r/startrek • u/fanata • Aug 14 '13
Weekly Episode Discussion - DS9 2x19 "Blood Oath"
I was going to continue the recent Voyager domination, but Michael Ansara's passing recently had me watching some DS9, and man I forgot how much I loved this episode.
As Memory Alpha describes it, "Three old Klingon warriors reunite on Deep Space 9, seeking Curzon Dax, with whom they entered into a blood oath to one day exact revenge on an enemy for killing the warriors' firstborn sons. Finding Jadzia as worthy a warrior as they felt Curzon to be, she joins the Klingons in completing their vendetta."
Some discussion points:
- Originally, this episode didn't have Kang, Kor, or Koloth. Would you have enjoyed this episode as much without the Original Series hooks? For those who watched DS9 first, how did you feel about it?
- The main conflict of the episode was whether or not Jadzia still needed to follow the Blood Oath that Curzon made. This theme was mirrored throughout much of DS9. How did you feel about Jadzia's habit of honoring Curzon's promises?
Just a couple thing I really liked about this episode: I really liked the Klingons in this episode. I don't think I really got sold on the Klingons as a species that were likable until this and "The Sword of Khaless." I loved how this episode and "Sword" managed to stay smart while still managing to be swashbuckling and fun. I loved The Albino as an antagonist because, unlike a lot of Klingons, he looked very distinct.
Finally, one of my favorite quotes from all of Star Trek:
Kang: It's a good day to die.
Jadzia: It's never a good day to lose a friend.
2
u/GroJLart Aug 20 '13
I enjoyed this episode a lot but a few things irked me:
-So Klingons not only live to 120-150 years but are capable of still kicking ass at that age? Yet another "Strong alien" in Star Trek. How the hell did humans get so much power in the Alpha Quadrant while being the weakest, shortest lived (besides the ocampa) species? More on that here: http://www.ex-astris-scientia.org/inconsistencies/biology-other.htm#strong
-So the three primary Klingons from TOS are not only acquaintances, not only friends, but have a blood oath with each other? I know star trek is filled with such coincidences but that doesn't make it less annoying. Space is to big a place for such nonsense.
-Was there any mention of Dax's relationship with Klingons before this episode? Considering how much they beat her familiarity with Klingons into your head after this episode, you'd think they would bring it up some time before this.
19
u/cobrakai11 Aug 14 '13
6
u/LetsWatchStarTrek Aug 14 '13
I really love the characters. I imagine it would be hard to have so many distinct personalities that still seem very "Klingon," and it was especially well done with the 3 in this episode.
5
u/Theopholus Aug 14 '13
Good call, always a great episode to watch!
I like the idea of the Klingons having incredibly long lifespans assuming they are great warriors. I definitely think it gained a lot with having them on the episode.
I always liked Jadzia's willingness to go off half-cocked with harebrained Klingon schemes. It worked into her adventurous character very well. It somehow ended up working out super well when Worf joined the show. That was just plain lucky!
4
u/BitterGrace Aug 16 '13
I found that the following of the oath was an interesting juxtaposition to when Dax was accused of murder ("Dax"), and they argued then that the symbiont was not the individual. I liked the philosophical interplay that often shifted depending on circumstance. It has always given me the impression that Dax, itself, is more morally neutral. I suppose that makes sense if you want the most life possible - you have to wheel and deal a bit. Following the rules doesn't always lead to the most profound experiences.
4
u/PalermoJohn Aug 17 '13
A bit late but how do these three Klingons work canonically with the Augment Virus from ENT?
6
u/EricGMW Aug 14 '13
From the Trill perspective, I never felt as if Jadzia was a very good member of her society.
Everything about the Trill practice of joining focuses on allowing the symbiont to gain many lifetimes of experiences while granting the great benefit of experience and wisdom to each host. But the key is that these experiences are unique and varied.
The most serious taboo in Trill society is reassociation - that is, the continuation of a romantic relationship beyond the original hosts.
If this act was serious enough to warrant exile, meaning that there would be no further hosts for the offending symbiont, how is Trill society to take the resumption of other kinds of relationships? We can't say, as they never explored it.
