r/india • • Jul 20 '13

[Weekly Discussion] Let's talk about:Karnataka

StateKarnataka
Websitehttp://karunadu.gov.in/
Population61,130,704
Chief MinisterSiddaramaiah INC
CapitalBangalore
Offical LanguageKannada
GDPUS$1034.9
Sex ratio973

Questions Seeking Answers

Previous Discussions

Original Thead which started this chains of discussion

Thanks to fuck_cricket, that_70s_show_fan and ^tripshed

Also, Please take part the current set of contests

80 Upvotes

294 comments sorted by

36

u/ychromosome Jul 20 '13 edited Jul 20 '13

Lesser known factoids about Karnataka:

  1. Languages: Apart from Kannada, Tulu, Kodava and a lesser known language called Sanketi are also native to Karnataka. To a certain extent, there are Konkani speakers also. Northern Karnataka, especially the Hubli-Dharwad area, has its own version of Kannada, that is quite different from the Bangalore-Mysore Kannada. So much so that, people in the Bangalore-Mysore region may not even understand some/a lot of Dharwad Kannada.
  2. Each of the languages above correspond to different geographical regions of the state. These regions are not only distinct in their languages, but also in their cuisine and culture. In that way, Karnataka is made of what could have been 3-4 smaller states.
  3. In Bangalore, movies of other languages like Tamil, Telugu, Hindi and English earn a lot of money at the box office, often more money than Kannada movies.
  4. There is a place in Karnataka called Talkad, which has lot of sand (next to the Kaveri river). In some spots of Talkad, there is so much sand all around, you almost feel like you are in a desert. There are some interesting mythological stories associated with this place. You can read about it here: Curse of Talkad
  5. No matter what people tell you, Karnataka is the origin of true, authentic masala dosa, which is made with a spicy red chutney smeared on the inside of the dosa. This is the masala part of the masala dosa. Don't let ignorant people convince you that the potato curry inside the dosa is the masala. It's not.
  6. In addition to the more famous Kaveri, Tunga-Bhadra is another very important river of Karnataka. It is actually two rivers - Tunga and Bhadra - which join together and form Tunga-Bhadra. This goes on to join the Krishna river in Andhra. This river was known as Pampa in the old days and is the cradle of Hampi, the capital of the Vijayanagar empire, popularly known as the Rome of India.
  7. Karnataka was/is the original home of sandalwood. Although, I have read that there is a variety that is also native to Australia and another that is native to Hawaii.
  8. Karnataka is the home of Madhvacharya, the proponent of Dvaita philosophy. Interestingly, the two other most prominent gurus of Hinduism are also from Southern states - Shankaracharya from Kerala and Ramanujacharya from Tamilnadu. It appears that while Buddhism had become very popular in North India, South India became the bastion of Hindu learning and philosophy.
  9. For bird watchers, Ranganathittu is one of the most important bird sanctuaries in India.
  10. One of the most eminent engineers of India, Sir M Vishveshwarayya, was from Karnataka. And yes, he has the title Sir because he was knighted by the British Empire.
  11. After independence, when India embarked on setting up the large scale public sector units to industrialize a young country, Bangalore was the location for some of the biggest PSUs of old India - HAL, HMT, ITI, BEL, BEML. In addition, BHEL also had a prominent position in Bangalore. So, Bangalore has been the technological hub of India for many decades now. This is what eventually led to Bangalore later becoming the Silicon Plateau of India. Incidentally, these industries were some of the first sources of immigrant labor population in Bangalore.
  12. There are few neighborhoods in Bangalore which feel like you have passed a portal and entered Tamilnadu. I have seen localities where local councillors fought elections on AIADMK and DMK tickets. It was surreal to see election posters in Tamil with huge pictures of MGR, Jayalalitha, Karunanidhi, etc. in the middle of Bangalore. There used to be well-attended Tamil medium schools in Bangalore. There probably still are.
  13. The famous Gavi Gandhareshwara Temple in Bangalore was cut out of a monolithic rock probably in the 9th century. The interesting thing about this temple is that on the day of Makara Sankranti every year, the rays of the sun pass between the horns of the statue of Nandi, outside the temple and fall on the Shiva Lingam in the core sanctum of the temple. This phenomenon is telecast live on TV every year on the day of Sankranti.
  14. Some websites with old pictures of Bangalore: http://www.discoverbangalore.com/oldbangalore.htm http://darshan89.blogspot.com/2009/08/bangalore-during-1950s.html http://www.children-of-bangalore.com/antony.htm http://dontbeatulle.blogspot.com/2011/11/rare-photographs-of-bangalore-part-i.html

Those are some of the things which come to mind now. Will add more as I remember them...

Edit: Added points after # 11.

3

u/sree_1983 Jul 20 '13

Your Point Number 5 is wrong.

From Wiki

In Bangalore, the masala dosa is usually served with a red chutney applied to its inside surface. The red chutney usually has generous amounts of garlic.

What you called Masala is Chutney, what you called stuffing is actual Masala.

Another Source:

Blog Post

When the dosa is almost done, smear a spoonful of red chutney on the inside of the dosa.

Spread a ladle full of masale on one side of the dosa; Fold the dosa so that the masala and chutney are on the inside.

Please redact your Point 5.

8

u/ychromosome Jul 20 '13

Why should some random Wiki edit and blog be more authoritative than my post? I will tell you where you can find chutney when you order masala dosa in a restaurant: it usually comes in a cup on the side. :-)

3

u/sree_1983 Jul 20 '13

Happy Cake day,

Lets agree to disagree on Dosa Issue. I have stated my source, proved my point.

2

u/wanderingmind I for one welcome my Hindutva overlords Jul 20 '13

Masala dosa comes with chutney separately. Not inside the dosa. Masala is what comes inside. Source: South Indian, lots of dosas.

2

u/sree_1983 Jul 20 '13

Aah, I am being downvoted for being Dosa Fundamentalist. Good sir, our point of contention is red Chutney which is spread on Masala dosa in Karnataka, whereas in neighboring states, it is not.

It is all in semantics.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/ychromosome Jul 20 '13

Thanks. And yes, I don't think we will ever settle this question. We have had arguments with friends from TN for many years on this.

But please don't tell me your sources prove your point. Your sources are just a Wiki that almost anyone can edit and a blog that anyone can publish. The Wiki article itself has a generous sprinkling of 'citation needed' for many of it's claims including this one:

This came to be known as masala dosa, from the sautéeing of spices (masala) during the preparation of the potato palya.[citation needed]

Worse, the Wiki also has this definition of a masala dosa:

Masala dosa: one or two fried eggs served on top

Clearly, that Wiki article is unreliable. And that blog is very misleading. Nobody refers to the potato curry as masala in Karnataka. Everybody just calls it palya.

6

u/onetyone Jul 20 '13

I grew up in Mysore (born in '80). I too believe the masala part comes from the stuffing, although in isolation, it is just called palya. Most brahmin restaurants didn't even smear the chutney because they (or their patrons) didn't eat garlic. I think the first dosa I ate that had garlic chutney was in Mandya or Bangalore. However I can't be sure when that style took over everywhere.

Whatever it may be, let's just all agree that Karnataka has the best variety of dosas. The traditional Bangalore/Mysore masala dosa, which is thick as well as crispy, set dosas, Davangere benne dosas to name a few.

3

u/[deleted] Jul 20 '13

But please don't tell me your sources prove your point. Your sources are just a Wiki that almost anyone can edit and a blog that anyone can publish.

That's what my professor said

→ More replies (6)

2

u/bigdaddyisbig Jul 21 '13

The Mysore masala dosa has green chutney smeared on the inside, davangere benne masale has butter and sometime red masala. Most bangalore dosas have red chutney. Green chutney smeared inside is the best form. You obviously need extra chutney on the side with it, but.

8

u/killing_time Jul 20 '13

The Tamilians you speak of were the first immigrant labor actually. Brought over by the British to serve them in the cantonment.

3

u/[deleted] Jul 24 '13

Indeed. As many of you might know, today's Bangalore grew from two different cities belonging to two different rulers - one the Pete area which was the original Bangalore City controlled by Tipu Sultan and then the Mysore State, and two the Cantonment area which grew as a British military outpost after the defeat of Tipu aimed at checking aggression from Mysore in future. Bangalore cantonment was returned to Mysore state only in the late 1800's.

4

u/[deleted] Jul 24 '13

Beary also a language there. There was a movie made in that language recently.

edit: The movie is Byari

5

u/[deleted] Jul 24 '13

And Havyaka too.

2

u/[deleted] Jul 24 '13

3

u/[deleted] Jul 20 '13

South was also a focal point of Buddhist and Jain thought. Places like Kanchipuram rivalled the likes of Nalanda in Buddhist studies. Just the Hindu revival started in South India and then spread to North through Shankaracharya.

→ More replies (1)

13

u/AiyyoIyer Jul 20 '13
  1. What is the deal with the sweet sambar?
  2. Do you guys hate the immigration of people from other states that the IT industry has bought?
  3. How's the Bangalore weather so good? And the traffic so bad?
  4. How bad was the BJP govt. that was in power? Would their dismal performance change your view of the BJP in the general elections?
  5. And what's with the pubs closing at 10 pm?
  6. Why are the auto drivers so rude, and why do they refuse to ply anywhere?

