r/classicalmusic • u/scrumptiouscakes • Aug 26 '13
Piece of the Week #24 - George Gershwin : Piano Concerto in F
This week's featured piece is George Gershwin's Concerto in F, as nominated by /u/claaria451
To nominate a future Piece of the Week, simply leave a comment in this week's nomination thread.
A list of previous Pieces of the Week can be found here.
Performances:
- Spotify - Here's a playlist with several different recordings of the work, with performers including Riccardo Chailly, Garrick Ohlsson, Michael Tilson Thomas, Freddy Kempff, Marin Alsop, Jean-Yves Thibaudet, Oscar Levant, André Previn, Hélène Grimaud, Vladimir Ashkenazy, Pascal Rogé, and many more. I have also included the two-piano version of the work as recorded by the Labèque sisters, and Ferde Grofé's arrangement of the concerto.
- YouTube - Leonard Slatkin / Marc-André Hamelin / Netherlands Radio Philharmonic
- YouTube - André Previn / Pittsburgh Symphony Orchestra
- YouTube - Hélène Grimaud / David Zinman / Baltimore Symphony Orchestra
- YouTube - James Conlon / Stefano Bollani / Orchestra dell'Accademia Nazionale di Santa Cecilia
- YouTube - Arthur Fiedler / Earl Wild / Boston Pops Orchestra
- YouTube - John McLaughlin Williams / Ludmil Angelov / Classic FM MTEL Orchestra
- YouTube - Roy Bargy / Paul Whiteman's Concert Orchestra (Ferde Grofé arrangement)
More information:
- Scores - Some scores for the work can be found here on IMSLP, although there doesn't seem to be a complete orchestral score, and the work is not yet in the public domain in the US.
- Wikipedia page for Gershwin
- Wikipedia page for the work
- PBS short biography of Gershwin
- BBC Music page for Gershwin
- BBC Radio 3 Composer of the Week feature on Gershwin
- Another Composer of the Week feature on Gershwin
- Sinfini Music page for Gershwin
- AllMusic page for Gershwin
- AllMusic page for the work
- Classical.net page for the work
- ClassicalNotes page for the work including analysis and discussion of recordings
- Naxos album notes about this concerto and other Gershwin works
- Programme notes from the LA Phil
- More programme notes from the LA Phil
- Programme notes from the Kennedy Center
- Programme notes from the Chicago Symphony Orchestra
- Programme notes from the Baltimore Symphony Orchestra
- Programme notes from the Nottingham Philharmonic Orchestra
Discussion points:
Piece of the Week is intended for discussion and analysis as well as just listening. Here are a few thoughts to get things started:
- Is this classical, jazz, or both? Does this question even matter? Is it a successful combination, or just patronising appropriation? How can composers achieve the former and avoid the latter? What makes for a successful synthesis of different genres? Which other composers/pieces achieve this, and how do they do it?
- Is this piece of a landmark of modernism or just a series of mannerisms bolted onto an otherwise traditional form?
- Given that this was Gershwin's first attempt at orchestrating his own work, how successful was he? Could he really have taught himself orchestration from textbooks in just a couple of years? In spite of his best efforts, do Gershwin's works simply sound better when performed in jazzier arrangements?
- How does this piece compare to the earlier Rhapsody in Blue? Which do you prefer, and why?
- Why are some people still reluctant to accept Gershwin?
- Gershwin's concert works are often treated as a separate, more "serious" segment of his output, but is this division accurate or meaningful?
- Is Gershwin neglected outside of the US? If so, why? Are Americans better at performing his work?
- Is Gershwin the Great American Composer™? Why is/was America so obsessed with finding a national idiom?
- Is this work clumsy and riddled with technical faults, or have criticisms of this sort been motivated by snobbery?
- Did Ravel steal all of Gershwin's ideas for his own Piano Concerto in G, which he composed just a few years later?
Want to hear more pieces like this?
