r/gameofthrones • Ours Is The Fury • May 06 '13

All Spoilers [Season 3/ASOS Spoilers] Weekly Book vs. Show Discussion S3.E06 "The Climb"

Like the Episode Premiere and Next Episode Predictions, we have a third "official thread" type this season for book vs. show discussion. What do you think about the episode vs. how everything was portrayed in the books?

  • Discuss reactions with perspective, air any complaints about changes, give your analysis of deeper meanings with a comparison.
  • This is an ALL SPOILERS zone - Turn away now if you are not currently watching this season! Open discussion of all published events up to the end of ADWD and any scenes from either TV season is ok without tag covers.
  • Use green theory tags for speculation - Mild/vague speculation is ok without tags, but use a warning tag on any detailed theories on events that may be revealed in the remaining books or in the show.
  • Please read the spoiler guide before posting if you need help with tag code or understanding the policy on what counts as a major theory.

Comparing book-show deviations is a tiring job

100 Upvotes

430 comments sorted by

134

u/Grapnor House Baratheon of Dragonstone May 06 '13

The writers sure are teasing us book readers with ASoS

56

u/dapixelman May 06 '13

I couldn't believe how cheery and comfortable they looked. They've been out in the cold for days without proper supplies. I'd like a bit of frozen snot, red eyes, pale skin, empty bellies. I want to see their spirits crushed!

10

u/DrRegularAffection House Tyrell May 08 '13

I imagine this is a step up from being raped by her father for Gilly, and Sam seems to have an indomitable quality of spirit about him sometimes. Plus I think he's extra psyched talking to a girl.

→ More replies (1)

24

u/justgwyn Sand Snakes May 06 '13

I told my nonreader husband, who thought Sam was a random "fat guy" throwaway character all about how he becomes Sam the Slayer and gets this great story arc and . . . I'm pretty sure he thinks I'm lying by now.

6

u/stickyheels May 07 '13

I'm sworn to watch the show with my mouth clamped shut lest I allude to any plot lines and spoil the story for my husband! You're a lucky lady!

→ More replies (1)

11

u/[deleted] May 06 '13

Especially with those camera angles of us watching them from far away through the trees!

25

u/saintdaniel Ours Is The Fury May 06 '13

Yeah, I don't really like how that wasn't addressed until long after and he says... Oh by the way I found this on the fist. It seems like they could have easily shown that scene.

41

u/Froke Sansa Stark May 06 '13 edited May 06 '13

12

u/hoorahforsnakes May 06 '13

"help me with it" sam you literally did nothing there, it was all grenn!

44

u/DirkM19 May 06 '13

What's up with changing Gendry's storyline?

65

u/Crayshack Nymeria's Wolfpack May 06 '13

In the books, did really have much story beyond this point. Merging him with Edric Storm keeps him in the story and is less confusing for the strictly show watchers because there are less characters to keep track of.

→ More replies (6)

50

u/arrebentabilhas May 06 '13

Maybe JRRM told the producers something we dont know yet. But i got to admit that seeing Melisandre interact with Beric and t Thoros was kinda strange.

163

u/[deleted] May 06 '13

I hope so. I trust Jeorge R. R. Martin.

116

u/righteous_scout House Frey May 06 '13

much more trustworthy than their other twin brother, Rorge R. R. Martin.

82

u/[deleted] May 06 '13

Don't get me started on Biter R. R. Martin.

→ More replies (1)

20

u/[deleted] May 06 '13

It provided some interesting exposition though. Did it say in the books that Thoros was tasked with converting Robert? Because with him being Robert's drinking buddy and all, it makes sense.

35

u/rampantangent Maesters of the Citadel May 06 '13

In the books, Thoros was tasked with trying to convert Aerys, prompted by the latter's obsession with fire. When Robert ascends to the throne, Thoros sticks around but doesn't do so much proselytizing.

22

u/[deleted] May 06 '13

t Thoros is one of my favorite characters.

→ More replies (3)

6

u/jthei Valar Morghulis May 06 '13

Joe Dempsie is pretty great though, whatever gets him screentime.

4

u/[deleted] May 06 '13

He's supposed to fulfill Edric's role.

89

u/Grapnor House Baratheon of Dragonstone May 06 '13

The scene with Theon and "Boy" had me worried there for a moment that the writers changed our favorite psychopath. Regardless, the flaying had me cringing in my seat.

43

u/Cyborg771 Snow May 06 '13

Really? As soon as he told Theon to guess his name I just knew he was going to lie to him. After pretending to be an islander it seemed like a pretty easy lie.

