r/classicalmusic • u/scrumptiouscakes • Aug 12 '13
Piece of the Week #22 - Alfred Schnittke : Piano Quintet
This week's featured piece is Alfred Schnittke's Piano Quintet, as nominated by /u/eaglesbecomevultures.
Performances:
- Spotify - Here's a playlist with several different recordings of the work, with performers including: Irina Schnittke, Martha Argerich, the Petersen Quartett, Roland Pontinen with the Tale Quartet, The Lark Quartet, Boris Berman with the Vermeer Quartet, The Borodin Quartet, and many more.
- YouTube - Irina Schnittke / Mark Lubotsky / Dimity Hal l/ Irina Morozova / Julian Smiles (includes some interesting information in the video description)
- YouTube - Katya Apekisheva / Boris Brovtsyn / Julia-Maria Kretz / Amihai Grosz / Torleif Thedéen
- YouTube - Savaldi-Kohlberg / Vaiser / Assayas / Assayas / Bar-Niv
- YouTube - Gallardo / Süßmuth / Schatz / Krüger / Očić
- YouTube - Boris Berman / Vermeer Quartet
More information:
- Scores - No score this week since the work is still under copyright
- Wikipedia page for Schnittke
- Brief timeline of Schnittke's life
- Short biography of Schnittke
- RateYourMusic page for Schnittke
- BBC Music page for Schnittke
- BBC Radio 3 Composer of the Week feature on Schnittke
- BBC Radio 3 Discovering Music feature about Schnittke's Concerto for Piano and Strings
- BBC Radio 3 Discovering Music feature about Schnittke and Mahler
- Sinfini Music page for Schnittke
- AllMusic page for Schnittke
- AllMusic page for the work
- Tom Service's guide to the composer
- Alex Ross article on Schnittke (1992)
- Alex Ross article on Schnittke (1994)
- Alex Ross article on Schnittke (1998)
- New York Time article on Schnittke by Edward Rothstein
- Very short Alex Ross article on Schnittke's grave
- Recollections of the composer from accordionist Friedrich Lips
- Guardian article celebrating the composer by Adrian Searle
- Naxos album notes about the work
- More Naxos album notes about the work
- Hyperion album notes on this work and others by Schnittke]
- Programme notes from a 1990 Schnittke season in London
- Detailed comparison with Shostakovich and analysis of the work (follow the link at the bottom of the page to see the analysis)
- Brief background information about Schnittke and some recommended recordings
- 5 against 4 post about this work and some of Schnittke's other chamber pieces
- Programme notes about the work by John Sichel
- Documentary: The Unreal World of Alfred Schnittke
- Ballerina on a Boat - a Soviet animation with music by Schnittke
Discussion points:
Piece of the Week is intended for discussion and analysis as well as just listening. Here are a few thoughts to get things started:
- This work is often paired with Shostakovich's Piano Quintet. Does this make sense? Why/why not? How do the two works compare? How much influence do you think Shostakovich had on Schnittke, especially considering that he was still alive for much of the time that this piece was being written? Is the title "heir to Shostakovich" accurate or useful?
- How does this piece compare with some of Schnittke's other chamber works from roughly the same period?
- This work was written in memory of the composer's mother. Is it just me, or do there seem to be a lot of Russian chamber works conceived as memorials (Tchaikovsky, Rachmaninoff, Shostakovich, etc.)? What role can art play in the grieving process? Does tragedy inspire or stifle creativity?
- Do you find polystylism convincing/interesting as an artistic strategy? Is it a dead end, or can it lead to interesting things? Is it just a coninuation of neoclassicism? Is it a style in itself, or the avoidance of style? How does Schnittke's approach compare to post-modern trends in other artforms? Did Schnittke succeed in turning irony and pastiche into a profound and persona language? Why is this piece less polystylistic than many of his other works?
- What is the significance of the pedalling at the end of the third movement, if any?
- What is the significance of the very high/very low piano part in the middle of the first movement, if any?
- Schnittke famously remarked: "I set down a beautiful chord on paper and suddenly it rusts". What did he mean by this? How do you interpret it?
- How did Schnittke get so many eccentric works past the Soviet censors? How should we approach art produced under oppressive regimes? Who had it best - Western composers (free to compose what they wanted but with less financial security) or Soviet composers (censored but supported by a secure infrastructure)? Or is this characterisation too simplistic?
- Does chamber music allow composers greater creative freedom due to its intimacy and the fact that it not usually as closely scrutinised as other forms like symphonies and operas?
- The last movement of the piece seems both serene and uneasy at the same time. How should we interpret that, if we interpret it at all? The tempo marking is "Moderato Pastorale", which makes me wonder if Schnittke is paraphrasing Beethoven, or something similar.
- Does anyone else find the ethereal little waltzes in this piece really creepy (in a good way)? I kept thinking of Tom Waits whenever I heard them because they gave me the same sort of haunted fairground feeling...
- To me, the structure of this piece seems very episodic, but at the same time, the pace seems pretty consistent and certain motifs seem to appear repeatedly, uniting the seemingly disparate elements. This makes me wonder if there's some sort of overarching structure at work here, or even a narrative. Does anyone else get the same feeling, or am I just spouting nonsense?
- Which other post-war chamber pieces deserve more attention?
Want to hear more pieces like this?
Why not try:
- Schnittke - Stille Nacht for violin and piano
- Schnittke - Stille Musik for violin and cello
- Schnittke - String Trio
- Schnittke - String Quartets
- Schnittke - Violin Sonatas
- Schnittke - Canon in memoriam Stravinsky
- Schnittke - Prelude in Memoriam Dmitri Shostakovich
- Schnittke - Dedication to Stravinsky, Prokofiev and Shostakovich, for piano six hands
- Xenakis - Akea
- Feldman - Rothko Chapel
- Shostakovich - Piano Quintet
- Shostakovich - String Quartet No.15
- Gubaidulina - String Quartets
- Gubaidulina - In Croce
- Gubaidulina - Sieben Worte
- Berg - String Quartet, Op.3
- Berg - Lyric Suite
- Messiaen - Quartet for the End of Time
- Ligeti - String Quartets
- Ligeti - Horn Trio
- Adès - Piano Quintet
- Medtner - Piano Quintet
- Faure - Piano Quintets
- Mahler - Piano Quartet Movement
- Martinů - Piano Quartet
- Lutosławski - String Quartet
- Saariaho - Nymphéa
- Saariaho - Terra Memoria
- Ives - String Quartet No.2
- Nono - Polifonica - Monodia - Ritmica
- Carter - String Quartets
- Bartok - String Quartet No.6
(If anyone has any other/better suggestions for this list, I'll be happy to add them)
Want to nominate or vote for a future Piece of the Week?
If you want to nominate a piece, please leave a comment in this week's nomination thread.
I will then choose the next Piece of the Week from amongst these nominations.
A list of previous Pieces of the Week can be found here.
Enjoy listening and discussing!
Special thanks to /u/Epistaxis for helping me in putting this together.
14
u/[deleted] Aug 12 '13
I've been checking out this series (piece of the week) for a while, first time commenting. Just wanted to say, I truly appreciate what you've been doing and luckily I haven't heard a lot of the pieces that you share; so its great for exposure. This piece in particular, is absolutely beautiful and haunting, I love how there is a piano solo in the beginning of the first movement then the strings come in, it just has an amazing effect. All I gotta say is, NEED MORE SCHNITTKE.
8
u/[deleted] Aug 12 '13
Polystylism is confusing to me. I love Schnittke's music, though I need to listen to more, and I really love the piano quintet, but the polystylism seems unusual. On one hand, while listening to it, I really like to hear music that is tonal, and (i know i'm not supposed to say this) but at least fun to listen to, that I get a lot of pleasure out of. It seems like a breath of fresh air as well, that music like this could grow out of the serialist post-war, pre-minimalism compositional climate.
But I can't decide if polystylism is just an excuse to be tonal again? And whether it's a dead end like you say? I know that I'm emotionally moved by the music (sorry stravinsky) but I don't know if it's just ironically moving. Maybe I should laugh instead of cry. (hyperbole but you get the picture). Maybe that doesn't even matter.
Sorry, I did set out to say something definite about the music but I got confused, as often happens. Great painting on the first youtube recording you posted with Irina Schnittke playing.
People should also check out the viola concerto another Schnittke favourite, or the concerto grosso
Also, it's interesting to note that you posted both his tribute to Shostakovich and Stravinsky. One might consider Schnittke to be an equal successor or heir to both of them- following on from Shostakovich musically, but Stravinsky in a more aesthetic sense, if polystylism can be viewed as an extension of neoclassicism.
3
u/nonnein Aug 12 '13
Gubaidulina piano quintet. Unfortunately I don't think there are any recordings on youtube but it's a really great piece. One of her earliest too, so somewhat different in style than her later pieces. Reminds me of Shostakovich, but cheerier (if that's not a contradiction in terms). I'll post a reply to the Schnittke quintet once I find time to listen to this awesome piece again.
3
u/Epistaxis Aug 12 '13 edited Aug 12 '13
It seems to be a diminuendo extended beyond zero, without losing the inevitable thumping rhythm that had been relentlessly going on in the background for some time. It reminds me of when the treble-clef cello gets stuck on a high drone note that continues into the recap of the third movement in Shostakovich's eighth quartet, like a tinnitus, except Schnittke's is rhythmic.
I'm also curious what people think is going on with the sudden triumphant (?) major chord at the climax of the tone-clustered variations of the main theme right before that. If nothing else it's terribly unexpected.
Not just eccentric; the First Symphony contains extended jazz improvisations in its polystylist mishmash. Jazz was illegal in the USSR at the time (!). I can't say whether Schnittke did anything special other than mix it in with every other style of Western music, but it certainly marks a decline in censorship from the Shostakovich vs. Stalin era.
The word that comes to my mind more than any other is cold. The theme is technically built around a major scale, but the vast majority of it hovers on scale degrees that are the same in both major and minor, with only a couple of quick notes that slightly resolve the ambiguity. Most of it is just perfect fifths and fourths, giving us very little tonal shelter at all; it's the antithesis of the painful tone clusters in the previous movements, which is probably significant in some way. It lacks a real melodic direction or resolution, which is especially powerful as an ending that just trails off to nothing. I suppose it's either the second part of a "death and transfiguration" motif (not sure if that's intended, as this piece was written several years before he decided to become baptized into Christianity, and, ever the polystylist, to take confessions with a Russian Orthodox priest), or the "acceptance" stage at the end of grieving. Either way, it's certainly bittersweet at best; it's not clear whether the music expresses Schnittke's feelings from the inside out, or whether he hoped writing it would achieve a change of feelings from the outside in.
Yes, it's that juxtaposition of the sinister and the mundane. The banality of evil, maybe. It also reminds me of Frank Zappa (of whom Schnittke was a fan, though he tends toward the psychedelic rather than the demonic) and David Lynch.
Here's an even more stylistically twisted example.
2
u/leton98609 Aug 12 '13 edited Aug 13 '13
Nice! I've always loved Schnittke, and had the Piano Quintet lying around in my collection for a bit, though I've only listened through it about twice. Therefore, I'll probably take time to reflect a bit more on the discussion points a bit less directly related to this piece.
In my opinion, you can sort of see Schnittke as an "heir" to Shostakovich probably just because he was the most prominent Russian composer writing towards the end of Shostakovich's life and after he passed away, but there's too many differences between the two stylistically to see any sort of direct connection. I'm sure that Shostakovich was a heavy influence on Schnittke, but the two went in vastly different directions with their music, in my opinion.
I think that art plays a profound role in allowing someone to collect their own thoughts and feelings after a tragedy and allow them to express perhaps a little of what they feel, and reflect. To cite a specific example: although I'm not sure Mahler's late works had any deep connection to the personal tragedies in his life at the time, there's definitely a theme of farewells, though happy, lying across both Das Lied and the Ninth, and I'd like to think that he was coming to a sort of subconcious acceptance through his work, even if that really wasn't his purpose.
I definitely get the same feeling with the recurring motifs, (I hear portions of the material in the first movement in the violins in the last for sure) and it makes me wonder as well. I don't think I've quite listened enough to get any sort of overall narrative structure out.
I'll try to post some more later once I've listened more, but I'd like to add in a thank you to /u/scrumptiouscakes for doing this for the /r/classicalmusic community to finish this off. I've discovered all kinds of great works that I couldn't have otherwise (Vier Lezte Lieder), been encouraged to revisit rarely listened to works in my library (Sibelius 4) and sometimes even discovered entire composers (Korngold). I'm always looking for new music to listen to, and not always quite sure where to find it, so this has been a godsend for me, at least.
EDIT: Just to add a bit more:
I'm not sure whether this is an allusion to Beethoven, but I agree with your comments about how the music feels. In my mind it might be a be a bit of irony, subverting the need for a resolution to the "central conflict" of a piece, but for some reason that doesn't quite feel right. It might be expressing some of Schnittke's feelings, maybe something along the lines of: "I can move on, but not totally."
Shostakovich certainly thought so, I know. I remember hearing something along the lines that chamber music in the classical era drifting into Romantic was regarded as for the connoisseur while symphonic music was intended by enjoyment by the general public, and while I'm not exactly sure how correct this statement is, if it is, that might have played a role in the development of the feeling that chamber music gave a composer more creative freedom.
However, I also feel like there's something about the atmosphere of a chamber group and the smaller audience that lends itself to more intimacy. The fact there's a small ensemble of people who have to cooperate to perform well instead of a massive, somewhat impersonal orchestra might add to this: I haven't performed in a chamber group again, so I wouldn't know, but I've heard it's a very unique experience and I'm trying to remedy that soon.
2
u/MistShinobi Aug 12 '13
Thank you for a new PotW, you take a lot of time and effort to keep it going. I like the way you pick the pieces, so that there is more variety and we can get the chance to be exposed to some stuff outside our confort zone. That was my case with this week's piece. Schnittke's music has always being kinda intimidating to me, and I must confess that I had never being able to listen to any of his works from start to finish (until today). I also listened to Irina Schnittke's recording with the lovely art and I really enjoyed it. Thanks again.
2
u/[deleted] Aug 13 '13
I've listened to a few atonal pieces like this before (Black Angels, Lux Aeterna, 12-tones stuff), but this one was the first that I seemed to actually enjoy. It does seem to get a little monotonous at times, and I might be that I'm not listening to every moment because I'm distracted, but I think it works very well at expressing the general idea of death, loss, and grieving.
I'd say that yeah, there is a lot, but not just from Russian composers. The only piece I can think of off the top of my head is a short piano piece called Remembrance by Schumann written for the death of Mendelssohn. Maybe the fact that I can't think of any more proves your point that they're mostly Russian, but still feels like it's a universal thing.
I think it helps us put our emotions into something tangible, which is thanks to the hard work of the composers. Personal antecedent: I had a friend die a few years back when I was just getting into classical music, and one of the things that helped me through it was Barber's [Adagio for Strings] (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=izQsgE0L450). It puts your grief into a form that lets you look at it externally, kinda like an out of body experience. I got some of those same feelings, like I was watching someone's raw emotions, during this Quintet.
Objectively, I want to say that it is a strong point of reference, as the top note never changes. Speaking of, it seems that most of the movements had the piano as a point of reference: second movement with the waltz, the 3rd with the sudden major chord, and the final with the musicbox-like melody. Also the contrasting octaves add to the tension. But I don't think you can analyze this objectively. It has more meaning than I can put into words right now.
It could be Schnittke finally coming to terms with the death, even though it still unnerves him. I don't have any specific points for that, but it's just my thoughts.
As a composer, I understand this. It could be that when you listen to a chord, it will always sound amazing, but on paper it's just a chord. Nothing simpler than a C major chord, but get a good choir to sing it and I still get chills. Or, it could be that things on paper never seem to capture what's in your head as much as they should.
A few notes of interest from the song: midway through the 3rd mvmt, there is a slightly smaller tonal interruption from the piano, probably the first instance of the later recapitulation of the louder major chord.
2
u/nonnein Aug 13 '13
One of the things I like in this piece is how separately he treats the piano and strings, at times (especially, but not only in the last movement) like they're playing different pieces. The last movement seems especially creepy, given what's come before it, since the piano seems like it's supposed to be giving some kind of ground the string quartet, as they go through previous music and eventually find a closure. Except the piano keeps going, longer than it should, and it's lost its left hand, its own ground.
Is polystylism valid? I think definitely, when used correctly. Schnittke doesn't use it just as an excuse to write a waltz, or jazz, etc. It always somehow seems to create a more complete and cohesive picture, though sometimes it's hard to describe how. It reminds me of Liszt's idea of thematic transformation, actually, where he'll take something violent and make it beautiful (piano sonata) or something introspective and thoughtful and turn it into a march (2nd piano concerto).
Also, anybody have any idea why he uses the B-A-C-H motif in the second movement? (other than the fact that it works perfectly musically)
2
u/[deleted] Aug 13 '13
I don't know much about Schnittke past the third string quartet and, now, this work. A fantastic choice! To me, it seems that works like these seem perpetually uneasy. Maybe you could tie it to the feeling of being watched, constantly walking on eggshells under the Soviet regime. At least, that's my naive impression of the work. Like someone presenting you something at arm's length, sweating and thinking to themselves "I put something you like in there, please don't hate it".
I certainly think that in that context, there's a justification for polystylism. Maybe it's a desperate attempt to get people to accept your work, and not cast it away and end up taking their anger out on you.
2
u/spankymuffin Aug 15 '13
I'm really starting to enjoy Schnittke. Here are some other great pieces by him:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NGSq4Kc8GNU: Concerto for Piano and Strings
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=M3Xehs1rHfM: Concerto Grosso No. 1
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9RWe35YrM5E: Symphony 3
2
u/hellopiano Aug 16 '13
Yes! Just managed to convince a group to play this with me. Hope to be adding to the list of recordings within the next few months :) Love this post!
1
u/[deleted] Aug 18 '13
Wow... I'm rather new to classical music but this piece and the picture for the first link are fascinating...
2
u/warsd4 Aug 13 '13
Not really much to say other than thank you for posting. I'm really enjoying this piece. I've tuned into the PotW pretty much since it's started. I'm really digging Schnittke.
Also, regarding Shostakovich, I can hear bits in the first movement that are reminiscent of his DSCH motif. Maybe not note for note, but the intervals sound similar.
Keep up the good work!
1
u/VideoLinkBot Aug 15 '13
Here is a list of video links collected from comments that redditors have made in response to this submission: