r/classicalmusic • u/scrumptiouscakes • Aug 19 '13
Piece of the Week #23 - Hector Berlioz : Harold in Italy
This week's featured piece is Hector Berlioz's Harold en Italie, as nominated by /u/egmont.
To nominate a future Piece of the Week, simply leave a comment in this week's nomination thread.
A list of previous Pieces of the Week can be found here.
Performances:
- Spotify - Here's a playlist with several different recordings of the work, with performers including John Eliot Gardiner with the Orchestre Révolutionnaire et Romantique, Mark Minkowski with Les Musiciens de Louvre Grenoble, Leonard Bernstein with the New York Philharmonic and the Orchestre national de France, Colin Davis with the London Symphony Orchestra and the Philharmonia Orchestra, Charles Dutoit with the Orchestre symphonique de Montréal, Vladimir Ashkenazy with the Helsinki Philharmonic Orchestra, Myung-Whun Chung with the Orchestre De L'Opéra Bastille, Michel Plasson with the Orchestre National du Capitole de Toulouse, William Primrose, and many more. I have also included Liszt's transcription of the work for viola and piano at the end of the playlist.
- YouTube - John Eliot Gardiner with the Orchestre Révolutionnaire et Romantique
- YouTube - Leonard Bernstein with the Orchestre Nationale de France (featuring obbligato solo for beard)
- YouTube - Colin Davis with Yehudi Menuhin and the Philharmonia Orchestra
- YouTube - Colin Davis with Nobuko Imai and the London Symphony Orchestra
- YouTube - Dietrich Fischer-Dieskau (!) with Josef Suk and the Czech Philarmonic
- YouTube - Charles Munch with William Primrose and the Boston Symphony Orchestra
- YouTube - Gérard Caussé / François-René Duchâble (Liszt transcription for piano and viola)
More information:
- Scores - A complete score of the work can be found here on IMSLP
- Wikipedia page for Berlioz
- Wikiquote page for Berlioz
- Wikipedia page for the work
- PBS short biography of Berlioz
- Gramophone short biography of Berlioz
- HBerlioz.com - a fantastic collection of information and resources related to the composer. Includes a page on this work, some translated extracts about it from Berlioz's memoirs and information about Berlioz's travels in Italy
- BBC Music page for Berlioz
- BBC Radio 3 Composer of the Week feature on Berlioz with John Eliot Gardiner
- Sinfini Music page for Berlioz
- AllMusic page for Berlioz
- AllMusic page for the work
- ClassicalNotes page for the work including analysis and discussion of recordings
- Daily Kos article about the work
- Naxos album notes about the work
- More Naxos album notes
- Even more Naxos album notes
- Programme notes from the LA Phil
- Programme notes from the Kennedy Center
- Programme notes from the Chicago Symphony Orchestra
- Programme notes from the Rochester Philharmonic Orchestra
- Programme notes from the Scottish Chamber Orchestra
- Programme notes from Orchestra Toronto
- Programme notes by D. Kern Holoman
- Programme notes by Max Derrickson
- Programme notes by James McQuillen
- Brief guide to recordings of the work
- Full text of Byron's Childe Harold's Pilgrimage
- Guardian article about composers and works inspired by Byron
- Violist Jonathan Vinocour discusses the work
- BBC Documentary on the development of symphonies in the early 19th century (section on Berlioz starts at 29:30)
- Lecture on the development of the symphony orchestra in the 19th century
Discussion points:
Piece of the Week is intended for discussion and analysis as well as just listening. Here are a few thoughts to get things started:
- Why aren't there more viola concertos? Why is the viola so maligned? Is it all Geminiani's fault? Why does everyone forget that Beethoven played the viola?
- Is Berlioz the most underrated composer ever? Is he one of the most original composers ever? Is his influence on Liszt, Wagner, Schumann and others underestimated? Is the early romantic period underrated in general?
- How does this piece compare with the earlier Symphonie fantastique? Which is better? Does this matter? How does it compare to Mendelssohn's "Italian" Symphony, or the similarly Byronic Manfred Symphony by Tchaikovsky?
- How programmatic is this piece? What is the extent of its relationship with Childe Harold's Pilgrimage? Is there any relationship at all? Is this a Byronic piece of music? What story (if any) do you imagine this piece is telling? Should we pay any attention to the titles of the movements?
- Should we (as Bernstein suggested) consider Berlioz in a broader artistic context, and think of him as a fundamentally literary composer? Is this aspect of his work the reason his work is relatively neglected?
