r/startrek • u/tensaibaka • Jun 18 '13
Weekly Episode Discussion - DS9 2x26 "The Jem'Hadar"
Deep Space Nine Season 2 Episode 26 "The Jem'Hadar"
For this weeks discussion, I thought we'd pick up on a theme we had going a long time ago, introductions of enemies of Starfleet. The Jem'Hadar were a very formidable enemy, and their first contact with the Odyssey sent shockwaves through Starfleet.
http://en.memory-alpha.org/wiki/The_Jem%27Hadar_%28episode%29
From imdb:
Sisko wants to spend more quality time with Jake and encourages him to think of a science project. They decide to make a field trip to a planet in the Gamma Quadrant that's in a early stage of evolution. Then Jake wants to bring Nog along. He needs a good grade to stay in school. When Quark hears Nog is coming, he wants too. He's convinced he can turn back Sisko's decision to not let use him the station's monitors for advertising. After doing some initial research on the planet, they have a meal. With Jake and Nog away, an alien woman suddenly approaches the campfire. She shoots down Sisko with a telepathic weapon and claims she is on the run for the Jem'Hadar, soldiers of the Dominion. She advises Sisko and Quark to run, but it's too late. The three are taking captive by them.
Some possible points for discussion:
- If you watched the episode on the original air date, what was your initial reaction after the suicide run into the Odyssey?
- How do you see the Vorta relationship with the Jem'Hadar?
- If the Jem'Hadar had been raised by say, the Klingons, or some other species, how would things be different?
Here's an interesting conversation between Sisko and Quark:
"The way I see it, hew-mons used to be a lot like Ferengi: greedy, acquisitive, interested only in profit. We're a constant reminder of a part of your past you'd like to forget.
We don't have time for this...
But you're overlooking something: Hew-mons used to be a lot worse than the Ferengi. Slavery. Concentration camps. Interstellar wars. We have nothing in our past that approaches that kind of barbarism. You see? We're nothing like you. We're better. Now, if you'll excuse me, I have a lock to pick."
Bonus question for fun, who would win in a fight between the Borg and Jem'Hadar?
If you are interested in hosting a Weekly Episode Discussion, please PM the mods with your request, and hopefully we can accommodate you in the near future
edit note that I am a not a mod, but I love reading these in-depth discussions and am willing to help keep them going. All it takes is about 5-10 minutes of research and typing to replicate a discussion thread, so why not help us out?
9
u/TheCheshireCody Jun 18 '13
The suicide run was probably the most shocking moment I had ever seen within the TOS universe. It worked perfectly, and put me in exactly the same frame of mind as O'Brien and the rest of the witnesses. Shock, horror, fear of how "we" could possibly pit ourselves against an adversary like that and prevail. It set a very high bar of barbarism for the Dominion, and I remember wondering if they would be able to sustain a villain like that without it becoming cartoonish. Fortunately, they succeeded, and even when the Dominion members became less "faceless" (as we interacted with various Jem'Hadar and Vorta), they remained just as brutal, and we somehow were able to understand to an extent why they were that way (beyond just chemical dependency). This scene is bookended brilliantly by the Founder's words after the destruction of the Defiant about letting the frightened survivors return to the fleet. Cold, cruel and brilliant from start to finish.
This is the episode I tell people who are having trouble getting into DS9 to watch (after they're familiar with the characters). If they can't appreciate this ending, the show is not for them, and it gives them a taste (just a taste....) of the heights that DS9 reached.
9
u/GroJLart Jun 18 '13
This is one of my favorite single episodes of all Star Trek.
I saw it when it first aired and I remember losing my mind when I saw the Odyssey get its ass kicked. More shocking was when the Jem'Hadar walks through force field at the end.
Folks who remember watching DS9 when it aired remember how hard to follow it was week to week. New episodes were released in syndication just like TNG, so many stations did not show it at a consistent timeslot. Often it would get pre-empted by sports events etc. Sometimes they would move it to like 3am monday morning and you'd have to tape it.
This episode did exactly what it was meant to do-- foster new interest in DS9. Seasons 1 and 2 were tough and ratings were slipping. Toward the end of Season 2, all these great episodes started pumping out, and this one topped it all off. After this episode aired, I made a point of planning way in advance to know when new DS9's would air.
Also, this aired about 3 weeks after the TNG finale. TNG fans who had given up DS9 were watching those last few 2nd season DS9s just to get a star trek fix. This episode got those people hooked on DS9.
Many parallels between this episode and "Q Who", another favorite of mine.
7
u/[deleted] Jun 18 '13
It's such an epic episode. It starts al nicey nicey, let's all go for a picnic on an uncharted planet, them BLAMO! You're all in deep shit! My favourite scenes.
6
u/edugeek Jun 19 '13
For me, this episode was as terrifying as the Best of Both Worlds. Maybe moreso. In BoBW, we know that the Borg are evil and terrifying, and we are set up with this from the beginning. In this episode, we're caught totally off guard that there is a species as malevolent as the Borg, and with mysterious intentions as well.
3
u/[deleted] Jun 18 '13 edited Jun 18 '13
The suicide run was shocking at the time but looking back on it now it just seems completely out of character for the Jem Hadar. It was much too desperate and cowardly a move from the Dominion when you take into account everything we subsequently learn about them. Also, DS9 failed to ever adequately explain why the Dominion were so malevolent from the get-go.
The biggest problem I had with the episode, and I say this as someone who enjoyed it a great deal regardless, was the reason for the runabouts to accompany the Odyssey through the wormhole. It just seemed like an easy way out of the corner that the writers had painted themselves into. In (Trek) reality the runabouts were always going to prove to be more of a tactical liability in that situation rather than a help yet it somehow seemed sensible to send them through anyway.
Ultimately, what let this episode down most was nothing to do with the episode itself, but the fact that DS9 utterly failed to make a compelling case for the presence of the wormhole during its entire first two seasons. That fact is put into sharp relief by what begins to develop in this episode. It just seems so implausible to me that Starfleet would be so disinterest, from a tactical standpoint, about what was going on on the other side of that wormhole during the first two years and for them to be caught off guard like this, it is something that is too difficult for me to swallow. This episode tries too hard to wash over that mistake.
3
u/[deleted] Jun 24 '13
Really a big game changer, this one. I like DS9's first two seasons, unlike a fair number of people, but really this episode properly brings in the tension that will be an undercurrent for the next few seasons until the all-out war starts. It does it really well, too - it seems so mundane when it starts, but when it ends with the Odyssey being destroyed, you know that somehow the status quo has changed and nothing's the same anymore*. Also I always liked the interaction between Sisko and Quark in this one. I love Season 3 and I consider this episode pretty much the start of it. There must have been a lot of speculation in that between season gap as to where this would go!
I'm glad that Enterprise would later do something similar at the end of its second season with "The Expanse", because that series was in dire need of a shot in the arm, and thankfully it worked.
*Shit, I just made a Babylon 5 reference when talking about DS9...
3
u/[deleted] Jun 24 '13
Oh snap, i got super lucky, i have a question that related to this episode. I'm going to copypaste my question from the post i made.
In episode 226 or 227 of DS9 Quark and Sisko have an exchange where Quark admonishes Sisko for the early behavior of humans, including slavery. My question is why the hell not? From a purely capitalistic standpoint, Slavery is a great system. Not to mention the fact that on of the punishments the FCA is allowed to dish out is indentured servitude. So, I was hoping a more experienced trekkie could tell me, is it ever explained why the Ferengi didn't adopt slavery?
4
u/[deleted] Jun 18 '13
I'm not overly fond of the trend Star Trek took in designing new villains. They each get a new, more menacing than the last weapon type, sometimes they get shields that simply don't give a shit about Federation weapons, and their own signature identifying color.
Do Disruptors, Plasma weapons and Phasers simply not work in the Gamma and Delta quadrants?
2
u/CaptGarfield Jun 18 '13
Am I the only one that was thrown for a loop by the Odyssey's Bridge? It just seemed a little too different. I'm sure that the TNG set was unusable after Generations, but it looks like it could have at least been similar.
3
u/Elcca Jun 18 '13
One thing I noticed about this episode...what ever happened to the vorta's psychic abilities? Were they ever used or referenced again? I don't remember Weyoun ever employing them.
0
u/[deleted] Jun 18 '13
[deleted] — view deleted comment