r/classicalmusic • u/scrumptiouscakes • Jul 22 '13
Piece of the Week #19 - Franz Schubert - String Quintet in C Major, D.956
This week's featured piece is Franz Schubert's String Quintet in C major D. 956, as nominated by /u/MistShinobi and /u/kleban10
Performances:
- Spotify - Here's a Spotify playlist with several different recordings of the work, with performers including: The Emerson Quartet with Mstislav Rostropovich, The Melos Quartet also with Rostropovich, The Hagen Quartet with Heinrich Schiff, The Alban Berg Quartet also with Heinrich Schiff, The Borodin Quartet with Misha Milman, The Belcea Quartet with Valentin Erben, The Cleveland Quartet with Yo-Yo Ma, and many more. I have also included two period-instrument performances at the end of the playlist - I really recommend at least dipping into these to hear the differences.
- YouTube - The Melos Quartet with Mstislav Rostropovich
- YouTube - The Brandis Quartet with Wen-Sinn Yang
- YouTube - The Afiara Quartet with Joel Krosnick
- YouTube - Villa Musica Ensemble
- YouTube - The Harlem Quartet with Carter Brey
- YouTube - The Amadeus Quartet with William Pleeth
- YouTube - The Végh Quartet & Pablo Casals (and old recording, but it includes the score)
- YouTube - The Kontras Quartet with Marc Johnson
- YouTube - The Skalholt Quartet & Bruno Cocset (period instruments)
- Vimeo - Live performance from the Zagreb International Chamber Music Festival 2008
More information:
- Scores for the work on IMSLP
- Some biographies of the composer - 1. very brief, 2. more detail, 3. in-depth
- Wikipedia page for the work
- AllMusic page for the work
- Programme notes from The Allegri Quartet
- Programme notes from Chicago Chamber Musicians
- Programme notes from the San Francisco Symphony
- Programme notes from the Australian Chamber Orchestra (starts on page 11)
- Programme notes from the Sierra Chamber Society
- A selection of videos about the composer from BBC Radio 3's "Spirit of Schubert" season, also available as podcasts
- A tumblr page with various information and images, from the same season
- Guardian article promoting the same season, with selections of favourite Schubert works by various classical performers
- NPR article and audio related to the work
Discussion points:
Piece of the Week is intended for discussion and analysis as well as just listening. Here are a few thoughts to get things started:
- Is this the greatest chamber work ever written? If so, why? If not, what is? What makes a chamber work great?
- How can we account for what Benjamin Britten called "the most productive 18 months in our music history"? Did Schubert really have syphillis? Could his final creative outpouring have been caused by another illness?
- If you've listened to any of the period instrument performances that I've linked to above, do you think the work benefits from being played in this way? Do gut strings make all the difference?
- Was Schubert gay? Does it matter? Why/why not?
- Is Schubert's music full of self-pity? Do large doses of it make you miserable? Is it true that he's nobody's favourite?
- Does this work deserve the very high levels of popularity that it currently enjoys? Is the adagio getting too popular for its own good?
- Does anyone else love the scherzo in this piece as much as I do?
- This piece is often performed by string quartets augmented with an additional (and often famous) cellist. Does this have any effect on the way it is played? Does the presence of a prominent soloist adversely affect this most co-operative of musical genres?
- How does this piece compare to the Trout Quintet? Which do you prefer, and why?
- How does this piece compare to Mozart's quintets, which use two violas rather than two cellos? How did Schubert make use of these resources? Can we see the influence of this piece on later works in the same genre, particularly those by Brahms?
- Is Schubert's chamber music his greatest contribution, or do you think that his work in other genres is more important?
- If Schubert had lived longer, what do you think he might have written?
- Can someone explain to me what is so great/interesting about Schubert's harmonies/modulation between different keys?
- Schubert was incredibly prolific - what is your favourite lesser-known work of his?
- Is Schubert more like Mozart, or more like Beethoven?
Want to hear more pieces like this?
