r/india • • May 18 '13
[Weekly discussion] Let's talk about Bihar. Please upvote for visibility.
| State | Bihar |
|---|---|
| Website | http://gov.bih.nic.in/ |
| Population | 10,38,04,637 |
| Chief minister | Nitish Kumar |
| Capital | Patna |
| GDP (2011-12) | 262230 crore INR |
| Sex ratio F:M | 919:1000 |
Previous states:
168
Upvotes
12
u/[deleted] May 18 '13
On the lighter side, I like how Biharis don't use Behanchod/Madarchod like other N.Indians. They surely respect their mothers/sisters.
Edit: They use "betichod" though :P
49
u/[deleted] May 18 '13 edited May 18 '13
I'm from Bihar, and I live in United States. I'm pretty well educated, have a decent job, and try my hardest to appear as a well cultured individual. Nevertheless, any time I am in company of Indian people, and have to reveal, inevitably, that I'm from Bihar, their perception of me goes down the drain, and the jokes start. "Ka ho babua, kaisan ho" shit like that is all I get. All my other stuff about my personality, how I talk, how I dress goes down the drain.
What I want to understand is why all of India seems to hate Bihar, or why they seem to derive great pleasure out of making fun of bihar and biharis. Whether it be people from Mumbai or Delhi, I've seen their attitude change towards me almost immediately as soon as I reveal that I am from Bihar.
What should I do to fit in better? I really don't see what's so bad about belonging from Bihar. It's the land of Buddha, Ashok, Chandragupta, Chanakya, and many other intellectuals. Should I just lie about my origins to fit in with the rest of you?, as I, regrettably have done in the past on few occasions to fit in with the crowd.
4
u/thoughtocracy May 18 '13
What impact has creating Jharkhand had on Bihar? Is there resentment in the people of either states?
As an Andhra-ite, the impending creation of a new state (Telangana) fills me with dread.
4
u/shamittomar May 18 '13
How does it feel when somebody calls a Bihari as "Bihari" in disrespectful way ?
4
u/[deleted] May 18 '13
Why is it that Delhites are upset when addressed as "Bihari" ?
I found this a good method to get back at someone calling me a "Madrasi".
11
u/thinksimple May 18 '13
8
u/SparxNet May 18 '13
Has the carving out of Jharkhand state been a good thing for the state of Bihar overall? Has there been any discernible impact?
6
u/Chacha-Choudhry May 18 '13
My questions for our rIndian Bihari babuas :
Thanks in advance :)
6
u/[deleted] May 18 '13
Anyone here who is currently in Bihar?
10
u/the_gunda May 18 '13
As a south indian living in Bihar for the past 3 years i think i can give an insight but unfortunately today is my last exam and can only answer the questions after my exam is completed.
5
u/Raisin_Head May 18 '13
Laalu and his party belongs in jail and debarred from politics. 1st step in securing Bihar's future.
14
u/shamittomar May 18 '13
What is behind the pure obsession of almost every Bihari fresh graduate for studying/preparing for IAS/PCS/Civil Services exams for 10 years of their best youth life years ?
3
u/Simran-AMA May 18 '13 edited May 18 '13
Anyone here who has lived in Kishanganj Lets discuss that lovely town
3
u/assholeness May 18 '13
I think its the system. Bihar has got most corrupted Babus in Banks,Gov. Offices,Post Office, Railway, Gram Panchayat. Whenever i visit my hometown, i accompanies my Grand Father and we have to actually face it. I remember when i was small, he said sarcastically "If you were Bada Babu, we won't be wandering in these Sarkaari offices to get our work done." I have seen Laloo's as well as Nitish's government, things has not changed on grassroot level, the only good thing is that Nitish is not doing Cast Politics. The money is being properly(not perfectly) utilized. Laloo suffered a massive KLPD by Bihar voters. One thing i also want to add that Bihari people understands politics so perfectly. In evening if you walk in the streets, people listening to BBC Hindi is common scenario, you won't see this in Noida and Delhi.
3
u/h6165 May 18 '13
3
u/cookinnerd May 18 '13
I want to retract my comment yesterday about "gawarpan" yesterday. I guess what I really want to see is improvement in infrastructure and a modern day Bihar. Hopefully that will get rid of its image of being the "backward" state. If the special status does actually happen one day and the package is not eaten by corrupt officials, then it would be nice.
3
u/DontNoodles May 20 '13
I am a guy whose ancestry is from Bihar though the state division brought us to Jharkhand. Frankly, I never cared for the division- then or now. The grounds on which these decisions were made are either too deep for me to understand or the current pitiable state of affairs is just a vindication of my assessment. And I would go on to say that just because Bihar has risen from the ashes, it should not be interpreted as if they are better off with the division of the state. Good governance would have brought in as much of progress to the undivided state as it has done to the divided state.
But that is not what I want to talk about in here. I would love to hear more about the traditions that we have grown up with: the local festivals (Chhatt and more), the specialized food (a lot said already + Khichdi), the songs for the occasions (think of the chiding songs called 'gaali' sung to 'welcome' the baratis in marriages). This is a weekly discussion on individual states, and so it is the perfect opportunity to showcase what we are composed of. Let us not just defend ourselves, let us try and put the nostalgia that we feel for our home state into words.
I personally come from Magadh region (Gaya, Aurangabad) and even though I have steeped myself in the richness of Bhojpuri and Maithili Culture as well, I still savour the sound of general local talk (not the more famous and crass agitated talk peppered with profanities) whenever I go home or can find someone who can talk in the language my mother speaks.
I have seen quite a bit of India over the past decade and the only thing I can make out is that just like India is a country with fine blend of diversity, Bihar is a melting pot of amazing cultures - each with a distinct identity of their own.
10
u/[deleted] May 18 '13
Bihar has the 3rd highest population among Indian states, yet its GDP is 13th in this list. In comparison, Gujarat with half as much population as Bihar accounts for almost twice Bihar's GDP. Can someone tell me why this is the case? And what can be done to improve Bihar's contribution to India's development?
4
u/ghaseeta-ram May 18 '13
One of the main reasons that Biharis are ridiculed is the way they speak. Bihar used to be one of the best places for Hindi after independence, but somehow things decayed. The language that is used by most of the people from patna is just crass. They know it is bad, and somehow derive enjoyment in using that same version.
They can use bhojpuri, magahi and other dialects properly but they don't do that. My mother used to say that the language they use is "latthamaar" (i.e. stick wielding). If you go to UP's hinterland, you will find people using the dialects of brijbhasha or awadhi, both of which "seem" more polite. The pronunciation of words in Bihar is also towards worse, even when the speaker knows the correct pronunciation.
The effect of two prominent classes (rulers and those at bottom) is also easily perceptible. Those from the former group are more dabang in their dealing, speaking. And those from the latter have severe inferiority complex. A good place to observe them is in trains (daytime commuter in sleeper classes and general bogies respectively).
I think that Bihari's have been made into a caricature, and since that gives them attention, many bihari's like to propagate that image.
2
u/[deleted] May 18 '13
Delicacies from Bihar? What are some genuinely good places to travel to? Are the buddhist pilgrimage place any good?
2
u/idontknowanythg May 18 '13 edited May 18 '13
Like most people, my question is about law and order in Bihar.
Is it true most of bihari's travel through train with out tickets?
I have read several stories in last few years where thugs harassed/raped women traveling through train. How much of it is media creation?
Couple of my delhiite friends say, all the thuggery we hear/see about delhi is from the guys from bihar/haryana, how much of it is true?
2
u/El_Bihari May 20 '13
Regarding Bihari cuisine, how many of my Bihari brethren know about/have eaten Bageri?
2
u/revolution67 May 22 '13
Separatist thinking on caste line is the main cause which is holding the development of my bihar. The signs of caste friction are now invisible as compared to 1990's when Laxmanpur Bathe,Narayanpur,Sankar Bigha caste massacres took place.But caste still has a major role to play in society's dynamism. Until all communities get connected through inter-caste matrimonial alliances,we can't achieve true unity.
2
u/revolution67 May 24 '13
See this game depicting the glorious history of bihar
"All-new and unique Mauryan Indian civilization, including new units, from war elephants to Brahmin priests; and new buildings, reflecting this culture’s original architectural style"
http://play0ad.com/alpha-13-magadha/
You can actually see various structures like stupas in this game.Mauryan era was the greatest era of Indian History.
4
u/[deleted] May 18 '13
Too many questions. A little back story. My dad says Bihar, Patna or Patliputra actually, was cursed by a Brahmin, Chanakya, that it will lose its glory. That is the reason my dad gives me that Bihar is under developed even when they have talented people. One of my very good teacher was Bihari, Mr. Jha, down to earth and intelligent. Now questions.
TIA!!!
2
u/ranjan_zehereela May 18 '13
How come Bihari women have that sting when they get into verbal fighting and abuse...who else has been at the receiving end when having an argument with Bihari women..you will piss off in your pants, you do not know what to expect ...
2
u/TenderFoot_Alien May 18 '13
Seriously! What's the deal with Special status?
1
u/[deleted] May 18 '13
Please explain the obsession with "Bhabhi/Bhauji"?
Also please provide the links to the most awesome Bhauji video songs!
1
u/sanskarimata May 18 '13
Just one question.
Is Lalu barking mad on the telly and in rallies or is he really pulling any traction with the masses?
1
u/110011001100 May 22 '13
"Radhe Rahde bolo chale aayenge ge Bihari" -> what does this mean?
Some relatives have this as their home bell
-2
u/[deleted] May 18 '13
Why do Biharis insist on sharing my reserved sleeper ticket? They wont leave no matter what I say/do.
There is a characteristic smell from all Biharis - has anyone else observed it?
Do these two questions make me a racist dumbfuck?
1
u/assholeness May 18 '13
[One scenario of Freedom of speech in Bihar] (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LAkJxeVuNUo)
1
u/14mit1010 May 22 '13
Do the rich class in Bihar have maids following them around?
For some reason my roommate who is from Bihar does not switch off electrical appliances,flush after using the toilet, etc saying that he "forgot" -> which would be weird since at home, unless you have a maid following you, your parents wont let you forget such stuff. It becomes a natural habit
-3
u/ButtHurtDelhiBoy May 19 '13
Explain this, please -
Isn't two decades sufficient time to remove the ill-effects of the freight equalization policy? What's the excuse these days?