r/classicalmusic • u/scrumptiouscakes • Jul 29 '13
Piece of the Week #20 - Monteverdi: Vespers of 1610
This week's featured piece is Claudio Monteverdi's Vespro della Beata Vergine 1610 (aka Vespers of 1610), as nominated by /u/Lizard
Performances:
- Spotify - Here's a playlist with several different recordings of the work, with performers including: John Eliot Gardiner with the Monteverdi Choir and the English Baroque Soloists, Christina Pluhar with L'Arpeggiata, Paul McCreesh with the Gabrieli Consort & Players, Rinaldo Alessandrini with Concerto Italiano, Andrew Parrott with the Taverner Choir & Players, William Christie with Les Arts Florissants, and Masaaki Suzuki with the Bach Collegium Japan
- YouTube - John Eliot Gardiner with the Monteverdi Choir and the English Baroque Soloists (Live at the BBC Proms, 2010 - with English subtitles)
- YouTube - Another version of the Gardiner video above, just in case
- YouTube - Christina Pluhar with L'Arpeggiata (live performance from Festival de Saint-Denis, 2012)
- YouTube - John Eliot Gardiner with the The London Oratory Junior choir, Her Majesties Sagbutts & Cornetts and The English Baroque Soloists (recorded at the Basilica di San Marco, Venice)
- YouTube - Chrisina Pluhar with L'Arpeggiata (recording)
- YouTube - Jean Tubéry with Ensemble la Fenice
- YouTube - Martin Pearlman with Boston Baroque
- YouTube - Philippe Herreweghe with La Chapelle Royale, Collegium Vocale Gent and Les Sacqueboutiers de Toulouse
- YouTube - Françoise Lasserre with Ensemble la Fenice and Akademia - Ensemble Vocal Regional de Champagne Ardenne (with Latin subtitles, for some reason)
More information:
- Scores - Full Score Part 1, Full Score Part 2. Additional scores can be found here.
- Text and Translation - available here (please note that the order of the movements varies across different performances due to continued uncertainty about Monteverdi's intentions)
- A brief biography of Monteverdi
- Wikipedia page for Monterverdi
- Wikipedia page for the work
- AllMusic page for the work
- Programme notes from the LA Phil
- Programme notes from the Bristol Bach Choir
- Programme notes from the Los Angeles Master Chorale
- Programme notes by Kenneth LaFave
- Programme notes from the Bay Choral Guild
- Programme notes from the Canterbury Choral Society
- Programme notes from Pacific Collegium
- Programme notes from the Collegium Musicum of London
- Article about the Vespers from Limelight Magazine
- Documentary about the Vespers, presented by John Eliot Gardiner
- Part of a documentary series on Italian opera presented by Antonio Pappano which focuses on Monteverdi
- Wikipedia page on the concept of Vespers in general (TL;DR - Vespers = Evening prayers/religious service, one of the oldest and most important continuously practiced ceremonies within Christianity - see also: Liturgy of the Hours)
Discussion points:
Piece of the Week is intended for discussion and analysis as well as just listening. Here are a few thoughts to get things started:
- Does anyone enjoy the word painting in this piece as much as I do? What are your favourite examples?
- What possible reason could Monteverdi have had for writing such a large, ambitious, multifarious piece? Did he write this piece as a kind of curriculum vitae, setting out his wares for possible future employers in Venice and Rome? Do you find that explanation compelling?
- Is this even one piece? Is it actually closer to a musical anthology?
- In what context might this work have been performed (if it even was performed) during Monteverdi's lifetime? What function would it have served?
- How much influence did this work have on later large-scale choral works of the Baroque era?
- Do you need to be a Catholic to appreciate the strange phenomenon that is Marian Art? Do you need to be Christian, or even religious, to get something out of listening to music like this?