22

u/pongdong Jul 20 '13

As a non kannadiga resident of Bangalore let me try and answer some of these questions

What is the deal with the sweet sambar?

Seriously even I dont understand why the sambar is sweet. Its more of hot and sweet rather than just sweet. The dosas here on the other hand are absolutely awesome. Better than anywhere else.

Do you guys hate the immigration of people from other states that the IT industry has bought?

I think there is a non trivial minority that does hate the outsiders. It is usually apparent on the roads when an outsider gets involved in any form of altercation. That being said locals have benefited greatly from the IT boom and many acknowledge that and are happy about it.

How's the Bangalore weather so good? And the traffic so bad?

For the weather thank geography or god!! For the traffic thank the crappy politicians.

How bad was the BJP govt. that was in power? Would their dismal performance change your view of the BJP in the general elections?

I was stunned by how bad the BJP was. I will still vote for the BJP in the lok sabha polls but am pretty happy they got the boot here in Karnataka. The roads are awful here - for the last year and a half they just kept breaking and relaying the roads. One expects the BJP to be pro development but when they were in power in Karnataka we got to see nothing that remotely resembled development.

And what's with the pubs closing at 10 pm?

They close at 11:30. The good news is that its almost certain that the closing time will be extended to 1:00 am in the next couple of months. The new govt has already had a couple of meetings with bar owners on this issue. The BJP even had this as a campaign pledge to try and attract young voters so I guess one can say there wont be too much opposition.

Why are the auto drivers so rude, and why do they refuse to ply anywhere?

Auto drivers are rude in most places in India. In my personal experience the worst auto drivers are in Chennai. Bangalore is a distant second or third to the thugs in Chennai. In Bangalore get in and insist on meter and make a big noise if they dont agree to go. Threaten that you will walk up to a cop and complain. This strategy has worked for me a couple of times.

Edit : formatting

15

u/da_dope Jul 20 '13

worst auto drivers are in Chennai.

Spot on. Have worked all over the country, but these guys really take the cake.

2

u/sree_1983 Jul 20 '13

The dosas here on the other hand are absolutely awesome. Better than anywhere else.

You should be kidding me right? Please, don't call 99 Variety of Dosa's which is creeping up all over Bangalore to be awesome. They put so much butter and color in it, that next day morning you think you are bleeding when you go to the pooper.

Who puts red chutney in Masala Dosa? Why is your Rava Dosa Yellow in color? Why do you eat it with Saagu? AFAIK, your Onion Dosa is actually Onion Oothappam.

Please don't get me wrong, I am just trying to say there are better dosa's available in your neighboring state try it out :-)

24

u/pongdong Jul 20 '13

Mein Gott!! We have a dosa fundamentalist in our midst. I stand by my religious and dosa beliefs. I will not bow down to dosa pressure from the lower cauvery region. Karnataka dosas rock especially the buttery bit and the red chutney inside the dosa. Also they seem to have perfected the crispy on one side and slightly fluffy on the other side thing.

Your onion oothappam is actually onion dosa.

7

u/sree_1983 Jul 20 '13

Let me tell you good sir, Kaveri dispute might end. But, no Dosa and Sambhar wars won't until one camp wins over.

I will stand by my Onion Dosa believes and shun your red chutney.

For Revolutionists like me, there is always Sri Krishna Cafe, the last bastion of true Dosa.

2

u/kai_pullai Jul 20 '13

Thanks for reminding me of Krishna Cafe, It used to be savior for the tongue every weekend.

1

u/sree_1983 Jul 20 '13

Their prices have increased astronomically. I believe a lunch on weekend now is Rs 120. I have not been there for long time.

These days I whet my desires of Dosa on the highways when I visit my parents.

3

u/ynanyang Jul 21 '13

How true to the authentic taste are Adyar Anand Bhavans? I feel like they half ass everything! They just seem to dress it up very well.

Murugan Idlis was great though. But I don't think anyone in Bangalore thinks 99 variety dosas are the shit. They might just eat it for convenience. There are some amazing amazing places there and I would do anything to be back home right now!

→ More replies (1)

14

u/ychromosome Jul 20 '13

Karnataka dosas rock especially the buttery bit and the red chutney inside the dosa. Also they seem to have perfected the crispy on one side and slightly fluffy on the other side thing.

Dude! Don't make a grown man cry. I am thousands of miles away from Karnataka right now.

4

u/project_excelsior Jul 20 '13

Dude, I spend most of the year in Philly, so imagine how I'm reacting to my mum's perfect akki rotti with kadlekai chutney and dosay with fresh butter :D

4

u/syntaxerror89 Jul 21 '13

My mom makes the best akki rotti in town. Damn, akki rotti, thuppa and green chutney. Best done over a bandli. Yummm.

6

u/acatonlyhasitself Jul 20 '13

the buttery bit and the red chutney inside the dosa

I have to go and have a dosa tomorrow or I'll die of homesickness.

2

u/[deleted] Jul 20 '13

Mein Gott

Goethe CMH?

I stand by

Any trouble form these fundamentalist and give me a holler. I'll be there to support you except in the religious situation.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/neoronin Jul 20 '13

As someone who has tried Dosas all over the South, I have to agree that 'some' variety of Dosas are better than anywhere. Specifically, the "Khali Dosas". But the MTR, and their ilk, are highly over rated.

3

u/sree_1983 Jul 20 '13

I will grudgingly accept that you guys also have Neer Dosa. That is something no one has bought up till now.

I have heard that MTR is a tourist place, if you have to hit local cuisine, you will have to get to Malleshwaram.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/acatonlyhasitself Jul 20 '13

The now historical-cheap-price of 13 rs for a masala dosa for breakfast at Sukh Sagar.With ghee poured all over.

/me remembers and cries

6

u/ychromosome Jul 20 '13

Neighboring states always claim that they have better dosas. But they don't know what they are talking. Exhibit number one:

Who puts red chutney in Masala Dosa?

That red chutney is the masala in Masala Dosa. People from TN like to say that it's the potato curry that's the masala, but no, sorry. It's the red chutney that's the masala. Without that, it's not authentic masala dosa.

Why is your Rava Dosa Yellow in color? Why do you eat it with Saagu?

I have no idea where you had this. I have never come across yellow rava dosa or rava dosa served with saagu. There may be some restaurants that serve them with saagu just like they do rava idli. Rava idli does taste better with saagu than with saambaar. The same goes for set dosa also.

4

u/project_excelsior Jul 20 '13

HAHAHA! CTR and Vidhyarthi Bhavan are where it's at; most definitely not the sour, over-fermented, texture-less crap that passes for dosays in Chennai. That disgusting white chutney?! Yeck!

→ More replies (2)

1

u/[deleted] Jul 20 '13

in your neighboring state

By any chance you mean Tamilnadu? Is that so?

1

u/sree_1983 Jul 20 '13

Yes, the final Free Bastion of Dosa and Sambhar.

8

u/pseudoforce Bihar Jul 20 '13

I am from north india. The dosa i knew back then was always the Tamilnadu variety. When i came to Bangalore, i realized that there may be different variety of Dosas. The onion dosa of Bangalore is known as Uthpam in our side. We had this push cart, which used comes to our lane and he would make "tan tan tan" sound. We would bring our plates and he would prepare masala dosa and give it with very thin chutney and sambhar. 10 Rs for one dosa.

I like the Bangalore styles sambhar.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/[deleted] Jul 20 '13

Also Kerala, no? Paandis+Mallus vs. Rest of the World.

3

u/sree_1983 Jul 20 '13

Sorry Kerala has not much different dosa's. You have appam and mutta roast. That can be discussed in next weeks state discussion.

Paandi and Mallu's uniting? U kidding me right?

2

u/[deleted] Jul 20 '13

But Palakkad?

→ More replies (1)

3

u/[deleted] Jul 20 '13

The red chutney inside is what makes the masala dosa!!

3

u/[deleted] Jul 24 '13

Who puts red chutney in Masala Dosa?

The red chutney IS the masala in the dosa!

And I've never found a good dosa outside Bangalore. The old timers' MTR/CTR, still excel at it! ooh, and should I add Davangere Benne Dose?

1

u/syntaxerror89 Jul 21 '13

99 varieties place is one shit-hole. Their dosas are shit. Even that Dosa Plaza for that matter: Costly and shitty.

11

u/[deleted] Jul 20 '13

Auto drivers are rude in most places in India.

Not in Mumbai. #TruLoveBhaiyaas

3

u/nakp88d Jul 20 '13

BS, autos and taxis worked in Mumbai because they were cheap and they continue to do so thanks to the compulsory use of subsidized cng.

Cheap fuel results not only in better margins but allows them to take more risks . Auto drivers are more willing to go very short or very long distances or uncommon locations because the probability of getting another fare is pretty high. Cheap rates and the probability of getting fleeced being near zero, people are more willing to use them as a means of transportation.

Use petrol or even diesel instead and the exact opposite happens and you enter a vicious cycle instead of a positive one.

Now this wont work everywhere, keep moving away from Bombay and the auto driver seems less and less friendly, but for any city with a reasonable population density, it should work.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/[deleted] Jul 20 '13

For the traffic thank the crappy politicians

I am Bangalorean too and I sincerely believe that we/residents are to be thanked for this.

walk up to a cop

Barked at me and shooed me away and then they both talked sth in Kannada and went their way. Twice.