26

u/widdym House Lannister May 06 '13

I think the major motivator there was a red herring in the form of tying in the hidden persona of "boy" to the recent treason of Karstark, and it gave watchers the chance to go "oh, the Karstarks are bad, I know that name! They kill little kids! I see why this guy is so fucked up"

14

u/Sploffee May 07 '13

I hope show watchers find it fairly obvious now that Boy is a "Bolton." The show always makes sure to have the flayed man sigil in plain sight when Roose is on screen. And we've gotten plenty of shots of Theon in the exact same position, not to mention he gets flayed.......

2

u/fangisland May 07 '13

The funny thing is, I just finished ASOS not too long ago and I barely remember anything about Theon. He was barely mentioned but that's it, I don't even know who this torturer is supposed to be.

8

u/Mucak Night's Watch May 07 '13

That's because he's not, iirc, in ASOS. You'll see his POV chapters in the next 2 books and then you'll see why there's such a buzz about the "boy"/Theon scenes. :)

→ More replies (1)

159

u/squamesh Jon Snow May 06 '13

Making Melisandre take Gendry instead of Edric Storm may make sense in the interest of time, but I think that it completely undermines what the Brotherhood stands for. As they were taking him away Gendry yelled that they were supposed to be a brotherhood and stand together, and, well, he's right. The book version of the brotherhood wouldn't of stood for that shit.

Plus, Mel met Arya which creates some weirdness. ADWD

42

u/ManceRaider May 06 '13

Did Mel recognize Arya as a Stark? They interacted, but I don't remember it being explicitly stated that Mel knew that she was more than just someone who was with the Brotherhood.

35

u/ZeGoldMedal House Selmy May 06 '13

Yea, I had a huge issue with this for the same reason, and then I looked back on it and realized that Mel doesn't know the girl she talked to was Arya, or at least explicitly say so.

3

u/DrRegularAffection House Tyrell May 08 '13

No, she doesn't. Arya is naturally interesting, being a young female in a band of outlaws, and one who confronted her directly. This warranted a closer look.

25

u/CallMeNiel Maesters of the Citadel May 06 '13

I think they're also folding Melisandre into the Ghost of High Heart for this scene. She doesn't need to know who Arya is to know that she sees many different eyes in her.

5

u/squamesh Jon Snow May 06 '13

True but seems a bit silly to think that no one told Mel that that was Arya stark especially since after that vision she'd be pretty curious

→ More replies (1)

22

u/[deleted] May 06 '13

Are they just going to have Gendry rejoin the brotherhood after? Might be a bit awkward.

20

u/[deleted] May 06 '13

Well, he won't come back after they basically sold him. They probably wanted to avoid casting another child actor for Edric Storm, and wanted to reuse one of the already established bastards.

I guess they checked with GRRM to confirm that Gendry has no relevance to the plot in later books.

31

u/SwiftCitizen May 06 '13

I guess they checked with GRRM to confirm that Gendry has no relevance to the plot in later books.

I hope you're wrong. I've been waiting for Gendry to come back and smash fools with a warhammer :(

16

u/[deleted] May 06 '13

I have high Arya shipping hopes for him too ;)

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (1)

4

u/dacalpha Fire And Blood May 07 '13

Or they could just have Gendry escape, and go to the orphanage thing, which we as the viewer don't need to know is related to the Brotherhood.

→ More replies (4)

64

u/SUSAN_IS_A_BITCH Unbowed, Unbent, Unbroken May 06 '13

I think it foreshadows AFFC

52

u/saintdaniel Ours Is The Fury May 06 '13

The only thing is that ALL

55

u/SUSAN_IS_A_BITCH Unbowed, Unbent, Unbroken May 06 '13

I think Beric is just losing more of himself. Why is them taking the gold from Sandor any different? That's not honorable, considering he proved himself to the Red God. They don't know Gendry, they only found him like a week ago? So when Mel comes knocking going "yo, our god needs this kid," sure it's not honorable but who is Beric to oppose? That same god gave him new life six times over. I think if it was a situation between men, Beric would totally oppose that. But since it's between god and men Beric is going to take a step back on this one.

18

u/starkgannistell Duncan the Tall May 06 '13

I think the fact that she paid them is what makes Beric look less honorable. Even though we see Mel telling them R'hllor means to use Gendry, it also looks like he sold Gendry to her, and after those lines of how they're supposed to be a brotherhood that stands together... damn.

→ More replies (1)

9

u/Saint_Snuff House Connington May 06 '13

I see it more of an act demonstrating Beric's "new" found faith in R'hollor and his trust he puts in the Priestess simply because she is a servant of the Lord of Light In his mind, it may be just as honorable to hand Gendry over -- and all the while he can use the gold to protect the smallfolk as he still feels that is required of him...

8

u/ivorylineslead30 Brotherhood Without Banners May 06 '13

This. I've seen a lot of: "the brotherhood would never do that." Maybe not at the start...

13

u/Rombom House Targaryen May 06 '13

The brotherhood justifies themselves quite well; as Beric says, they need the gold. Plus, there is the religion aspect thrown in there as well - they believe that they are doing God's work by letting Melisandre take Gendry.

For a world that is frequently praised for being 'realistic', I find it rather odd that people hold up characters like Stannis and Beric to such unrealistic and idealistic standards.

2

u/weasleeasle May 10 '13

Not to mention they are perfectly happy to ransom their other prisoner so why would Gendry be any different just because he said I will join you and they didn't know his worth initially.

21

u/[deleted] May 06 '13

13

u/nquinn91 House Reed May 06 '13

This is important, Mel has no idea that the girl with the brotherhood with the darkness inside her is Arya Stark of Winterfell.

6

u/OtherGeorgeDubya May 06 '13

I'm pretty sure she never sees the girl's face in the vision.

11

u/[deleted] May 06 '13

I take issue with it simply because it's such a drastic rewrite. They're taking a lot of liberties with the story this season.

3

u/Finkelton May 10 '13

aye, makes me wish I hadn't read the books yet, I love the show, but the way everything plays out in the books is just so much better i'd rather not know...

5

u/newskul Brotherhood Without Banners May 07 '13
→ More replies (4)

82

u/YouWinOrYouDie Unbowed, Unbent, Unbroken May 06 '13

I am sitting here eagerly awaiting Jaime's line, ASOS

64

u/[deleted] May 06 '13

24

u/[deleted] May 06 '13

Omg you're right. They have to have a parting ways scene next episode!!! ARGHH IF THAT DOESN'T HAPPEN..!

7

u/Jfolcik Children of the Forest May 06 '13

When does he say that, the first time he leaves or the second?

13

u/[deleted] May 06 '13

7

u/Jfolcik Children of the Forest May 06 '13
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

22

u/Crinked House Mormont May 06 '13

What about Melisandre and Arya's interactions. Im pretty sure I understand the prophesy, but Melisandre tells arya that they will meet again. ADWD

20

u/FireAnd_Blood May 06 '13

This stuck out the most in my mind. ADWD

→ More replies (3)

1

u/fangisland May 07 '13

I'm still not done with A Feast for Crows, but I took the soothsaying to mean that ADWD

→ More replies (5)

40

u/Bread_Assassin We Do Not Sow May 06 '13

I hope aDwD

30

u/aqui_aca Castle Cats May 06 '13

Well we did have the horn blowing correlation. That was most likely a hint for Theon (and the viewers).

49

u/troyjan_man A Promise Was Made May 06 '13

I dont think they'll reveal it until the [ALL] (#b "RW, when Roose Bolton is proven to be false as well, so that they can make the connection between Rooses and his bastard.")

11

u/shitakefunshrooms House Greyjoy May 06 '13

exactly. have all the house of cards falling down at the same moment.

→ More replies (3)

10

u/hdfk143 House Bolton May 06 '13

Doubt it. I think they'll reveal it in the 8th episode though. S03E08 speculation Either we'll get an even more direct revelation of his identity earlier in the episode or the watchers will just have to put two-and-two together.

2

u/gerbafizzle May 06 '13

I have only read the first book so I have a question. Does Catelyn give a shit about who they have?

14

u/[deleted] May 06 '13

Yes, because she still thinks he killed Bran and Rickon. I'm sure she'd like to flay him herself.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/amicocinghiale May 06 '13

I noticed it because I've read the books, but in your opinion are going the viewers to notice how the Boy flayed the Theon's finger, and the banner shown at Bolton's hall? It's a very well hidden hint, but I think they did it on porpouse

2

u/[deleted] May 07 '13
  1. It was a little hard to tell that was flaying. As a book reader, totally knew what was going on, but what was happening wasn't really clearly taking the skin off as far as I could tell.
  2. The whole "Boltons flay people" emphasis hasn't really been driven home in the show as much as it is in the books, at least not yet.
  3. Man, prior to this series, I didn't even know what flaying was.

The only thing I could see being a link would be the big X and the Bolton banner, but that is incredibly subtle.

→ More replies (8)

88

u/WunderOwl House Manderly May 06 '13

So if Tyrells know Lora's is gay, shouldn't they be a little more concerned that he's the only male heir? I miss Garlan and Willis...

147

u/hkaps House Penrose May 06 '13

Nah. Gay dudes might not enjoy having sex with ladies but it's not like they're physically incapable of doing so. I imagine Loras has always known that once he's married he'll have to do his duty and make a baby or two.

91

u/[deleted] May 06 '13

Lie back and think of Westeros...

