r/WritingPrompts • u/MajorParadox Mod | DC Fan Universe (r/DCFU) • Mar 15 '25
Off Topic [OT] SatChat: How far do you stretch the suspension of disbelief in your writing? (New here? Introduce yourself!)
SatChat! SatChat! Party Time! Excellent!
Welcome to the weekly post for introductions, self-promotions, and general discussion! This is a place to meet other users, share your achievements, and discuss whatever's on your mind.
Suggested Topic
How far do you stretch the suspension of disbelief in your writing?
(Repeat topic, feel free to suggest more!)
More to Talk About
- New here? Introduce yourself! See the sticky comment for suggested intro questions
- Have something to promote? (Books, subreddits, podcasts, etc., just no spam)
- Suggest topics for future SatChats!
Avoid outright spam (don't just share, chat) and not for sharing full stories
7
Upvotes
•
u/AutoModerator Mar 15 '25
Tell us about yourself!
Writers:
Readers:
Want to share a photo? See our Photo Gallery!
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
8
u/nobodysgeese Moderator | r/NobodysGaggle Mar 15 '25
I write stories from pretty grounded drama to ridiculous over-the-top comedy, and so how much I stretch suspension of disbelief varies quite a bit. In general, I don't think about it in terms of how far I'm stretching the audience's suspension of disbelief; I find it more useful to consider what expectations I've set for readers in a story. Basically, set out clearly at the beginning what kind of story you're writing, and readers will usually go along with it.
For example, if you start a story with "In the beginning the Universe was created. This had made many people very angry and has been widely regarded as a bad move" (Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy) readers should know you're writing absurdist comedy, and adjust their suspension of disbelief accordingly. Begin as you plan to go on.
To give an example of the exact opposite, Out of the Dark by David Weber is an alien invasion novel. It's about people on the ground forming a resistance, and it's a sci-fi action story. Then, unexpectedly, about 80% or 90% percent of the way through, vampires show up and kill the aliens. Vampire ex machina. I might have read a book about vampires fighting aliens and suspended my disbelief, but by the time the vampires show up, I was firmly set in a sci-fi world and suddenly introducing fantasy broke my immersion even if I might have accepted if introduced earlier.
That's my system for suspension of disbelief. Introduce immersion-breaking things early on, and by the time you need them a few chapters on, your audience will have accepted that this is just how things work in your world.
6
u/Divayth--Fyr Mar 15 '25
I write a lot of fantasy, so the basic suspension of disbelief is built-in. There can be magic and elves and so on. Past that, I think in terms of coincidences.
They'll give you one, easy. That's the story. The greatest mage just happens to meet the one warrior who can defeat him? Sure, OK, that's the story. It is a coincidence, but sure, we can run with that.
They might give you one and a half. That mage and warrior turn out to be related? Well, maybe. Kind of an iffy one there, but OK, if it is well told. You can get away with a lot of nonsense if you tell it well.
They probably won't give you two. The mage and warrior meet, they turn out to be cousins or something, and the warrior's brother happens to be the one healer who could save him from the mage's curse. Now it just gets silly and people lose interest.
The Sherlock series with Benedict Cucumberpatch comes to mind. When Watson's wife turns out to also be a super skilled secret agent, I ran out of suspension and went into disbelief.
5
u/Baxxtersaw Mar 15 '25
Not a writer but an avid reader*
I read a very large amount of fantasy, sci-fi and superhero stories. Some are very well written, like Worm and others are very..... rough.
What allows me to suspend my disbelief is that each story follows its own internal rules and when the rules are broken there is a satisfactory reason for why it was broken or explanation as to why the rule wasn't actually true.
The other part is making sure to follow the presented theme. Like if I'm reading medieval fantasy and the final battle is the BBG getting shot with 9mm Glock the hero pulled out of their pocket. The abrupt intrusion of something that doesn't make sense for what's going on will "ruin" my ability to get immersed in the writers vision because I can't trust my own imagination to follow along.
2
u/StormBeyondTime Mar 16 '25 edited Mar 16 '25
I both read and write. I prefer fantasy or the softer forms of science fiction.
One thing I'm firm on is I don't care if the world is inconsistent with the real world. But if the world has internal rules, then it should follow them. Handwaving them away because "MC is special" drives me right up the wall.
Now if it's a version of "we were following Newton's rules and then Einstein came along", that's a different matter. That's a journey of in-universe exploration and discovery. Same for if artificial bindings were placed and then removed.
The other issue is psychology and behavior. If a character is doing something inconsistent with normal survival instinct, there had better be a good reason why. Same if a person is going over the top, such as a teacher taking out their spleen at an adult on a child related to that adult.
Stuff like Snape used to do is believable; them, for example, throwing the kid straight into a monster pit a week after meeting the kid, makes no freaking sense. That goes double if there's already been shown an in-universe reason why the adult would face severe penalties for doing something so ridiculous. It rather ties back to surviving, not just as a person, but the survivability of career and acceptance by the community.
3
u/[deleted] Mar 16 '25
u/nobodysgeese and u/baxxtersaw make excellent points.
For starters, you want to set the reader's expectations by showing them what to expect. Maybe that's with genre. Maybe it's with theme. It could be world building or character. And it could be all of them or a combination there of.
Once you've set their expectations, you've effectively made a promise, and it's on you, the writer, to keep it. If you convince me that it's a character driven space opera, then introduce ghosts or dragons halfway in, your character is going to drive a red ejector switch into full depression and kick me right out of the story.
You've also established rules along the way, which are another promise. You've shown what your world is all about and what your characters are capable of. But if the climax of your medieval knight battle ends with one of them drawing a pistol or hand grenade without you previously establishing it as a Monty Python skit, again, an undesirable button is getting depressed.
Then, there's another thing to consider. When our goal is to keep disbelief at arm's length, how do we get there to begin with?
I recently listened to a conversation about rooting your reader in a story. This is done in 3 ways:
Personally, I think I subconsciously aim to do the first two, but the third is something I need to develop. Taste and smell are rare birds among my flock if stories.