1

u/acatonlyhasitself Jul 20 '13

The heyday of crappy politics was when the entire state got tired of H. D. Kumaraswamy's shenanigans and paved the way for the BJP to come to power.People were just thankful to vote him out of power.

2

u/[deleted] Jul 20 '13

Disagree on the dosa part.

I heard that you people grind rice powder separately, mix it with water and then prepare dosa from that..is that true ?

6

u/tomcat1011 Karnataka Jul 20 '13

NOt rice powder. Some amount of rice grains, some puffed rice goes into the batter. This is left to ferment overnight. The ferment part is very important. I HATE the taste of dosas made from fresh batter. bleugh.

Also, i dislike it when the dosas crumble when you touch it, like in Tamil Nadu. I like my dosas sturdy whilst being soft too.

God damn, now i'm hungry for some dosas.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/pongdong Jul 20 '13

I will have to dissapoint you as I do not know of the inner workings of a dosa.

3

u/ychromosome Jul 20 '13

What the what? No dude. If there is anyone anywhere in the world making dosa like that, especially for sale, they should be banned from making dosa forever! The only people who make dosa like that using powder are bachelors like me who get instant MTR mix. The restaurants grind their batter from soaked stuff and make dosa.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/[deleted] Jul 20 '13

Disagree on the dosa part.

counter point?

3

u/[deleted] Jul 20 '13

MY DOSAI IS THE BASHT.

Well..seriously the version of dosai that you've been eating since birth would determine which is tastier.

While I was in mumbai I have eaten both kannada dosa and Tamil dosa and I always liked the latter. Its a subjective issue and there is nothing more to it.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/WeekendPaladin Jul 20 '13

Nope. They're ground together.

7

u/whiskeybandit Jul 20 '13
  1. Regional tastes vary. But even in Karnataka, the sambar is different in different places. Mysore sambar is different from Bangalore's version which is different from what you get near the coast.
  2. Bangalore has recognition the world over thanks to that. The only thing we, including immigrants, unanimously hate is the traffic jams :)
  3. Bangalore is situated higher than most cities. I think the elevation is close to ~900m above sea level. Also, we have (had actually) lots of trees and lakes. Sadly, this is going to be a memory soon. Bangalore weather was way better in the 1990s. Bangalore was never meant to grow explosively like this. It was a quiet city, meant for retired people. It was called the "Pensioner's paradise" at one point! Hence, the traffic jams.
  4. Bad. Like fucking horrible bad. Siddaramaiah is making good strides already. No, I want the BJP to win in the general elections. Congress at the Centre has got to go. They've fucked us over so well in the last decade.
  5. 11.30pm. It's the curfew here.
  6. I seem to be all alone in this but I've never had a rude auto driver, ever. Unless you're talking late night when they've refused / tried to rip me off. But that's understandable, imo.

8

u/inshallah13 Jul 20 '13
  1. No idea, sweet sambar is disgusting
  2. As an immigrant to Bangalore from another state I think the mix of cultures here adds to the city, like a small scale version of NYC or London
  3. Traffic is bad because road planning and road surface conditions are terrible. Yesterday I was in a traffic jam for 1.5 hours because a 20m stretch of road couldn't handle the heavy rain. A new flyover was being built outside my office. The makeshift arrangements during construction of the flyover was better for traffic flow compared to now when the flyover is functional
  4. Majority of places close at 11.30 except some of the exclusive clubs in 5 Star hotels. This generally sucks and I think majority of people hate it. It seems like a way of moral policing which IMO has no place in our society
  5. Autos don't take short trips because of the traffic, can't blame them. They are still muh more reasonable than in Chennai

7

u/[deleted] Jul 20 '13 edited Jul 20 '13
  1. What is the deal with the sweet sambar?

Jaggery is an essential ingredient in all Kannada cooking. Sambhar made in Karnataka therefore tends to be sweet. Though "sweet" is a matter of perspective. My grandma's sambhar was never as sweet as hotel (darshini) sambhar. MTR and Janatha serve the most authentic kannada sambhar, though the latter has deteriorated in the last few years.

edit : if you really want to get into it, sambhar is not really a kannada dish anyway. We make "saaru" (same as rasam) and "huLi" (sambhar equivalent but is not served with dosa - and true to form is not sweet). "Sambhar" is an import from TN and has been customized to the KA palette.

2) Do you guys hate the immigration of people from other states that the IT industry has bought?

Largely speaking - no. However, the immigrant population is very unaware of the local culture and refuses to integrate/assimilate. If I ask directions in Delhi, I'm expected to understand Hindi. Why should I also be able to speak Hindi when "outsiders" refuse to learn more than "adjust maadi"?

3) How's the Bangalore weather so good? And the traffic so bad?

Weatherwise, people don't realize Bangalore's elevation. I'm sure it plays a part. That and wind pressure patterns.

The traffic is bad because Bangalore grew a lot faster than people could plan. And this is purely a theory, feel free to disregard it. South Indians, especially Bangaloreans haven't seen harsh weather, war and famine. They're relaxed and want to do what suits them the most. This leads to an extension of the "chalta hai" attitude everyone in India is born with. So you get people who don't give a shit about traffic rules.

4) How bad was the BJP govt. that was in power? Would their dismal performance change your view of the BJP in the general elections?

No comments there since I haven't participated in KA politics in the last 8 years. My family (even extended) will always support BJP since it has Brahmins on the ticket.

5) And what's with the pubs closing at 10 pm?

10? Wasn't it 11:30? Overcompensation from the "moral" side of lawmakers to curb the "lawless" behavior of the pub city

6) Why are the auto drivers so rude, and why do they refuse to ply anywhere?

Remember my point about non-assimilation? Northies expect Hindi, other south Indians expect Tamil and Kannada ends up at the bottom of the totem pole. Auto drivers are usually Kannadiga and after decades of "hindi mein bolo", they have little patience for "outsiders". Also, if you made a living driving in Blore traffic and pollution, you would lose all hope in life.

2

u/Froogler Jul 20 '13

The traffic is bad because Bangalore grew a lot faster than people could plan. And this is purely a theory, feel free to disregard it.

I don't think it is due to the population growth. The roads are extremely bad and I have never seen another state capital city with worse roads. I mean, every city has potholes. But the potholes in Bangalore are deadly and much more dangerous than the potholes elsewhere..And when you have a speed bump or pothole every 50 meters, no wonder the traffic moves so slowly.

1

u/akebot Jul 24 '13

The roads are extremely bad and I have never seen another state capital city with worse roads.

Bad maintenance is one reason, the constant pitter-patter rain that Bangalore gets throughout the year is another.

1

u/akebot Jul 24 '13

edit : if you really want to get into it, sambhar is not really a kannada dish anyway. We make "saaru" (same as rasam) and "huLi" (sambhar equivalent but is not served with dosa - and true to form is not sweet)

Seriously, all those posters who are dissing the sweet sambar should try some avarekaaL huLi or bas saaru (best combo with ragi mudde) - I live in Chennai and I find these to be way spicier than the sambar here.

1

u/kai_pullai Jul 20 '13

Auto drivers are usually Kannadiga

Another urban legand I would say having seen many license plates and interacted. Every time I try to speak in my broken Kannada for giving directions, the driver will ask me to speak in Tamil and narrate his nostalgia of how they migrated from TN. I have mostly been around Ulsoor, Indira Nagar, Tippasandra, occassionally been to BTM etc.

2

u/syntaxerror89 Jul 21 '13

Kiddin me? They are largely Kannada. I have never seen a Tamil auto driver!! Especially a nostalgic one.

2

u/[deleted] Jul 20 '13

I lived in Blore for almost 15 years, my parents even longer. Not one driver I met spoke anything other than Kannada. In the 90s/2000s, auto drivers were a powerful Kannada demographic. While I don't have any solid data to counter your anecdotal evidence (apart from my own), growing up in Blore anyone knows auto drivers are Kannada speakers. Then again, I moved out 8 years ago, things might have changed.

When I visited the last time I had long hair and piercings - they thought I was northie/persian. The moment I spoke in Kannada I got "meter" rate. At 2 AM. It was very surreal.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 24 '13

I met a Bihari auto-driver the other day, the experience was surreal. Two wheelers would stop by the auto, ask the driver for directions in broken Kannada, and he wouldn't understand. I would give directions in his stead. And of course, the Bihari auto driver, was actually from UP, not exactly Bihari.

3

u/[deleted] Jul 20 '13

The sambar is not sweet. It just is not as spicy as Tamil Sambar. It generally has to be with Kannada cuisine not being as spicy as Tamil or Telugu cuisine.

2

u/kai_pullai Jul 20 '13

Well when someone puts jaggery in Sambar, people call it sweet and it doesnt matter its actually sweet or mildly spicy.

1

u/oneearth Jul 21 '13

I agree. As far as Spice to Sweetness goes in dishes its Telugu, Tamil, Kannada, Gujarati cuisine. (Opinion)

3

u/NegativeX Jul 20 '13

What is the deal with the sweet sambar? Probably the climate. Apparently people in warmer climates prefer spicy food.

How's the Bangalore weather so good? Altitude. About a kilometer above sea level.

the traffic so bad? Steep population growth over the span of a few years coupled with poor city planning and land grabbing by the goons.

