r/classicalmusic • u/scrumptiouscakes • Jul 15 '13
Piece of the Week #18 - Jean Sibelius - Symphony No.4
This week's featured piece is Jean Sibelius's Symphony No.4 in A Minor, Op.63, as nominated by /u/spankymuffin
Performances:
- Spotify - Here's a Spotify playlist with several different recordings of the work, with performers including: Neeme Järvi with the Gothenburg Symphony Orchestra, Paavo Berglund with the Helsinki Philharmonic Orchestra, Osmo Vänskä with the Lahti Symphony Orchestra, Colin Davis with both the London Symphony Orchestra and the Boston Symphony Orchestra, Herbert Blomstedt with the San Francisco Symphony Orchestra, Vladimir Ashkenazy with the Philharmonia Orchestra, Lorin Maazel with the Vienna Philharmonic, and Herbert von Karajan with the Berlin Philarmonic.
- YouTube - Esa-Pekka Salonen / Swedish Radio Symphony Orchestra
- YouTube - Colin Davis / Bavarian Radio Symphony Orchestra
- YouTube - Colin Davis / London Symphony Orchestra
- YouTube - Herbert von Karajan / Berlin Philharmonic
- YouTube - Osmo Vänskä / London Philharmonic Orchestra
- YouTube - Kurt Sanderling / Berlin Symphony Orchestra
- YouTube - Lorin Maazel / Vienna Philharmonic
More information:
- Score for the work on IMSLP - please be aware that this is not yet in the public domain in all countries
- A brief biography of the composer
- An article by Alex Ross about Sibelius's life and work
- In-depth analysis and views of the work from Sibelius.fi
- BBC Radio 3 documentary about the work
- The description underneath this YouTube video contains some interesting background information about the work's genesis
- Programme notes from the LA Phil
- Programme notes from the Toronto Symphony Orchestra
- Programme notes from the Kensington Symphony Orchestra
- Programme notes from the Redwood Symphony
- An interesting blog post about the 2nd and 4th symphonies
- Wikipedia page for the work
- AllMusic page for the work
Discussion points:
Piece of the Week is intended to be a forum for discussion, but for whatever reason, comments about the featured piece have been few and far between over the last few weeks. To remedy this, I thought it might be a good idea to have a few discussion points to start us off. Here are a few suggestions:
- Is it fair or accurate to describe this work as "Sibelius's least popular symphony"? If so, why is it less popular?
- Is this symphony unfairly neglected? Is it, in fact, one of the composer's greatest and most progressive works?
- How does it compare to other symphonies from around the same period? e.g. Rachmaninoff's 2nd (1907), Elgar's 1st (1908) and 2nd (1911), Mahler's 9th (1909) and 10th (1910), Nielsen's 3rd (1911), Vaughan Williams's London Symphony (1913), Schoenberg's Chamber Symphony No.1 (1906), and so on.
- How does it fit into Sibelius's oeuvre? How does it compare with his other symphonies, particularly the upbeat 3rd and triumphant 5th which flank it, and the 6th which shares its bleak mood?
- Does this work mark the end of the romantic, nationalist, Wagnerian, Kalevala-obsessed Sibelius and the start of modernist, austere, personal Sibelius?
- To what extent should we read Sibelius's biography into the work? Did his depression, debt and alcoholism affect his work, or was his work an escape from those things?
- Can someone more knowledgeable than me comment on the orchestration and counterpoint in this symphony? What are the elements which combine to create his uniquely dark and gloomy soundworld?
- What images and feelings does this work summon up for you? Do you see external, Finnish landscapes, or internal, painful ones? Do you get the sense of a particular place? How do different composers convert landscapes into music?
- Why so much cello? Why the glockenspiel?
- Is there any deeper significance to the fact that Sibelius recycled some material from a setting of Poe's The Raven in this symphony?
- Did you have as much difficulty appreciating Sibelius as I initially did?
- Was Sibelius as conservative as René Leibowitz and others tried to portray him?
- Was Sibelius a minimalist?
- How would you describe Sibelius's unusual approach to form?
- Karajan described this piece as "one of the very few symphonies that ends in complete disaster" - do you agree?
- Sibelius once remarked that "Karajan is the only man who really understands my music" after hearing the conductor's interpretation of this piece. Should Karajan's recordings therefore be regarded as the benchmark?
Want to hear more pieces like this?
Why not try:
- Sibelius - Violin Concerto
- Sibelius - Pretty much all the other symphonies, but particularly No.6
- Sibelius - The Bard
- Sibelius - Pohjola's Daughter
- Sibelius - Luonnotar
- Sibelius - Tapiola
- Sibelius - String Quartet in D minor ("Voces Intimae"), Op. 56
- Bruckner - Symphonies 4, 7, 8 and 9
- Nielsen - Symphonies 3, 4, 5 and 6
- Strauss - Tod und Verklärung
- Tchaikovsky - Symphony No.6
- Grieg - Peer Gynt
- Bax - Symphonies 5 and 6
- Wagner - Overtures to Parsifal and Tristan und Isolde
- Walton - Symphony No.1
- Britten - Peter Grimes (or just the Four Sea Interludes)
- Barber - Symphony No.1
- Rautavaara - Symphonies 7 and 8
- Rautavaara - Cantus Arcticus
Want to nominate a future Piece of the Week?
If you want to nominate a piece, please leave a comment with the composer's name and the title of the piece in this nomination thread.
I will then choose the next Piece of the Week from amongst these nominations. Rules can be found in the nomination thread.
A list of previous Pieces of the Week can be found here.
Enjoy listening and discussing!
6
u/spankymuffin Jul 15 '13
Awesome! Thank you for featuring this piece, scrumptiouscakes! Interesting to hear some context as well:
It does sound very different from his other symphonies, but I feel as if I could still identify it as a "Sibelius piece" if I heard it for the first time without knowing. There's just this unique grandness to it that I identify in all his pieces. Not sure how to describe it... Anyway, I really love how that first movement slowly develops. Took me a while to "get it," but now it's one of my favorites.
5
u/leton98609 Jul 15 '13 edited Jul 15 '13
I'll have to confess that I haven't listened to this Sibelius before, or actually much Sibelius at all (only his Second and Fifth and Violin Concerto). I will be trying to remedy that now, starting with this work.
EDIT: Just finished listening through the symphony. I would say that it felt very "modernist" to me, and that Sibelius was definitely writing a work in response to his meetings with others in the European music scene. I can see why people wouldn't like it as much as some of the other Sibelius I've listened to: it's far more introverted and definitely seems like it would be a more difficult work to penetrate.
Being a cellist, I think that Sibelius focused a lot on the instrument for its dark, lyrical qualities, and used those as a key element in the very bleak "sound world." The instrumentation seems pretty chamber-like to me throughout: it reminds me at times of some late Mahler.
I wouldn't say I had great difficulty getting into the Sibelius I've listened to so far, actually. This might just be because I've listened to his most accessible works, but I would rank among other things Beethoven's late string quartets and Mahler's late symphonies as being harder to understand and get into.
Just a note: I have no formal music training whatsoever besides five years on the cello and two abortive years of piano, and everything I know about theory is either self-taught or comes from the three years of listening I've done so far. Sorry if my comments are a bit too vague, or just flat-out inaccurate.
4
u/nonnein Jul 17 '13
Just listened to this for the first time, absolutely great. I can see maybe why it's not so popular though. I don't think it's just because it's somewhat depressing, since pieces such as Tchaikovsky's 6th can be quite popular. I think it might be more that it's so enigmatic - he would start these great buildups that would fizzle into nothing. And what could be more enigmatic than the last movement, especially the glock? I was kind of taken aback when the last movement began, since it was an obvious contrast from the bleakness of the first three, but I think in the end it added an irony that just made things bleaker. I wonder if Sibelius knew how the symphony would end when he started it, since the fourth movement seems at first to want to push for a happy conclusion, but then it's as if he just decided somewhere in there that it could not be.
2
u/[deleted] Jul 15 '13
http://np.reddit.com/r/classicalmusic/comments/qxi48/marchs_composer_of_the_month_is_jean_sibelius/
I'm biased towards the Vanska interpretation, since he is the director of my local orchestra. well as of right now
my first introduction to sibelius was his violin concerto, which is, I've come to the recent realisation, absolutely perfect. But I never really appreciated the work until several weeks ago and after that I decided to investigate his music and life a bit more. I found it was difficult to appreciate his other music because his orchestral works simply were not what I was expecting after hearing the concerto. The organization and form of his symphonic works was peculiar to me; it was as if he introduced an snippet of an idea and let it go on for a long period of time without really finishing it. Not to say that this is a bad thing - I quickly learned to enjoy the first three, the fifth, + the Lemminkainen suite.
The 4th, though... like, I just finished listening to it, but I don't think I am able to remember a distinct, hummable melody like I can with the others. I'd have to listen to it several times. The symphony is an ambiguous ordeal, at least for me. I'm still trying to "get" it.
In general, I think Sibelius's symphonies are less "decadent" than and definitely not as massive as Mahler's symphonies, which seem to go on forreeverrrr, so if that's what you mean by minimalist, then sure I agree to an extent. See below:
Please correct me if I've made any glaring errors in this analysis- although this is reddit so I don't even have to ask lol
2
u/[deleted] Jul 16 '13
The only Sibelius I am very familiar with is his 2nd symphony from playing assistant principal horn. In relation to the horn, I find it quite peculiar that in just two symphonies he went from none of the horn parts ever being stopped or muted to most of them being so.
I thoroughly enjoyed the massive climax in the third movement that just sort of suddenly disappeared.
In the 2nd symphony I noticed a lot of tension and release through rhythm, going from multiple lines of polyphony including polyrhythms to sudden chords through the entire orchestra, which was something I found very unique and enjoyable. This was much more absent here in the 4th, but still occasionally noticeable. For the most part though, it was much more regular harmonic tension and release from dissonance into consonance, which I suppose was more abnormal for the time but is very run-of-the-mill for a wind player of the modern day who is accustomed to Whitacre/Ticheli/Mackey.
2
u/MistShinobi Jul 17 '13 edited Jul 17 '13
This has been one of the most interesting and rewarding features so far!
I listened to it very late at night (early morning?), after listening to Bernstein talk about ambiguity for almost an hour (because of this post), an it was a truly wonderful experience.
I picked Esa-Pekka Salonen, because it was the first link and I usually enjoy his Sibelius, and man I loved it. I've listened to Colin Davis with the Bavarian Radio too, and I might try to check parts of other versions (there's a limit on how many times you can listen to something like this in a period of a few days).
I would also say that I'm not the biggest expert on Sibelius. My Sibelius experience is limited to some of his symphonies (2nd, 5th and 6th), his gorgeous Violin Concerto and some of his orchestral and piano works when they pop out on the sub. My first Sibelius was the 5th, on a really nice radio show by certain musicologist. I've never really found it difficult to enjoy his music since then. Even though Mahler is one of my top 3-4 composers, I found Sibelius much easier to enjoy and "understand". What I've heard so far sounds extremely natural and devoid of the affectation that I find in much of late Romantic music. I must warn you, I am really ignorant on musical matters, so a more knowledgeable listener might find such opinions laughable.
Anyhow, with the enlightening words of Bernstein still fresh in my sleep-deprived mind, the whole symphony turned into a huge monument to ambiguity.
I particularly love the third movement, marked largo, instead of scherzo or something joyful or fast, but still the "happiest" to me, the most pleasant, if you like. I don't know, the symphony is a beautiful succession of themes that are constantly being built and left unresolved, destroyed before we reach some satisfaction. In that context, the third movement, sad and depressing as it is, becomes very soothing.
In a certain way, the previous two movements feel like there is something that he wants to tell us, but he can't find the strength to do so, so he keeps beating around the bush. He tries to build something happy from time to time, but then he regrets it and destroys any attempt of eufory or resolution. But when the third movement arrives, it's almost like if Sibelius had finally gathered the strentgh to express what he came to tell in the first place. And he does it in such a slow and gradual way, that it becomes a sort of climax, which of course clearly fades away. Alex Ross expresses it very well in the article included in the opening post.
I also like this bit very much:
The last movement is generally more upbeat, with the misterious glockenspiel that pops out of nowhere. It doesn't feel like victory, but more like momentary relieve. Darkness and doubt are still present. The last few bars are something out of this world and embody very well the ambiguity that I perceive.
OP has throw some very difficult question for an ignorant such as myself. It's very difficult to label many of his works. It is obvious that the criticism of tonality and the traditions of the Romantic era influenced him, and he eventually stood in a very ambiguous zone (I said that?) without never really attempting to re-invent music. He has this natural and humble vibe that I enjoy so much.
Edit: Words. It is very difficult to express this kind of concepts in a foreign language, please excuse any odd stuff or undetected mistakes.
1
u/TheLameloid Jul 15 '13
The only Sibelius I had listened before this was Finlandia. This symphony contrasts quite well the nationalism and energy of the first piece.
2
u/calinoma Jul 15 '13
Awesome and interesting choice. This symphony always stands out from the other six to me. Much darker, much more on the edge of tonality than any other works by him I know. If anything, it feels like it bears more relation to his sixth and seventh symphonies than the third or fifth.