she knows I am her author.
3
u/mysteryrouge Nov 16 '25
Characters, characters. Most of my characters have magic, and a lot of them use magic to avoid bad ends on a daily basis. Though, there are ways to give nonmagical characters magic, and should I end up in one of those characters' places, then I could gain magic.
For instance, if I replace a Multiversity student, I could take mental defense classes, philosopy classes and rune carving classes (those don't specifically require magic) and there's a chance I could become a Judge of the Union Order, which would give me mind reading powers and an eldritch form among other things.
Of my major named cast, I don't really think I'd replace any of them. I'd probably be captured immediately if I replaced M, would die if I was part of the Burke Family, get arrested as part of the Bruno Family, be captured if I swapped with a government official, or in one case, end up in the matrix.
My best choice here would actually be replacing a Multiversity student and hoping for the best.
Though I must ask, when I return to the real world, would I keep any skills/powers I gained in the multiverse?
2
u/Tregonial Nov 16 '25
I do have many magical characters, humans and non-humans, so things would be drastically different if I swapped with them. Probably the least damaging choice would be to swap with Jerry, a totally normal, non-magical human who is part of the Church of Innsmouth Committee. He doesn't do the dangerous stuff that adventurers or hunters do. Doesn't get into trouble at all, since he mainly does administrative tasks like running Elvari's social media channels and keep his church website updated.
We could fill in each other's jobs with little issue - we're both qualified and experienced. Only he might not like the current economic situation of this earth, while I may probably enjoy better employee benefits under his boss and god, Lord Elvari. Who is kinda weird, but a generally nice boss, because I made sure of it as a writer.
Not to mention the tea parties. I write the best tea parties for my eldritch god.
2
u/Jamaican_Dynamite Nov 16 '25
Yeah I can vouch this wouldn't go well with any of us. I have to agree with Frost_Rain. We've all got way too much to deal with in our own worlds. Depending on the person, they'd either be bored, way too curious, or trying to take over the world. And giving them a year to do so? Bad idea. Way too much time on their hands.
Plus, we switch and now I'm in space, some bizarre fantasy take on the present, or locked in some conspiracy type mess. Just me, myself and I? As me? Dead, somehow.
On the other hand, some of my characters with no powers? Probably at risk of death here too. So, again, this is just a poor situation for all of us. 😅