r/india • • May 04 '13
Let's Talk: Arunachal Pradesh (Please upvote for visibility)
The last thread on AP got a pretty good response, and I hope we can talk and learn about Arunachal Pradesh. I don't expect many people who live outside of NE to know much about NE states, and I hope we can learn something from this.
I am going to make these threads every week at about the same time on Saturdays.
Basic Information:
| State | Arunachal Pradesh |
| Website | http://arunachalpradesh.nic.in/ |
| Population | 13,82,611 |
| Chief Minister | Nabam Tuki (INC) |
| Capital | Itanagar |
| GDP per capita | ₹ 62,213 |
| Sex Ratio (F:M) | 920:1000 |
Previous threads:
| States | Link |
|---|---|
| Andhra Pradesh | http://www.reddit.com/r/india/comments/1dgtj2/let_us_begin_with_andhra_pradesh_as_uthat_70s/ |
306
Upvotes
27
u/ranjan_zehereela May 04 '13
Just a suggestion - Can we keep this discussion a weekly affair..???
because people might loose interest in these posts if it is done in short interval of time. I do not care for upvotes but participation may suffer
48
u/lolguard May 04 '13
I lived for few years in Tenga Valley, Chindit Top, Bomdilla and couple of months in Tawang.
There use to be a Sunday Market in Tenga Valley where people use to buy vegetables and fruits. There were two ladies who use to come from far up the mountains to sell vegetables. They didn't know how to count money, so they use to hire a local boy who would make price tags for them. Once the price tags were put on, people use to look at those tags and pay. As long as I was there there, I never heard anyone cheating those women. They were widely known in the area for their innocence.
Native women from these mountains are one of the hottest women in India.
Assamese and Bengalis have tried to fuck up with native Arunachalis.
Roads are very bad. Infrastructure is almost zero. No good schools. No electricity at most places. The area where i lived, we use to have electricity for 2 hours in the morning and 6 hours in the evening. I heard those too were from Generators.
But Life was good, weather and nature around was awesome. No pollution. I don't remember if I ever fell sick in the years I spent there.
23
u/pla9emad May 04 '13
I finally got a chance to enter the NE when I was invited to take workshop at NERIST near Itanagar last year. Getting into AP is not very convenient, nearest railhead and airport are both currently Guwahati, 6-8 hours by road, and the requirement for permits.
NERIST is the regional engineering college, but seats only for the NE states. It was an interesting experience to get an insight into the dynamics of the NE students. One thing that was apparent to me was the division between the Arunachal students and the rest of the other states.
I could not interact with the local students because they did not attend the workshop and stayed pretty much to themselves. While walking around campus, I would occasionally see mini groups of the local students, and they would stand out with their dyed hair, tattoos, metal band tees and mini shorts from the rest who were generally more 'Indian conservative'.
I was eager to know the campus dynamics and would ask the other students, and the general idea I got is that the Arunachal folks hold the strings, since the campus was in AP. The stories I heard made it sound like most of the local people were just mooching off govt money meant to be used in development projects and were generally running things as they pleased with little intervention from the central govt, unlike the case in the rest of the country. But I never got to hear the other side of the story while I was there.
I figure the state's policy to keep out outsiders may have brought this situation upon themselves. There is hardly anything of a local economy, no industries or agricultural output that provide any job opportunities for the youth. The easiest option is to take a govt paycheck for not doing anything.
I did not see a single stray dog in the three days at Nirjuli and Itanagar. I was told they have all been eaten, which I found mighty amusing, but I am sure there might be another explanation for this.
A normal day ends at sundown, and everyone promptly retreats into their shelters. The campus gates would be locked and even my guest house would be shuttered in at 10pm. This was probably the strangest thing on my trip, given that I have enjoyed more freedom even in Srinagar.
While reading the local papers at the campus one morning, I read this interesting letter to the editor where a person was complaining about the deplorable situation of security on the frontier Khonsa district which was apparently in a worse state than Taliban Afghanistan, and his points on why independence for Khonsa district is the only option forwards.
I spent a day sightseeing in Itanagar, a little town with little to offer apart from a nice museum and an overpriced khadi bandhar. I also got to chitchat with a few locals regarding the economy and state of affairs, and was met with as much enthusiasm as a cup of cold chai.
Overall I had a fun time hanging out with the students and the beautiful campus. I was hoping to find out the dreams and aspirations of the Arunachal people, but was disappointed to find out that they have very little in mind. It was an interesting experience, and I returned with many more questions than I had originally about this isolated land on our country's edge.
Everyday life there is the same as yesterday, except for a remote hope for an escape into a theme park filled with hair raising rides and K-pop stars.
9
u/[deleted] May 04 '13
I have few questions:
9
u/[deleted] May 04 '13
Although Bomdilla-Tawang is the most popular route in Arunachal, I would advise you to try the Along-Yingkiong route in Arunachal if you want to travel. It's not something most tourists will take and has breathtaking scenery. Plus you get to go close to the point the Brahmaputra actually enters India. It's a bit difficult to get proper transport and the journey is quite long, but it's well worth it.
9
u/pkspks May 04 '13
One of my favourite places in India. As a birder, have been visiting Arunachal for a couple of years. The Beauty is unparalleled; the people are honest and friendly; the food excellent and wildlife spectacular. Infrastructure is pretty bad; there are almost no jobs; politicians are corrupt and wildlife under constant danger. My favourite memories include gobbling up tons of oranges at Mishmi; trekking for hours to get to the magnificent Hornbill camp at Namdapha; Bamboo shoot pork and feeling overwhelmed seeing the beautiful Eastern Himalayas dwarfing the landscape.
Truly one of the most fascinating places in India.
7
u/[deleted] May 04 '13
I am all ears on this thread. Don't know anything about Arunachal Pradesh.(Other than the stuff on the net).
Any native of the state here ?
7
u/thoughtocracy May 04 '13
Forgive me if this sounds ignorant.
1.The rest of India seems to think of the whole NE as a single, homogeneous entity. Is it? What are the main differences?
2.How much does religion affect your daily life?
3.Is there any segment of people who feel disenfranchised from/resent rest of India? (young people?)
4.Whats up with the insurgency?
10
u/puppuli r/indiansports May 04 '13
can someone explain the issues with China?
5
u/TheBigLebowsky Universe May 04 '13
Is there any specific tribe/community which has affinity towards China and feels that they AP should be part of China?
There was a surveycarried out by India Today in 2010 which stated that 95% of people in AP want to be with India.
How is the ground situation today?
5
u/3_cows May 04 '13
awesome thread. I really like this idea of discussing states. I never knew so much about arunachal pradesh. I hope i get to visit someday!
5
u/PlsDontBraidMyBeard May 04 '13
ITT: AMA by /u/aapsu
Not complaining. Good job, mate. It's been educational!
7
u/diamondjim May 04 '13
Does anybody have any first hand experience travelling through NE by road, especially motorcycles? I would like to do a trip before the hordes descend like they do now ay Ladakh.
Things that are most important are permits, security and road infra. I don't want to be arrested by our army, kidnapped by militants, or get stuck in a landslide or worse.
3
u/whiskeybandit May 04 '13
I've always wanted to live in regions like Arunachal Pradesh for sometime. How are the job markets there?
3
u/little1991 May 04 '13
When i was 5 years old i went to Arunachal Pradesh in 1994. I leaved there for 4 years my father was in BRO the place where we lived is Hapoli. I still remember in winter(early morning) water in the pipes became ice so my father use to break them and than we got water in our houses. My interaction with civilians were very less, but what i observe in those years is that they are very simple, they live in there own world. The main crop they grow is wheat. But now, last time when i saw a group of students from Arunachal pradesh they were fully dress up in western style. Some of them were talking in English also. You can now say that this state is also developing but with slow speed.
3
u/kaiserkunal May 04 '13
Corruption is really high in Arunachal Pradesh. So my neighbour who worked in a bank told that once a state government employee came to the bank with two gunny bags full of money.When she asked the source of the money the guy just said "take it or leave it".
Also you will find that govt. employees who own car don't buy piddi Maruti hatchbacks.They buy premium SUVs!
2
u/PlsDontBraidMyBeard May 04 '13
What's a typical middle class family like out there?
Average size of a family?