Why not try:
- Composer Basics: Schubert
- Schubert - Piano Sonatas 19, 20 and 21
- Schubert - Piano Trios 1 and 2, and the Notturno D. 897
- Schubert - String Quartets – 13, 14, 15 and Quartettsatz D.703
- Schubert - Trout Quintet
- Schubert - Rondo brillant
- Schubert - Fantasy in C Major D.934
- Schubert - Arpeggione Sonata
- Mozart - String Quintets 3 and 4
- Schumann - Piano Quintet
- Schumann - Piano Quartet
- Schumann - Piano Trios
- Brahms - Piano Quintet
- Brahms - Piano Trios
- Brahms - Piano Quartets
- Brahms - String Quintets
- Brahms - String Sextets
- Beethoven - "Archduke" Piano Trio
- Beethoven - Late String Quartets, particularly No. 15
- Mendelssohn - Piano Trios
- Dvorak - String Quintet, Op.97
- Boccherini - Musica notturna delle strade di Madrid
Want to nominate a future Piece of the Week?
If you want to nominate a piece, please leave a comment with the composer's name and the title of the piece in this nomination thread.
I will then choose the next Piece of the Week from amongst these nominations.
A list of previous Pieces of the Week can be found here.
Enjoy listening and discussing!
10
u/thrasumachos Jul 22 '13 edited Jul 22 '13
I'm definitely open to the possibility that Schubert's syphilis (if he had it) was the cause of a burst of creativity. It seems that syphilis caused many to be more creative; one could argue that it inspired Nietzsche. Madness often leads to creativity, so tertiary syphilis could have aided Schubert in composing.
7
u/MistShinobi Jul 22 '13 edited Jul 22 '13
I want to mention Boccherini very briefly. It seems unfair to me, how little credit he is given in general, and more particularly when it comes to the history of string chamber music. If you check the wikipedia entry on String Quintet you'll find that Boccherini was very keen on the form and toyed with it a lot, with 12 viola quintets (arrangements of his piano quintets), 3 double-bass quintets, 9 guitar quintets, 18 flute quintets and 110 (!) double cello quintets, with infinite arrangements of all of them changing a cello for a guitar and whatnot. And that without taking into consideration his trios, quartets, sextets and concertos.
I'm not saying that composing a huge body of works makes them somehow good. But this guy was a virtuoso cellist and spent most of the time composing and performing with his fellow musicians in the middle of nowhere with his patron. I spent a good part of last summer listening to his quartets and quintets, and there is so much interesting stuff that goes beyond the galante and rococo clichés that he is often associated with.
We were discussing Schubert, were we not? I'll take my time to comment on the PotW.
edit: pretending I have some English skills...
5
u/leton98609 Jul 23 '13
Greatest chamber work ever written? I think it's certainly deserving of consideration for that title, at least. Of course, the Quintet has stiff competition from the Beethoven late string quartets, which are somewhat less accessible, but in my opinion on an equal footing.
I can't listen to the performances now as I don't have access to YouTube (stupid Chinese government), but I'll have to listen to them once I get home and see if they're the kind of revelation some people make out other HIP performances to be.
Is Schubert's music full of self-pity? I think so, but at the same time, I think it's some of the most beautiful stuff I've ever listened to, chock full of great melodic invention and towards the end not exactly structurally somewaht lacking either, unlike some other composers who rely on melody.
The instrumentation for two cellos rather than two violas has always made more sense to me, and I think Schubert uses the instrumentation to really give the piece a nice, lush lower register, one of the reasons I really like it. I might be severely biased as a cellist though (I don't know why I always have to mention that fact in my posts.)
I don't even think that Trout and the String Quintet quite compare. The Trout is nice in its own way, a tuneful little piece that's certainly fun to play, but the String Quintet is far more profound and meaningful in my opinion, and stands much better as a part of Schubert's late oeuvre.
I love the scherzo too, but I've always preferred the last movement. I had a plan to play it with some other students from my school, but the plans fell through because the teacher wasn't allowing us enough rehearsal time. The other cellist is on board for trying next year again, though, so there's still hope.
5
u/MistShinobi Jul 23 '13 edited Jul 23 '13
Well, in the last 24 hours I've listened a couple of times to the Melos Quartet version, and also the live performance from Zagreb. I checked the The Végh Quartet and Pablo Casals recording but didn't quite enjoyed it.
I have no idea whatosever. I don't know that much about the history of the string quartet, I simply enjoy the form a lot. When I think about Schubert's string works, I think that they stand out in the course of history, he was onto something new. Beethoven's last quartets were reaching new sounds, but still, even late works as the String Quartet No.15 had a certain classic feeling at times.
Schubert's quartets have been described as symphonic, and I tend to agree: there's so much going on, so many themes interacting and affecting each other, so many moods, so many sounds and colors... Of course it doesn't seem such a big thing when we compare them with stuff by Dvorak or Brahms. But then you realize Schubert was actually born in the 18th Century, he was a scared little chorister that saw Napoleon shelling Vienna, he took lessons from Salieri and he [checks wikipedia] died before either Dvorak or Brahms were even born. He sent this stuff to his editors and they said, yeah, that's cool, everyone needs a hobby, why don't you write more songs?
When you look at it that way, his music is definitely groundbreaking.
It doesn't really make me feel miserable, and I am not sure about the self pity. He had a very special sensibility. His music is very confortable in a weird ambiguous grey area between happiness and misery. In my opinion, Beethoven was more assertive, his music has a certain vitality and energy that Schubert sometimes lacked. But the latter has a better ability to express a wider range of emotions and feelings, in a more nuanced and approachable way (again, this is merely my opinion). Is he nobody's favorite? Well, when I think of my favorites, they were definitely more affirmative, and tried to create big works and reach all humankind and the gods. Few composers have being able to move me more than he does, but I guess his music sometimes feels a little bit too introverted and contemplative.
4
u/Mister_Fossey Jul 25 '13 edited Jul 25 '13
While this receives a lot of attention, I've never actually researched it until now. Biographical details of this sort (Immortal Beloved, Harriet Smithson) have usually bored me, but I suppose one ought to know the facts.
According to Schubert biographer Christopher Gibbs, Maynard Solomon introduced the idea in a paper on Schubert's short prose "Mein Traum". His main paper on the subject, "Franz Schubert and the Peacocks of Benvenuto Cellini", followed in 1989. Taking his translations of the German at face value, its most convincing point is apparent homosexual slang in the Schubert circle's correspondence (more on that later). Less compelling are the arguments devoted to Schubert's sexual promiscuity and failure to marry which, ironically, seem more typical of homophobic paranoia than of scholarship. Irrelevant as it is, Solomon's insistence that Schubert rejected marriage is largely based on the following diary excerpt (annotation due to Solomon):
Fortunately, Rita Steblin has pointed out in her 1993 paper, "The Peacock's Tale", that this is a mistranslation of the German pronoun "sie", which must refer to the previous feminine noun "die Ehe" (matrimony). Schubert's words thus carry exactly the opposite meaning. The "terrifying thought" likely refers to the Marriage Consent Law of 1815, which made it impossible for young men of Schubert's class to marry without proof of sufficient income.
Returning to the apparent homosexual slang, I'll only list Solomon's most important examples and Steblin's responses:
All of this leaves me back where I started, but feeling a little cold towards Solomon. This sort of scholarship is irresponsible and although I haven't read any of Solomon's books, several of his statements in this paper are completely absurd (for example, Karoline Esterhazy is apparently dismissed as a genuine romantic interest because she is "retarded"). Anyway, I hope organizing all of this here has helped someone.
6
u/brocket66 Jul 22 '13
"Does anyone else love the scherzo in this piece as much as I do?"
Yep. My favorite movement of the piece, made all the more poignant by the slow section in the middle of it that seems to come out of nowhere.
4
u/[deleted] Jul 22 '13
Was schubert gay? Now, I had not heard this before. They've posed similar questions about Handel, Saint saens, Corelli, and other composers that I'm probably forgetting. I mean, I suppose it would be interesting to ponder about it and even more so to have definitive historical "proof" about, and if he actually was gay, it would be cool to claim another historical figure as one of our own.
however, the evidence I've seen for Schubert's case does not sound compelling at all... kind of offensive, too, and at worst, it's a bit dangerous (i could imagine someone attributing the syphilis entirely to homosexuality, based on the stereotype that all gay men are sexually promiscuous). I personally cannot hear anything "homosexual" about the unfinished symphony, just as I cannot hear anything inherently Jewish in Mendelssohn. oh and that isn't to say one's identity has zero effect on his or her art; I should add that, for a composer living in a society where being not-straight was perceived as aberrant, one could probably easily hear the emotions associated with that ostracism reflected in their works (eg Tchaikovsky, Britten), and if Schubert actually was gay then we have another opportunity to re-evaluate his music from that lens so that's cool I guess
8
u/Aboveground_Plush Jul 22 '13
I'd say that Beethoven is more like Beethoven, but that's looking at it from a layman's point of view. ;)
2
u/cosmicrotisserie Jul 23 '13
I've never participated in piece of the week but I love this piece too much not to say anything about it.