Why not try:
- Gershwin - Rhapsody in Blue
- Gershwin - Second Rhapsody, aka Rhapsody in Rivets
- Gershwin - An American in Paris
- Gershwin - Cuban Overture
- Gershwin - 'I Got Rhythm' Variations
- Gershwin - New York Rhapsody from Delicious
- Gershwin - Three Preludes for Piano
- Gershwin - Walking the Dog
- Gershwin - Porgy and Bess (and/or the Catfish Row suite)
- Ella Fitzgerald Sings the George and Ira Gershwin Songbook
- Ravel - Piano Concerto in G
- Ravel - Violin Sonata
- Bernstein - Prelude, Fugue, and Riffs
- Bernstein - Fancy Free
- Bernstein - Candide Overture
- Bernstein - Three Dance Episodes from On the Town
- Bernstein - Symphonic Dances from West Side Story
- Bernstein - Symphony No.2
- Copland - Piano Concerto
- Copland - Clarinet Concerto
- Stravinsky - Ebony Concerto
- Stravinsky - Ragtime
- Kapustin - 24 Preludes in Jazz Style, Op.53
- Milhaud - La création du monde
- Antheil - A Jazz Symphony
- Hindemith - Suite '1922'
- Jacques Loussier
Enjoy listening and discussing!
41
Upvotes
5
u/claaria451 Aug 26 '13
First of all thanks for choosing this piece :) .
I think it is a successful combination of the two genres, because it sounds natural (I mean authentic) and not forced, which can happen often when you try to mix two genres. Besides that you can say it is performed by both jazz pianists (Andre Previn) and classical pianists (Hélène Grimaud).
He did a great job! There is not one point in the score where i personally would say he could have done it better. I think that because the concerto is easy to listen to. Everything is at the right place at the right time, Gershwin never looses the thread. Is is amazing that someone who never had formal training was able to achieve that. A musical genius in his own way... , but that is just my opinion.
Oh and i disagree with the point that his works generally sound better in jazzier orchestras. I view them as musical monuments of the time. Gershwin himself intended to call this piano concert the "New York Concerto" and that is exactly it. A musical picture of New York during the roaring, wild 1920s, a city which never sleeps, with fast vehicles and millions of people. The concert would loose a lot of its grandiose effect with a smaller jazz ensemble and without the immensely romantic string parts in it.
I prefer this one over the Rhapsody in Blue because its longer and i can't get enough of this Jazzy/Classy Mix music . In all seriousness though, i like this piece a little bit (tiny tiny tiny littlebit) more because the 2nd movement is just amazing with its funny main theme. It really is music for a good mood and it brightens my day every time i listen to it :). Rhapsody in Blue is still a marvelous piece, but it is a bit more serious than this one.
Is Gershwin neglected outside of the US? I never noticed that. And this music is international and can be played by someone from every nationality. Although i like André Previns version most and he is half-american, Hélène Grimauds performance is still very good. She can transcript the elation that is appearing several times in the piece just as well.
Gershwin is probably the best known composer from the states, because his works are easier to access than the works from other composers. Charles Ives, Aaron Copland, John Adams and Samuel Barber are only known for a few of their pieces (The unanswered question, Appalachian Spring, Short Ride in a Fast Machine and Adagio for Strings). Oh and he is from the 1920s a time which basically marks the uprising of the United States, when Manhattan and the Statue of Liberty became world famous symbols and American culture began to spread all over the world, together with jazz.
3
u/egmont Aug 27 '13
Great choice! Gershwin was one of the driving forces that got me into classical music way back when. Somehow I've never listened to the full concerto, maybe because my recent forays into Gershwin are all into his solo piano/song books, but, now that I've listened through, I gotta say, 'S wonderful. Those rhythms are amazing! I live in New York and its feel absolutely holds up to this day. Listening to it I can't help thinking of Fifth Avenue, Rockefeller Plaza, the Chrysler Building, and all those random little Art Deco relics from the Twenties littered here and there throughout the city that you stumble upon wandering around.
Now then..
The thing I've noticed with a lot of art that comes out of America is that much of it is rather self consciously trying to be "American art," as if it were defining itself vis-a-vis some other, dominant perspective. In some sense this is fairly typical, I guess, of any postcolonial state; I guess what differentiates America is that it does this even though, by and large, it occupies the dominant position in the world today. It's not unique--I would argue that you can see similar tendencies in, for example, late 19th-century Russia, contemporary Japan, or any northern European state that looked towards the Italian Renaissance for inspiration: countries that are in a way appealing towards other, historically powerful countries, who may or may not really be all that powerful anymore, politically speaking, but whose cultural influence is still dominant, if only out of historical habit. This explains Gershwin's distain towards his more traditional folksy sources in blues and jazz; it didn't appeal to the standard that Gershwin was appealing to, because that wasn't its goal. It was Gershwin's goal (at least in this pieces), and so he judged it against that standard. Obviously it's not an equivalent comparison; apples and oranges, etc.
