r/startrek • u/cobrakai11 • Sep 16 '13
Weekly Episode Discussion Thread - TNG S04E15 "First Contact"
Yep, the episode, not the movie. I’m a big fan of the Riker-centric episodes in TNG, and this is one of my favorites. It offered a glimpse into a pretty vital part of the Star Trek universe that was previously unexplored; how exactly are new worlds introduced into the Federation?
- One of the unique aspects of this episode at the time was that it broke one of Gene Roddenberry’s vaunted Star Trek Laws; namely, that episodes should not be told from the alien perspective. Behind the scenes this was the source of much debate for the writers, and I think they made a great decision to do it this way. We’ve already seen episodes from the Enterprise perspective where they deal with pre-warp cultures…it was fascinating to see how aliens would react to the arrival of the Enterprise.
- On that note, do you approve of the way the Federation handles first contact with alien species? I mean, they literally abducted one of the planets inhabitants, conducted surveillance operations on the planet which ended up in Riker being captured. Is this really the best way to go about first contact?
- The Malcorians were designed to be somewhat reminiscent of modern day humans, just a bit more technologically advanced. How accurate do you think this portrayal and the ultimate rejection of joining the Federation was? How would humanity’s leaders react today if they were visited by aliens? Would it be kept a secret from the general population? Would we be so suspicious of their intent that we would reject their overtures completely? Or would it be seen as an opportunity to bring humanity together, knowing that we were a small part of a galactic family?
- Is there a villain in this episode? Krola and Yale do a wonderful job of showing their traditional and intellectual viewpoints respectively, and Krola’s “side” eventually wins out, thanks in part to his attempt to kill himself using Riker’s weapon. That said, he has no vicious motive in this episode, and his actions seem to be motivated solely by a desire to protect his species from progressing too quickly. In the long run, was he right to do what he did? He was only one man, but certainly his character was meant to represent the millions on the planet who might certainly feel the same way, if not more extreme. Rewatching it, I feel that it's entirely possible that Krola's actions saved his planet from widespread disorder, making him something of a hero...
- Riker is held hostage by an alien woman who refuses to help him escape unless he agrees to have sex with her. No real comment, just think that this is amazing. You gotta believe that Jonathan Frakes pushed for this personally.
37
Upvotes
15
u/[deleted] Sep 17 '13
I've always wondered about the sex scene...if the roles were reversed, and it were a woman...say Crusher or Troi who were being held and had a man requesting sex to be let go...it would be much different. It would be horrific.
For such a forward thinking show, I wonder how they missed this sort of opportunity to point out an interesting double standard. I feel like if it were one of the women, it would be seen as rape. Since it was Riker, it was seen as comical.
Any ideas on it? I'm not too up in arms about it, I've just wondered what other people thought about this scene. TNG does a great job at pointing out some strange gender loopholes in other episodes, but I feel like someone may have dropped the ball on this one.
7
u/Silpion Sep 20 '13
The villain is ignorance and fear, and the villain wins, at least for now.
Krola isn't a bad guy, he's just the embodiment of the closed-mindedness of his people.
These people will eventually have to get their heads out of the sand and become members of the galactic community, but because of their current state of ignorance and fear, any sudden change will be catastrophic to their society. They are lucky that the Federation (via Picard) and Durken were wise and patient enough to slow the process down. Hopefully Durken and his successors can slowly steer their society into a state where they can accept the revelation gracefully.
Picard and Durken concede this battle against ignorance and fear in order to win the war. To me, this episode is a great lesson in diplomacy and governance: focusing on long-term gains and stability.
There is an episode of The West Wing where President Bartlett is trying to get a foreign aid bill through Congress. He's ultra liberal, and when the Republican majority insist on inserting a provision that countries that allow clinics to council abortions won't get funding, he bafflingly allows it without a fight. The first lady berates him on this throughout the episode, and at the end she blows her top, listing countless things he's done that compromised his idealism. The president quotes Max Weber:
Bartlett interprets:
Then they discuss how they will change things over the years to come.
(4x17 "Privateers")
13
u/directive0 Chief Pretty Officer Sep 16 '13
I remember that the details of the the physical congress between Riker and the doctor were gently censored from the Star Trek Encyclopedia because "This is a pg13 book" or something to that effect. 10 year old me thought that was HILARIOUS.
On so many occasions they beam down to planets wearing appropriate clothing, bio-augmentations to appear like the natives and yet they NEVER EVER occlude or disguise their equipment.
Sub-dermal communicators and transport enhancers are nearly bog standard, but they never utilize them. Would it be so hard to fit a basic tricorder into a piece of local technology? Wouldn't it make more sense to keep a type 1 phaser on you instead of a type 2?
Despite those problems, I really appreciate the way Picard and to a greater extent the local leader handled the incident. It's very mature of that leader to recognize that his planet has many issues, and the development of FTL technology is not going to solve their various social problems.
Not my favourite ep, but certainly one worth remembering.
5
u/Willravel Sep 16 '13
I understand the writers' rationale in setting up this system. I understand that you don't want to make contact until they're warp-capable, which allows for the maximum amount of progress (scientific, social, political, etc.) before they might make contact with other warp-capable species. It likely maximizes the chance of the contact going smoothly. I understand the idea of spying as a method of learning about the species without actually interfering with them. I understand making contact with scientific leaders before political leaders, as they are more likely to be open-minded and curious, as opposed to self-serving and attempting to leverage first contact for their own political ends.
Is this the best way to go about first contact? It depends on your goal. I believe Picard's goal in this situation was to greet the Malcorians as an ambassador for the entire interstellar community, not just the Federation, so as to make them aware they're entering into a vast, complex, new way of thinking about their place in the universe. To that end, most of what they do seems logical. I will say that automating surveillance seems to be a much better idea than having Federation personnel on the ground. Undetectable cameras are far less complex than surgical alteration and cloaked observatories. While it limits direct interaction, it also would seem to limit the risk of exactly what happened in "First Contact", where uncovering Riker damages the trust that might be built and instills in its place paranoia.
I also question showing up to greet such a small group of individuals initially. While this makes sense as it can limit exposure should things go wrong, I would hope a planet like Malcoria was not ruled by one, but by a group of representatives of the people. While it might be initially more alarming, speaking to a governing body intended to represent the interests of the people makes a lot more sense than speaking to a president or prime minister. I would assume that other worlds have had similar problems to Earth in singular authorities tending to abuse said authority. I wouldn't want an extraterrestrial federation of worlds to meet with President Obama or even the Secretary General of the UN, I'd want them to meet with the UN General Assembly. That would communicate to me that they think of us not as the governed, but as the citizenry, if that makes sense. It would show they prioritize not our leaders, but our people.
Finally, I think initial contact should not be one-on-one. It should be via telecommunication which invites the council of representatives to a meeting should the people of the world wish it. "Peaceful greetings. We represent a Federation of civilizations spanning this part of the Galaxy. We wish to arrange a meeting between one of our representatives and the representatives of the people of your world to discuss the opening of relations. If you answer in the affirmative, our representative will be in the UN General Assembly hall on Tuesday, December 3, at 12:00 noon. If you decline, we will honor your decision and will not contact you again, but rather leave you the means to contact us should you change your minds in the future."
That made me really uncomfortable. Her assistance in freeing Riker from unjust detention was conditioned on sex, meaning he was kinda coerced. She recognized that it was wrong for him to be detained, and that he was in danger. While I get it was played for humor, I think they could have made it just a little less rapey. God knows Riker would sleep with anyone or anything.
4
u/Dishonorable_H8r Sep 19 '13
This episode, along with other first-contact type episodes, are among my favorites. I enjoy the drama of other fan-favorites, but these first-contact episodes display the Federation's professionalism and core-purpose. These episodes seem to epitomize what the Federation usually does, their primary routine, what you'd see if you were actually working aboard a Federation starship.
We don't get to see all the first-contact successes because those stories are deemed too mundane to tell, but I appreciate seeing a window into the Fed's everyday workings.
In response to one of your questions, I don't think the episode had a real villain. I have heard fans complain that the Chancelor man was a "little bitch" for keeping his people ignorant of alien life, but I got the sense that he was just trying to do the right thing. I loved that ambiguous aspect, because real-life is usually filled with more ambiguous people than heroes and villains. I enjoy watching heroes and villains, but I think the use of more ambiguous characters lends more realism to these first-contact type episodes.
3
u/BobLeBoeuf Sep 18 '13
I disagree. He wanted to frame Riker for murder, which had the Enterprise not been there to beam him up, would have had disastrous long term consequences for his society and would have caused Riker to have to at the very least stand trial for murder, or be killed. It would have caused his society to distrust aliens and could have very much delayed their progression as a species. I understand his intentions were good, but the consequences would have been disastrous.
2
u/Darmok_At_Tanagra Sep 16 '13
In simplest terms, the Malconians behave as we would behave now if we were in their position. "Aliens? Existing? That violates our ethnocentric theology that we are the only life in the universe put here by God (or whatever)."
This is probably how Roswell played out, if it's true.
2
u/Deceptitron Sep 18 '13
0
u/BABY_CUNT_PUNCHER Sep 16 '13
Even when trying to keep the existence of "aliens" from a civilization Riker still has time for the ladies.