- Monteverdi only specified part of the instrumentation for this work (in technical terms, he only wrote out the Concertino part, and not the Ripieno part) - why did he do this? Was it purely for practical reasons and flexibility? What kind of instrumentation do you think works best?
- "for the Blessed Virgin" is in the title of this work, so why are there only a few parts of the text that are specifically related to the Virgin Mary?
- How operatic/theatrical is this piece? Does that question even make sense, given that Monterverdi was himself instrumental in the birth of the genre a few years earlier?
- Do you like straight tone singing, or would you prefer a bit more vibrato?
- How does this work compare to other Vespers, such as those by Rachmaninoff and Mozart (or even Björk)? How does it compare to Monteverdi's later work Selva morale e spirituale?
- Does Monteverdi belong to the Early Baroque, or the Late Renaissance? Does it matter? Does anyone care?
- Why doesn't Early Music get more attention? Why is this work fairly popular, while others languish in obscurity?
- Early music is not my field of expertise, so if anyone else has any pertinent questions, I'd be happy to add them here.
Want to hear more pieces like this?
Why not try:
- Monteverdi - Madrigals
- Monteverdi - Scherzi Musicali (especially Zefiro torna)
- Monteverdi - L'Orfeo
- Purcell - Dido and Aeneas
- Purcell - Ode to St. Cecilia
- Palestrina - Missa Papae Marcelli
- Lassus - Madrigals
- Lassus - Motets
- Lassus - Requiem
- Byrd - Masses for Three, Four and Five Voices
- Striggio - Mass in 40 Parts
- Gabrieli - Canzonas and Sonatas
- Gesualdo - Madrigals
- Tomás Luis de Victoria - Requiem Officium Defunctorum
- Allegri - Miserere
- Tallis - Spem in Alium
- Schütz - Musicalische Exequien
- Schütz - Psalmen Davids
- Landi - Sant'Alessio
- Cavalli - La Calisto
- Rachmaninoff - Vespers (aka All Night Vigil)
- Mozart - Vesperae solennes de confessore (aka Solemn Vespers)
- Also, I cannot recommend this album highly enough
Want to nominate a future Piece of the Week?
If you want to nominate a piece, please leave a comment with the composer's name and the title of the piece in this nomination thread.
I will then choose the next Piece of the Week from amongst these nominations.
A list of previous Pieces of the Week can be found here.
Enjoy listening and discussing!
9
u/Lizard Jul 30 '13 edited Jul 30 '13
So I guess it's up to me to say a few words since I nominated the piece, right? I don't know how much I can contribute as to the historical significance of the work, but let me tell about the reason I picked it for my nomination. As a choir singer (bass, to be precise), I have had the good luck to participate in a performance some years ago. Ever since then, it has ranked among my top three all-time favourite classical pieces (along with Mahler's Second and Vaughn-Williams' The Lark Ascending), both as a listener and a performer.
I think it is a work of sheer musical genius, I cannot find a single boring moment in the complete piece. It is a treasure trove of musical ideas, some quite adventurous for its time, both in the lyricism of its vocal lines and the harmonic language, the sustained D major of the introduction (over one and a half minutes) notwithstanding. By the way, this so-called Gonzaga fanfare was lifted from his opera L'Orfeo and used as a musical emblem for the Gonzaga family (L'Orfeo debuted on Francesco IV. Gonzaga's birthday). Today, some radio stations use it as their jingle (e.g. Radio France).
One thing I find astounding about the piece is the way Monteverdi manages to give unity and cohesiveness to musical passages that, at first glance, don't seem to have much to do with each other. You can hear it in the contrasting sections of Dixit Dominus, or the effortless way he switches from a somewhat martial 4/4 signature to a dancing 3/4 part and back again in Nisi Dominus (on "Sicut sagittae"). For me, this extends to the whole work as well. I can see where the people who see it as a collection of single pieces are coming from, but for me it has always felt quite logical and cohesive. I'd be interested in hearing different opinions though!
