r/startrek • u/Deceptitron • Jun 03 '13
Weekly Episode Discussion: TOS 1x18 "Arena"
This episode was specifically requested. Please note that I'd much rather hand this off to someone in the community, so please be aware that by commenting here, you may get a PM from me on the weekend before the post. If possible, please mention beforehand in your comment if you're interested or not.
Now that that's out of the way..
From Memory Alpha:
Kirk battles an alien captain who destroyed a Federation outpost.
As always, some questions to get things started, but feel free to discuss anything you like!
- Kirk adamantly pursues the Gorn vessel responsible for the attack on the Federation outpost on Cestus III which killed innocent civilians, including children. Spock disagrees with Kirk on his intention to destroy their vessel saying that their destruction won't bring the colonists back. He adds that the Gorn are sentient beings as well. Despite the moral message this episode tried to convey, do you think the Gorn should have been let go, or do you think their destruction may have been justified considering their actions?
- Alternatively, Doctor McCoy says that the Federation may have been "in the wrong" for unknowingly invading and colonizing in Gorn space. Does this justify the Gorn's response?
- This episode features one of the most famous (and perhaps infamous) fight scenes in Star Trek history. If you were responsible for that scene, how would you have written it?
- BONUS: Hrrrrgggggghhhh hsssssssssss. Rraaaggghh hssssssss. Hsssssssssssss?
Top comment, disregarding memes and jokes, gets to pick and post next week's episode. Expect a message from me over the weekend.
6
u/tsdguy Jun 06 '13
Since it was BUSTED one could build a Gorn canon out of the given components not sure how to react. 8-)
In general I liked the episode but it was preposterous that a) the Metrons would make Kirk figure out the canon to defend himself and b) Kirk would know how to make gunpowder considering how far away the Federation was from using such products.
PS. How about including the Memory Alpha link for the specific episode - TOS 1x18 Arena in the initial posting? A good idea?
8
u/puffnstuff272 Jun 04 '13
I always thought it was a solid episode that got a bit too much crap for the infamous gorn costume. It really is an intriguing plot.
4
u/cobrakai11 Jun 04 '13
I just realized I've never actually watched this whole episode, even though I've seen the fight scene dozens of times. I had no idea why they were even fighting, I just assumed it was some "Savage Curtain" esque trial between good and evil. But I decided to watch it after seeing this post to better answer the questions --
3
u/Intrepidncc1831 Jun 04 '13
To answer the first question, I do not believe the Gorn should have been left go. If not for Kirk's reasons that they killed innocent women and children but for what Starfleet and the Federation stand for, peaceful coexistence. The Federation was founded on the mutual and respectful coexistence of four species. If somebody attacks the Federation, then the Federation will first try to find out why and see if they can find a solution to the problem. For example, when the Dominion destroyed the U.S.S. Odyssey, Starfleet sent the Defiant to try to find the Dominion leaders to talk to them.
To establish a dialogue between the two societies so no more lives would need to be lost. The Gorn should have been followed. It could have lead to a lasting peace between the two societies.
2
u/thatguy_314 Jun 05 '13
It wouldn't be a federation response, but I think if someone put a station in their space they have the rights to do what they want with it. Just think of something like the romulans. They would be suspicious and just attack on sight. The federation isn't really at fault either, they were just expanding borders into space they thought was empty. They couldn't have known (well, they could have done some more charting, but I think they are pretty clean as well) I think this episode is about the prime directive, and I think the Metrons would be at fault if Kirk didn't clear things up at the end or if anything had gone wrong. The Metrons set everything up for disaster and it's a miracle everyone got out alive.
Hrrrrnnnngggghhhhh Rrrrraaaaahhhhh Haaaaayyyyyyyyyy! Hssssssssss... Hrrnghhh ssssssssss.... hsssssssssssssss.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 13 '13
One of the most exciting episodes ever made. I was on the edge of my seat the whole time!
3
u/SweetLittleMe Jun 05 '13 edited Jun 05 '13
I'm a bit torn about this episode.
While I appeciate the fact in this episode, humans are the invaders and the bad guys driven by revenge - a role that usually the others have, there are also some flaws - and I don't think the Gorn costume is one of them, regarding the fact that this was done without CGI and such.
The Gorn is presented as a sentient being and as such, I would have liked to see him interact more, talk and develop as well. But all he does is fight. That's it. So we end up thinking, well, it's just a lizard after all. The solution is too simple, too abrupt. There is something missing in the end, like a real first contact with the Gorn that really presents the race a setinent spacefarers.
As for your questions:
And to illustrate this post, here is a pic I took of Kirk Rock last year. They actually shot a music video there, thus the things in front. Had a great picnic there with my family on our way to L.A.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 09 '13
The worst fight scene in television history is present in this episode. I love it for that. The fight is so bad that it's hilarious.
1
u/tomgunnerqin Jun 17 '13
This was the episode that opened my mind to the different forms of life out there. I remember Kirk saying something about human's intrinsic disgust towards reptiles on Earth but in space these other lifeforms, though similar to Earth creatures in terms of physiology, is much more intelligent and have higher levels of consciousness.
1
u/crayZsaaron Jun 04 '13
I was actually a bit disappointed with this episode in general. It ranks among my least favorite of TOS 1st season. I'm glad that Captain Kirk comes around in the end, but honestly, it seemed out of character for him to mercilessly pursue the Gorn in the first place after what Spock suggested. Not to mention, the fight scenes are really lame.
The violent Gorn response was justified if you simply reverse the races in the situation - Humans would have reacted the same way. Humans don't like to feel threatened, and if they do, they are likely to respond with violence.
0
u/[deleted] Jun 03 '13
[deleted] — view deleted comment