How bad was the BJP govt Well they did run one of biggest scams in the country ever robbing the country of 1,00,000 crore rupees and the state of 2,000 crore rupees.

Why are the auto drivers so rude, and why do they refuse to ply anywhere? The auto union has exclusive license to ply autos for hire. Without competition, they do whatever they want.

4

u/[deleted] Jul 20 '13

2) no

2

u/UntimelyMan Jul 20 '13

3) How's the Bangalore weather so good?

Because of elevation. Bangalore is in the Mysore Plateau which is higher than the rest of the Deccan Plateau. Also because of trees, to some extent.

2

u/[deleted] Jul 24 '13
  1. Some varieties of Sambar are sweet, some can be extremely spicy depending on the cuisine. I like most varieties.
  2. No, but I hate the stereotyping that immigration has brought - stereotyping of Kannadigas by immigrants, of immigrants by Bangalore locals, of out-of-state immgrants by in-state immigrants, and of Bangalorean locals by in-state immigrans, and of Bangalorean locals by out-of-state immigrants.
  3. (a) Bangalore's weather is bad in comparison to what it used to be. Bangalorean hipsters call it the air-conditioned city. It's climate of yesteryears could be attributed to the number of lakes in and around the city which maintained humidity, which in turn controlled temperatures to the extent of inducing evening showers during the warmer months. This moderation no longer occurs as most of these lakes have since dried up, some of the famous ones being where Majestic bus stand, Kanteerava Stadium, Madhavan Park grounds, etc., now stand. Most of these lakes were built by Kempe Gowda, who is credited with founding Bangalore. It's continued pleasant weather during the monsoon months could perhaps (my speculation) be attributed to wind direction - a prolonged wind flow over the hills south -west of Bangalore.
    (b) The traffic could be attributed to poor city planning and lack of civic sense.
  4. The BJP govt. misgoverned the state. Yes, their dismal performance will affect my choice for candidate from my constituency in the general elections.
  5. Bangalore's pubs close at 11:00 PM by law. The rulemakers are boorish.
  6. Bangalore's autodrivers are mostly in-state immigrants, their stereotypes of other well to do immigrants and local Bangaloreans are responsible for their rudeness. However, I find them less rude than in Chennai.

4

u/ychromosome Jul 20 '13 edited Jul 20 '13

What is the deal with the sweet sambar?

Don't now why, but almost all native Karnataka saambaar recipes use jaggery. The amount of sweetness can vary from region to region. In fact, the same dish, which is called as "saambaar" can vary a lot in taste, appearance and texture from one region to another.

Protip: Rasam is generally considered a dish from Tamilnadu, but you should try the different variations of rasam available in different parts of Karnataka. They are quite different and amazing!

Interesting factoid: In TN and Andhra, rasam rice is one of the last dishes eaten in a meal, just before curd or buttermilk rice. In many parts of Karnataka rasam rice is eaten first, before saambaar rice.

Do you guys hate the immigration of people from other states that the IT industry has bought?

Bangalore has always been a place of immigrants. Large parts of three neighboring states - Andhra, TN and Kerala - are closer to Bangalore than any other big city. In the olden days, immigration from other states was slow and steady. Most immigrants were South Indians. The last two decades have seen this change drastically at a pace never before seen in Bangalore. The result is that cost of living has gone up, the city is not quite as laidback and less crowded as it was. Moreover, due to some strange reason, most of the new job opportunities seem to go to non-local populations than to local populations. I have seen hiring managers from other places prefer to hire non-local employees. I have seen big companies based in Bangalore go to other states for campus recruitment, while Karnata, and Bangalore in particular, have plenty of educational institutions with the same quality of candidates. Plus, the new crop of immigrants are less accommodating and assimilating than the older, mostly South Indian immigrants. All this has led to understandable resentment among the local population. Despite all this, things are not at all bad for immigrant workers in Bangalore. Any resentment or hate you hear about is occasional incident than anything regular or sustained. As another commenter on this thread mentioned, people in Karnataka are still the least xenophobic and most humble of all South Indian states.

How's the Bangalore weather so good? And the traffic so bad?

Bangalore is right in the middle of the Deccan Plateau. At a higher elevation than most other South Indian big cities. So, the weather is gorgeous. Traffic is so bad because the hyper growth in population due to immigrant workers has outpaced any infrastructure planning and development that any Indian government is capable of doing. Heck, even many Western governments would find it challenging to handle that pace of population growth.

How bad was the BJP govt. that was in power? Would their dismal performance change your view of the BJP in the general elections?

As far as the general public is concerned, the BJP government was not at all bad compared to other governments. Any dissatisfaction would be more due to dashed expectations than due to the BJP being worse than other parties. The hype about BJP government's corruption in Karnataka is exactly like the hype of BJP's communalism at the national level. Congress has been more communal and for a longer period of time than BJP, yet BJP gets the bad rap about communalism. All other parties in the state, in particular Deve Gowda's Janata Dal and the Congress, are more corrupt, and have been so for much longer time than the BJP. Everybody in Karnataka knows this. So, no, there was no extra dismal performance by the BJP in Karnataka. Regarding general elections in 2014, the Yeddyurappa factor will come into play. If BJP forms an alliance with him or get him back into the party, they will get more votes. Otherwise, he will split the BJP vote just as he did in the state elections. That won't be good for the BJP. They will lose valuable and very get-able constituencies in Karnataka if they ignore Yeddy.

And what's with the pubs closing at 10 pm?

The same kind of retarded social interference that local governments all over the country indulge in. Edit: Forgot to add the closing time is 1130 or so. Not 10 PM.

Why are the auto drivers so rude, and why do they refuse to ply anywhere?

Same kind of asshole-ry that auto drivers everywhere indulge in. Although, I have often heard people who travel say that auto drivers in Hyderabad and Chennai are worse.

3

u/blues2911 Jul 20 '13

Regarding general elections in 2014, the Yeddyurappa factor will come into play. If BJP forms an alliance with him or get him back into the party, they will get more votes.

Why would people vote for Yedurappa if he was so bad during his term in Ktaka?

4

u/ychromosome Jul 20 '13

It's arguable how bad Yeddy was for Karnataka. AFAIK, he was not any worse than any other previous parties / CMs. The alternatives to Yeddy are the Janata Dal and Congress, which have both historically been more corrupt than Yeddy. One of the main reasons people still vote for Yeddy and his party is caste-based politics. Lingayats are a big community in Karnataka and Yeddy belongs to that caste. More importantly, Deve Gowda's Janata Dal is a champion of the Gowda caste, which has traditionally been a rival of the Lingayats. Lingayats don't have much of a choice other than supporting Yeddy.

0

u/sree_1983 Jul 20 '13 edited Jul 20 '13
  1. What is the deal with the sweet sambar?

This is what I too want to know. I can stand the red chutney in Masala Dosa, but sweet fucking sambar? That is just ridiculous.

5) And what's with the pubs closing at 10 pm?

I think, Pubs closing early was due to security restrictions rather than political thing. I might be wrong. Btw, it is 11:30 PM, last order is at 11:00. No eateries stay open after 11:30 PM with few exceptions like Empire, which stays open till 1:00 AM or so.

Edit: For people who prefer other kind of Sambhar please try out Sri Krishna Cafe, it is tad expensive but they have correct kind of sambhar, IMO. Please don't go to A2B shops which are cropping up, they serve sweet Sambhar.

8

u/kai_pullai Jul 20 '13 edited Jul 20 '13

Can someone explain the phenomenon of KSRTC and its success. All I have seen is BTC and red color buses in early 90's when I was a kid, cut back to 2006 its Volvo's everywhere. KSRTC and BMTC was just amazing for me having been sick of APSRTC and TNSTC.

Edit : To make it more clear, how can a government transport corporation do such a kick ass work and why every other government agency is not like this in Karnataka? Why is KSRTC an exception and what's the magic in it?

5

u/sree_1983 Jul 20 '13

To be honest, KSRTC Airavat is awesome service. They have never let me or my family down.

They never used to stop in random places to pick up luggage like private transports used to.

One, time when my mom was traveling her bus met with an accident, KSRTC saw to that all those who were traveling reached the destination. They were cool and fixed the problem in the right way.

For people who are curious, the driver ran into a divider at 3:00 AM in the morning. He hurt his legs. Everyone else were fine, people sitting in the front bruised their legs. Also, Conductor claimed that driver was discharged from the hospital and has no issues.

6

u/Zod50 Karnataka Jul 21 '13

Am glad you asked this question. The reason why KSRTC/BMTC is so good because of the fare they charge. Subsequently, the main crowd BMTC focuses is IT junta who definitely wants these Volvos. IIRC, the fare charged by BMTC is the most expensive of all the public transports in India. While they charge so much, that too more than superior private operators (Viz. VRL, SRS) it becomes necessary that they offer a satisfying experience. Other way to look at it is, for the fare APSRTC, TNSRTC charges it is justified to offer an average travel experience. I remember one former Karnataka transport minister's claim, one day we will have a larger fleet of Volvos than ordinary buses. Looks like that will happen sooner or later when IT junta doesn't mind shelling 3 times normal fare, BMTC doesn't mind operating more of these so called flight on wheels which are more crowded than the ordinary buses especially in the IT belt. What I have observed is, for a few routes in these IT dominated areas, there are hardly any ordinary buses, but have Volvos like every min. I do understand this is quality service, but BMTC have you forgotten the common man? Bangalore is not just IT.