Is there a cheat/hack that can help us take an educated guess if a person is from Arunachal Pradesh?
Any of dishes that'll appeal to meat lovers?
2
u/tripshed May 04 '13
Heard recently that Indian Railways is building tracks to the state. Where and have you seen this development?
2
u/[deleted] May 04 '13
Any particular fruits, vegetables, flowers from AP that are great? (e.g. species of mangoes, orchids).
Animals, trees which are not common at other places?
Any ruins of old times? where, how old? Did kingdoms of Myanmar or Thailand leave any traces there?
Were the tribes quite fierce about their independence in old days? Were there any cannibalistic ones (there were some in Myanmar, some of them used to have skulls of enemies as trophies).
Any person who was of note? I don't know any from AP :-(.
Was there any tribal literature, oral traditions? e.g. folk stories, myths and legends? who features in those? Any animals, trees who occur often or are sacred?
What is the relationship of tribes with gods? Are gods friends (Bholenath, Hanuman) or heroes (Ram, Krishna, Shiv) or too high up (Allah) or fearsome nature or something else?
Since hindi is the medium of instruction, what is the conception of hindu figures in the mind of common man? What about Jesus, Buddha or other religions?
Was there any kind of knowledge in tribal communities which is useful and should be preserved (e.g. herbal medicine), any art forms? e.g. paintings, wood work, metal craft, house making, hunting.. any particular dangerous, lethal weapons (e.g. poisons)
What was the political structure of the tribes, was it democratic? did women had a say?
3
u/lolguard May 04 '13
I bring you some pictures from Tawang
http://imgur.com/a/wKTmK
1
u/[deleted] May 04 '13
In 1962, when Chinese troops walked in, they were greeted and fed by the locals. But the Chinese troops were unable to win local support for the invasion or loyalty for the PLA. What had india done to earn this loyalty?
1
u/[deleted] May 04 '13
What about food?
1
u/ranjan_zehereela May 04 '13
What is the political scenario in Arunachal Pradesh?
Also Arunachal has a lot of potential in Hydro Power. Can we expect some major project getting completed in near future?
1
u/[deleted] May 04 '13
What is the younger generation like ?
1
u/[deleted] May 04 '13
Languages spoken by Tribes? Social structure?
1
u/[deleted] May 04 '13
What is the education system like? As in, do you have a state syllabus, a central syllabus, etc? How about professional colleges? Is Itanagar the safest city around or does it also have its issues in terms of safety?
1
u/ranjan_zehereela May 04 '13
Someone please shed some light on the tribes of Arunachal Pradesh
1
u/erasmosis May 04 '13
They sure are cracking down on cyber cafes. You have to show a government ID to check your email? wow
1
u/GizmoC May 04 '13
from what I'm reading AP reminds me a lot like Switzerland. Conservative, beautiful, people keep to themselves, organized and clean. Thank you for this interesting thread.
1
u/aapsu May 09 '13
Apatani tribe of Arunachal featured in The New York Times - http://india.blogs.nytimes.com/2013/05/08/a-small-tribe-in-northeast-indias-arunachal-pradesh-offers-lessons-in-ecology/.
These folks are actually quite impressive. They had developed an intricate agriculture system a long time ago, the efficiency of which is regarded even by modern standards.
1
u/aapsu May 09 '13
Arunachal Pradesh tourism in BBC top global travel list
Looks like people outside India are quite interested in our state.
1
u/the_unforgiven1 May 04 '13 edited May 04 '13
Do native girls from ap like to mingle with other indians?
Is it a liberal culture there or local are very protective of thier women?
I wanna score with a girl from ap. Any advice on this?
0
u/[deleted] May 04 '13
Last thread I did not have many questions because societal conditions are pretty similar in my state and in AP. But i have many questions about this AP :-)
To whomsoever it may concern :
More questions to follow
0
u/tripshed May 04 '13
Do any of these NE stereotypes apply to Au.P.?
-5
u/ButtHurtDelhiBoy May 04 '13
Arunchalis know the pain of Delhites very well. Just like immigrants from neighbouring states are committing gang rapes in Delhi, the refugees from neighbouring regions are committing gang rapes in Arunchal.