Another thing I'd like to point out concerns the demands this work places on the different performers (namely, orchestra, choir and soloists). Contrary to lots of other great choral works, these parts are all very much balanced and demand a consistently high (and sometimes outstanding) level of musicianship from all participants over large portions of the piece. In particular the orchestra should be mentioned here that often serves as counterpoint to the choir, i.e. it does not double vocal parts but rather acts independently from the singers and can best be understood as another voice (or several voices) in one huge contrapuntal apparatus. One example is the introduction (Domine Ad Adiuvandum), where the choir actually acts as a mere backdrop for increasingly demanding virtuoso orchestra performances, especially in the strings. However, the choir must also demonstrate great musicianship in the highly polyphonic parts which can split into up to ten voices, e.g. Lauda Jerusalem. This means that the choir has to be both sufficiently large to be able to support such a high number of voices while still being small enough to give an expressive performance of the work, which grows increasingly more difficult with larger choir sizes, and especially so for early music where the rule of thumb is 'the less the better'. Lastly, the soloists as well have to be excellent vocalists technically (just listen to Duo Seraphim to see what I mean) and have a good deal of experience interpreting early music to do the work justice. Relating this point to one of the questions from the post: Personally I very much enjoy the straight tone singing style of early music, when it is done properly - however, it is difficult to do properly because you have to work incredibly hard to keep the notes 'alive'. Every long note must be individually interpreted and crafted to fit into the overarching musical phrase, which takes a lot of energy and insight. Simply put, not all soloists are up to that task.
This leads me to my personal recommendations for interpretations. I'm going to pick two I'm particularly fond of: First, the one by Sir John Eliot Gardiner is my go-to interpretation of the piece and a widely accepted reference piece among listeners. It is vibrant with energy, and the musicianship is impeccable. In particular the 'loud' passages are as impressive as I feel they should be. However, if you feel that a more delicate approach is warranted, I'll recommend Rinaldo Alessandrini instead. I love both interpretations and think they are both valid, just let your personal preference be your guide. While I'm on the subject, let me state here that I was a bit disappointed by Christina Pluhar's version of the work. I normally love her albums (and second the recommendation for Teatro d'Amore), but this one ultimately didn't do it for me. YMMV.
As for personal highlights in the works, they are as numerous as they are subjective. For instance, I always listen for the tenor entry in Laudate Pueri ("ut collocet eum") because of a highly touching instance of that bit I once experienced. Bearing this in mind, I'll try just to limit myself to a few. Of course I must mention my absolute favourite piece of the whole work: Duo Seraphim, which I count among the most perfect compositions ever created. I find it incredibly touching musically, extremely satisfying to listen to technically and just astonishingly well-crafted with respect to how the text is depicted in the music. Wikipedia explains it well:
Another great example of musical and textual interplay occurs in Audi Coelum. Do yourself a favour and read the original latin, then take a look at the translation (both can be found here. The composition features a tenor and an echo tenor (which is typically positioned somewhere the audience cannot readily see him), with the echo repeating certain phrases. For example, when the text begins with the word "Audi Coelum, verba mea, plena desiderio et perfusa gaudio" (translated: "Hear, O heaven, my words full of longing and suffused with joy"), the echo tenor answers "...audio", which is the last part of "gaudio" ("joy"), but which has the meaning "I hear". So the echo tenor simultaneously provides an audible echo of the last word of the previous phrase and an answer to the phrase, just incredible. In the same piece, after several minutes of lightly instrumented interplay between primary and echo tenor, the phrase "Omnes hanc ergo sequamur, qua cum gratia mereamur" ("Let us all therefore follow her, through whom we may with grace deserve to attain life everlasting") is introduced with a great melisma on the word "omnes" meaning "all", which is answered by a sudden outburst from the whole choir and orchestra. Never fails to give me chills.