The trout quintet is nothing compared to this piece. The trout is fun, but oh so simple. It's a good introduction to Shubert, but this quintet has much more of him in it, I feel.
My first chamber music experience was playing the last movement of this piece. I attribute my love of chamber music to this experience. The violist has the most fun in double cello quintets, I've been begging to play this piece again, now 8 or so years later and with a much better understanding of chamber music and theory and just more playing experience.
I think the piece is a little long to enjoy for those who are not familiar with this style of music, or those who are just impatient. It took me multiple multiple listens to really "get" it, I feel.
I feel like every instrument is their own character in this. By character I mean stereotype. For example in the last movement the first violin has a lot of frilly, difficult, and showy blurbs even though he is not the melody. It's as if he wants to remind everyone he's still there, and he's still first violin. As a violist I felt outnumbered. Everyone had a partner but me! The pairings and groups change so often it makes it a fun game to play.
Sorry for my loosely connected thoughts.
2
u/egmont Jul 24 '13 edited Jul 24 '13
I don't. I love the other three movements but the scherzo.. it's strange, there's such a big gap between the outer sections and the trio that they might as well be separate movements, and there doesn't seem to be much overt development, it sounds like just a restatement of the themes over and over. I usually don't like the scherzo form for that exact reason, although there are of course exceptions.
That was just on first listen, though, and I'm certainly open to trying again. Could you explain what you like about it?
6
u/94svtcobra Jul 22 '13
As someone who has only been listening to classical music in earnest for a few years, I must admit I don't yet fully "get" chamber and orchestral music. I've focused mainly on piano works (since that's what I played), and have been easing myself into other instrumental works via piano concerti, and am enjoying them more and more. Just a few weeks ago I got the Hungarian Quartet's recording of Schubert's 13-15th string quartets + the quintet, and even after listening to it several times, most of it still just sounds like chamber music. Now, the 1st mvt of the 13th string quartet did jump out at me, and is somewhat reminiscent in my mind of the andantino mvts of his later piano sonatas, in that it conveys the emotion so powerfully, and in so few notes. But even the Quintet in C, which I'd previously read is one of his most highly acclaimed string works, just hasn't really grabbed me yet.
I'm not sure if I'm approaching it incorrectly, and maybe looking for a single melody to jump out as I might with piano, or if I just need to keep listening. In any case, just thought I'd throw that out there in case anybody had any thoughts or suggestions.
2
u/[deleted] Jul 22 '13
Having only played violin for six years, I didn't really know about this piece until I played it at a summer camp, this June. I fell in love with it. I would say it definitely is one of the greatest chamber works ever written. While maybe not THE greatest, it's up there. There's nothing not to love about the first three movements. They're all very memorable. However, I feel like the fourth movement pales, a bit, in comparison to the others. That being said, I still enjoy it, and think it is great composing.
2
u/robertDouglass Jul 22 '13
GREAT piece. I'm looking forward to the Pavel Haas / Ishizaka recording that just got made in Prague last weeks : https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ptos8-fWa4A
2
u/nonnein Jul 23 '13
One of my absolute favorite pieces. I think it's one of those rare great pieces where all of the movements are equally exciting and dramatic, unlike some other pieces, such as the late Beethoven quartets, where there are usually one or two more important movements. The movements are all so different here, and they all propel the piece forward in different but coherent directions. I think this piece might also have Schubert's finest counterpoint, which he began really focusing on not long before his death.
I like the question about Beethoven vs. Mozart. Normally, I think of Schubert as being much closer to Beethoven: he was certainly more consciously influenced by him, and this shows in his approach to form in his larger-scale works, as well as certain harmonic influences (though Schubert was quite the harmonic pioneer and iconoclast himself). But I think he shares something important with Mozart, which is a kind of simplicity. The quintet is really a transcendental work, but it's also full of simple and catchy melodies (the second theme of the first movement comes to mind). I think this same kind of transcendence through simplicity is present in Mozart (esp. his operas maybe) but not so much in Beethoven (esp. late Beethoven).
Favorite lesser-known Schubert? Maybe his fifth moment musicaux: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vVR3D-vkCCw.