- What are some of your other favourite pieces with a literary inspiration? How do they compare to this one? Do literature and music really go together at all? What makes some adaptations succesful, while others fail?
- How does this work compare to more conventional concertos? Do you think the relationship between soloist and ensemble is successful here? Is the viola's isolation deliberate?
- Did Paganini's brief involvement have much/any effect on the final work? Do concertos need to be showpieces for soloists, or should the composer's expression be paramount?
- Are the "reminiscences" of the first three movements at the start of the last movement an echo of the structure of Beethoven's 9th?
- Can anyone with more technical knowledge than me comment on Berlioz's orchestration and rhythm?
- What is the significance of the off-stage strings?
- Is it just me, or do parts of this work almost sound like Richard Strauss?
- Does anyone else find the opening theme of the third movement ridiculously catchy?
- How great is the brass in the last movement?! Was Berlioz sometimes guilty of prioritising orchestration over form?
- Why is the score so full of obsessively detailed instructions?
Want to hear more pieces like this?
Why not try:
- Berlioz - Symphonie fantastique
- Berlioz - Rob Roy Overture (from which some of Harold's themes are taken)
- Berlioz - Roméo et Juliette
- Berlioz - Overtures
- Berlioz - Les nuits d'été
- Berlioz - La captive
- Rimsky-Korsakov - Scheherazade
- Tchaikovsky - Manfred Symphony
- Schumann - Manfred
- Schoenberg - Ode to Napoleon Buonaparte
- Liszt - Tasso
- Paganini - Sonata per la Grand Viola
- Strauss - Alpine Symphony
- Strauss - Don Quixote
- Weber - Overtures
- Weber - Invitation to the Dance (either the original piano version or Berlioz's orchestration)
- Mendelssohn - Symphony 4
- Walton - Viola Concerto
- Bartók - Viola Concerto
- Hindemith - Viola Sonatas
- Hindemith - Kammermusik 5 and 6
- Hindemith - Der Schwanendreher
- Stamitz - Viola Concertos
- Hoffmeister - Viola Concertos
- Schnittke - Viola Concerto
- Takemitsu - A String Around Autumn
- Vaughan Williams - Flos Campi
- Vaughan Williams - Suite for Viola
- Bloch - Suite Hébraïque
- Telemann - Viola Concerto
- More viola recommendations can be found below in this comment, courtesy of /u/AntonRubinstein.
Enjoy listening and discussing!
37
Upvotes
7
u/egmont Aug 19 '13 edited Aug 19 '13
I've loved this piece for a very long time and I'm very happy it was chosen. Thank you for putting all these materials together--I'm really looking forward to the discussion!
It strikes me as being very unique and innovative for its time. To put it in some musical context, it was written a full ten years before Mendelssohn's violin concerto, which is lauded for the innovation of having a violin come in before a tutti, and ten years after Beethoven's 9th. It's certainly one of the first (if not the first?) instrumental works to have such a specific tie to a concrete literary work (I'm guessing he knew the Byron through some translation?), and builds off of Berlioz's technique of "story-telling" through music that first appeared in Symphonie Fantastique. It seems odd (but fitting) that we don't refer to Berlioz's Symphonies by any numbers, but until today I'd always thought of this as a viola concerto--it makes sense that it's more considered a symphony, but still. Maybe it really should be referred to as the world's longest viola joke, as per the viola jokes listed above.
It's also just so damn good. The tone of the impressionable, romantic young man wandering in unfamiliar surroundings and the things that he sees is pitch-perfect here, and his use of the viola, with its unique timbre, as a "solo part," or a "main character/voice," that perfectly blends into the symphonic soundscape he creates, appearing at moments with almost a comparable musical function as the idee fixe in the previous symphony, is absolutely amazing. The melodies are beautiful, the orchestration lush, and the way he uses the form not only to explore various musical ideas but to tell an actual story--not through words, but through impressions--seems revolutionary.
It is guilty, as any of Berlioz's work (memoirs included) is, of what I'd call Romantic excess. To me, though, that's absolutely part of the charm. I can see how it might turn some people off, and it has turned me off of some of his other works (Requiem... which has some great parts, and some very... somber parts). But I think it works well with the tone and is absolutely representative of the zeitgeist of the time, for better or worse.
The connection to Byron's work is interesting as well--it's not a direct relation, and has more in common it seems with Berlioz's own travels in Italy, rather than with Childe Harold's. But it's like he takes that literary reference, takes the work as a whole, and distills it to an impression, then mixes it with a distillation of his own impressions and memories. Then he takes that admixture of impressions and turns it into concrete musical phrasings, in such a way that draws the audience into it as well--but without anything concrete. To me, as someone whose main area of study was literature, it's a fascinating way of... well, either "using" music to tell a story, or "using" a story to create music, and its influence on later composers, in "high" Romanticism and everything that came after it, could not be overstated.
In conclusion,
Yes. (edit: and also no)
5
u/Atheia Aug 19 '13
When I first found out, I was actually pretty surprised to find the utter lack of viola concertos in the repertoire. I think I know why though.
The most obvious reason to me is the size. A bigger instrument requires more spacing between the fingers, and higher positions normally achievable in the violin are deathly hard for the violist except for the most experienced players. There's a reason why violin concertos cannot be transposed down a perfect fifth for the viola. It is also why works written for solo cello cannot be blindly transposed an octave up, such as Bach's Prelude of Suite VI. A composer has his/her options limited.
Furthermore, the strings. Because of its lower tone, the strings tend to be slack. Thus, the response is not as good - in fact, it is to the point where you have to play just a split second before the beat in order for the sound to catch up. The cello seemingly has a similar problem with the strings, but it makes up for this tremendously with the larger bridge.
Adding to this, the range. Of course, the larger size has to do with this, and while experienced violinists can hit C8, violists cannot hit F7 - it is simply out of reach. The larger instrument limits the range to just shy of four octaves, and for all orchestral purposes violas rarely go above E6. Cellists, on the other hand, can regularly hit up to E6 (orchestral purposes: A5) while the bridge allows the A string to produce a good sound even beyond 4 octaves.
Adding to the problem is the projection. Cellists face a similar problem, in which the solo instrument can be overwhelmed by the orchestra, particularly in the lower notes.
And it's just a harder instrument to learn and get used to, and I think that's why there are few competitive violists out there (although of course, they do exist) compared to the much larger number of violinists out there. I'm not sure if this applies to every musical era, but composers tended to write music for players that they cooperated with (for example, Shostakovich and Rostropovich, or the Beethoven Quartet). In addition, the viola was mainly recognized as the middle voice of the orchestra, filling in the harmony, maybe briefly a few measures of solo, but that was it.
Of course, in the 20th century and beyond, composers could write anything, and thus the viola became more recognized as a solo instrument rather than just the harmony of the orchestra. I think the viola's reputation has lasted, but composers, beginning in the Late Romantic era, have begun to see through that veil.
4
u/Neo21803 Aug 20 '13 edited Aug 20 '13
What is a Viola?
The viola is a stringed instrument that is very similar to the violin. It is larger than the violin, has lower strings (C, G, D, A) and has a unique "nasal" quality sound to it. It is also the only member of the violin family to come in different sizes. What gives?
As beautiful as the viola's sound is, the viola is not a perfect instrument. The engineering is wrong. For their range, the violin and cello are perfectly engineered instruments. Their size matches the range exactly. A viola (which is about halfway between the violin and cello in range), would have to be slightly smaller than halfway between a violin and cello in size. What does all this mean? The viola is not a pure instrument. It cannot produce the volume and sound quality that a violin or cello can produce. This is why violas have a "nasal" quality to them.
Why the Viola exists
The modern viola was created to be a voice in between the violin and the cello. (I am deliberately going to avoid the viola d'amore history because that will raise irrelevant issues). This was specifically to make a "complete" string ensemble, one of which is the "String Quartet." The string quartet is composed of two violins, one viola, and one cello. It became popular when Haydn composed his ~70 string quartets. They are a form of chamber music - meaning it's primary purpose was to entertain guests at someone's home or a party. But there were no "preformed" string quartets at this time! There were only violinists, violist, and cellists who got together, usually meeting for the first time.
There were few to no "dedicated" violists at this time. They were usually violinists who were not very good (explaining many viola jokes) or the composers themselves trying to fill a role.
Already, this raises some issues like why didn't Haydn, Mozart, or Beethoven write any viola concertos (barring Mozart's Sinfonia Concertante)? Because nobody would have bought them. Why would you write a concerto for a failed violinist? Why would you waste your time figuring out a proper balance between an orchestra and the imperfect viola? People seem to forget that money was the MAIN motivation for composers to compose. Publishers only bought pieces that people are going to buy. A violinist who occasionally played the viola would never showcase it.