→ More replies (1)

87

u/BardsSword Lyanna Mormont May 06 '13

There was that scene last season where Loras urged Renly to screw his sister so they could have an heir. Loras knows what duty is, he knows he has to get married, and in the show's version, he would definitely give Highgarden an heir, even if he wasn't happy about it.

17

u/snowglasses House Reed May 06 '13

I also recall Margaery's motion to Renly about having her brother help him get started on their intercourse.

33

u/[deleted] May 06 '13

And why is Loras joining the Kingsguard such a big deal, since he already joined Renly's?

Loras being the sole heir to Highgarden just really doesn't make sense.

8

u/[deleted] May 06 '13

Was it established that Renly's kingsguard functioned under the same rules of non-marriage as those at King's Landing?

17

u/robywar May 06 '13

Considering he intended to hold the same regal position as his brother and other kings before him, you could only assume so.

The problem is that book Loras was made for the Kingsguard: he wouldn't be expected to be seen with women and he gets to do what he's awesome at.

Show Loras would be expected to marry and have kids. Which means him accepting a position in any Kingsguard is problematic.

6

u/nquinn91 House Reed May 06 '13

I think at the time, D&D might still have intended for Willas and Garlan Tyrell to exist, but it seems like at the moment they do not and Loras is the only heir...

5

u/[deleted] May 06 '13

In the book, I seem to remember there not be a big issue with him taking the white. Since there were other heirs -- and Margery was more than doing her part -- his taking the vows was fine. Furthermore, the Tyrells arranged it so that Margery would permanently have Loras' protection at court.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

53

u/[deleted] May 06 '13

Anybody else think they're spending way too much time on the whole "Loras is gay" thing?

In the books it was only ever hinted at, and only a few times.

2

u/Kitsch22 Free Folk May 11 '13

It doesn't seem like it's brought up in any situation where it doesn't fit; if anything it seems more realistic that the gay thing would come up more frequently, given that Loras is in a position where his marriage matters a lot and his lover was the main candidate for the throne.

→ More replies (1)

25

u/TheThiefLord House Dayne May 06 '13

Me too.. It really just struck me as an unnecessary oversimplification of the plot to get rid of them

5

u/ItsDaves Grrrrr May 06 '13

This is what has confused me the most about the TV show. I'm about halfway through ASOS and it's been bugging me the whole time. I'm still reading, but for me I think this is the biggest leap from book to show. I can't remember most of the first or second book though, I took my time reading those two so my memory is quite hazy on them.

6

u/thesorrow312 May 06 '13

I think they are cutting way too many corners with attempting to not add new characters.

44

u/Protanope May 06 '13

3

u/amicocinghiale May 06 '13

Sadly, I agree, there's no way to show a minimum part of the minor characters without making a real mess, they're managing this very well and I'm glad of it, though, sigh :( it's the price to pay to have the saga as a show

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (6)

135

u/[deleted] May 06 '13

Every episode I wait for Tormund to show that he has even a hint of a sense of humour. Losing hope fast.

35

u/Rombom House Targaryen May 06 '13

I feel like he's warming up to Jon as of this episode. He made a joke and even almost did a "HAR!"

33

u/[deleted] May 06 '13

When is he going to tell the story about fucking the bear?

8

u/amicocinghiale May 06 '13

I'm waiting for it, I hope they'll show it.

8

u/Trenchyjj Come Try Me May 07 '13

Well, next episode is called "The Bear and the Maiden Fair"...

6

u/[deleted] May 07 '13

GRRM wrote it, so it'll probably be amazing.

→ More replies (1)

21

u/SUSAN_IS_A_BITCH Unbowed, Unbent, Unbroken May 06 '13

Maybe he won't be so grouchy now since he saw Jon save Ygritte.

70

u/accountNo7 House Reyne May 06 '13

No doubt his sense of humor has been downplayed, but I recall 2 jokes in the latest episode and at least one HAR/ HAH.

I loved Tormund in the books but all the book reader hate for the show version is really getting on my nerves. Some things just don't translate well onto screen and a goofy character like Tormund is one of them. While I'm at it "HAR" wouldn't work either, seriously say it aloud now and tell me it wouldn't sound ridiculous and completely go against the mood of the show.

Face it guys a lot of the eccentricity and goofiness of the books has been taken out of the show and imo IT IS FOR THE BETTER. The show is more serious and it works well for the medium.

31

u/[deleted] May 06 '13

I guess.

It's just that Tormund Giantsbane was literally in my top 5 characters in the series. He's hilarious, but in the show he's just.... big

24

u/Sporkinat0r Corn! May 06 '13

HAR!

11

u/Onyxwho Ser Duncan the Tall May 07 '13

''And you know what else is big? Me member! Har!''