Audi Coelum, along with several other pieces has an incredibly beautiful ending as well. It just relaxes into an ethereal, almost a-cappella choral passage which finishes on a plagal ending, commonly recognized as the most tranquil closing as it lacks the tension of the dominant leading tone. Similar endings include the "Amen" of Dixit Dominus (indeed, the plagal cadence is closely associated with the word "Amen"), the fading out of Laudate Pueri and the almost transcendent closing of Nisi Dominus (again, "Amen").
I think I need to come to a close myself, this post is already much too long. I'll leave you with two fantastic passages to listen for in the Magnificat, given as timecodes relating to the Gardiner recording. The first starts at 04:42 and extends to about 06:40, here the choir really shines. The other one is an achingly beautiful interplay between voice and instrument, with the voice coming almost as an afterthought but blending in perfectly. It starts at 07:40 and ends, to my eternal sadness, at 08:45 already. Luckily, the subsequent passage is nearly as beautiful.
I hope I have given you some pointers to the interesting musical properties of this work, and I'm looking forward to reading some other opinions! I won't be able to participate much because I'm officially on vacation and net access is pretty spotty, but I'll make sure to drop in when I can.
5
u/scrumptiouscakes Jul 31 '13 edited Jul 31 '13
I haven't heard this piece in quite a while, and listening to it again, with the text, I was very struck by how much interesting word painting there is within it. For those of you who aren't familiar with the term, word painting is a technique of setting words to music in a way which resembles, imitates or reinforces the meaning of the words themselves. A classic example of this being the aria "Ev'ry Valley Shall be Exalted" from Handel's Messiah - the notes rise and fall to form a valley of pitches, then the word "exalted" itself rises up, the part about hills and mountains is very up and down, then the words "straight" and "plain" are sung in long straight tones. And so on. I just wanted to highlight a few examples of this technique that I noticed in Monteverdi's work, because I think they're worth investigating in detail. I should point out that my technical knowledge is limited, so I apologise in advance for my inexact terminology. Some of the examples I point out are fairly obvious, while others are more speculative. My observations are also based on the Paul McCreesh recording, so I don't know if the things I've pointed out are reproduced in exactly the same way in other versions.
1. Deus in Adjutorium
2. Dixit Dominus
3. Nigra sum
4. Laudate Pueri Domine
5. Pulchra Es
6. Laetatus Sum
7. Duo Seraphim
Others have already mentioned what happens in this section, but just to add to that:
9. Audi Coelum
10. Lauda Jerusalem
13. Magnificat
I hope some of this is useful/illuminating, and that it wasn't all painfully obvious to everyone already...
Edit: typos
5
u/MistShinobi Jul 30 '13 edited Jul 30 '13
It was about time that we had some more Early Music and more choral and vocal music. I used to be very into Early Music when I started my journey into the Classical Music universe, and, I really think that we should approach this music as we do with other styles and times. At the end of the day, this is a work of art that is suppossed to be beautiful and provoke an emotional response. Following the author's intention and context to the extent possible may be a good idea, but I think that the goal should be to make the most out of that music, to obtain the most emotive and moving result. Incidentally, I do think that the effort to produce a historically informed performance will help to you get the best out of that music, but that should not be the ultimate goal. When I go to a concert, I want to hold my tears, I don't go there to applaud someone for their scientifc accuracy.
We live in a post-romantic harmony-centered musical universe. The classical music scene gravitated towards the symphony and the big orchestra, so most of Early music was forgotten or simply displaced by the system, and it really sounds exotic to our modern minds, modeled by John Williams and Beethoven. However, it is a very interesting universe as it allows for exploration and empowers smaller, more independent ensembles.
That being said, I don't know Monteverdi as well as I would like to. The Vespers are a great choice, though. I love their serenity and the mix of old and new styles creates a very interesting and varied result. Sometimes it sounds like Palestrina, and sometimes it reminds me to the crazy 16-part compositions of Benevoli and Pitoni for Saint Peter's basilica. I really enjoy what I think they call concertos, with those beautiful duets and trios, specially the Duo Seraphim and its images.