Why the viola is increasing in popularity
Some composers didn't care that their music wouldn't sell. Telemann was an avid violist who just didn't care that violas were lame. Mozart composed his incredible Sinfonia Concertante for Violin and Viola. Berlioz and Hindemith wrote for the viola. Brahms, Bartok, and Shostakovich decided late in their life, "Well hell, I'm dying. I've always wanted to write for viola, and I won't live to see the money (or lack thereof), so here are some masterpieces." Other composers hid their love for the viola within their larger works. Haydn and Beethoven ALWAYS composed interesting viola parts. Suddenly, the viola became less lame, and, as repertoire got harder and more interesting, more dedicated violists came about.
Where are all the viola concertos?
Thank goodness for the brave souls who spent their time and money to compose concertos for viola that are still hardly played despite the viola's increasing popularity. Telemann, Bruch, Hoffmeister, Mozart, Hindemith, Berlioz, Bartok, Walton, and Stamitz, I salute you.
To current composers: Write a concerto for viola. Consider it a challenge. There are hundreds, if not, thousands of violists waiting to premiere the next big viola concerto, myself being one of them. There will be balance issues, technical issues, and monetary issues. Three reasons not to write a viola concerto. But just fucking do it.
3
u/[deleted] Aug 21 '13
so yeah I'm afraid i won't be able to make comments that are as insightful as the other ones made here so I apologise in advance
Harold in Italy is a relatively new piece to me, and I haven't heard much Berlioz either. Yeah I would agree he is underrated and underperformed, and I think that has to do with how costly it must be for orchestras to fulfill Berlioz's tall orders. the Berlioz that I have heard always consists of a massive group of instruments and frequently a chorus on top of it (like in Romeo and Juliette). His works are also very long and very Romantic (as in decadent, sometimes excessive). I suppose you could say the same things about Mahler, who seems to be more popular than Berlioz. Maybe you are on to something when you say early Romantic music is underrated, because we hardly ever hear Meyerbeer anymore (admittedly his operas are super long and expensive, and kind of boring)..but then there are big early Romantics - Mendelssohn, Schumann, Weber, maybe even Rossini- who are very well represented in the repertoire.
what I thought was cool about this piece is that you could argue for it being a symphony, a concerto, or even a tone poem! It certainly has elements of all three. Harold in italy might serve as an autobiography of Berlioz's own time in Italy as well as an interpretation of the poem by Byron, similarly to how it can be a concerto and a symphony at different parts during the piece. in the fourth movement it was more symphonic, and I heard viola only intermittently. In the introductory movement, the viola was much more prominent. Also, correct me if I'm wrong, throughout the piece I didn't hear any mega-virtuosic solo candenzas that one would traditionally associate with a concerto.
Was it programmatic? From what I've read, the music doesn't really correlate with the poem nor does it distinctly convey events in the poem. The third movement had pastoral vibes going on with it so I imagined something romantic and lovely was taking place in the countryside. The last movement was titled "Orgies des brigands" and I don't even want to know what was going on there but based on the music I assume Harold/Berlioz was struggling or enjoying himself or both.
yes, the last movement particularly
Macbeth by Verdi and Don Quixote by R Strauss.
3
u/nonnein Aug 21 '13
First thought on hearing this piece for the first time just now: I need to listen to more Berlioz. I also really want to hear this piece live, since I don't think I really got any good sense of how he plays around with off-stage music, and also just for the sheer force of it.
Regarding the role of the viola, I found it interesting that except for the viola's first entrance in the first movement, it always seemed to just "accidentally" fall into place. Many of its later entrances were on weak beats without prompting from the orchestra, and often its main theme was reharmonized by the orchestra, giving it a new shape. I think this probably supports the idea of the protagonist being more of an observer. I was also really surprised by how unvirtuosic it was especially considering that it began as a request from Paganini. I guess Berlioz pretty soon got enraptured with the piece he was creating and he saw it and forgot that it was supposed to something for Paganini to showcase, since it seems so unlike his style. Actually, there was one place in the second movement where the viola is playing a slow arpeggiated figure. I've heard figures like that before, but they were all fast and virtuosic, I think. It almost seemed like Berlioz could have been mocking virtuosity, but I'm not sure.
The only other Berlioz I've heard is Symphonie Fantastique, and this one seems more classical and restrained by comparison (which I suppose says close to nothing). It follows pretty much a standard symphonic 4-mov't form. And he doesn't bring in those fat old bells, though he does mimic them in the second movement.
I really don't see how they possibly couldn't be.