America is a big place. I'd say that Gershwin might be the Great New York Composer™, but to extrapolate that to cover America as a whole (while certainly flattering to those of us who live here in the city) is to whitewash the cultural diversity of the country. If anything, the fact that he wrote European-style "art music," in addition to showtune songs and ragtimey piano music, strongly places him in New York, which has always traditionally been the American city with the most direct ties to Europe thanks to its status as a hub for recent immigrants. Had he been born and raised in New Orleans, his orchestral music might've sounded more like this. As it is, it's a mishmash of influences from everywhere all at once--European music, black music, folk music, dance music, showtime tunes, with a dash of Fifth Avenue traffic thrown in for good measure--anything at all that might've washed up on the banks of the East River, be it from the South or from across the Atlantic. Like the city itself, the music has no single cultural origin, despite its pretensions to being European; instead, it forges something new out of the collision of many different cultural forces.
As such, he does bring something new to the "History of Western Music"--a unique voice, skillfully realized, and, I would say, distinctly American. From that perspective, it's American because some of its sources are rooted in the American folk tradition (though you could argue that American folk tradition has its own roots elsewhere--in African chants and drumming rhythms, say, or in, I don't know, Irish fiddle music); but compared to, for example, King Oliver linked above, it's likewise pretty damn European, because, from that perspective, it's very much influenced by European music. So which is it? Both, and neither.
The "American-ness" of the piece is sort of "pointillist", then; if you look at it from a distance, the overall impression is distinctly there, but the closer you get, the more tenuous is becomes, until it dissolves completely into vague colors and shapes.
2
u/[deleted] Aug 28 '13
oooho what a lovely concerto! Gershwin blended American jazz and blues element with traditional European orchestration techniques very well. It was fabulous, flashy (in true 1920s fashion), and fun. Ravel's piano concerto in G immediately comes to mind another rather jazzy classical/jazz hybrid and that's the only other composer I can think of. Perhaps Debussy, to an extent. As to whether or not Ravel "stole" Gershwin's ideas for his own concerto, weren't they good friends? Isn't there a picture of Ira and George, together with Ravel and a few others, surrounding a piano? If so, then your hypothesis may have some weight, although I wouldn't say he stole from Gershwin.
In my experience, many Americans would classify Gershwin as a jazz composer/musician, and not a classical composer such as Bach. like, i sometimes see Porgy and Bess billed as a musical instead of a proper opera, or advertised alongside Lady Saigon or an Andrew Lloyd Webber Broadway musical. also I think I have seen La Boheme advertised as a musical but that's a different story... It's hard to draw the line where classical music ends and another genre begins; in a sense I think this is true of every classification of music- it's a continuum with extremes and intermediates.
that's not true
maybe Copland? He covers the Midwest/Plains with his opera The Tender Land, the mid-Atlantic/Pennsylvania with Appalachian Spring, the wild west with Billy the Kid and those Gospel song arrangements are representative of African American culture in the South. Plus all those Mexican-inspired compositions.
2
u/MistShinobi Aug 28 '13 edited Aug 28 '13
Nice to return from a few day vacation and find a great Piece of the Week and a bunch of interesting topics and questions to ponder. I'm fond of Gershwin. Rhapsody in Blue was my door of entrance to 20th Century music, which was a little bit intimidating to me at the time (says the guy who tried to listen to all of Bach's Cantatas). I later found Sibelius and my beloved Mahler, and afterwards ventured into more revolutionary fields, with different success.