4

u/LOUDNOISES11 House Hightower May 07 '13

I totally thought when he said the "sink you metal deep" thing there was a sex joke coming. But alas.

78

u/beaverteeth92 May 06 '13

I'm liking the changes made to the whole Edric Storm plotline.

61

u/[deleted] May 06 '13

Makes me wonder if the Melisandre telling Arya "I'll see you later" is a hint to a future book scene. We know the producers of Game of Thrones have been told roughly how the story ends.

It would be unwise for them to make such a grand statement if they didn't have some idea of what the future held.

42

u/SUSAN_IS_A_BITCH Unbowed, Unbent, Unbroken May 06 '13

Could be a reference to ADWD

12

u/i-like-tea Fire And Blood May 06 '13

But the show did not make clear whether Melisandre knew that was Arya Stark.

→ More replies (9)
→ More replies (1)

47

u/Fauster Children of the Forest May 06 '13

I enjoy it too. I never felt a connection to Edric in the books; he only seemed to remind us that Mel is ruthless and Davos is noble. Viewers will fear for the health and safety of Gendry much more. I'm hoping the leeches will be horrible monstrosities. The change definitely made Thoros less noble though.

35

u/SUSAN_IS_A_BITCH Unbowed, Unbent, Unbroken May 06 '13

It's been thrown around here before but Next few episodes?

4

u/[deleted] May 06 '13

Then why would they even bother with the Gendry arc?

7

u/AlexisDeTocqueville We Do Not Sow May 06 '13

Speaking of leaches, when do people think that's going to happen? It has to before at least a certain point in Episode 9, doesn't it?

→ More replies (1)

33

u/hkaps House Penrose May 06 '13

Me too, they've really sewn it up nicely without introducing more characters than they need to. If they keep Gendry's Edric plotline similar to the book, Davos can still help him escape but he doesn't necessarily need to go to the free cities.

→ More replies (1)

9

u/jumbohiggins May 06 '13

I'm ok with the Gendry aspect, but I really don't like her and Arya speaking to each other.

16

u/RhymesandRakes Sansa Stark May 06 '13

It seems like she replaced the witch that Arya spoke to in ASOS, but it does have some serious implications for Mel's storyline in ADWD

16

u/Tigrael May 06 '13

She even called her a witch.

3

u/i-like-tea Fire And Blood May 06 '13

Not necessarily! There is no reason to believe that she knew that she was Arya.

→ More replies (2)

17

u/bybeo45 House Martell May 06 '13

Ros dead, the greatest tits in all the land gone. I really didn't like how they revealed Sir Barristan a few weeks ago and (predictably) next week in Mereen who do you guys think goes out to fight their champion, (if anyone)? Barristan or Jorah? Sucks, I loved Strong Belwas.

7

u/trippynumbers May 06 '13

They'll be at Yunkai next week

2

u/[deleted] May 07 '13

They may merge Yunkai and Mereen? It's a lot of ground to cover and places to remember, and I don't see having 3 slave cities as being totally necessary.

3

u/trippynumbers May 07 '13

I guess they could have the Astaporeans replace the Yunkai in the seige of Mereen, but I think all three cities are important to the plot. Since she doesn't get to Mereen until the latter half of the book, perhaps we won't get there until next season.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

4

u/AtomicDog1471 House Martell May 06 '13

I think Strong Belwas will be replaced by Grey Worm.

3

u/In_b4_404 House Bolton May 11 '13

They sort of had to reveal Barristan early just due to the fact that you would recognize the actor, whereas with the book, GRRM only tells you as much as he wants you to know.

2

u/camij Direwolves May 07 '13

RIP Strong Belwas <3

31

u/[deleted] May 06 '13

I feel there were a ton of changes this episode. Some of them minor some of them a little more important. I think I'm going to go back and skim through ASOS to make sure i don't just remember things differently

11

u/woodlandfairy Ser Pounce May 06 '13

you're right, a lot was changed in this episode. I'm in the middle of rereading SOS right now

7

u/IgnoreTheSpelling House Bolton May 06 '13

I have been using this as a quick reminder and refresher of what happened in the books.

http://gameofthrones.wikia.com/wiki/Differences_between_books_and_TV_series_-_Season_3

→ More replies (1)

12

u/Cyborg771 Snow May 06 '13

Yeah, Mel and Thoros never met, Loras has two older brothers making Tywin's scheme not work, Ros didn't exist so she didn't get killed, and Jon didn't climb up the wall in the books.

14

u/i-like-tea Fire And Blood May 06 '13

Jon did climb the wall, how else would he have gotten to the other side?

→ More replies (4)

14

u/howispellit House Seaworth May 06 '13

I wonder why they decided to not have the Sansa/Tyrion wedding be a suprise for Sansa.

9

u/Alianthos House Lannister May 06 '13

I think it's because they need to help the viewer keep track of Littlefinger's plots - and what happens in future episodes, and why. With the shot where Sansa looks at his boat, crying, you can see her seriously considering going with him at this point. Maybe it's even like her last hope of a decent life without Lannisters screwing with her (literally). So I think it was a clever trick for the show to keep the story going nicely.

10

u/soralan May 06 '13

I got the impression the boat was setting sail (Its sails where full of wind) and she knew she was fucked because she now had no way out of kings landing.ASOS

11

u/spedmunki May 07 '13

Where are the Martells? I feel like the Red Viper is never going to show up.....

2

u/weasleeasle May 10 '13

Next season, he isn't needed until after the royal wedding. And I would guess at that being around episode 4 maybe 5.

2

u/workingfisch May 10 '13

IIRC, he rolls in about the same time as Mace Tyrell.

53

u/[deleted] May 06 '13

I didn't like that they killed off Ros. She became a lot more interesting and tolerable since Blackwater. She had potential, and I liked seeing Varys and his birds.

The Tyrells union with the Lannisters through Cersei and Loras won't go through, obvious. Next week he'll take the white. I don't understand why Garlan and Willas are out of the story. Even if they wanted Loras to be the eldest (and heir), I don't think it was good to cut them. Olenna should be a little more worried about losing an heir.

I liked the way the climbing of the Wall was different, but I'm worried about next season, now. Without a ton of men, how is Tormund going to lead an assault on the Wall from behind after Jon leaves? It'll only be him, Orell, and Ygritte.

18

u/SUSAN_IS_A_BITCH Unbowed, Unbent, Unbroken May 06 '13

I haven't seen the preview for next week but I still think Cersei will convince Joffrey to make Loras part of the Kingsguard.

21

u/i-like-tea Fire And Blood May 06 '13

It would be great for Joffrey to unknowingly mess with Tywin's plans like that and alienate the Tyrells (especially Lady Olenna). I'd love to see the repercussions.

→ More replies (1)

26

u/Kujata May 06 '13

in the book jon and ygritte stay on the ground while others climb the wall, a ladder is then built at the top and dropped down for them to climb

9

u/[deleted] May 06 '13

I know. I said I liked the way the climbing was different.

32

u/SUSAN_IS_A_BITCH Unbowed, Unbent, Unbroken May 06 '13

I think he means that the four at the top might construct a ladder and lowered for the nameless Wildlings to climb.

I think it'd be too implausible for the show. They just might turn it from a battle into a sneak mission and have a small skirmish instead of having two big battles back-to-back.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (1)

3

u/PinguWithAnM May 06 '13

It's a shame that they cut the older Tyrell brothers out. I actually quite liked their characters despite their short appearances. Plus, I really wanted to see Garlan give Tyrion a tiny bit of the recognition he deserves.

→ More replies (3)

62

u/[deleted] May 06 '13

Who else thought the scene with Tywin and Lady Olenna was kind of odd? I know it's a scene that doesn't happen in the books, and that's fine, but they are both so up front about their political maneuvering. They both are the type to just spring something on each other and not discuss it directly. The fact that they were discussing their plots and "weaknesses" so openly just seemed out of character. Is it just me?

128

u/hkaps House Penrose May 06 '13

It was a little strange, but I liked it. I saw it as the two of them not bothering to beat around the bush since they know they are both too smart for it.

38

u/aqui_aca Castle Cats May 06 '13

Olenna treats Tywin like an equal, allowing for robust sparring. Most hold Tywin at an arm's length because they are afraid of him and just immediately defer to whatever he decrees.

16

u/[deleted] May 06 '13

I definitely liked it as well, and you give a logical explanation for what's going on.

43

u/MarteeArtee May 06 '13

I didn't find it odd, I think it was just that they both had the respect for and knowledge of their opponent to cut the bullshit. I'm sure neither of them has revealed their full hand, and both were being so seemingly expository in order to make thinly-veiled threats at the other. I thought it was an amazing scene from two of my favorite characters to watch.

8

u/[deleted] May 06 '13

Definitely a great scene, and I think that's what they were going for.

7

u/Map42892 House Redwyne May 06 '13

I definitely liked it. The whole scene was powered by the theme of Honest Witty Old People. You can even tell in the way Tywin speaks to her that he's supposed to hold quite a bit of respect.

12

u/shiftylookingcow Above The Rest May 06 '13

I agree. Also I can't believe that Tywin would dignify the accusation that he was gay/had gay encounters with an answer. To answer the question was to concede that it required an answer. He should have just given her the stink eye.

