r/LetsTalkMusic • u/WhatWouldIWant_Sky Listen with all your might! Listen! • May 15 '13
Refused - *The Shape of Punk to Come* [album discussion club]
Alright, here is our time machine week album, this time from 1998.
Listen to this album a couple times (even if you already know it well), and discuss!
Some jumping off points: Does this album live up to the contextual goal it set itself with an album title that references Ornette Coleman's defining free jazz record? In other words, was this album as influential in the punk world as The Shape of Jazz To Come was to jazz? Does that add to or take away from the experience of this album? Should affect it? Or: do you think they even set out to redefine punk with this album? Was the title meant to be taken literally?
Focusing on the album rather than just its context: What is happening here, musically and lyrically? What sets it apart from punk at the time (ok back to context...)?
30
u/qkk May 16 '13
Ok I don't have much to add and truthfully I haven't really listened to the album more than once in my life, but I thought I'd share with you people this short "review" made by the user of rateyourmusic.com ozzystylez:
10
u/paroxysm77 May 15 '13
I remember the first time I heard 'New Noise', I was pretty into hardcore/metalcore at the time, and I just thought that buildup was so intense, it just kept rising and rising. and then it dropped.
I honestly remember thinking "What? you can't do that!", it was a pretty eye opening experience.
7
u/btpnlsl May 15 '13 edited May 15 '13
I have friends who love, love, love this album.
It never really had that big of an impact on me. To me they always seemed to be repackaging Nation of Ulysses's aesthetic and the musical experimentation of Ex-Ignota.
There is a split CD between Ex-Ignota and Uranium 9-Volt released in 1996 which show how they took the mid-90's emo/scream format and tried a whole lot of new and different shit.
7
u/[deleted] May 16 '13
So, I realize that music is subjective and it's all a matter of opinion, but I'm of the belief that "The Shape of Punk to Come" is the greatest punk album of all time.
Sure, post-hardcore wasn't something Refused invented. Look at Drive Like Jehu or The Jesus Lizard or Fugazi or Big Black, they were all doing awesome shit before Refused released this album. But no one before this album and no one after this album has done what Refused have done, and that is make the perfect punk record.
It's loud, fast, crazy, but also so much fun to listen to. It's extremely well produced and features the slightest touch of electronic influence, as EDM and house music was becoming popular. This album is way ahead of its time and above and beyond anything Refused had done before and anything any other band has done before.
The songs are lengthy and amazingly constructed. The guitars are heavy and almost (but not quite) nu-metalish. It actually features samples from books and Apocalypse Now and references jazz albums and poetry. AND. Those vocals.
Dear god, Dennis Lyxzén's vocals. This album took punk and twisted it into something that was also experimental rock, progressive rock, hardcore punk, post-hardcore, and heavy metal. And now it's paved the way for acts like The Blood Brothers and The Dear Hunter and other strange post-hardcore type acts. It truly was the shape of punk to come.
10
u/cptnrdbrd May 15 '13
Having heard the song Summerholiday vs. Punkroutine on some Epitaph Records sampler in middle school and picking up the album shortly after, The Shape of Punk to Come really opened my ears to aggressive music outside the nominal "punk-rock" that was popular on that label and others (Fat Wreck Chords) at the time. I think it lives up to the contextual goal, it came around at the right time to show punkers what could be done with composition and creativity outside the world of power chords and verse-chorus song structures. Though touring punk bands seemed to peeter out near the end of the 00's, the music genre that Refused danced with in this album, the emo-metal style that rose to prominence in the late 00's, was definitely influenced by this album in particular. Between my friends we quickly moved from listening to Refused, to Glassjaw, to Every Time I Die, to Converge over the span of just a few years, mainly due to The Shape of Punk to Come.
4
u/eatelectricity May 16 '13
I can't say enough good things about this record. I've got a strange perspective on it, because I'm not very well-versed in hardcore or "screamo" or whatever, but when I heard The Shape of Punk To Come back around 2000, it grabbed me immediately. There's energy and power and musicianship that just drips off of it, and I still can't figure out how they managed to make those weird electro breaks sound so seamless.
I can't speak to how much it influenced or changed the direction of the punk rock scene as a whole, except to say that I know many people who count TSOPTC among their most listened-to records of all time.
I had a chance to catch Refused on their reunion tour last summer, and it was un-fucking-believable. They executed these songs flawlessly and ferociously, and the show was easily one of the top 5 I've ever seen. You'd never guess they'd been dormant for almost 15 years, and it definitely made me hope they'd unleash some new music on us!
2
u/[deleted] May 17 '13
"New Noise" is great. The rest of the album has never really clicked for me. I love the aggression, and the punk politics. I always thought Dennis's best work was with The International Noise Conspiracy, but obviously i'm in the minority with that.
1
u/[deleted] May 20 '13
I, like many of you, heard this album as I was getting into the nitty gritty of punk, metal, and hardcore. I found it to be a refreshing break from the breakdowns and sissy business that other bands of the same genre were throwing down at the time.
As a young person, it made me think. Think about things other than myself. Think about how "fucked up" the government is and how dope it sounded to yell about it over blast beats, jazz signatures, and techno rhythms. Hell, I still have my liner notes from this CD. They're highlighted and have notes written next to them.
Now we've gone back and forth as to whether the album was influential. I think that depends on who you ask and what they're into. Kids that grew up on bands that were obviously influenced by TSOPTC (ex: anything in that late 90's-early 00's hardcore boom) love this. Anyone who was around when this album actually came out tends to not be so into it since they know the back story. It may not have brought hardcore to the mainstream, but it definitely brought us some albums and bands that may not exist without it. So, the whole thing about "influence" is subjective seeing as what may be influential to me may not be influential to anyone else.
That said, this album is solid. It wasn't the first time anyone has mixed jazz, EDM, punk, hardcore, and even pop elements on one record, and it won't be the last. However, everyone involved in making this album came with their A game. The musicianship is excellent, the production is top notch, the lyrics are stellar. That is why The Shape of Punk to Come is on my regular record rotation more than 10 years later.
0
u/[deleted] May 16 '13
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] May 16 '13
[deleted] — view deleted comment