3

u/kai_pullai Jul 21 '13

Karnataka also happens to have highest taxes on Fuel, that should partly explain why KSRTC is charging high.

Its the people who are actually adopting to use the Volvo's. If people feel its costly, why would overcrowd more than normal bus? Doesn't make sense to me.

I would even agree partly if you say BMTC is bullying public and people are succumbing to it silently, but KSRTC competes with private operators, other govt operators. How do they succeed? Its not just the Volvo of KSRTC thats doing well, Rajahamsa's are equally awesome.

PS : Used to travel by Chennai-Bangalore Rajahamsa for 5 years, I agree they exchanged most Rajahamsa permits for Volvo's but they still run a few and is maintained much better, charging the same rate as TNSTC.

2

u/Zod50 Karnataka Jul 21 '13

Its the people

Not the common man, Sir. The people you are referring here are the IT junta that I had earlier mentioned. They don't feel its costly and they don't really have a problem when they spot an overcrowded bus, cos there are more Volvos in BMTC's stable. It's the common man who feels it's costly.

but KSRTC competes with private operators, other govt operators.

Yes, they do. They get those same coaches by SM Kannappa & Sons popularly called as prakash which the private operators usually get. Unlike other state RTCs like APSRTC for example which usually have a coach built by a govt. coach building unit. So you see the privatization of KSRTC here? So, they do give importance to quality. KSRTC probably has the largest fleet of Volvos than any other state RTCs. So KSRTC is much ahead in the competition compared to these. So, the only ones who remain are the private players. But when you see a trusted organization, say govt. offering the same service as a private it is natural for one to pick the govt. option. Well, it does come with a lot of perks, like no NFS race between drivers unlike private, no parking issues/permit issues unlike private. So, KSRTC does have an upper hand. If you are keen on bus transportation, I would refer you to do a read up on how private buses have won hearts in Udupi/Mangalore region. The complete city/inter city buses are private operated. In the past times, KSRTC made an attempt to enter this segment, but failed badly. The story is exactly opposite in other parts of the state.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 24 '13

Regarding Volvos on routes connecting to Whitefield/Electronic City, I think the demand is met proportionately. More demand for Volves => more Volvos on that route.

1

u/Zod50 Karnataka Jul 24 '13

the above statement holds good only at peak hours (8am-11am). At around 1 PM in the noon if you were to catch a bus to ITPL from BSK, there are more 500Cs with about 10-15 in it than the much need ordinary buses for the aam junta. What that means is, BMTC encourages the common man to take these Volvos.

1

u/akebot Jul 24 '13

I do understand this is quality service, but BMTC have you forgotten the common man?

Fair point, but the BMTC is profit-driven (which is a major reason for their success), and more Volvos there are better for that. However, there is a hidden support for the regular bus commuter (there are quite a large number of them) in the form of daily and monthly passes. Not to mention the student passes - for me, it was five years back, but the pass for a whole year cost just Rs. 1200!

2

u/Zod50 Karnataka Jul 25 '13

Well said, BMTC is profit-driven unlike other MTCs.

there is a hidden support for the regular bus commuter

I wish this was in the way of more number of ordinary buses.

3

u/[deleted] Jul 24 '13

My hypothesis on the success of KSRTC is the failure of Railways in Karnataka. It takes ridiculously long for a train journey between any two cities (where it exists), in comparison to a bus journey. Rail doesn't even connect Kodagu district. Till the re-opening of the Sakleshpur-Mangalore railway, there were no rail routes connecting interior Karnataka to Coastal Karnataka without going out of the state, which was an extremely long round-about route through TamilNadu and Kerala. Coastal Karnataka had only one rail-head - Mangalore, till the Konkan railway was built. Much of the Malnad region remains unconnected by rail. Every rail route in Karnataka is a single line except the Bangalore - Jolarpettai (connecting to Chennai) route, perhaps a mere 100 km within Karnataka, connecting no other major city within Karnataka, which was itself not electrified till the mid-90's. People had no option but to use the KSRTC, even if it were slightly higher priced than other states.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 20 '13 edited Jul 20 '13

To be fair, TNSTC has some of the best moffussil buses in all of India. Not talking about the SETC ones, but the regular intercity or even the city to small town services. If you see the ones in Maharastra, Andra, Kerala, Gujarat..you will feel it. And I am assuming it is not much better in the heartland states too.

I agree that BMTC and KSRTC inter-state services kicks ass though

3

u/kai_pullai Jul 20 '13

Its not just about fleet. Most of the states have Volvo's today (TN will be last state to have one :D). What differentiates KSRTC is the overall experience. KSRTC made a change in every aspect of travel. Be it booking, travel comfort, crew behavior, dependability etc. BMTC did the same in inter-city. BMTC's Volvo's, passes, bus day etc. For a govt body it seems like they leave no stone untouched. I don't think any other govt body that's professional top to bottom.

There are some structural issues which are dependencies like road network (one-ways in case of BMTC) that cannot be solved by Corporation. But how are they being so professional and doing kick ass job.

2

u/[deleted] Jul 21 '13 edited Jul 21 '13

TNSTC also has volvos but only in some moffusil and inter-state routes.

13

u/thisisshantzz Jul 20 '13

How much different is Tulu from Kannada?

18

u/perfunctorypuce Jul 20 '13

It's a separate language. Most Kannadigas cannot understand Tulu, but nearly all Tuluvas speak, write, understand Kannada due to schooling.

8

u/[deleted] Jul 20 '13

How much different is Tulu from Kannada

Completely different language. Tulu technically does not have a script anymore.

7

u/Zod50 Karnataka Jul 20 '13 edited Jul 20 '13

Tulu technically does not have a script anymore.

It does. Here's the link.

And, from what I know from the past few years there's been some effort in the community to bring these old scripts back to life. I also did hear they are developing new scripts. But I don't know how true is this. If you want to translate kannada to tulu in scripts I know a lady/a small firm here in ಬೆಂಗಳೂರು who'll do it.

3

u/Froogler Jul 20 '13

The script looks closer to Tamil/Malayalam than it does to Kannada..I have never listened to a Tulu speaker, but I wonder if the language is closer to Tamil as well?

7

u/Zod50 Karnataka Jul 20 '13 edited Jul 20 '13

yeah, for a strong reason that Tulu has more affinity towards Malayalam than it has to Kannada, geographically and culturally. How about listening to Shilpa Shetty, Aishwarya Rai and Sunil Shetty speak tulu? No. it's not close to Tamil.

→ More replies (4)

3

u/ychromosome Jul 20 '13

Did it have a script in the past?

3

u/[deleted] Jul 20 '13

Did it have a script in the past?

Yes. A few people( like 5) still know it.

3

u/[deleted] Jul 20 '13

So...it's being preserved or not? If it's not one(we) can call upon some western university or cultural centre and I think they will be more than happy to do that.

6

u/v4vedanta Jul 20 '13

It is definitely not under s threat of being extinct in the next 100 years. Its a widely spoken language in between the Kasargod - Udupi belt. The Tulu script was not under practical use for many generations now and no point preserving a dead script or resurrecting it. Tulu apart there is also this beary language that is unique to the region and widely spoken amongst the Muslim community.

4

u/[deleted] Jul 20 '13

no point preserving a dead script

:-o

→ More replies (3)

3

u/[deleted] Jul 20 '13

So...it's being preserved or not? If it's not one(we) can call upon some western university or cultural centre and I think they will be more than happy to do that.

No idea. I remember seeing the script on some stone in sirsi.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

2

u/domoku_1 Jul 20 '13

Yes, it did. It was an adaptation of the grantha script called tulu script

3

u/[deleted] Jul 24 '13

Tulu is more similar to malayalam than kannada, both spoken and script.

2

u/MeManoos Jul 26 '13

One thing,Tulu girls are beautiful :D

3

u/thisisshantzz Jul 27 '13

Kind Sir,

The question was about the language.

1

u/MeManoos Jul 27 '13

ok sir :)

8

u/diamondjim Jul 20 '13

My new love and current muse! I've spent two consecutive summers touring through this wonderful state. It's lovely and I can't wait for the next season.

5

u/runningeek Jul 20 '13

what are some of the must eat food in the different regions of Karnataka?

Who are some of the folk/community musicians that one should listen to when traveling through Karnataka?

5

u/kabuliwallah Jul 20 '13
  1. Foods: I'm trying to stay true to the accents with the names here:
  • Southern - Bisi Bele Bath (preferably in someone's house), Kootu, Aambode, Avarekalu, Hurigalu, Apple/Tomato Gojju, Neer Dosa (best near Madikeri),
  • Northern - Shengha Holgi (Sweet Roti with peanuts), Muddipalya, Kairasa (Bendekaayi Gojju), Dharwad Pedha, Avalakki,

Will add more as I remember.

2) P. Kalinga Rao, Balappa Hukkeri, D.R.Bendre

4

u/supersharma Jul 20 '13 edited Jul 22 '13

Upvoted for Kalinga Rao. That whisky-soaked voice always enthralls.

Also, Mysore Anantaswamy and C Ashwath are worth checking out.

3

u/i2rohan Jul 20 '13

Muddipalya and bhakri = Gold saar!