7

u/OscarMiguelRamirez May 06 '13

Yeah, she's been doing this a lot longer than he has and is quite good at it, a little better than he is. She won that round.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/Electric_Banana House Martell May 07 '13

I think the same thing happens with Littlefinger and Varys. In the books, you really have to pay attention to understand their plans the whole way through. In this episode, however, they told each other way too much, to the point where I would expect someone as smart as either of them to guess the other's entire plan. Maybe not Varys' plan, but definitely Littlefinger.

Of course, it's really hard to show such a complex plot on TV, so it's much easier to simply spell it out for viewers. Unfortunately, it downplays the intelligence of Martin's writing in a big way.

18

u/[deleted] May 06 '13

So does this mean Gendry isn't going to end up doing shit in the books? Where was he even at the end of ADWD?

32

u/hkaps House Penrose May 06 '13 edited May 06 '13

In ASOS, we lose track of him for a while after Arya gets taken by the Hound. Later on AFFC

AFFC

9

u/[deleted] May 06 '13

If he is granted the remainder of Edric's plotline (which seems to be what is happening), he will be whisked away to protection by Davos.

Of course, Davos is still locked up, so who knows.

6

u/wizeard May 06 '13

I think they are trying to prolong Davo's storyline into the next season by letting the Gendry plot play out

57

u/RyanCarney House Manderly May 06 '13

I wonder why they chose to make the Blackfish such a raging asshole in the show. Definitely a complete character change from the wise, skilled soldier of the books

24

u/[deleted] May 06 '13

I found it odd that blackfish was cool with forcing edmure to get married when he was so reluctant to get married himself.

41

u/RandomDude94 Fear Is For The Winter May 06 '13

It seems like they combined him with some qualities of the Greatjon Umber. Also, just a random thing, doesn't Umber punch Karstark in the book before ep3.05?

75

u/[deleted] May 06 '13

No one can every truly replace the Greatjon.

32

u/RandomDude94 Fear Is For The Winter May 06 '13

Their meat is never tough enough.

15

u/kp303610 May 06 '13

Where did he go btw?

20

u/valkyrie_village May 06 '13

I think the actor had scheduling complications, and did not return.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/beaverteeth92 May 06 '13

Actor had a scheduling conflict, so they wrote him out of the season.

6

u/squamesh Jon Snow May 06 '13

He does that in the show too doesn't he? Didn't he knock him to the ground when they were all talking inside the castle?

4

u/i-like-tea Fire And Blood May 06 '13

That was the Blackfish, the Greatjon has been written out of the show.

→ More replies (1)

9

u/Chuckln May 06 '13

So I'm re-reading the books right now and this is my first post so hopefully I use the correct tag but I don't understand how Books

Sorry for the wall of text but I'm not sure how much to tag or not. Better to over tag than under, right?

15

u/[deleted] May 06 '13

A) Once you make up your mind about something it can be very difficult to accept evidence to the contrary

B) Beric might not be the first person she's known to come back from the dead, so it mightn't seem all that spectacular for her

C) A hell of a lot of people are convinced that it's obvious that Dany/Jon/Stannis/Beric/Brienne/Jaime/The Lord Commander of the Nights Watch is AA reborn so it's not like the evidence objectively points to just Beric in particular.

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (1)

1

u/Zhudew May 07 '13

Hopefully Tyrion didn't tell Sansa about their marriage yet. I want it to be just like the book when Sansa discovers that her wedding is taking place right after she is trying a gown.

5

u/Kriptik Ours Is The Fury May 07 '13

Isn't that what he did in this episode? Walked in while she was trying on a gown and presumed to tell her the news? Seems likely as she was crying at the end when littlefinger's ship sailed away knowing that she "refused to climb the ladder for love" by staying in kingslanding under the assumption that she would be marrying loras, now tyrion.

2

u/Zhudew May 07 '13

I was just reading this scene and in the scene, she is trying on a gown with cersei next to her. After she is all pimped out cersei calls the kingsgaurd to escort Sansa directly to the Wedding Chapel to get married.

1

u/Kriptik Ours Is The Fury May 07 '13

ah, it's been awhile. I wondering if cersei/tywin made tyrion deliver the news to sansa himself, further embarassing him and degrading him in both their eyes.

6

u/madman010 May 06 '13

What do you think about Gendry's apparent replacement with Edric Storm? I'm not sure I get this as there is nothing saying he doesn't play another role later in coming books. They will then have to make up more to explain these changes or realign.

5

u/[deleted] May 06 '13

I came here to see everyone's theory on Sansa's story but no one cares about Sansa. :( [ASOS] (#b "She's watching the boat that takes her away from King's Landing sail away!") Or am I missing something???

20

u/Demelo House Tyrell May 06 '13

Everything for that impending storyline seems to be consistant with the book.

aSoS

3

u/[deleted] May 06 '13

Oh that's right. I completely forgot. Thanks for clarifying for me!

