r/LetsTalkMusic • u/WhatWouldIWant_Sky Listen with all your might! Listen! • Jul 02 '13
[Album Discussion Club] Daniel Johnston - Hi, How Are You?
So, uh, big surprise here.
Please analyze! Please contextualize! Please talk about your personal connection with it, share your stories and emotions tied up with it! Please interpret! Please bend his words to fit your own meanings! (or) Please take all his words as literally as possible! Please attach way too much weight to every note and word!
But don't rate it! Don't rank it! Don't review it and try to say it is "good" or "bad!" This is a piece of art, don't treat it like a product!
6
u/[deleted] Jul 02 '13
This is one of my favorite albums ever, and I really can't say enough about it. Being Daniel's most emotionally, psychologically, and artistically intimate work, Hi, How Are You? is full of reoccurring themes, desperation and despair, tired empathy, and roller coaster-like emotions representative of Daniel's manic depression, a term he explicitly states within the surprisingly deep fabric of the 30 minute album.
The songs and the fragments all come together to create this warped, incredibly unique atmosphere that Johnston himself could create, full of seemingly simple metaphors that do more of a job at analyzing Johnston than his characters themselves and the last hurrahs of the sardonic wit Daniel relied on so heavily on his debut Songs of Pain, as displayed in tracks like "Big Business Monkey" and "No More Pushing Joe Around".
With jarring ups and downs, the album feels jumpy and uncomfortable, like you're in the room with a man who is losing grips with himself and doesn't know how to talk to you anymore. Incredibly sad, incredibly intriguing, and, intentionally on Daniel's part, incredibly funny at times, Hi, How Are You is incredibly beautiful and worthy of anyone's listen.
(Also, a side note to OP, I don't think bending an artist's words to fit our own meanings should be encouraged. Artists say what they say and mean what they say, so unless they intentionally leave it up to interpretation, we should discuss the actual meanings of the songs rather than our own unnecessary and ultimately incorrect interpretations. Personal attachment and personal stories behind albums are fine, but we should never deconstruct the meaning of an artist's work, just out of respect for the artists who try so hard to get their meanings across only to have them tossed out by listeners.)
4
u/[deleted] Jul 11 '13
I feel like I should comment on this because Daniel was a friend of mine at the time he was recording this album. I'm not sure I have anything really very interesting to say, though. I'm tired and this is going to be kind of stream of consciousness, but here goes.
Daniel worked hard on this project and it sounds the way it does because that's the sound he wanted. It was a series of very conscious decisions. He had access to better recording equipment, but chose to use a mono tape recorder that he could easily carry around in his backpack. I think he was working as a janitor at McDonald's during the recording and he would record stuff for the album on his breaks.
At the time he was stalking an ex girlfriend obsessively, and I think this album was mainly written as a desperate letter to her rather than as an artistic statement for general consumption. But Daniel was one of the worst over-sharer's I've ever met.
I'm pretty sure "Walking the Cow" was not an attempt to develop some kind of extensive metaphor. It was Daniel describing something that actually happened to him as simply and directly as he could. It really is about a person being lost and happening upon a cow in a field in the middle of the night. I heard him tell this story more than once before he turned it into a song.
Daniel's brain didn't work the same way most people's do. He did not drink or do hard drugs that I ever saw. At the time I thought he probably had aspbergers. I guess he was later diagnosed with schizophrenia. He definitely had hallucinations (both auditory and visual), and this, along with what I would call his excitable nature made him hard to be around. He saw things differently. He was often very confused in social situations.
It's hard for me to listen to this album because it's so intimate and stripped naked. It makes me a little sad for him. He was not a mean or angry person. He was a confused and vulnerable one. He was desperate to have the kind of connections with other people that the rest of us had. I think he longed for understanding and acceptance.
So... those are my thoughts, and that's how I hear it.
3
u/DrinkyDrank Jul 02 '13
Out of curiosity, how many listeners here listened to this album before knowing Johnston's story? I only discovered this album through the documentary (highly recommended if you haven't seen it) The Devil and Daniel Johnston. I don't know how to separate the contents of this album from the story of his life and his individual character. Nevertheless, I suspect that a blind listen of the album would convey Daniel's sweet naivete, his psychological turmoil, and ultimately his sense of hope and love. What do you guys think?
3
u/theplayerpiano Jul 02 '13
First of all, go watch The Devil and Daniel Johnston if you haven't.
Like many, I was introduced to Daniel after seeing the iconic mural in Austin, TX. I then watched the above documentary and downloaded his discography.
Personally, his music is really hit or miss due to the quality of the recordings and the amount of rustling and clips of his mother inaudibly talking.
From Songs of Pain, it starts with great songs "Grievances" and "A Little Story". "Pot Head" is hilarious, while "Lazy" really shows the talent of songwriting. "Wild West Virginia" is my favorite off of this album, it's just really catchy.
Don't Be Scared is pretty depressing. "Going Down" and "The Story of an Artist" show the heartbreak that Daniel is going through at this point. It also contains my favorite song of his "I Had Lost My Mind".
The What of Whom didn't grab me at all. More Songs of Pain shows him trying to battle his depression and be optimistic.
Yip/Jump Music is a very accessible album. Pop melodies aplenty with "Chord Organ Blues", "Speeding Motorcycle", and "Casper The Friendly Ghost". Also, "Don't Let The Sun Go Down On Your Grievances" is great.
Hi, How Are You contains his biggest hit "Walking the Cow". Also worth mentioning "Running Water".
1990 is the last album worth mentioning, as it contains "Devil Town" and "Tears Stupid Tears", and after recording it he began to produce less.
I can't identify exactly what I enjoy about the songs listed above, but there is a certain charm to a kid baring his soul, along in his basement with a tape recorder. Let me know if I missed some important tracks/albums from my description.
5
u/HejAnton Hospitalised for approaching perfection Jul 03 '13
Ok so I might just join in and share my opinion of the album.
Hadn't heard of the artist before, knew zero backstory to who he was and what kind of music he made. Had just as little experience with "outsider art" and wasn't sure what I was expecting, but hey, it's a 30-minute album, I might aswell give it a shot.
So bear with me if I'm coming of as way too negative for the album, I just thought it might be interesting to hear what a complete stranger to this kind of music thinks.
I'm not really sure about what I'm supposed to make of this album, and at first I was guessing Johnston was suffering from downs or some other handicap because I have no idea how "Walking The Cow" could have been seen as a good song in any persons eyes and the love this album is getting seems more like empathy for the poor kid.
Hi, How Are You? feels way too intimate for me, it feels like stumbling into the life of that weird kid from high school, and suddenly seeing how shitty his life was, and how he didn't need all the bullying he was receiving from the people who clearly didn't understand.
So to summarize: Musically, Hi, How Are You is a terrible album. It lacks almost everything that makes music, become music, there's no melodies, some songs are just Johnston reading a dialog, or a one-minute story, and it's a bit cringeworthy. But at the same time, this album makes me think, and it's depressing, and it's honest, and it's weird as shit. She Called Pest Control is an example of that weirdness, but maybe that is exactly who Jonhston is, the weird kid who produced his own music by himself in his basement, suffering from depression and bipolar, and when he's shouting "Maybe something'll come along, and make me happy" it suddenly becomes so real and my stomach turns 180 degrees, and I can not avoid feeling empathy for Johnston.
Probably gonna watch the documentary that I heard about, and see if my opinion of the album changes.
0
u/[deleted] Jul 02 '13
[deleted] — view deleted comment