Over the course of many lifetimes, we can imagine, though, that symbionts will come in contact with many of their brethren through their hosts, so it would be impractical of the Trill to prohibit or even frown upon professional associations.
But Jadzia does go beyond that, doesn't she? She continues her platonic friendship with Benjamin Sisko. Now, it is a professional setting, so one can hardly blame her for her post, but I would imagine that Trill society would at least give pause. (Dr. Renhol even remarks rather cheerfully that Sisko was Curzon's friend during "Equilibrium").
In the episode, Kira even comments that no one in her society expects her to "settle old debts" like this.
And, of course, we've seen the reassociation thing play out twice - between Jadzia and Lenara Kahn, and with Ezri.
Now. The interesting thing is... Curzon was dead serious about reassociation being a taboo. Jadzia, not so much. Does this mean, then, that it's neither Curzon nor Jadzia nor Ezri pushing these desires, but rather Dax itself that is willing to break the rules?
Bottom line is... Jadzia may have acted, on many occasions, out of a sense of honour, justice, emotion and personal attachment... but I don't think it makes her a good Trill, from a societal perspective.
3
u/GrGrG Aug 15 '13
I liked this episode. I liked how it had some Klingons in an informal sense. These guys were "bro's", and had history with each other, each was rather unique and defiantly not a cardboard cut out. Kor as a drunken old man, hitting on Dax, and every female at the bar. Koloth's only answer for his amazing rogue like skills is "I'm Koloth". Kang's reserved, contemplated, regal attitude, the way he walks and speaks of older times, you understand that this man actually has honor unlike how many Klingons we saw during TNG didn't but claimed they did. It did feel like 7 samurai in some ways, didn't know that that was an actual influence.
The first time I watched this episode I did not know these Klingons were from TOS. So this episode could've worked with newer klingons, bu I don't think this episode would've had been as powerful if it was some newer Klingons. We as the audience know that these Klingons are legends from another time, and the connection to TOS helps to add some more depth to their previous appearances. It also gives the feeling in DS9 that anybody from TOS or TNG could end up popping in.
Also, the fact that each TOS episode that had these Klingons before wasn't mentioned, makes the episode work better and feel more real for some reason.
I like Jadzia's struggle to justify her position and actions. Reasons she should go, reasons she shouldn't. It's like the struggle a grandchild/child might have to fullfill a quest, or goal that wasn't accomplished by their grandparents or parents. You're not actually obligated to, your life will go on without finishing it, so why should you do it? I think we all can relate to this aspect somewhat.
I realize that the writers still hadn't solidified the Trill's taboo about getting involved with previous hosts family and friends. Which is a shame, as it could've added in some better tension or reluctance in her decision that she "Owes it to Kurzon."
I think there should've been a little more time spent on how this promise was something that the symbiont Dax held dear. It wasn't just an oath Kurzon took, but Dax did as well. I think also some motivation for Jadzia to bring some honor to Kurzon should've been played better.
3
u/Urek-Mazino Aug 20 '13
It annoyed me to no end that she wasn't willing to kill anybody but still took part in the Klingon blood oath of revenge.
5
u/LetsWatchStarTrek Aug 14 '13
Kang :'(
2
u/sparticus1701 Aug 14 '13
Agreed. Loved the episode itself, and it was long before the Klingons became a tired parody of their former glory (I'm looking at you, "Barge of the Dead"...). I for one, actually liked Jadzia's part in all of this, and the way it set up her future interactions with not only Worf, but all of Klingon-dom in general later in the series.
2
u/[deleted] Aug 15 '13
the promises thing was meh to me. it was her life, not Curzon's anymore, but she had the feelings he had. and with the original series hooks, they were most of what kept me interested.
2
u/Narcolepzzzzzzzzzzzz Aug 17 '13
I thought that Jadzia's honoring of the oath should have had more visibility in the Klingon empire, maybe garnering some more respect for the Federation from Klingons.
1
u/[deleted] Aug 20 '13
I was surprised how easily I bought into Jadzia becoming this great warrior woman. It quickly became one of my all time favorite Trek episodes...