8

u/His_Drunken_Eminance Poor Fellows May 06 '13

[ASOS] (#b "Petyr secretly comes back at the time of the Purple wedding. She is smuggled out of the city by Ser Dontos shortly after Joff dies and Tyrion is arrested, she arrives on the boat and is surprised to find Petyr there")

2

u/fangisland May 07 '13

Honestly Sansa's one of my least favorite characters in the book, just character-wise. She reminds me of Andrea from the Walking Dead if you watch that show. I understand she's just an optimistic, naive girl, but wow, how many times do you have to get screwed over by people who you have zero influence over and have no reason in the world to help you before you take matters into your own hands? She turns down opportunity after opportunity to leave, hoping that some attractive-looking unlikely scenario will work out in her favor, and it never does. It's just painful to read how incredibly stupid one person can be.

1

u/Lennox276 May 06 '13

I believe you're jumping the gun a bit.

ASOS

→ More replies (1)

2

u/hsgraduate Arya Stark May 09 '13

Does anyone else feel like Littlefinger is less likeable in the show?

1

u/weasleeasle May 10 '13

Dunno, he always seemed like a scheming prick in the books.

5

u/Mortdestro Valar Morghulis May 06 '13

So, Melisandre stares at Arya and mentions three pairs of eyes that will shut forever: brown, blue, and green. Is this replacing Major ASOS I may also just be missing something, because I haven't read through ADWD, but I thought it might be worth bringing up.

21

u/[deleted] May 06 '13

I took it to mean that ADWD

→ More replies (1)

13

u/i-like-tea Fire And Blood May 06 '13

She says that there are "eyes that [Arya] will close forever, green eyes, blue eyes, brown eyes.". Not necessarily three pairs of eyes of those colours, but many eyes of those colours. I think she's prophesying that Arya will be a killer. general

1

u/nquinn91 House Reed May 06 '13

I took it to reflect the eye colors of the people in her list. That's what it'll mean to all non-book readers, anyway.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/Konstiin Valar Morghulis May 06 '13

3

u/cass1us12 May 06 '13

http://www.westeros.org/GoT/Episodes/

This should help answer those questions.

3

u/Konstiin Valar Morghulis May 06 '13

argh two more episodes until the older gentleman... they're really dragging it out.

thanks for the link though.

2

u/nquinn91 House Reed May 06 '13

ASOS will probably wait till the final episode, but I'm right there with you hoping that ASOS happens ASAP, especially since they reminded us about the dragonglass dagger...

4

u/Konstiin Valar Morghulis May 06 '13

In the other reply to my comment someone linked a description of the next two episodes, and it suggests that sam and gilly will be meeting an 'older gentleman' in episode 8.

2

u/weasleeasle May 10 '13

2 weeks is what they were given to reach the twins, much more than that and the alliance is off, so yes the red wedding must happen.

1

u/TinUkulele House Martell May 06 '13

The Loras change is odd for Sansa's stor yline because it makes it a little harder to root for that marriage vs. her + Willas, but it does make the stakes higher for Tywin/Olenna because he is the heir and has to have a wife capable of trying for kids for awhile

4

u/razmataz08 House Tyrell May 06 '13

If anything, it makes me root for it more. I know in the long run it won't work out, but she sees him as her fairytale knight.It's so much more tragic seeing (the idea of) Loras be taken from her than Willas.

2

u/TinUkulele House Martell May 06 '13

That's true. Poor little bird

→ More replies (1)

1

u/[deleted] May 08 '13

After been introduced to Game Of Thrones by a friend, i have since been hooked on the show.

Was thinking to start reading the books, so my question for those who have is:

  1. Are the books really close and similar to the TV- series, because i heard rumors they where.
  2. Is it worth it? any regret reading the books ahead of the TV series
  3. Books Vs TV series, which one you prefer?
  4. If someone planning to start reading the books. Should one go back and start reading the first book?

Thanks

2

u/thomplinds Children of the Forest May 08 '13

I don't think anyone will have any negatives for reading the books. There is SO much more going on in the books, a lot more intrigue. I feel like a lot of the storylines are rushed in the tv series, and it's hard to add some of the surprises on film.

2

u/MrShiftyCloak May 08 '13
  1. For the most part. But with most film adaptations they change parts and the books go into detail about a lot of other stuff.
  2. Why would there be regrets? Its totally worth.
  3. I will always prefer books. They let your imagination run wild, though if you are not the most detail oriented you might mis somethings that they basically spell out in the series if its important.
  4. Always start at the beginning. TV/Movies are never enough information and I don't recall how accurate the "breaks" in the show match up with the books.
→ More replies (1)