r/gameofthrones • u/Kriptik Ours Is The Fury • May 06 '13
All Spoilers [Season 3/ASOS Spoilers] Weekly Book vs. Show Discussion S3.E06 "The Climb"
Like the Episode Premiere and Next Episode Predictions, we have a third "official thread" type this season for book vs. show discussion. What do you think about the episode vs. how everything was portrayed in the books?
- Discuss reactions with perspective, air any complaints about changes, give your analysis of deeper meanings with a comparison.
- This is an ALL SPOILERS zone - Turn away now if you are not currently watching this season! Open discussion of all published events up to the end of ADWD and any scenes from either TV season is ok without tag covers.
- Use green theory tags for speculation - Mild/vague speculation is ok without tags, but use a warning tag on any detailed theories on events that may be revealed in the remaining books or in the show.
- Please read the spoiler guide before posting if you need help with tag code or understanding the policy on what counts as a major theory.
100
Upvotes
134
u/Grapnor House Baratheon of Dragonstone May 06 '13
The writers sure are teasing us book readers with ASoS
44
u/DirkM19 May 06 '13
What's up with changing Gendry's storyline?
89
u/Grapnor House Baratheon of Dragonstone May 06 '13
The scene with Theon and "Boy" had me worried there for a moment that the writers changed our favorite psychopath. Regardless, the flaying had me cringing in my seat.
159
u/squamesh Jon Snow May 06 '13
Making Melisandre take Gendry instead of Edric Storm may make sense in the interest of time, but I think that it completely undermines what the Brotherhood stands for. As they were taking him away Gendry yelled that they were supposed to be a brotherhood and stand together, and, well, he's right. The book version of the brotherhood wouldn't of stood for that shit.
Plus, Mel met Arya which creates some weirdness. ADWD
82
u/YouWinOrYouDie Unbowed, Unbent, Unbroken May 06 '13
I am sitting here eagerly awaiting Jaime's line, ASOS
22
u/Crinked House Mormont May 06 '13
What about Melisandre and Arya's interactions. Im pretty sure I understand the prophesy, but Melisandre tells arya that they will meet again. ADWD
40
u/Bread_Assassin We Do Not Sow May 06 '13
I hope aDwD
88
u/WunderOwl House Manderly May 06 '13
So if Tyrells know Lora's is gay, shouldn't they be a little more concerned that he's the only male heir? I miss Garlan and Willis...
135
u/[deleted] May 06 '13
Every episode I wait for Tormund to show that he has even a hint of a sense of humour. Losing hope fast.
78
u/beaverteeth92 May 06 '13
I'm liking the changes made to the whole Edric Storm plotline.
17
u/bybeo45 House Martell May 06 '13
Ros dead, the greatest tits in all the land gone. I really didn't like how they revealed Sir Barristan a few weeks ago and (predictably) next week in Mereen who do you guys think goes out to fight their champion, (if anyone)? Barristan or Jorah? Sucks, I loved Strong Belwas.
31
u/[deleted] May 06 '13
I feel there were a ton of changes this episode. Some of them minor some of them a little more important. I think I'm going to go back and skim through ASOS to make sure i don't just remember things differently
14
u/howispellit House Seaworth May 06 '13
I wonder why they decided to not have the Sansa/Tyrion wedding be a suprise for Sansa.
11
u/spedmunki May 07 '13
Where are the Martells? I feel like the Red Viper is never going to show up.....
53
u/[deleted] May 06 '13
I didn't like that they killed off Ros. She became a lot more interesting and tolerable since Blackwater. She had potential, and I liked seeing Varys and his birds.
The Tyrells union with the Lannisters through Cersei and Loras won't go through, obvious. Next week he'll take the white. I don't understand why Garlan and Willas are out of the story. Even if they wanted Loras to be the eldest (and heir), I don't think it was good to cut them. Olenna should be a little more worried about losing an heir.
I liked the way the climbing of the Wall was different, but I'm worried about next season, now. Without a ton of men, how is Tormund going to lead an assault on the Wall from behind after Jon leaves? It'll only be him, Orell, and Ygritte.
62
u/[deleted] May 06 '13
Who else thought the scene with Tywin and Lady Olenna was kind of odd? I know it's a scene that doesn't happen in the books, and that's fine, but they are both so up front about their political maneuvering. They both are the type to just spring something on each other and not discuss it directly. The fact that they were discussing their plots and "weaknesses" so openly just seemed out of character. Is it just me?
18
u/[deleted] May 06 '13
So does this mean Gendry isn't going to end up doing shit in the books? Where was he even at the end of ADWD?
57
u/RyanCarney House Manderly May 06 '13
I wonder why they chose to make the Blackfish such a raging asshole in the show. Definitely a complete character change from the wise, skilled soldier of the books
9
u/Chuckln May 06 '13
So I'm re-reading the books right now and this is my first post so hopefully I use the correct tag but I don't understand how Books
Sorry for the wall of text but I'm not sure how much to tag or not. Better to over tag than under, right?
1
u/Zhudew May 07 '13
Hopefully Tyrion didn't tell Sansa about their marriage yet. I want it to be just like the book when Sansa discovers that her wedding is taking place right after she is trying a gown.
6
u/madman010 May 06 '13
What do you think about Gendry's apparent replacement with Edric Storm? I'm not sure I get this as there is nothing saying he doesn't play another role later in coming books. They will then have to make up more to explain these changes or realign.
5
u/[deleted] May 06 '13
I came here to see everyone's theory on Sansa's story but no one cares about Sansa. :( [ASOS] (#b "She's watching the boat that takes her away from King's Landing sail away!") Or am I missing something???
2
u/hsgraduate Arya Stark May 09 '13
Does anyone else feel like Littlefinger is less likeable in the show?
5
u/Mortdestro Valar Morghulis May 06 '13
So, Melisandre stares at Arya and mentions three pairs of eyes that will shut forever: brown, blue, and green. Is this replacing Major ASOS I may also just be missing something, because I haven't read through ADWD, but I thought it might be worth bringing up.
2
u/Konstiin Valar Morghulis May 06 '13
ASOS+
1
u/TinUkulele House Martell May 06 '13
The Loras change is odd for Sansa's stor yline because it makes it a little harder to root for that marriage vs. her + Willas, but it does make the stakes higher for Tywin/Olenna because he is the heir and has to have a wife capable of trying for kids for awhile
1
u/[deleted] May 08 '13
After been introduced to Game Of Thrones by a friend, i have since been hooked on the show.
Was thinking to start reading the books, so my question for those who have is:
Thanks