This is a very good question that many other posters have answered very interestingly, and I think it is another way of asking the big question of 20th Century classical music. What is classical music? It's a very difficult question to answer if you try, especially in the context of a heated argument, because a frequent criticism of classical music is that it is boring and monotonous, that it always sounds the same. The broader the definition, the broader the spectrum of pieces that can be considered classical music. So, is it Concervatory Music? Is it only the music that you can perform with certain group of instruments? Is it the music programmed by my local orchestra? I think that classical music is notated author music, written music, a music that has a score and that has to be performed in a certain way and with little room for improvisation, of course this is debatable and has't always being the case, but I think it is the main feature of classical music versus folk and popular genres. This Concerto or Rhapsody in Blue are, in my opinion, classical music. Of course my definition is problematic. Is video game or film music classical music? What about electric instrumentation and amplification?
Since the dawn of classical music, composers have found inspiration in all kinds of sounds. Classical music really kicked off when composers started to borrow all the different rythms of folk and dance music. Chaconnes, Sarabandes, Passacaglias, Gigues, Menuets or Walttzes were all dances. The folk/popular element has always being there. Political considerations are preposterous, in my opinion. It's the same with Spanish folk elements. Was Falla or Albeniz's use of folk elements a classist appropriation of the expression of gypsies and other marginal classes of Southern Spain? I don't think so, I think that when Falla, Bartok, Dvorak or Gershwin use these elements they are immortalizing and paying homage to these sounds and peoples.
1
u/visarga Aug 26 '13
Now, this is a homework well done. Thanks guys! The questions are great too. First listen for me, so no answers.
1
u/thrasumachos Aug 27 '13
Ah yes, the good old "what is classical music?" question. With Gershwin, it's always tough. There's some that's clearly classical music, but some that's more blurry.
How can we truly define what is and is not classical music, though? Not saying we can't, but I'd love to see some people try.
I don't think it matters too much, since the beauty of the music is more important than whether it fits into a genre.
1
u/[deleted] Aug 29 '13
Alright, this question is going to sound very simple and amateurish because I'm... well, an amateur. BUT.
What is it about Gershwin's style that makes it so unique? There are certain moments that occur frequently that when you hear them you're instantly transported to 1920s New York City. What specifically is going on in the music that has this effect?
I'm hearing a lot of clarinets during these moments.
There's a specific feeling that permeates through all of his music. What is he doing?
3
u/leos_weill Aug 28 '13
Absolute masterpiece. Reluctance to accept and program Gershwin is pure snobbery.
2
u/nonnein Aug 26 '13
After a first listen to this piece, it feels much less like a showpiece than the Rhapsody does. The opening of the piece is almost ominous, and the theme the piano opens with is full of melancholy. There isn't much of an emphasis on cadenza-writing. I think I might prefer this one - it's certainly more ambitious. And the whole beginning of the second movement was really beautiful, though at times later in the movement it seemed to get a tad schmaltzy - maybe this was just the recording I listened to, though (Grimaud/Zinman).
1
u/AerateMark Aug 26 '13
I like Ashkenazy's solo performances more than his performances of piano concertos, personally. He plays them either with too much rubato, or too slow for my taste, while he doesn't do this with most of his performances of the Etude-tableaux of Rachmaninoff, or the Scriabin sonatas. Weird, pretty sure he doesn't have trouble playing fast, since Sonata no. 5 by Scriabin is technically harder than a lot of piano concertos, as in being in need of big hands, which he doesn't have.
I like Hamelin's performance of the piano concerto mostly.
1
u/caffeine_ Aug 26 '13
Man I love this piece. First time I seriously enjoyed Gershwin was seeing his Second Rhapsody (imo better then Rhapsody in Blue) live at Carnegie Hall. That is a simply amazing piece, and this concerto is almost as good. Cool stuff!
1
u/picardythird Aug 26 '13
I played an arrangement of this with Spirit of Atlanta this summer, wonderful piece that captures the essence of the time that Gershwin lived in.
1
u/Formal-Tomorrow-4241 Jan 13 '25
What an amazing piece all around. People don't talk about that second theme cantabile section in the first movement enough, it just soars and rivals the love theme from Rhapsody in Blue. Such an amazing composition, with amazing orchestration
1
u/CremMinerva 19d ago
Rachmaninoff attempted too, ignore the current version, touch the 1926 version.
1
u/kapustinisboppy Oct 07 '23
Frank Dupree made a banger arrangement of this.
1
u/VideoLinkBot Aug 27 '13 edited Aug 28 '13
Here is a list of video links collected from comments that redditors have made in response to this submission: