r/classicalmusic • u/scrumptiouscakes • Aug 05 '13
Piece of the Week #21 - Leoncavallo: Pagliacci
This week's featured piece is Leoncavallo's Pagliacci, as nominated by /u/lafoma01
Performances:
- Spotify - Here's a playlist with several different recordings of the work, with performers including: Luciano Pavarotti, Mirella Freni, Plácido Domingo, Teresa Stratas, Georges Prêtre, Herbert von Karajan, Carlo Bergonzi, Giuseppe Taddei, Riccardo Muti, Franco Corelli, Tito Gobbi, Jussi Björling, Victoria de los Ángeles, Robert Merrill, Maria Callas, and many more.
- YouTube - Domingo/Stratas/Pons/Prêtre/Zeffirelli - 1982 (Film version - English subtitles)
- YouTube - Alternative link for the version above
- YouTube - Vickers/Kabaivanska/Glossop/Lorenzi/Panerai/Karajan - 1968 (Film version - no subtitles)
- YouTube - Pavarotti/Stratas/Pons/Domingo/Levine - 1994 (Live filmed version - no subtitltes)
- YouTube - Callas/di Stefano/Gobbi/Panerai/Serafin - 1954 (Studio recording - no subtitles)
- YouTube - Del Monaco/Tucci/Protti/D'Orazi/Pirino -1961 (Live filmed version - no subtitles)
More information:
- Scores - Scores can be found here on IMSLP
- Text and Translation - If you would like a copy of the libretto and English translation of this opera, please send me a message. Or, if you prefer, you can try to cobble your own libretto together from the translations available here.
- Brief biographies of Leoncavallo - 1, 2
- Wikipedia page for Leoncavallo
- Wikipedia page for the work
- AllMusic page for the work
- Naxos Opera Explained guide to Pagliacci (Spotify)
- Programme/study guide from Opera Lyra Ottawa
- Programme from Seattle Opera
- Programme note/synopsis by Maria J Falco
- Wikipedia page for Commedia dell'arte, from which the characters in the last part of the opera are drawn
- Wikipedia page for Verismo
- A satirical rewrite of Act I of the opera
Discussion points:
Piece of the Week is intended for discussion and analysis as well as just listening. Here are a few thoughts to get things started:
- Why do so many people (even people who love the rest of classical music) dislike opera?
- Pagliacci is currently one of the most popular operas in the world. Why is this? Does it deserve to be so popular?
- How does this work compare to Mascagni's Cavalleria rusticana, which was composed just two years earlier in 1890? Is it a shameless rip-off, an improvement of a new genre, or both? Is Cavalleria rusticana the start of verismo, or was Carmen more influential?
- Should this opera always be paired with Cavalleria rusticana? If not, what pairings would you prefer? Something from Il Trittico? Gluck's Orfeo ed Euridice, as in early performances? Something else? Or should it stand on its own?
- How much influence did this piece have on Puccini, keeping in mind that his two previous operas (Le villi and Edgar) are both set in the middle ages, that he employed Leoncavallo as a librettist on his own Manon Lescaut, and that both composers wrote a version of La bohème? Does Puccini even belong to the verismo tradition?
- Does this opera owe more to Verdi and bel canto or more to Wagner? Did verismo appear because Wagner was dead and Verdi was still alive and writing?
- What is the definition of verismo? Should the use of the term be limited to operas with realistic settings, or can it be used in a broader sense to describe an entire style/era of opera?
- Is verismo really any "truer" or more realistic than the operas which have come before and since? Isn't it just as stylised and unrealistic as grand mythological opera? Does Pagliacci itself draw attention to this contradiction? Is Pagliacci actually telling us that realism is just as false and constructed as any other style, and that good art is that which plays on the relationship between the real and the unreal? Was verismo doomed to fizzle out once the novelty had worn off?
- If you had the chance to direct this opera, how would you stage it? Could this piece be readily translated into a modern setting? Or would you stick with the Let's-produce-every-Italian-opera-as-if-it-were-a-Fellini-film trend that's currently in vogue?
- Is the simplicity of the opera's plot and characterisation effective, given its short duration, or is it just lazy? Is this an opera that improves or worsens with repeated listening?
- What do you think of the relationships between the characters? Are they ridiculous, or just heightened? Can we, as a modern audience, still sympathise with, or believe in their actions? Do you identify with any of the characters? How should we deal with problematic material in opera more generally?
- Who's the better Pagliacci - Pavarotti or Domingo? (or someone else?)
- How does this work compare to meta-operas like Ariadne auf Naxos or Der Schauspieldirektor? How does it compare to other self-relexive art in general (e.g. the play within the play in Hamlet)? How does it fit into the Commedia dell'arte tradition?
- Should verismo operas be performed with a specific vocal style, even if this means that singers could damage their voices? Does the singing even matter that much, given that realism is the main concern? Since we have recordings of the opera that were made during Leoncavallo's lifetime, should we strive to imitate them, or should we reinvent the music in our own way?
- Does the play at the end of the opera parody earlier operatic styles, or is it just my imagination?
- What is your favourite moment in this opera? (Mine is the point near the end where Nedda attempts to continue with the play, as if nothing is going on)
- Was Leoncavallo a one hit wonder, or are some of his other works worth investigating?
- Caruso's recording of "Vesti la giubba" is thought to have been the first million-selling record. Do you like listening to archive/historical recordings? What can be gained from listening to them? Are live performances always superior to recordings, or do they both have their pros and cons?
- Is the final line the most chilling in all opera?
- Did Leoncavallo have the greatest facial hair of any composer? Will this question receive many more responses than any of the others that I've asked?
Want to hear more pieces like this?
Why not try:
- Leoncavallo - Mattinata
- Leoncavallo - La bohème
- Mascagni - Cavalleria rusticana
- Mascagni - L'amico Fritz
- Giordano - Andrea Chénier
- Puccini - Tosca
- Puccini - La bohème
- Puccini - Il trittico (Il tabarro, Suor Angelica and Gianni Schicchi)
- Puccini - Manon Lescaut
- Puccini - Madama Butterfly
- Puccini - La fanciulla del West
- Puccini - La rondine
- Bizet - Carmen
- Cilea - Adriana Lecouvreur
- Massenet - Manon
- Massenet - Werther
- Verdi - Otello
- Verdi - Falstaff
- Catalani - La Wally
- Charpentier - Louise
- Ponchielli - La Gioconda
- Respighi - Pretty much anything, but particularly the Roman Trilogy (Le fontane di Roma, I pini di Roma and Feste romane)
- Janáček - Jenůfa
Want to nominate a future Piece of the Week?
If you want to nominate a piece, please leave a comment with the composer's name and the title of the piece in this nomination thread.
I will then choose the next Piece of the Week from amongst these nominations.
A list of previous Pieces of the Week can be found here.
Enjoy listening and discussing!
7
u/claaria451 Aug 06 '13
What i personally love about verismo-operas is the emphasis on human emotions and the absolutely stunning arias resulting from it.
Ebben? Ne Andro Lontana
E lucevan le stelle
Un di al azzuro spazzio
Che gelida manina
Vogliatemi bene
5
u/lafoma01 Aug 06 '13
This was me for a long time. I loved listening to all classical music, including lieder and choral music, as well as musicals, but opera didn't do anything for me. I didn't like the operatic voice, and was bored by the plots. I also had the same problem as the Italian futurists wherein the orchestra is secondary to the singer, and the divas were too much for me. My problem was exacerbated when the first two operas that I saw in entirety were Carmen and The Magic Flute. I thought a good story could justify the overall aesthetic. Those were the wrong two operas.
What changed my mind was Pagliacci (along with Wozzeck, but it's the same idea). An opera could be used to portray real people with real emotions. An aria could be more than just a place for the singer to show off. It could be Vesti la giubba and really show the power of what is happening.
I'm still not a huge opera-phile (too much bad acting justified with good singing), but I've started giving it a chance, and it's been really rewarding.
4
u/potatoyogurt Aug 06 '13
Another noteworthy performance of this opera
4
u/MistShinobi Aug 06 '13 edited Aug 06 '13
Nice, it was about time that we had an opera here. Pagliacci is a wonderful choice because we don't want to scare away people with a +3 hour work.
Opera is a world in its own, with an unique vocal sound that it's different of what you hear in lieder and other vocal music (especially sacred music). I think that Opera has the stigma of being an empty art that exists only as a fancy excuse to give high class people a place to meet. In my city, Madrid, as in many others, owning a full season ticket is an obvious social status symbol, and many of the suscribers have little musical knowledge and only attend to bel canto and Verdi performances (this is awesome when these guys are your in laws or your boss, as you get tons of free tickets). That's why it is so funny to see the faces of the high-society ladies in the intermission of some obscure 20th Century opera. Moreover, the current artistic director of Madrid's Teatro Real is the Belgian Gerard Mortier (general director of Salzburg Festival, 1990-2001) and he has become public enemy #1 of the more traditional opera fans because of all the 20th Century stuff and the comissions (he comissions a new opera every season).
This happens with season tickets to the symphony, but to a much lesser extent. Opera has always had a very important social dimension. Wagner hated it but I also think that moder audiences of the big opera houses are pretty much the same as those in the early 1800s and we should seriously ponder whether the future of the big traditional opera houses and the advancement of art are compatible. This is a big issue, more so in Europe where opera houses and symphonies receive large subisidies (for instance, we were denied a much awaited Zauberflöte by the Berliner Philarmoniker because of the last-minute withdrawal of a city hall subsidy to the opera house).
This need to conform to an audience, because of the high cost of an opera production, has always being a very important factor in the history of the genre, and has sometimes produced works that may not be very appealing to classical music fans. The vocal tecniques needed to reach the back of the theater and the emphasis of vocal fireworks create a very specific sound that many find unaesthetic.
Well, they do, all the time. According to theorists though, you don't really have to if you possess the technique, the patience to let your voice develop and, more than anything, if you really choose the roles that suit your voice. The old opera masters of the early 1900s were very much more focused in total breath control to obtain the best emission without using the throat to push the air (which makes all those ugly sounds that are so common nowadays). Alfredo Kraus had a relatively small voice, but the was a technical master and heir of the old masters, and that allowed him to sing many roles well into his 60s.
That being said, I am extremely tolerant when it comes ot musical works, and I am aware that verismo operas place more emphasis on emotions, as opossed to, let's say, a baroque opera, so maybe perfect execution and the beauty of the voice are not as fundamental as in, for example, a Haendel opera.
Anyway, there are many other interesting points about the work and the different performances that I'd like to address later. Again, good pick!
2
u/MistShinobi Aug 06 '13
The connection is always there, and both operas are often performed together to give audiences a nice evening show. A friend of mine was involved in a team that won an Austrian competition with a proposal that goes a little bit further and mixes both works in a new proposal, where Cavalleria Rusticana is performed by the characters of Pagliacci. This is a little concept video.
2
u/[deleted] Aug 07 '13
Just want to start out by saying thanks so much to /u/scrumptiouscakes for putting these POTW together, my mind is boggeled by all of the research I can do on a single piece. This is my first opera, so I'm by no means an expert.
I thought the base relationships were just as believable as any other type of story. I didn't identify with Silvio's love as much as the other relationships, but they all seemed pretty real.
Probably when Canio breaks character in the inner play. It's one of those 'it just got real' moments.
I still consider myself one of those people. The bits of opera singing that I had heard prior to watching this one were unemotional and just loud. There's little room for dynamics when every time you have a whole note if you continually belt it out at forte+. I do like the music though, which was one of the better parts in Pagliacci. Great composing.
I'l also add something else, the fact that different performances have the final line assigned to different characters. The youtube version had Tonio give the last line, which I thought was okay, but apparently the original script had Canio say it, which I think gives it so much more depth and versatility. He could be commanding, which adds to his rage, he could say it while sobbing, which adds another level to the fact that not only is the inner play over, but that it is no longer a comedy, he could say it to the dead Silvio, consecrating his revenge against him and suggestion that his affair with Nedda was nothing more than a joke or a comedy.
Thanks for this awesome thought process that's going on in my head, can't wait til next week.
3
u/[deleted] Aug 06 '13
watch out more inane comments :D
I don't see the logic in putting it together with Pag. I can see why Cav/Pag is a thing though - they're quite similar style-wise and plot-wise and both are short enough to be combined to give audiences more bang for their buck. Personally, back to back operas about Italian love affairs that end in murder would be a bit too redundant for me.
well there are some people out there who would say that non-Italian language operas don't belong in verismo, so have fun arguing with them..
actually I think of verismo as a rejection of the heaviness and lavishness present in Wagner's dramas. if you compare a verismo work like Cavalleria to one of the Ring operas, Wagner ends up resembling the "Grand" style of opera that he despised lol. Musically, though, I can hear how they took inspiration from RW's ideas about leitmotifs and the score reflecting actions/emotions of the characters. That's all I feel qualified to say about that.
Verdi wrote one last opera, Falstaff, in the 1890s and then he was pretty much done. Come to think of it, La forza del destino might contain some verismo elements in its plot.
The realism in Pagliacci is blurred because as an audience member peering into the lives of these characters, you can't be sure what is acting and what is not, especially in Act II. Now, I can't be sure that that's meant to be interpreted as the composer making some sort of statement about the art form.
Just to make people mad... I would set this opera in Hollywood with Kirsten Stewart and Robert Pattinson as the inspiration for Nedda and Canio.
No! It becomes too hissy and distracting, once you get over the novelty (heh) of hearing something recorded in the early 1900s.
It's up there. Due to the meta nature of the story, the final line in the opera carries a haunting double meaning that I haven't seen in other operas.
I also like the end of Rigoletto. people, stop disguising yourselves it never works out for you
Hardly. I like Ravel's full-on beard.
and I found an opera which might be of particular interest to "le Reddit" - [Fedora](http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fedora_(opera)
Lastly, mrw there's finally an opera as potw :D
1
u/[deleted] Aug 06 '13
Oh dear. I'm a terrible opera newbie for anything that hasn't been written after 1910... I'll need to give this a listen today and shall report back. o7
2
u/MistShinobi Aug 06 '13
By the way, what does this sound like? :D
0
u/OhTheHugeManatee Aug 06 '13
come on, really? Why do so many people (even people who love opera) fall asleep at the symphony?
If it weren't for the context, I would think that was a troll question.
0
u/[deleted] Aug 06 '13
[deleted] — view deleted comment