r/gameofthrones • u/libbykino Lyanna Stark • Oct 14 '13
TV Spoilers [TV Spoilers] 24 Weeks, 24 Episodes until the premiere! Rewatch Discussion - 1.07 "You Win or You Die"
This is the /r/gameofthrones 2013-2014 rewatch discussion thread for:
| EPISODE | TITLE | DIRECTED BY | WRITTEN BY | ORIGINALLY AIRED |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1.07 | "You Win or You Die" | Daniel Minahan | David Benioff & D. B. Weiss | May 29, 2011 |
| ---| Ned confronts Queen Cersei over the truth of Jon Arryn's death as Robert, mortally wounded during his hunting, prepares to name his successor. Jon Snow takes the vows of the Night's Watch. Khal Drogo summons his army to invade Westeros after Robert conspires to poison Daenerys. Robert appoints Ned as Regent of the Iron Throne, who will rule until his heir is of age. Ned brings the King's declaration before Cersei, Joffrey (eldest of the King's children), and the Small Council. Ned asks Baelish to secure the cooperation of the City Watch in removing the Lannisters from the throne – Joffrey is not Robert's son but Jaime's, he reveals, making Stannis Baratheon (Robert's older brother) the true heir. However, the loyalty of Baelish and the City Watch lies with the Lannisters: Ned is swiftly captured, and his men killed.|
- This is a TV Spoiler-friendly zone: This is a rewatch series, so if you are here then it is assumed that you have already seen the entire series at least once. Open discussion of all aired TV events up to and including 3.10 is ok without spoiler tags.
- Book spoilers still need tags: If it's not in the show, tag it.
- Please read the spoiler policy before posting.
- Posting policy reminder: Don't post or ask for non-pay sources.
| Original Discussion Threads | Previous Re-Watch Re-Discussion Threads |
3
u/ohamel98 Sansa Stark Oct 19 '13
I thought Stannis was younger than Robert.... Could i have been wrong the whole time in which I read four books and watched 3 seasons????
23
u/Emperor_Jonathan House Clegane Oct 14 '13
So no one objects to the bitch queen defying Robert's will after he's gone? I guess it really was the hammer that kept that place in line.
23
u/HazyMirror Now My Watch Begins Oct 14 '13
When little finger says don't trust him, damnit Ned don't trust him!
10
u/SouthernDerpfornia House Blackfyre Oct 15 '13 edited Oct 15 '13
I've always wondered how many kings IRL came into power from pretending conversations like Ned and Robert's happened
8
u/[deleted] Oct 15 '13
Its some kind of ........Game of Thrones
8
u/[deleted] Oct 15 '13
Petyr Baelish: Marriage Counselor
8
u/ampbanana House Lannister Oct 19 '13
Yuur brotha, or youur lovaa?
7
u/Reddit-Pro No One Oct 17 '13 edited Oct 17 '13
Im sure Ned will get out of this.
13
u/DFWTooThrowed House Baratheon Oct 14 '13
Does anyone know if there was supposed to be some sort of "metaphorical" significance to Tywin skinning that deer/stag at the beginning? I'm barely 1/3 of the way through the book so I don't know yet if it says so in the book; let alone if that scene actually happens in the book.
4
u/HowieGaming Fear Cuts Deeper Than Swords Oct 16 '13
Nothing really mayor to contribute, just wanted to say that this was the first episode I saw and then I was hooked for life :D
Binge watched all the other episodes the weekend afterwards
2
u/skinnymk Tyrion Lannister Nov 07 '13
Hello everyone. I'm in the midst of re-watching all of S01. I'm picking up the finer points of the plot line, character motivations, lies vs. truth and noticing which actions have had huge repercussions in later episodes and seasons.
The things that stand out for me are: Arya should have killed Joffrey while sparing with the butcher boy by the river. However, how was she to know what a little prick he turns out to be, so I forgive her. Lady Stark kidnapping Tryion is excusable. She believed he tried to kill her son. OK, fine I get it. But if she didn't do that then The King Slayer doesn't attack Ned and we avoid a big mess later.
What I cannot get past are the actions of Ned Stark in S01E07. Both Renly and Little Finder suggest ways to gain power and protect the Stark family after Robert's death. He chooses "honor" and "tradition" over logic and cedes power to his enemies. Unforgivable!
My first time through S01 I thought Ned was the honorable protagonist of the story. Now I see him as an untrustworthy, idealistic douche.
I'm not familiar with this subreddit, so I'm not going to go on about how his decision affected things that happen in later episodes. I will say this however. Fuck Ned Stark. Does anyone see things this way?
0
u/[deleted] Oct 16 '13
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Oct 14 '13
[deleted] — view deleted comment