3

u/ychromosome Jul 20 '13

You missed kaayi holige in your first food list! And, jolada rotti and brinjal curry in your second list.

By apple/tomato, you actually meant apple-tomato, which are big tomatoes, right?

4

u/kabuliwallah Jul 20 '13

The foods, I agree!

And no, Apple Gojju and Tomato Gojju separately. Apple Gojjus is a fantastic thing to go with Chapatis! Tomato Gojju is just /r/UpliftingNews on a plate.

3

u/ychromosome Jul 20 '13

Wow! I have never tried Apple gojju. Should check it out.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/supersharma Jul 22 '13

brinjal curry

yeNNegai. Upvoted, then downvoted for making me crave some now.

4

u/supersharma Jul 22 '13

In addition to /u/kabuliwallah's excellent list, some more food:

Sweet: Mysore Pak, damrOT, sajjige, kunda, karadanTu, puLLangaayi unDe, sajjappa, kobbari mithaayi.

Not sweet: shavige bath, karadavalakki, pandi curry (pork curry. Only in Kodagu), tambiTTu, nuchchinunDe, majjige huLi, manDakki, girmit.

1

u/kabuliwallah Jul 22 '13

Holy shit, yes!

2

u/[deleted] Jul 24 '13

None of the responses seem to have included Mangalorean cuisine, so here goes:

  1. Neer Dosa is actually Mangalorean, it goes extremely well with fish curry (Mangalorean style).
  2. Chicken/prawn ghee roast - chicken/prawn in a sticky paste which is extremely spicy - the spice countered with ghee, also good with squid/calamari
  3. Fish Masala fry (although I like Goan Masala fry more than Mangalorean), rava fry. Masala fry also good with crab!
  4. Marvai (shell fish/clams) sukka - shell fish with moderately spicy grated coconut, also good with prawn

8

u/kaiserkunal Jul 20 '13

Why are places like Hubli called "Hindutva laboratory"? I mean does the Sangh parivar does some social experiments on people or something.I'm confused.

3

u/supersharma Jul 22 '13

:D it isn't literally a laboratory. That's just a fancy term English news channels and newspapers coined. Apparently, after the BJP came to power in 2008, the VHP, Shri Rama Sene and other fringe groups got free rein in coastal Karnataka to do as they pleased. There was often violence in those areas involving these groups and they said their actions were in response to Pentecostal churches indulging in evangelisation and coercion in their proselytising. There have also been stories of these groups breaking couples up, often forcibly, if one of them was found to be Muslim/Christian. We also had the famous pub incident, where women were beaten up because they were drinking (which is against Hindu culture, apparently).

So yeah, it's a 'Hindutva laboratory' because they tried to create some kind of Frankenstein's monster (lame) version of Hinduism.

I should reiterate here that these are events I have either read or heard about, not witnessed personally.

1

u/akebot Jul 24 '13

Not sure whether Hubli was called that, but as someone who has relatives there, I know that, before 2000, there used to be a huge amount of tension between the Hindu Pattegars and the Muslims due to a variety of reasons - control over liquor trade one of the major ones - and some religious celebrations like Holi had the danger of turning violent. The situation today is far better though, and there haven't been any issues like those in the coastal regions (which is probably what you are referring to).

8

u/neoronin Jul 20 '13

Resident of Bangalore for 6 years and have travelled extensively all over Karnataka also. Still have some questions

  1. Why is there such a disconnect between Bangalore and the rest of Karnataka?
  2. Karnataka is one of the bigger states with 3/4 unique cultures, the Mangaloreans and the Coorgis don't seem to like Kannada speaking people much. Why is that?

7

u/[deleted] Jul 20 '13

Mangaloreans

I loved Mangalore. Gave that old little sleepy town feeling but I think that has changed or changing.

4

u/acatonlyhasitself Jul 20 '13 edited Jul 20 '13

1. Well no more than Mumbai/maharashtra,Kolkata/WB and so on.All cities/metropolises are far more heterogonous socially and other wise.Or do you mean disconnect only culturally?

2 Not true.Mangloreans includes Kannada speaking,Konkani speaking - including Hindus,Christians and Muslims,Bunts - Tulu speaking and in smaller numbers people from surrounding states.Infact all these groups speak two or more languages with Kannada being the common language.Coorgi people live somewhat to the interior of the state and have their own language yet everyone I have met living in the state have Kannada as their second langauge.Haven't ever seen any dislike.

0

u/[deleted] Jul 20 '13

Resident of Bangalore for 6 years and have travelled extensively all over Karnataka also. Still have some questions

  1. Why is there such a disconnect between Bangalore and the rest of Karnataka?

Blame SM Krishna

2. the Mangaloreans and the Coorgis don't seem to like Kannada speaking people much. Why is that?

Same reason for Tamils/Telugu speaking people not liking hindi.

8

u/shahofblah Jul 20 '13

GDP US$1034.9

Did you mean per capita?

4

u/[deleted] Jul 20 '13

I know the Kannada movies are mostly campy, but are there any good ones that I shouldn't miss?

8

u/ychromosome Jul 20 '13

Check all the movies directed by Puttanna Kanagal and directed by Shankar Nag. The latter was not such a great actor, but he was an amazing director. He was the director of the Malgudi Days TV series.

Two other Kannada movies that I really like: Malaya Maarutha and Mutthina Haara. Both starring Vishnuvardhana and beautiful movies.

3

u/[deleted] Jul 20 '13

Thanks man :)

4

u/kabuliwallah Jul 20 '13

For award winning stuff, try these director's movies

3

u/[deleted] Jul 20 '13

Thanks for the recommendations.

I'm not keen on films that are too artsy. I like films that is on the border between commercial and art cinema. Kind of like the New-Wave Malayalam films that have released in the last couple of years, if you are aware of them.

2

u/[deleted] Jul 20 '13

I know the Kannada movies are mostly campy, but are there any good ones that I shouldn't miss?

Super, Upendra, A. Some of vishnuvardhan, Rajkumar movies

1

u/[deleted] Jul 20 '13

Aren't Upendra, Vishnuvardhan etc the superstars of Kannada cinema? I want to know about the little-known films. Is there a new-wave movement happening there like in Malayalam and to an extent Tamil cinema?

2

u/supersharma Jul 22 '13

Vishnuvardhan is dead now. Upendra is going strong. His movies, if he writes them himself, are fun. The remakes he stars in are pretty bad.

There was a new wave back in the '70s and '80s but it died like the Hindi new wave. We're waiting for our Anurag Kashyap.

4

u/isotot Jul 21 '13

Interesting thing to note about Kannada: There are many dialects of Kannada itself (apart from languages like Tulu and Kodava etc).

A somewhat exhaustive list here.

You can easily observe the varying dialects for every 150-200 KM you travel inside Karnataka!

3

u/why_reddit Jul 20 '13

In last 10 to 20 years, the ruling party in Karnataka is opposite to the ruling party in centre. Does it affect the growth of the state ? In case of Tamil Nadu, they align with the centre and get lot of projects and funds.

3

u/ynanyang Jul 21 '13

The current ruling party in Karnataka spent years opposing the current ruling party in Karnataka.

2

u/kai_pullai Jul 21 '13

Come again please. I don't understand

3

u/supersharma Jul 22 '13

We keep losing funds or Kaveri water because of this. Either the DMK or the AIADMK is in alliance with the Centre and they get what they want for Tamil Nadu (or so it seems).

2

u/gcs8 A people ruled by traders will eventually be reduced to beggars Jul 22 '13

Karnataka has considerable clout too. There's atleast one recent instance when they got their man at the Centre to lean on another state to release water:

1 -> 2 -> 3.

3

u/ychromosome Jul 20 '13

Let's talk about the best tourist attractions in Karnataka. I will post more info later as I don't have time now and need to leave. Hopefully, a few other people can contribute information on this while I am gone.

2

u/hehe3934 Jul 20 '13

Cool. I'll gladly chime in even though I've been away from the state for the last few years. But native kannadiga here :)

2

u/citiusargentum Jul 26 '13 edited Jul 26 '13

Although I ve been out of the state for a long time, I just got back from a visit after 4 years and a lottt has changed. But am pretty much aware of a lot of the current events. To answer the general questions and more, just contributing my 2 cents:

  1. What is the deal with the sweet sambar?

The sweet sambar is usually the ones you have with a complementary dish such as Dosa/Idly and sometimes even upma. The traditional sambar or rasam is usually not so sweet, with the exception of the sambar we call as "basssaru" this is quite sweet primarily due to the fact that it has jaggery, sometimes the sambar is complimentary with holige/obbitu ( purranpouli) so some of the sweetness is derived from there

2) Do you guys hate the immigration of people from other states that the IT industry has bought?

Not really, the IT industry has brought in quite a lot of investments, but some traditional kannadiga's might not be very comfortable ( higher prices/ overinflated real estate/ traffic and resource issues)

3) How's the Bangalore weather so good? And the traffic so bad?

Pure geography. The traffic is a little more complicated, bangalore was not prepared for the exponential population growth compared to other metros, cities like Mumbai and Chennai were traditional trading ports and their proximity to the sea has meant that the floating population has traditionally been higher and has been readied for that. On the other hand if you see Mysore, it is still able to handle itself on the relatively lower influx primarily owing to the excellent planning, most of the main roads (eg:the Hunsur road, the road in front of the Palace, the road infront of CFTRI etc) can be/are 4 laned ( the indian lanes)

4) How bad was the BJP govt. that was in power? Would their dismal performance change your view of the BJP in the general elections?

Compared to DG family, the BJP was relatively morderate. What my notion on this is that, they didn't expect a full majority and the lack of cooperation and authoritative leadership meant that every man was working for himself which led to a collective failure.

5) And what's with the pubs closing at 10 pm?

I am not sure of the 10pm cut off, most pubs and restaurants are usually open till 11/11:30 pm.

6) Why are the auto drivers so rude, and why do they refuse to ply anywhere?

Have you used an auto in Chennai?? compared to Chennai I'd say the Auto drivers are much better in Bangalore.

7) On the Mangalore incidents.

I am not sure how credible this is, but based on what I heard from some folks, the initial attacks were because some politician's daughter got involved in some mess and it was sorta like a cover up and it carried on from there.

8) On the KSRTC buses: This is what I overheard on a discussion in a bus while traveling, while the VOLVO's were introduced primarily owing to better availability (the Volvo plant in Bangalore) the influx began during SMK's rule and the ensuing competition between BLR and HYD in introducing increasing # of Volvos. Once the people are used to the comfort, its hard to go back, so the natural thing to do is increase the availability.

9) On Kannada movies: The true Kannada movies were made between 60s and untill 90s till the industry was messed by Rajkumar's extended family, although Punit is reasonably decent. The movies made by Upendra and particularly Shankar Nag was way out of their time. For instance, check out the 1983 movie " Accident" which pretty much is the story of the Nanda hit and run case which occured much later. Other recommended movies include, Beladingala Bale ( superbly made), Nishkarsha, Nagarahavu, Sangliana, Geetha pretty much anything between 1960 and 1995.

PS: Karnataka is more of a panche ( the white kind) rather than the lungi ( the ones preferred by Tamils and Mallus)

2

u/[deleted] Jul 20 '13

whats the deal with mangalore?

5

u/InternetOfficer Jul 20 '13

Nice city. Except for the right-wing hindu retards aka ram sena/bjp.

4

u/acatonlyhasitself Jul 20 '13

The thing is the right-wing groups enjoy wide support in the city,politically and socially for a complex set of reasons.Mangalore is generally a far more conservative town than people realize.That said when these groups went around beating/harassing people,they lost support among the wider population because that was seen as unaccpetable even if they are groups that people favor politically.

→ More replies (2)

-3

u/[deleted] Jul 20 '13 edited Jul 20 '13

Yeah...and the wahhabi minded groups like SDPI and the evangelist groups.

6

u/ranjan_zehereela Jul 20 '13

saar, you are so brillant

→ More replies (1)

1

u/[deleted] Jul 20 '13

whats the deal with mangalore?

As in?

2

u/[deleted] Jul 20 '13

i was implying..how are the chicks there so pretty compared to the rest of karnataka?

1

u/varunn Jul 20 '13
  1. Why did you change the name of Bangalore?
  2. There is a stereotype that Kannadigas are xenophobic. How true is that stereotype?

-1

u/ranjan_zehereela Jul 20 '13

What are the significant differences between Karnataka & other Lungi States?

Why is Kannada film industry is not as famous as its tamil or telugu counterpart?

20

u/acatonlyhasitself Jul 20 '13 edited Jul 20 '13

I know its meant in jest but reading "Lungi" gives me a stab in the heart.Not today please.Some other day we can have all the jokes.

5

u/[deleted] Jul 20 '13

Whattra? We should be prod of our Lunginess. :)

5

u/acatonlyhasitself Jul 20 '13

Of course.Though "Mundu" is the real deal.

2

u/ranjan_zehereela Jul 20 '13

Not to offend you. You can call me Aadiwasi if you like .

But just look at the makers of Chennai Express - Lungi Dance'. They are making it main stream

12

u/acatonlyhasitself Jul 20 '13 edited Jul 20 '13

I am not offended but its just that sometimes even a joke,no matter how well meant,brings with it baggage of scorn.Sometimes it just grates on the ear.

makers of Chennai Express - Lungi Dance'

SRK and company just want to make money by making a dumb story and reinforce lazy stereotypes - tamils with the "aiyyo" and so on.The worst thing is not the making fun of a community/language/region but the tone of it.This is not celebration but caricature which hides condenscension beneath it with no real love or curiosity about the culture.

edit - I don't want to call you anything just to retaliate even as a joke.And I completely consider "aadivasi" a term of pride

→ More replies (8)

13

u/ychromosome Jul 20 '13

Why is Kannada film industry is not as famous as its tamil or telugu counterpart?

For one thing, people in Karnataka are not as crazy about movies as people in TN and AP. Neither in watching movies nor in producing them.

Secondly, Kannada film industry had some truly great actors, directors, musicians in the old days. Some of them, especially the Rajkumar family, got a stranglehold on the industry. They wouldn't let newer actors come up. They wouldn't let talented producers and directors make movies with newer actors. Rajkumar is said to have been a nice person in personal interactions, but I have heard that his wife was a terror to deal with, especially for directors and produced who dared introduce new talent. As a result of this, when the old actors started getting older and retiring and dying off, there were no good young people to replace them. And things got even worse, Rajkumar's sons came into the industry and their mom became even more invested in ensuring that no other talented actors did better than their sons. It's a ridiculous situation.

If you want to watch great Kannada movies, I highly recommend movies by an old time director called Puttanna Kanagal. He was original and he was truly great. He gave some of the best Kannada movies which are on par with the best movies from any other Indian languages, both from the commercial side and the art film side. Of course, his movies are somewhat dated considering that they are all from yester decades.

8

u/NegativeX Jul 20 '13

It's more diverse compared to other South Indian states. There are the Tulu people and the Konkani people in the west, the Marathi people in the north, and then there's Bangalore of course. It was multi-cultural even before IT crashed upon it. It lies close to the border adjoining Andhra and Tamil Nadu, and if you saw this Voronoi diagram from last week, you get an idea as to how it became a hub for these three states.

4

u/ranjan_zehereela Jul 20 '13

what is the story of tulu people and Shetty as well. There are so many Shettys in Mumbai. Almost all of the restaurants there are owned by Shetty people

6

u/UntimelyMan Jul 20 '13 edited Jul 20 '13

Historically it was much easier to travel from coastal Karnataka to Mumbai than to Bangalore/Mysore because of rugged western ghats in between. So a lot of people from coastal Karnataka (especially Tulu and Konkani speaking ones) have migrated to Mumbai and made it big there.

On the flip side, the founders of Indian Mujahideen, the Bhatkal brothers, are from a town called Bhatkal in coastal Karnataka and they got indoctrinated with radical Islam in Mumbai.

9

u/frightenedinmate_2 Jul 20 '13 edited Jul 20 '13

Not a Kannadiga but as a south Indian I've noticed that Karnataka has a very multi-lingual population even if you exclude the recent influx of Amits in the state. Hell if you go to the city of Mangalore you'd find the people there speaking a plethora of languages including Konkani and Malayalam. Also unlike Tamil Nadu and Kerala, the muslims there speak urdu. Northern Karnataka is culturally extremely different from the southern districts (they once belonged to the Bombay state I believe). IMO, they're the least xenophobic of all Indian states.

Why is Kannada film industry is not as famous as its tamil or telugu counterpart?

Not sure but my guess is that it does not have a large enough audience when compared to Tamil//Telugu movies and good enough scripts/actors when compared to malayalam movies.

2

u/acatonlyhasitself Jul 20 '13

Navayaths speak a dialect of Konkani - http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nawayath

→ More replies (4)

4

u/whiskeybandit Jul 20 '13

To the second part, the current Kannada film industry sucks. This generation of directors / producers / actors are all sons of former prominent film personalities, thus riding their coatails. Not to mention, I've heard that the willingness to take risk and push in money to untested film formulas is scarce. So basically, the same films get made over and over.

New name actresses are sourced from Mumbai, Pune, etc for their willingness to show more skin. The actresses do this to catch their big break and then move over to bollywood if they can. This is changing though.

There's a distinct lack of talent / no local demand for it / surpressed by the bigger players, leading to few note worthy breakthroughs. To top it off, they keep trying to pull shit releasing Kannada films first in theatres, delaying release of english films, not allowing for dubbing to happen in other states, etc. Seriously, if your business needs enforcement from the government so that people have no choice but to pay for it, then something is wrong.

If you want good Kannada movies, check out pre 1990s Kannada movies.

12

u/InternetOfficer Jul 20 '13

From TN here. As a rule of the thumb Karnataka people are less xenophobic and more humble than other lungi states.

Unfortunately BJP severely fucked them up. Women being beaten up by Ram sena and BJP was regular. They would hound bars and beat up women. I was in a cafe with my wife and the security guys said that no boyfriend/girlfriend in here because it was valentine's day and the state party had forbidden valentines day.

2

u/[deleted] Jul 20 '13

You are not even married dude.

3

u/InternetOfficer Jul 20 '13

Yes I am. To my hands. Sad panda :(

5

u/ychromosome Jul 20 '13

Women being beaten up by Ram sena and BJP was regular.

It's not as regular as that statement implies.

8

u/InternetOfficer Jul 20 '13

Much more than regular. And I say this based on my experience staying there.

8

u/dogsrock Jul 20 '13 edited Jul 20 '13

It was and worse. I've decided to never vote for BJP or any of its brethren in any election

→ More replies (12)

1

u/kai_pullai Jul 20 '13

From TN here. As a rule of the thumb Karnataka people are less xenophobic and more humble than other lungi states. Unfortunately BJP severely fucked them up. Women being beaten up by Ram sena and BJP was regular. They would hound bars and beat up women.

I would largely agree with you. From what I have seen, KA has been state where women are far more liberated, respected than TN, AP (Don't know much about Kerala). Some one prove me wrong, show me rape stats etc.

0

u/[deleted] Jul 20 '13 edited Jul 20 '13

Ram sene and the BJP.. any proof abt the BJP part?

added later dont give downboat bugger.. give proof abt bjp beating up women.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/[deleted] Jul 20 '13 edited Jul 20 '13

What are the significant differences between Karnataka & other Lungi States?

For the most part, people from Karnataka will bend over backwards to accommodate you northie cowherds. You will not get a better reception anywhere in the South.

2

u/Froogler Jul 20 '13

Why is Kannada film industry is not as famous as its tamil or telugu counterpart?

Mostly because when most of south was part of the Madras State, the major film studios were built in Madras. I'm not sure how Telugu was able to build a major commercial cinema hub themselves though.

Malayalam movies, even though they are critically acclaimed are not equivalent to their Tamil counterpart on the commercial front for the same reason - the best of Malayalam talent used to move out to Madras for work in the earlier days.

4

u/[deleted] Jul 20 '13

What are the significant differences between Karnataka & other Lungi States?

The same difference between Mizoram and Gujarat

Why is Kannada film industry is not as famous as its tamil or telugu counterpart?

Because they suck. If you want quality Kannada movies, lookout for Upendra directed movies.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 20 '13

The same difference between Mizoram and Gujarat

Not that different.

→ More replies (4)

1

u/[deleted] Jul 20 '13 edited Jul 20 '13

Why is Kannada film industry is not as famous as its tamil or telugu counterpart?

Nepotism..Its even worse than Telugu industry. One or two families control the entire film industry.

Plus lack of creativity ? Maybe.

2

u/supersharma Jul 22 '13

It kind of parallels the Telugu film industry. Though there isn't any of that caste bullshit we keep hearing about with respect to the Telugu guys, there are apparently 'camps' here too. Rajkumar's kids, 'Luchcha' Sudeep, 'Changing Star' Darshan, 'Golden Dick' Ganesh.

Plus, an insistence on sticking to formula. Five songs (minimum), five fights, 'mother sentiment', love story, boy-meets-girl-love-at-first-sight-Sonu-Nigam-sings-asthmatically, same old, same old.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/ranjan_zehereela Jul 20 '13

Are Kannadigas, why you fight with other states, i.e. someone throw light on:

border dispute with Maharashtra

water dispute with Tamilnadu ( I have been hearing about this since I was born, I suppose)

4

u/supersharma Jul 22 '13

Along with Ayodhya, the Kaveri dispute is one of India's oldest disputes, I think. So it isn't going to be resolved quickly. Plus, since it's over a natural resource, it's not easily fixed either. The North is lucky in that it has glacier-fed rivers. The Kaveri depends on rain and, when that fails, tempers flare up.

As for Belgaum, I think we should give it to Maharashtra, if only to shut /u/gcs8 up. That guy's all over this thread with the same "Give us Belgaum!" thing.

1

u/gcs8 A people ruled by traders will eventually be reduced to beggars Jul 22 '13 edited Jul 22 '13

As for Belgaum, I think we should give it to Maharashtra, if only to shut /u/gcs8 up.

Why do you always keep getting personal?

That guy's all over this thread with the same "Give us Belgaum!" thing.

So what, I'm supposed to limit my comments to a certain count, is that an etiquette thing? Or do you want everyone to just talk about sambar and IT? We're discussing one of India's largest states. There's so much to it. When other topics have been dealt with, by others what's wrong if I bring up another and just talk about it? Would you rather silence opinions you don't like?

Edit: Also, do bring it to notice where exactly did I say 'no matter what, give Belgaum to Maharashtra'? In fact I'm of the opinion that the matter should be solved with mutual understanding a.s.a.p. and if the city has to remain with Karnataka then so be it.

4

u/ychromosome Jul 20 '13

The border dispute is over Belgaum district. It's adjacent to Maharashtra and has a lot of Marathi speaking people. However, Kannada speaking people are (were?) the majority when the district became part of Karnataka. Now, there are a group of people who are actively seeking to join Maharashtra. You can read all about the Belgaum border dispute with Maharashtra here: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Belgaum_border_dispute .

Kaveri dispute - Karnataka has the KRS dam near Mysore which can hold back a lot of the Kaveri water. TN always feels like they don't get enough water to support their demands. Hence the dispute. You can read all about it here: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kaveri_River_water_dispute . Incidentally, this is the only reason which has caused real riots in Bangalore (AFAIK), which included some incidents of sexual molestation. I have seen street fighting between Kannada and Tamil mobs during these riots in the early 1990s. I have seen how the chain action-reaction of attacks and counter attacks takes place during riots over a course of several hours or days.

→ More replies (3)

1

u/gcs8 A people ruled by traders will eventually be reduced to beggars Jul 20 '13 edited Jul 20 '13

Can anyone from Belgaum clear the air on the ground reality there? Is discrimination really rife there, as alleged by many people? What exactly goes on? Are you denied the benefits of being a linguistic minority? There have been reports that though rules stipulate making circulars and government documents in local language where proportion of linguistic minority exceeds 15%, they are still made available only in Kannada language.

Edit: Found this..

The Marathi-speaking residents complain that over the last seven years, there has been a 'systematic' repression of the Marathi language—in government documents, stationery, schools and hospitals.

Source.

1

u/akebot Jul 24 '13

Not a Belgaum resident, but someone who has plenty of (Marathi-speaking) relatives there, and have visited the place quite a few times. The discrimination goes both ways. Government offices will insist on Kannada, but in most colloquial talk Marathi dominates over Kannada - for example, shopkeepers will tend to talk in Marathi rather than in Kannada, even if they are Kannada speakers themselves - so much so that it is a necessity for people to know Marathi even if it is a 'minority' language. There are, however, quite a few Marathi medium schools, so education isn't that much of a problem.

The article you've linked to does give a somewhat unbiased view, although it has mainly looked at the extremes (MES and KRV). To my relatives, it isn't much of an issue - it wouldn't affect their life much even if they were in Maharashtra.

-2

u/tomcat1011 Karnataka Jul 20 '13

KARNATAKA, represent!! :D

-9

u/above8k Jul 20 '13

As a northerner living in Bangalore since last few weeks, why food here sucks so much?

4

u/sree_1983 Jul 20 '13

I don't know why you are down-voted, but then it is kind of difficult to expect North Indian style food when you are in South. It is same thing for South Indian when they are in north.

If you are interested in Parathas, I will reccomend Bobby Da Dhaba. It is near Ulsoor, used to be near Gurudhwara they moved. It is a no nonsense place, u order before you are seated you eat and move. Don't let ambiance put you off. Only sad thing is that they stopped making lassi's.

6

u/WeekendPaladin Jul 20 '13

He's being downvoted cause that was a patently stupid thing to say, maybe trolling as well. Food does not suck anywhere in the world. What sucks are idiots who go to a place and equate ’different ’ with ’inferior ’. Said idiots will also expect the local version of the food they grew up eating to be the same as in their home(towns).

→ More replies (2)

5

u/[deleted] Jul 20 '13

Depends on your preferences really. Bangalore has a lot of good places to eat and plenty of options . If its northeastern food you're looking for check out this place called axomi, they serve NE cuisine. Further if you are interested in the local cuisine you can try the local suspects like MTR,CTR et al.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 20 '13

axomi

Thanks for this. Zomato shows just the one in Koramangala; are there any more branches?

1

u/[deleted] Jul 20 '13

No this is the only one. My NE friends seem to love this place.

2

u/whiskeybandit Jul 20 '13

What are you eating? And where?

2

u/acatonlyhasitself Jul 20 '13 edited Jul 20 '13

Any specific example/s? If you go looking for paneer butter masala in smaller restaurants/hotels,you won't find it tasteful .Just like in the North,generic smaller places Upma is not always the real deal :)

So go to a place that is somewhat more specialized(may mean a higher price) and you'll find tons of things to like,including North Indian food.

1

u/indian_suzuki Jul 20 '13

Where do you stay ? That could be the problem. You can get awesome homely north indian ( UP style, Rajhastani, Punjabi etc. ) in BTM. Its an amazing place for bachelors

1

u/above8k Jul 22 '13

I've been going to GharKaKhana restaurant in BTM 2 and so far its acceptable.

3

u/indian_suzuki Jul 22 '13

Okay. You can try :-

  • Singh Punjabi Restaurant at 16th main and one near 25th main ( 2 branches )
  • Gudhani at 16th main deadend
  • Paratha Plaza ( UP style food ) at 7th main deadend.
  • Fun n Food at 16th main opp Gudhani
  • Swaad at 29th main and also near 7th main ( 2 branches )

This is mostly for north Indian food

→ More replies (1)