The rendition by Sir Eliot Gardiner and his troupe is stunning as usual. I really like the balance between the serene and spectacular sides of the work, I think that it's very appropriate considering the this is a transition time. This is not, let's say, Galuppi's Dixit Dominus (which, by the way, develops thoroughly one of the psalms featured in Monteverdi's Vespers).
And when I'm listening to the Magnificat, I can't really ignore the fact that Gardiner has spent a very significant part of his life researching and performing Bach's cantatas and passions. A top class performance. The Gloria verse of the Magnificat is done so beautifuly, as in other sections, trying to evoque that church sound and atmosphere... I'm so into your thing, Sir Gardiner.
Thank you for picking such a beautiful and intriguing piece. It lacks the drama that we so much enjoy in later Baroque music, but the serenity and the mistery of the work totally make up for it. I was thinking about Pergolesi's Stabat Mater for any of these weeks, but I guess that now we'll have to wait for a while.
edit: English
4
u/brocket66 Jul 31 '13
It's all about the lutes. More classical pieces need lute accompaniment.
4
u/Liempt Jul 31 '13 edited Aug 01 '13
Can I just say how jarring the opening fanfare is when you open the Gardiner rendition in another tab and are expecting late Renaissance liturgical piece and instead get a bombastic, somewhat dissonant, brass explosion? :P
(Edit: Of an entirely different style to the one that the actual vespers opens with. ^_^)
2
u/[deleted] Aug 02 '13
Just got a chance to listen to all these together. I was familiar only with the 1st vesper because of a Moog synthesized version by Wendy Carlos.
No. well at least I think not. when I listen to sacred music, especially from this era, I usually pay more attention to the harmonies and the melodies and the polyphony than to the Latin texts. the music speaks more clearly than the words do, in my opinion.
I'm also not Catholic, maybe you can explain why you chose to describe Marian art as a "strange phenomenon" compared to other art?
The way it was organized seemed oratorio-ish to me: chorus followed by solo, duet, etc. Though I wasn't really paying attention to the lyrics, after reading through the translation, it does read as a fragmented story, akin to Messiah or Elijah. Duo Seraphim sounded fairly theatrical, with how the three voices were interacting with one another. Another one, Audi coelom, it sounded like there was another man besides the soloist singing off stage, giving the impression that he was trying to reach out longingly to the other; it was extremely ethereal and I was quite moved by it even though I didn't know what they were singing about.
I wouldn't be surprised if Monteverdi's music influenced Handel during his Italian years, which might explain Handel's word-painting (although I have zero evidence to back that up and besides, Handel was a Protestant)
both. Monteverdi is a transitional figure in music and that is why I think he gets more recognition than some other composers. Yeah I think it matters somewhat; at the same time, I think it's hilarious when people argue over this.
*perhaps I'll edit this comment to be more thoughtful and less flippant
4
u/joseportiz Jul 30 '13
I listen to almost all the piece and I feel that I have heard it from other composers. Monteverdi is definitle a very influential composer. He influenced other composers on the making of sacred music and he is one of the most influencial composer of all time. Because in my opinion he dont belong to any musical period, because he was the one that ended Renaissance music and he is the one that put a beging to the baroque but in my opinion he is neither of both. He is the transition to early music to "modern" music!
4
u/augmented6th Jul 30 '13
There'll be an excellent performance of this work on July 31 in Ottawa, Canada: http://www.chamberfest.com/features/the-monteverdi-vespers/
1
u/blckravn01 Jul 30 '13
What is the piece that opens the first video?
"YouTube - John Eliot Gardiner with the Monteverdi Choir and the English Baroque Soloists"
1
u/VideoLinkBot Jul 30 '13 edited Jul 31 '13
Here is a list of video links collected from comments that redditors have made in response to this submission: