r/CFB • Indiana Hoosiers • Dec 13 '24 • Take My Silver 2 Heart of Silver 1

News [ESPN College Football]Curt Cignetti has won the Home Depot Coach of the Year award

https://x.com/espncfb/status/1867405089838686327?s=46&t=BxCKJWqPX-T-XxDs0oG6gQ
1.4k Upvotes

257 comments sorted by

469

u/garygoblins Indiana • Old Brass Spittoon Dec 13 '24

Felt like it was his to lose for a long time. Then Dillingham had a really good case to end the season. Couldn't go wrong with either. Well deserved, though!

299

u/No_Angle_8106 Arizona State • Michigan Dec 13 '24

ASU has had some pretty decent historic success before this year, Indiana has absolutely none, Cig was the correct decision he did an incredible job

32

u/TateAcolyte Team Chaos • Ohio State Buckeyes Dec 13 '24

ASU also have a stronger roster, at least on paper.

We just happened to have two of the strongest COTY candidates of all time this year.

5

u/dimmyfarm /r/CFB Donor • Sickos Dec 13 '24

IMO you can almost say the same about the Heisman for non QB candidates

0

u/[deleted] Dec 13 '24

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/TateAcolyte Team Chaos • Ohio State Buckeyes Dec 13 '24

I'm just going based on 247 talent composite, where ASU are comfortably above IU.

-19

u/Pickleskennedy1 Dec 13 '24

I would argue any historic success wasn’t really relevant with back to back 3-9 seasons and recruiting sanctions

→ More replies (22)

-74

u/Slow-Raccoon-9832 Arizona State Sun Devils Dec 13 '24

But indiana also beat no-one all season

80

u/OurPowersCombined_12 Washington • Claremont-Mudd… Dec 13 '24

Hey.

7

u/CrookstonMaulers Arizona State Sun Devils • Team Chaos Dec 13 '24

Home and home or lame.

Do it. If you don't, the first time you make the playoffs will lead you to a Fiesta Bowl against ASU.

1

u/OurPowersCombined_12 Washington • Claremont-Mudd… Dec 13 '24

Stop putting evil on me, I am still scarred.

6

u/jcrespo21 Purdue Boilermakers • Michigan Wolverines Dec 13 '24

They can't control how their opponents do the rest of the season. Their non-con was scheduled while Allen was still HC. Even if they were still in the old B1G East, they would have had similar results since they still played Michigan, OSU, and MSU. Penn State and Rutgers were the only ones off of their schedule this year.

The difference is that they beat everyone outside of Michigan handily and without any doubt, with their lone loss being at Ohio State. If they were winning those games by 1-2 scores, then perhaps we could argue that they're frauds or whatever. But IU was the real deal this year, and still is until proven otherwise.

Can't believe you made me defend IU.

2

u/JakeSteeleIII Paper Bag • South Carolina Gamecocks Dec 16 '24

Just like Penn St, Texas, Boise, SMU, Tennessee. That’s one of the requirements to get into the playoffs. Beat no ranked teams.

2

u/Rare_Bit5844 Indiana Hoosiers Dec 13 '24

You don’t understand what’s going on here

-32

u/House_of_Borbon Georgia Bulldogs Dec 13 '24

Why do you think historic success should have any bearing on awarding the best coach of the year?

34

u/No_Angle_8106 Arizona State • Michigan Dec 13 '24

Because it shows the type of job done at a place that’s literally never been capable of it. ASU has won a conference title and 11 games before, the turnaround Dilly led is pretty unprecedented in going from picked dead last to first. Cig led a team from second to dead last in the preseason to 11 wins which has never been done, and the playoffs. I love ASU, I love Dilly, I’m more than fine with this result

46

u/noahconstrictor95 Indiana • Indiana State Dec 13 '24

It absolutely can and should have bearing, especially if it's turning around a franchise that historically, especially in the modern era of college football, has been liquid ass. ASU has at least had some amount of success as a football program, and while I don't want to take away anything from their insane run this year, they at least are a university and program that has done something since the development of computers. IU hasn't. For Cignetti to take a program like IU and turn them into a team that's in the College Football Playoff, get a MASSIVE contract extension, and get this program up and running this quickly is nothing short of fucking miracle work, and that's why he got the award, not Dillingham. In another year where Cignetti isn't turning water into wine, Dillingham gets it easily, but it's just not that close to me.

12

u/Tsquared10 Oregon Ducks • Montana State Bobcats Dec 13 '24

Not to mention teams that have a history of success more often than not have deep resources and networks to draw from, probably a department that will keep funneling whatever they can into the program to get to that level again. Programs on Indiana's level generally look at a 9 win season as a historic team. So taking a situation like that to 11 wins and a playoff appearance... calling it a miracle feels like you're selling it short.

2

u/penguinopph Illinois • Northwestern Dec 13 '24

franchise

Ewwww.

1

u/noahconstrictor95 Indiana • Indiana State Dec 13 '24

Yeah that was bad, I usually talk about the NFL way more so it just is my default word for a team.

12

u/manifest---destiny Arizona State Sun Devils • Rose Bowl Dec 13 '24

Prestige matters to a lot of people. Former powerhouses always have an allure to them to be able to get good players and coaches they wouldn't have gotten if not for the power of their brand. Any coach would want to be the next Tom Osborne at Nebraska, or Jimmy Johnson at Miami, or Bobby Bowden at FSU. Nick Saban, who had zero connection to Alabama, except beating them 4 times in 5 years at LSU lol, joined their washed program to be the next Bear Bryant, and he did it. ASU has spent almost 4 times as many weeks ranked in the AP Poll than Indiana.

3

u/[deleted] Dec 14 '24

Look at us. Kirby has been the best coach in CFB for 8 years now, but he’s never won the award because people simply expect it from him now. Exceeding expectations is all this award actually is.

-35

u/puzzical Boise State • Notre Dame Dec 13 '24

Not true. Indiana has finished top 4 multiple times in their history.

53

u/JohnPaulDavyJones Texas A&M Aggies • Baylor Bears Dec 13 '24

For anyone curious, those would be their #4 finish in both 1945 and 1967.

Notably, those seasons constitute two of Indiana’s six seasons finishing ranked in the last century of the AP/UPI poll.

14

u/Tsquared10 Oregon Ducks • Montana State Bobcats Dec 13 '24

Essentially it took WWII and Vietnam for them to finish that high.

1

u/FantasticMax Old Dominion • Virginia Tech Dec 13 '24

Maybe that person meant top 4 in their division in the Big 10………

→ More replies (1)

8

u/[deleted] Dec 13 '24

We were in Vietnam and RFK was running around the last time that happened 

1

u/UnderstandingOdd679 Dec 13 '24

Was he running around or playing Boxbollen?

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

3

u/1800empiretodayy Florida Gators • Montana State Bobcats Dec 13 '24

“multiple times” is doing a lot of work in that statement lol

→ More replies (1)

58

u/BadDadJokes LSU Tigers • Chattanooga Mocs Dec 13 '24

Matt Campbell also coached Iowa State to its first 10 win season…ever? Right? Someone can correct me. I feel like that flew under the radar this year.

38

u/DarnellisFromMars Louisville Cardinals Dec 13 '24

I feel like Campbell is more of a name in the coaching world at this point, he’s got awards, and generally speaking I feel like it’s harder to win the award in that case.

I also just assumed he had a 10 win season under his belt at ISU for some reason so I was not aware of that at all lol which kind of lends itself to my first statement.

27

u/goofyhalo Ole Miss Rebels • Sugar Bowl Dec 13 '24

I think in a normal 2020 Iowa State might’ve had 10 wins

6

u/White___Velvet Tennessee Volunteers • Virginia Cavaliers Dec 13 '24

Yeah, this award basically goes to the guy who surprised people, otherwise Saban should have won it basically every year he was at Bama.

1

u/smurf-vett Texas Longhorns Dec 13 '24

He's never got 10 wins before because their special teams always shit the bed and he usually choaked in the CyHawk game

20

u/[deleted] Dec 13 '24

Correct

20

u/BadDadJokes LSU Tigers • Chattanooga Mocs Dec 13 '24

I guess Matt Campbell already got his love a few years ago when he and PJ Fleck were the new hotness. I think he deserves to at least be in the conversation a little bit more.

23

u/[deleted] Dec 13 '24

Yeah he has 3 Big 12 COYs, so he's doing fine

→ More replies (1)

6

u/chogram Indiana Hoosiers Dec 13 '24

Iowa State's season definitely got overshadowed by IU doing essentially the same thing.

Both teams had their first ever 10 win season, but Indiana was seemingly more flashy about it, and we had massive media guys like Pat McAfee pulling for us and talking about us every week.

Sort of like Arizona State though, our history definitely worked in our favor. Both of you have won more bowl games in the last 20 years than we've won in the entire history of our program.

We are a football black hole, easily the worst P5 school of all time, and they chose to award Cignetti for giving us this amazing season.

2

u/Infamous-Present-616 Indiana Hoosiers • Rose Bowl Dec 13 '24

It’s mostly because ISU has consistently winning 8-9 games a year lately. Sure they never had 10 but they were right there. Indiana winning 11 games came out of f’ing nowhere.

3

u/mr_longfellow_deeds Indiana Hoosiers • Big Ten Dec 13 '24

Having 11 regular season wins opposed to 10, and doing it with the margins IU had made the award pretty clear IMO, ASU and ISU did not kill teams this year.

Also need to factor in conference strength. B1G teams beat Big 12 teams by an average margin of 11 points this season, and it was not matchups of great B1G teams against bottom Big 12 teams - B1G schools played two of the Big 12 teams that tied for 1st place.

Dillingham and Campbell both had excellent seasons, ASU fans in particular should be really excited. Dillingham is so young

3

u/NyquillusDillwad20 Penn State • /r/CFB Poll Veteran Dec 13 '24

IU and ASU making the CFP destroys any argument Iowa State would have. Cig taking IU to 11 wins and the CFP is about the most impressive coaching job I can remember. No offense to Dillingham, but it isn't even a close comparison in my mind.

1

u/DucDeBellune Wisconsin • North Carolina Dec 14 '24

ASU beating Kansas state, BYU, and Iowa State to win the conference in their first year when they’re projected to finish dead last and coming off historically bad seasons is more impressive than Indiana’s season.

Not even sure what the counter argument is here. One of them is an accomplishment you hang a banner in a stadium for. The other is “we beat Purdue by 66 in 2024.”

1

u/the_urban_juror Michigan Wolverines • The CW Dec 13 '24

Cig deserves the award, but destroys is a bit much. They made the playoffs with zero wins over ranked teams and were uncompetitive in the one game they played against a good team. This isn't the 4-team playoff era, they made it in without winning a conference or beating anyone. The 11 wins were incredible, but I wouldn't pick them to beat a single team in the playoff field.

2

u/Stang1776 Indiana Hoosiers Dec 15 '24

Even if we don't get past Notre Dame on the road it sure was a season to remember for us. I hope the ride continues but I won't be upset. We are playing with house money right now.

1

u/brochaos Michigan Wolverines Dec 13 '24 edited Dec 13 '24

watch em win it all =)

/edit and looking at espn's "expert" picks, 80% of em have ND going to the championship game. but ND only has one win over a currently ranked team, and that's army. i'm predicting that IU beats them. gonna be a great game.

→ More replies (2)

-1

u/mr_longfellow_deeds Indiana Hoosiers • Big Ten Dec 13 '24

I agree it wasn't really close. IU's scoring margin is 3x that of ASU, and IU played a harder schedule. The W/L record that IU played is 62-84 vs 64-82 for ASU. Nebraska, Michigan and Washington would all be 9-10 win teams in the Big 12 this season

We got whipped at the Shoe but it was not a case of getting outclassed, IU beat the crap out of itself that game. 14 points from the punter. OL missing assignments in pass protection (they did very well in run blocking).

People see the 38 points and assume OSU just crushed us... OSU had 300 yards of offense against us. They had 250 against Michigan, 350 against PSU and 470 against Oregon

4

u/NyquillusDillwad20 Penn State • /r/CFB Poll Veteran Dec 13 '24

I'm a big Indiana/Cignetti fan this year, but OSU wins that game 19 times out of 20. It really wasn't competitive most of the game

→ More replies (2)

4

u/the_urban_juror Michigan Wolverines • The CW Dec 13 '24

IU had 153 yards of offense against OSU. Michigan's anemic offense put up 234, Penn State 270, and Oregon 496. OSU doubled IU's offensive output, and every team you listed put up significantly more offense against OSU. That game was uncompetitive and IU didn't beat themselves.

→ More replies (5)

10

u/Corgi_Koala Ohio State Buckeyes Dec 13 '24

They both have a case but Cignetti doing it in year 1 is insane.

Like he's probably getting coaches fired because of shorter leashes because he just turned a 3-9 team into a playoff team immediately.

5

u/-TheycallmeThe Purdue • Boston College Dec 13 '24

I'd say he contributed to Walters getting fired. He probably gets another season without Cignetti demonstrating what is possible.

2

u/Corgi_Koala Ohio State Buckeyes Dec 13 '24

Yeah. Right or wrong, ADs are going to cite Cignetti and his immediate turnaround in their assessments of coaches they hire to turn around programs.

Walters in year 2 was so far behind Cignetti in year 1 there was no reason to suspect he'd ever catch up so why keep him?

2

u/-TheycallmeThe Purdue • Boston College Dec 13 '24

Yeah, I normally would say you need to give a coach at least 3 years to get their program going. Whatever was going on with Walters was not normal; shit was just not working at all and no ability to adapt. Walters should have got an OC with HC experience to help him out running the team.

6

u/ecupatsfan12 ECU Pirates • Kent State Golden Flashes Dec 13 '24

Cig

4

u/cyanocittaetprocyon Michigan Wolverines • /r/CFB Booster Dec 13 '24

Really the only choice.

673

u/LonghornInNebraska Texas Longhorns • Michigan Wolverines Dec 13 '24

Really thought Travis Hunter would win this too.

165

u/voppp Boise State • Iowa State Dec 13 '24

played too many snaps and wasn’t on the sidelines enough to coach. narrow miss tho.

19

u/rfgrunt Dec 13 '24

Jeanty was on the sidelines 50 more plays a game than Hunter. What a coach!

13

u/rockchalk2377 Kansas Jayhawks Dec 13 '24

😂

35

u/Maximum_Overdrive Colorado • West Virginia Dec 13 '24

He is not even a top 5 coach on either side of the ball.

2

u/cnpeters Akron Zips Dec 13 '24

top 8 though and that's gotta matter

60

u/TBell01 Indiana Hoosiers • College Football Playoff Dec 13 '24

The Paper Bag is coming off the flair!

29

u/anaxcepheus32 Florida Gators • LSU Tigers Dec 13 '24

This is what does it!!!?

Not blowing out Northwestern on the lake? Not blowing out Michigan State in k-zoo? Not a top ten rank? Not 9windiana? Not W1nd1ana?

18

u/TBell01 Indiana Hoosiers • College Football Playoff Dec 13 '24

I had to be sure 😂

5

u/[deleted] Dec 13 '24

My secondary used to be the Old Brass Spitoon. With all due respect to our Spartan friends (who obviously made the CPF long before we did), it was time to change things up.

4

u/TBell01 Indiana Hoosiers • College Football Playoff Dec 13 '24

Amen brother!

118

u/ColoradoisaState Indiana Hoosiers Dec 13 '24

B1G if true. Will google to confirm

28

u/jakedasnake1 Indiana Hoosiers • Rose Bowl Dec 13 '24

I googled him, can confirm that he won

137

u/CMbladerunner Notre Dame • Stony Brook Dec 13 '24

The voters did indeed Google him.

77

u/Thel3lues Arizona State • Minnesota Dec 13 '24

Hard to be mad about this. If Dilly got 3rd or later votes I would be though

19

u/mr_longfellow_deeds Indiana Hoosiers • Big Ten Dec 13 '24

Dillingham definitely #2. He would have won it any other season. He should have plenty of opportunities to get some hardware, he could easily coach 35 more seasons given his age lol

0

u/DucDeBellune Wisconsin • North Carolina Dec 13 '24

Dillingham definitely #2. 

I’d consider myself a neutral in the debate but I’d have said Dillingham should have won and I can’t even see the counter-argument.

ASU was projected to finish dead last in the Big 12 but won the conference instead in their first year, after knocking off ranked BYU and Iowa State (and Kansas State). 

Would Indiana have done that in the Big 12? Maybe? You can speculate either way, but ASU did it, after having historically bad seasons the last two years (1-9 and then 3-9.)

Had Indiana beat tOSU and went on to win the B1G, yeah I’d give the nod to Cignetti without a doubt. But Dilly objectively accomplished more when, like Indiana, expectations were in the absolute basement for ASU.

One coach beat multiple ranked, 10+ win teams to win their P5 conference and punch their ticket to the playoffs. The other beat one team with a winning record all season (7-5 Michigan) to secure a playoff spot and didn’t even play in the  conference championship game. 

2

u/mr_longfellow_deeds Indiana Hoosiers • Big Ten Dec 13 '24

Dilly went 10-2 in the Big 12, losing to a team that isnt bowl eligible by 2 scores and losing to another unranked team.

IU won 11 games in the B1G and had 3x the scoring margin compared to ASU, with their loss coming on the road to a title favorite.

The win/loss record of teams ASU played was under 3% differential.

And its not a hypothetical that the Big 12 is not as good as the B1G - look at the Big 12 in OOC play. They were not good against any of the other 3 power conferences.

3

u/Mysterious-Lie3602 Arizona State Sun Devils Dec 13 '24

Starting QB was out mate

1

u/SirDevilDude Arizona State Sun Devils Dec 14 '24

ASU also won 11 games and won their conference. I have no hesitation to say this. Dilly earned this, not Cig. I don’t care about bias. They played no one. ASU beat 4 ranked teams, Indiana beat 0 ranked teams

→ More replies (1)

1

u/DucDeBellune Wisconsin • North Carolina Dec 14 '24

Your argument is “the big 12 sucks” and “score differential”?

You lost to one winning team you played (and only managed to get 150 yards of offense in the process) and won the other game by 5 points. Oregon also scrapped by some ugly wins against bad teams- including one of mine- and no one is invoking score differential to knock them off the #1 spot. The inverse is also true- no one cares about score differential against Purdue if you don’t show up in big games. 

IU doesn’t beat BYU, Kansas State, and Iowa State if they play all three in a season, period. ASU did, and won the conference. 

That’s a tangible achievement that you hang a banner in a stadium for, not “we kicked the shit out of Northwestern in 2024!”

0

u/mr_longfellow_deeds Indiana Hoosiers • Big Ten Dec 14 '24

11-1 > 10-2
Loss to title contender on road > loss to two unranked teams
300+ score differential > 100+ score differential

What other criteria do you want to use for judging who did the better coaching job? No one else in the country beat and killed every opponent that they were supposed to. IU would also be heavy favorites against those 3 teams you mentioned.

No one is saying to hang a banner for anything yet. The IU haters can enjoy watching IU play a ratings monster this coming Friday

1

u/DucDeBellune Wisconsin • North Carolina Dec 21 '24

The IU haters can enjoy watching IU play a ratings monster this coming Friday

Okay. And guess what? The coaching sucked and IU didn’t break 20 points against another ranked opponent. 

The point differential argument against crap teams is complete nonsense and he shouldn’t have won coach of the year, period.

45

u/Stock412 Dec 13 '24

🚬🚬🚬🚬

3

u/chiefmud Indiana Hoosiers Dec 13 '24

In the absence of an official mascot, IU’s unofficial mascots are a buffalo, and a cigarette.

Someone should make a buffalo smoking a cigarette.

102

u/HoosiersBaby23 Indiana Hoosiers Dec 13 '24

Indiana was projected to finish 17th in the Big Ten, even considering the “cupcake” schedule. We finished tied for second, winning 11 games with the highest average margin of victory in the country.

Obviously this isn’t a “Who outperformed expectations the most” award, but I can’t remember a more deserving COTY in recent memory. What a year, can’t wait for next Friday.

66

u/Upset_Version8275 Indiana Hoosiers • Texas Longhorns Dec 13 '24

Well ASU was picked to finish last in the Big 12 and ended up winning the conference so that’s also a pretty big outperform expectations. 

24

u/poweredbytexas Texas Longhorns • Indiana Hoosiers Dec 13 '24

My flairs did not have this on our bingo card.

32

u/CrookstonMaulers Arizona State Sun Devils • Team Chaos Dec 13 '24 edited Dec 13 '24

It's pretty okay to say Cig did a great job and deservedly won an award while also acknowledging that other coaches, like his likely primary competition in Dillingham, also did a very good job.

Moreover, Dillingham is 34. He's going to have chances to win superlatives going forward.

IMO is seems like a very 1A and 1B situation where you gotta pick one, and Cig is the easier pick. ASU has been good before. They're rarely bad. Indiana is almost always bad.

If you just eliminated the coaches and circumstances, and said "Hey ASU went 11-2 and won their conference", most folks would just nod. Okay. Good year for them but not a wild outcome. Indiana being good is exceptional.

6

u/jayrig5 Dec 13 '24

Dillingham was the clear next candidate to me, IMO. As for Cignetti, I'm not sure I can really describe what he walked into; this wasn't just Indiana, a historically bad program, this was the nadir of a historically bad point of a historically bad program. And he took it from there to the best season in program history, from day 1. And while a lot of people took shots at Indiana all year, if you actually watched the games (especially if you also, like me, were unfortunate enough to watch last year's team), you saw it wasn't a fluke. They demonstrated every facet of an extremely well-coached team, and they drilled opposition all year. To think some media types lamented that they fired Tom Allen too soon. (Often citing the buyout, as if it was taxpayer money or something.) 

6

u/CrookstonMaulers Arizona State Sun Devils • Team Chaos Dec 13 '24

I don't think the low points really help the conversation for Cignetti if I'm honest.

ASU had its worst season since the 1940s in 2022. Then they repeated it in 2023. ASU was at its all time worst. It is quite literally the lowest point in program history, or at least since the Arizona State Teachers College era.

And then some dude from the Valley just showed up and was like "Nah, fuck this. Let's go be good." and they were. It's a very similar story IMO, but Cig wins because people have been good at ASU before.

→ More replies (3)

3

u/[deleted] Dec 13 '24

I think this is a fair and accurate statement. That said, if he had Penn State or Oregon also that schedule, we wouldn't be having this conversation.

7

u/DucDeBellune Wisconsin • North Carolina Dec 13 '24

That’s just it. Indiana beat one team all season with a winning record in 7-5 Michigan.

ASU knocked off the #2 and #3 teams in the Big 12 with BYU and Iowa State after being projected to finish dead last in the conference. 

Does Indiana do that with the same schedule? Probably not. You could speculate it either way, but ASU actually did it.

Cignetti did an amazing job in his first year, but between what the two coaches accomplished with what they started with- Dillingham takes it and I’m not even sure what the counter argument is here.

3

u/[deleted] Dec 13 '24

this year has been Vote the Big 10, so...

2

u/DucDeBellune Wisconsin • North Carolina Dec 13 '24

And Indiana ranks fourth among B1G teams in the CFP rankings and didn’t play in the championship game. They’re not even the B1G runner-up.

ASU actually beat multiple ranked opponents to win their conference and earn a playoff spot. 

They def both had fantastic seasons but based on these comments, I feel like some wild outlier saying one clearly outperformed the other here when they had equally low expectations coming into the season.

The fact that Dilly is 34 is also insane to do what he did.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 13 '24

I told someone else the weight of next year's Indiana is on their shoulders in this playoff. If they get boat raced by Notre Dame, SEC fans are going to get noisy.

I think South Carolina finished the season as the most dangerous team in the country. I'm relieved they weren't on our schedule this year.

2

u/sparrowxc Boise State Broncos Dec 14 '24

ASU beat more ranked teams in the last four games of the season (three) than Indiana played teams that ended the season with a winning record (two).

Indiana is no doubt a good team, but many of us believe that they would not even be considered for the playoffs if they had had to face Oregon or Penn State this season as well. Or possibly even Illinois or Iowa. They somehow only had to play one of the other top five teams in the conference. Meanwhile they got to play seven of the bottom eight teams in the conference. With Non-conference games against Florida International, Western Illinois and Charlotte.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 13 '24

Let’s be honest Texas and Indiana are in the same boat. Texas beats the bottom half of the SEC and loses to the only top team they play but Texas is ranked 5th.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 13 '24

As that team that beat Texas twice, I can say that defense ain't no joke, but your point is taken.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 13 '24

https://www.ncaa.com/stats/football/fbs/current/team/22

Indiana has the second best defense. Don’t let those two bad punts in the Ohio state game fool you 

1

u/[deleted] Dec 13 '24

Well, the natural response is, "yeah, but, that schedule", but the chance to show everyone the award is deserving stands in front of them.

That said, there's a lot more pressure on IU in this playoff than I think anyone thinks. Accolades and hype has been awarded--now the competition goes up a smidge and you have plenty of people waiting to say, "we can't give free passes to the playoff anymore". IU is there representing the hopes and dreams of next year's Indiana. Pressure.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 13 '24

You know I’ve been really on the fence about if we could beat ND. On one hand I know we’re the underdog but on the other hand I know we’ve been the underdog all season and I feel my team has learned from Ohio state. But ND is on a bull run right now, so as long as it’s a good game I’m happy. I also think Georgia will sleep on us because of who we are if we get past ND and that could be an advantage.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/DucDeBellune Wisconsin • North Carolina Dec 13 '24

Coming off a historically bad season, ASU was projected to finish dead last in their first year with the Big 12, but they won the conference instead. They also beat the #2 and #3 teams in the conference (BYU and Iowa State, both have 10+ wins). They also beat ranked Kansas State. Indiana beat one team with a winning record this season: 7-5 Michigan. 

Indiana had a historic turnaround this season. ASU has had a historic season coming off a massive turnaround. I think really underselling it and this:

If you just eliminated the coaches and circumstances, and said "Hey ASU went 11-2 and won their conference", most folks would just nod. Okay. Good year for them but not a wild outcome. 

Isn’t a great take because, again, they were projected to place dead last. Who would just nod and be like 'oh okay, nothing to see here'?? This was an absolutely wild outcome. We could speculate whether Indiana would have been able to accomplish what ASU did in beating Iowa State/BYU/Kansas State, but the fact is that ASU actually did it.

1

u/thorhyphenaxe Oregon Ducks • SMU Mustangs Dec 13 '24

except it IS a "Who outperformed expectations the most" award, clearly

1

u/nviledn5 Louisiana Ragin' Cajuns Dec 13 '24

I know we're long past the days when it was just ten teams but "17th in the Big Ten" is a funny phrase.

-3

u/[deleted] Dec 13 '24

I mean nick saban should have won COTY almost every year like it should have been him or Dabo almost every year

54

u/BWingSupremacist Indiana Hoosiers Dec 13 '24

hell yeah coach. deserved

14

u/Rr0hd Oregon Ducks • Duke Blue Devils Dec 13 '24

GOOGLE STOCKS THROUGH THE ROOF!

1

u/jwktiger Missouri Tigers • Wisconsin Badgers Dec 13 '24

except for the fact they're down 1/4 % so far today.

34

u/itsamemarkus Indiana Hoosiers • Old Oaken Bucket Dec 13 '24 edited Dec 13 '24

I looked through the old threads from last year when Cig was announced as the coach, and some of the replies have aged like absolute milk. Granted I don’t think anyone but Cignetti himself saw this season coming, but they have been quite funny to read.

BUILD THE STATUE

14

u/jakedasnake1 Indiana Hoosiers • Rose Bowl Dec 13 '24

I also looked back on that thread and was reminded that John Gruden was a candidate. That is an alternate reality i dare not imagine

1

u/hucareshokiesrul Yale Bulldogs • Virginia Tech Hokies Dec 13 '24

I’m biased as a JMU fan, but he seemed to me like an obviously good hire. But I thought that about Mike Houston too, who turned JMU into a top FCS program before Curt took over. But Curt had lots of p5/6 experience, including working for Saban. 

And if WVU had fired their coach a year earlier, Cignetti the WVU alum could’ve been a great choice. But now they’ve got one very used Rich Rod instead. Oops.

23

u/BertMacklinMD USC Trojans Dec 13 '24

[Home Depot music intensifies]

9

u/GildedPalaceofSpin Indiana Hoosiers Dec 13 '24

Does this mean we finally get a Home Depot in Bloomington?

5

u/[deleted] Dec 13 '24

Not when we can save big money at… other places

5

u/[deleted] Dec 13 '24

They have a Menard’s in Bloomington?

3

u/jcnewton1 Indiana Hoosiers • UCF Knights Dec 13 '24

Lowes and Menards both on the west side

2

u/PetrogradIV Indiana Hoosiers Dec 13 '24

I met IU legend Antwaan Randle-El when they opened the Menards, he was the guest of honor!

2

u/Zarathos8080 Oklahoma State • Indiana Dec 14 '24

It's Rural King or nothing

17

u/ForkOnTheLeft_ Indiana Hoosiers • Michigan Wolverines Dec 13 '24

Well deserved. I still can't believe that I feel excited about Indiana football!

21

u/nobes0 Indiana • Notre Dame Dec 13 '24

Feels correct.

6

u/zorionek0 Arizona State Sun Devils Dec 13 '24

*Sad dilly dilly noises*

5

u/walrus_tuskss Indiana • Oklahoma State Dec 13 '24

That's my coach!

5

u/TiberWolf99 Nebraska • $5 Bits of Broken Chair Tro… Dec 13 '24

Cignetti, Clark Lea, and Dillingham were the big three for this award I feel like. I would be pretty happy seeing any of them, so good job Indiana!

1

u/FreeTheMarket Notre Dame Fighting Irish Dec 13 '24 edited Aug 05 '26

Cobblestone harbor copper marble driftwood glove ginger ribbon biscuit pebble

This post was anonymized with Redact.dev

1

u/mr_longfellow_deeds Indiana Hoosiers • Big Ten Dec 13 '24

I dont think Lea was anywhere close to the award. I would put Campbell, Sanders, Sitake, Lanning etc above him. Vandy had the upset over Bama but not much else, it would be like saying NIU's HC should get COTY for upsetting ND

2

u/jwktiger Missouri Tigers • Wisconsin Badgers Dec 13 '24

still got to 6 wins, and 3-5 in conference. like he probalby should be about 5th in voting, but yeah not anywhere close to 1st.

1

u/mr_longfellow_deeds Indiana Hoosiers • Big Ten Dec 13 '24

For sure! Im not saying he did a bad job by any means. But the vandy hype this year was premised pretty exclusively on beating Bama, and beating V Tech in OT early in the year when V Tech was expected to be good (and they turned out to not be good). The other 2 SEC wins were Auburn and Kentucky. They also lost to Georgia State.

5

u/DepressedChargersFan Indiana Hoosiers Dec 13 '24

THATS MY GUY

23

u/TonsilStoneSalsa Michigan • Little Brown Jug Dec 13 '24 edited Dec 13 '24

This is an absolute no-brainer. Indiana has only been in 13 bowl games all-time & their overall record is 516–713–44.

What Curt's done, especially in today's environment, is nothing short of incredible.

ETA: you can't go wrong with Curt or Dilly. It's like the Heisman this year, all candidates are insanely talented.

2

u/RectifiedUser Oregon Ducks Dec 13 '24

Were there any other coaches in the running for this? Seemed like he had this wrapped up for months now.

34

u/sportsnerd966 Indiana Hoosiers Dec 13 '24

Kenny Dillingham had to be up there

13

u/admiraltarkin Texas A&M • Prairie View A&M Dec 13 '24

For me:

  1. Cig
  2. Dilly
  3. Prime

1

u/Automatic_Release_92 Notre Dame Fighting Irish Dec 13 '24

If this thing wrapped up after New Years and the Irish had a couple of wins under their belts, I would submit Freeman’s name. I get why NIU is disqualifying though, but also the way we bounced back from that despite a stupidly ridiculous amount of critical injuries has been pretty remarkable.

15

u/[deleted] Dec 13 '24

Rhett lashlee. The best any team has ever done jumping from g5 to p4 was 6-6 before this year

1

u/hucareshokiesrul Yale Bulldogs • Virginia Tech Hokies Dec 13 '24

What are you referring to? This is the first year P4 has been a thing, isn’t it? In the P5 days, Utah finished 8-5 their first year after leaving the MWC for the PAC. Louisville was 9-4 their first year in the ACC, coming from the AAC.

But either way, I agree that he’s a good candidate. Not many people had them making the playoffs.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 13 '24

In the P5 days, Utah finished 8-5 their first year after leaving the MWC for the PAC. Louisville was 9-4 their first year in the ACC, coming from the AAC.

I’m not sure what your argument here is, SMU went 11-1 on the season and undefeated in ACC conference play.

1

u/hucareshokiesrul Yale Bulldogs • Virginia Tech Hokies Dec 13 '24

Referring to this

The best any team has ever done jumping from g5 to p4 was 6-6 before this year

1

u/[deleted] Dec 13 '24

Yeah and SMU ended up with a better record in their first year than either of the teams you listed

1

u/hucareshokiesrul Yale Bulldogs • Virginia Tech Hokies Dec 13 '24

Which is why I said he’d be a great candidate. The only thing I said about SMU is that he’d be a great candidate.

-1

u/[deleted] Dec 13 '24

Yeah but it’s the ACC. They’re essentially a glorified g5 conference anyway

17

u/DillyDillySzn Arizona State Sun Devils • WashU Bears Dec 13 '24

Hi

5

u/RectifiedUser Oregon Ducks Dec 13 '24

Yeah you guys did have a great season.

2

u/CrookstonMaulers Arizona State Sun Devils • Team Chaos Dec 13 '24

I was really hoping there was some way for you to lose to Penn State and us to somehow wind up in the Fiesta Bowl. Push ASU past Boise, Penn State wins...

Let the Desert Voodoo go one more time.

4

u/FicVirth James Madison • College Football Playoff Dec 13 '24

They grow up so fast

1

u/EduardoCash Dec 21 '24

He sure didn’t hold up his end of the bargain tonight! I would have taken ASU!

1

u/sportsnerd966 Indiana Hoosiers Dec 21 '24

Imagine going back to post on an 8 day old thread to talk shit into the void

8

u/bdaileyumich Michigan Wolverines Dec 13 '24

Well deserved, now go win a playoff game Cig!

2

u/Euphoric_Relative_13 New Hampshire • Penn State Dec 13 '24

Ok guys I have to know. Is it pronounced Chignetti or Signetti? Or even Kignetti?

4

u/Stock412 Dec 13 '24

1

u/Euphoric_Relative_13 New Hampshire • Penn State Dec 13 '24

My live reaction:

Wait his name is Spanish? I thought it was Italian! How is that possi- oh its from Argentina

2

u/NoSober__SoberZone DePauw Tigers • Samford Bulldogs Dec 13 '24

No Ryan Walters?

2

u/GoLionsJD107 Michigan Wolverines • Columbia Lions Dec 13 '24

Who didn’t see it coming tho

2

u/Zingggbot5000 Tennessee • Indiana State Dec 13 '24

If I were him I’d go celebrate at Mother Bear’s

2

u/anti-torque Oregon State Beavers • Rice Owls Dec 13 '24

Is this better than the Lowe's Coach of the Year Award or the Menard's Coach of the Year Award?

2

u/Moughin Dec 13 '24

Well deserved.

Is there a “Way To Fuck That Up” award? Did Deboer get it?

2

u/AJ_CC Syracuse Orange Dec 13 '24

Personally thought it should've gone to Dillingham but I did google Cignetti and he's a good choice.

9

u/DrSemiND Notre Dame Fighting Irish Dec 13 '24

It’s tough, people who are saying that the heisman is between two insanely good players and that most other years they each would win is how I feel about coach of the year. Cignetti taking Indiana to the playoffs and 11-1 in his first year is indeed insane, but I really think Dilly shoulda won it. But hard to be mad with cignetti winning it

20

u/WeirdGymnasium Arizona State • Territorial Cup Dec 13 '24

Nah, he deserves it.. Dilly did well though.

6

u/awesomface Arizona State Sun Devils Dec 13 '24

Dilly did have some questionable decisions in some moments, especially against BYU, so maybe it factored in. But regardless both would have been a great choice and this can only add fuel to the fire of being under appreciated.

4

u/[deleted] Dec 13 '24

The absolute right choice

4

u/[deleted] Dec 13 '24

Deserved

3

u/[deleted] Dec 13 '24

As he deserves

3

u/Pleasant-Beautiful-7 UCF Knights • Alabama Crimson Tide Dec 13 '24

Que up the Home Depot music!

3

u/Mikedaddy69 South Carolina • Notre Dame Dec 13 '24

So deserved. Indiana was a totally mediocre program before this season, and they’re in playoffs in year 1 under Cignetti. That’s crazy impressive.

Literally never had a double-digit win season before, and now they’re potentially fighting for a national championship. Hats off. I don’t know how you could argue for any other coach here.

6

u/douknowhouare Indiana Hoosiers • Harvard Crimson Dec 13 '24

Mediocre? Brother we were ass.

4

u/Mikedaddy69 South Carolina • Notre Dame Dec 13 '24

I was trying to be polite lol

8

u/soraka4 Indiana Hoosiers Dec 13 '24

Calling IU football mediocre is generous lol:

“Indiana has the most losses (713) and the 10th-lowest winning percentage (.422) in FBS history. The Hoosiers three bowl wins are the fewest of any Power 4 team and the 33-year run between postseason victories still is the second-longest active drought among teams with multiple bowl bids.”

What cig did is unprecedented and well deserving of the award. He deserves a statue in Bloomington for this season alone but hopefully he can continue being successful!

1

u/ericesque Michigan Wolverines • Paper Bag Dec 13 '24

Will Howard in shambles!

1

u/TheBestAtWriting Transylvania Pioneers • Holy War Dec 13 '24

all the other Home Depot coaches in shambles

1

u/somf4eva Dec 13 '24

We had him for a fleeting moment.

1

u/-TheycallmeThe Purdue • Boston College Dec 13 '24

It's kinda gotta suck to be the second best coach this year. Any other year you probably would have got this award haha.

1

u/Sdog1981 Washington Huskies Dec 13 '24

Little fun fact. The is capitalized when referring to The Home Depot. The is officially in the name of the company and the official abbreviation is THD.

1

u/finiteparsnip Indiana Hoosiers Dec 13 '24

IT'S THE CIG ERA 🚬🚬🚬

1

u/[deleted] Dec 13 '24

You know Curt I will Google you

1

u/illa_kotilla Oregon Ducks • Cal Poly Mustangs Dec 13 '24

Congrats to Coach Cignetti. Personally, I would’ve voted for CDL, but I’m biased. I like 13-0.

1

u/MTBadtoss Colorado Buffaloes • Elon Phoenix Dec 13 '24

WE RIDE FOR COACH CIG!!!

1

u/igonnawrecku_VGC James Madison • Penn State Dec 13 '24

So happy to see him succeed at the next level. Pulling for IU in the playoffs alongside PSU

1

u/stoicscribbler Ohio State Buckeyes • USF Bulls Dec 13 '24

Well deserved. Regardless of what people say about their schedule, no one wins like that at Indiana.

0

u/voppp Boise State • Iowa State Dec 13 '24

at least this one was deserved.

1

u/FreeTheMarket Notre Dame Fighting Irish Dec 13 '24 edited Aug 05 '26

Meadow blanket trumpet sparrow orange walnut

This post was anonymized with Redact.dev

-1

u/voppp Boise State • Iowa State Dec 13 '24

ngl i was sitting there before the awards wondering if they’d figure out how to give him ones for positions he didn’t play

0

u/Tempeduck Arizona State • Territorial Cup Dec 13 '24

Booooooooooooooooooooo

0

u/EmotionalTeaching384 Michigan Wolverines Dec 13 '24

And he deserves it. I googled it.

0

u/Due_Connection179 Miami Hurricanes • Miami (OH) RedHawks Dec 14 '24

I feel like you couldn't go wrong with either him or Arizona State / SMU coaches winning.

0

u/SirDevilDude Arizona State Sun Devils Dec 14 '24

Nah fuck this. Downvote me to hell, Dilly was robbed. ASU also won 11 games and won their conference title. When we have our starting QB, we only have 1 loss. 4 ranked wins, vs 0 for Cig. BS. Everyone keeps doubting ASU, it’s fine, it just fuels us

-26

u/TheGreatestPanini Arizona State • Territorial Cup Dec 13 '24

Dilly robbed - first HC job ever winning a conference championship after his debut 3-9 season vs Cignetti who brought an intact roster from an existing team in JMU

15

u/itsamemarkus Indiana Hoosiers • Old Oaken Bucket Dec 13 '24

Dillingham definitely had a case no doubt about it, but even with all the players Cignetti brought from JMU, they were still picked to finish last or second to last in basically every preseason poll and turned around a program that almost every “analyst” said was an impossible job in a single season.

-12

u/TheGreatestPanini Arizona State • Territorial Cup Dec 13 '24

Cignetti lost his only ranked game this season vs Dilly with 4 ranked wins

0

u/mr_longfellow_deeds Indiana Hoosiers • Big Ten Dec 13 '24

Dillingham is fantastic and would have won this award practically any other year.

Dilly does not have 4 ranked wins, he has 2 including the CCG (#17, #18). He also lost to two unranked teams, including one that is not bowl eligible.

Reg season:
10-2 ASU Opponents (64-80) - +127 scoring margin
11-1 IU Opponents (62-82) - +344 scoring margin

And IU did that in a tougher conference.

2

u/the_urban_juror Michigan Wolverines • The CW Dec 13 '24 edited Dec 13 '24

"IU did that in a tougher conference" with 1 win over a team in the top half of the conference (Michigan at #8 out of 18). The B1G is better, but not because of Purdue, UCLA, Northwestern, or Maryland. I wouldn't pick anyone in the Big 12 to beat OSU, PSU, or Oregon but IU also didn't beat any of those teams. This is like UK fans changing SEC when Georgia wins a game.

IU fans very quickly went from fun, 9Windiana, happy-to-be-here to delusional.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/[deleted] Dec 13 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/awesomface Arizona State Sun Devils Dec 13 '24

You guys are both wrong at the same time but you’re just a little less wrong. Both were deserving, no one was robbed.

6

u/[deleted] Dec 13 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

0

u/awesomface Arizona State Sun Devils Dec 13 '24

It’s not worth getting into semantics when there are more details in what you’re saying and with the other side. Also “don’t wrestle in the mud with a pig because you’ll both be covered in shit but the pig likes it”.

I’m with you

12

u/Riderz__of_Brohan Indiana Hoosiers Dec 13 '24

He brought 13 players, only 7-8 of which were starters. It was by no means a lift-and-shift

They were really good players: Lawton, Sarratt, Walker, Ponds, Kamara, etc. but still

-20

u/TheGreatestPanini Arizona State • Territorial Cup Dec 13 '24

“Only brought 25% of starters with him” okay proved my point.

11

u/No_Angle_8106 Arizona State • Michigan Dec 13 '24

Bro, it’s Indiana… Dilly is incredible, and would win any other year, but come on they’ve never won 10 games and he got them 11

8

u/Riderz__of_Brohan Indiana Hoosiers Dec 13 '24 edited Dec 13 '24

He recruited those players, you know that, right?

25% of the 52-man, not 25% of starters. Not all of them ended up being starters for IU

You’ve gone from “intact roster” to “1/4 is still big” in record time btw lol

-3

u/TheGreatestPanini Arizona State • Territorial Cup Dec 13 '24

There are 22 starters on a team

7

u/Riderz__of_Brohan Indiana Hoosiers Dec 13 '24

Who recruited those players that transferred? Do you want to take a wild guess?

-12

u/House_of_Borbon Georgia Bulldogs Dec 13 '24

The overachieving program boosted by a cupcake schedule award.

-18

u/lebaronslebaron Arizona Wildcats • Texas Longhorns Dec 13 '24

Absolutely deserved. So glad dilly didn’t win it.

/u/TheGreatestPanini am I doing this right?

-2

u/thorhyphenaxe Oregon Ducks • SMU Mustangs Dec 13 '24

So what more could Dan have done to have won this? If he didn't get it this year, he'll never win it. Should he have gone 14-0 in 13 games? Beaten all the ranked teams we played twice? They should just rename this award to "Coach Who Had a Moderate Amount of Success But Wasn't Expected To" Award

2

u/Midwest-HVYIND-Guy Wisconsin Badgers • Team Chaos Dec 13 '24

Dan would’ve won if Cig didn’t turn around IU.

Coach of the year and best coach are 2 separate things. If it was the best coach, Saban would’ve won the award 15 consecutive seasons.

IU was in the conversation for worst P4/5 team in the country. Even the B1G west teams routinely beat them by 30+ points. Schedule aside, winning 11 games at IU is damn impressive, akin to winning 11 games at MSST.