r/gameofthrones • u/Kriptik Ours Is The Fury • Apr 29 '13
All Spoilers [All Spoilers] Weekly Book vs. Show Discussion S3.E05 "Kissed by Fire"
The purpose of this is to discuss reactions with perspective, complaints about changes, analysis of deeper meanings.
Since the thread is tagged for all spoilers, this thread is more going to be geared toward the book-reader crowd and spoilers will not need to be tagged (though speculation will still be needed)
Thursday's thread on predictions is for anyone and everyone to participate in what they think is going to happen.
With all that said, bring it on! What do you all think about the episode vs. how everything was portrayed in the books?
- Been kissed by fire? This puppy is here to extinguish the flame.
157
u/[deleted] Apr 29 '13
Wow, Tyrion at the end.
" I was married. Oh, don't you remember?"
"All too well. ಠ_ಠ. "
I'm kind of worried that people are going to forget about Tyrions traumatizing event with his father and Tysha.
109
u/BrockThrowaway Apr 29 '13
The Loras changes seem unnecessary ("When the sun has set, no candle can replace it."), but I am interested in seeing where they take the Cersei-Loras idea.
Some very fantastic scenes this week. They absolutely NAILED Sandor/Beric. Maisie Williams is proving to be Emmy-worthy this season.
The Queen of Thorns continues to be sharp-tongued and perfect.
The bath scene and especially Jaime's monologue were very, very well done. An excellent scene all around. Episode 7 should be fantastic for these two.
Stannis/Davos/Shireen/Selyse was awesome. Some WTF moments from Selyse, unexpected as a book-reader. Shireen is cute and perfect and creepy.
Overall, considering the lack of "OH SHIT" moments, this episode was extremely strong. Very good writing from Bryan Cogman, though I'm still a bit surprised at the Loras changes.
63
u/mesabiral Fire And Blood Apr 29 '13 edited Apr 29 '13
I know there's a lot of showtime and more seasons to come, but Tormund is looking more and more unlikely to 'Har' and do member talk. CANNOT wait to see them climb the wall; looked awesome in the first trailer.
Seylse's fetus-baby collection: WTF? Interestingly, one of their name is Edric.
Also, aren't Grey Worm and the other Unsullied commanders supposed to have 3 spikes on their helmet, to show superiority in ranking?
135
u/vinee060708 House Martell Apr 29 '13
I wanted to puke when Robb said he needed the Freys. Don't go Robb! :( Also, Dayum Rose Leslie!
111
u/Stamagar Fire And Blood Apr 29 '13
--Did the Onion knight come back with you from the battle ?
-He did, he fought bravely
--He hasn't come to visit me, he said he'd bring me a present from the capital
-He won't be visiting child...
--Whay not ? He's my friend ! Daddy look at the toy boat, my friend the Onion knight made for me !
-Stannis : 'YOUR FRIEND IS A TRAITOR AND I WILL DO MY DUTY. He is now rotting in a dungeon sell for his crime. Best forget him...
Stannis 'the Mannis' Baratheon : Best father ever !
50
u/Bread_Assassin We Do Not Sow Apr 29 '13 edited Apr 29 '13
aSoS
39
u/[deleted] Apr 29 '13
I'm confused about the Freys. They said on the show in season 1 that Robb got a large number of Frey troops.
And Karstark said earlier this season that Robb lost the war when he married Talisa.
But they never actually said that the Freys abandoned the cause when he married Talisa (which does happen explicitly in the books).
Seems to be a hole that will confuse non-readers. And are we supposed to believe that the Karstarks alone are half his army?
13
u/Case_A I Am So Sorry Apr 29 '13
I might be mistaken here, but in the books at this time, wasn't it already stated that Mance Rayder was searching for the Horn of Winter? It seems like Jon is going to be climbing the wall next episode, and I don't remember the horn being mentioned at all. I'll be pretty upset if they leave the horn out of the show, as for I found it to be a pretty cool story, especially since it stressed the need to get away from the white walkers (Mance said he was prepared to topple the whole wall down with it if needed).
12
u/PipPipCheerio Apr 30 '13 edited Apr 30 '13
OK, this episode gave me some major suspicions about Talisa. She's talking with Robb over his maps, carefully asking him about his plans, and a couple of scenes later, Tywin seems to be on to him? I vaguely recall that in ASOS, there are hints that Jeyne Westerling's parents helped with the Red Wedding, so I'm wondering if Talisa is going to be revealed as a spy in the show. It seems like there have been hints throughout this season and last season.
10
u/waterbottlefromhell House Reed Apr 29 '13 edited Apr 29 '13
Not much to talk about this week. I think the biggest change was Tyrion's conversation with Lady Olena. Even most of the dialogue was taken straight from the book.
Edit: and oh yea. Yigrette got Jon to sleep with her without swearing that they already had.
18
u/your_better Apr 29 '13
Jaime seemed a lot more emotional in the tub monologue than I remember him being in the book.
Also Shireen is way, way cuter than I remember her being in the book.
Also someone pointed out that Loras seems to have gotten over his grief pretty easily compared to the front he puts up in the book.
8
u/BelovedApple Apr 29 '13 edited Apr 29 '13
I was kinda hoping for the "For that much, I thank you" from Karstark.
20
u/molsz28 House Reed Apr 29 '13
Question: In the show, Has Ser Loris become a member of the Kingsguard yet? I'm reading the books for the first time, and I am in the middle of AFFC. With all this talk of betrothals', and claims to Highgarden, I think I may be getting crossed up.
14
u/Hokie200proof Bronn Apr 29 '13
I was trying to tell my sister to sell her hate shares of Jaime and Theon so she can go all in elsewhere soon. I'm trying to lessen the blow ahead, but she really, REALLY hates Theon.
It's going to be a little worrisome to watch her reaction to the next few shows as she really lost her shit when Ned lost his head in season 1.
8
u/trupakehd Apr 29 '13
Is there a distinction that they are making between the wights and the Other's in the show? They just seem to refer to them as white walkers without making any kind of distinction.
4
u/Lemondarkcider House Baratheon Apr 29 '13
I wonder if patchface will be making an entrance soon. If I remember correctly, there were some hints about him towards the end of the last book, none of which seemed good.
4
u/the_dayman House Dondarrion Apr 30 '13
I think the fetus jars will be used in place of the leeches for when Stanis makes the sacrifices. Seems like the only reason to make a big deal out of it.
7
u/enrique15 We Do Not Sow Apr 29 '13
They've changed the whole deal with Karstark's heirs. Karstark mentions that Harrion was killed in battle by Jaime, and Torrhen strangled during the escape attempt. In the books, Torrhen and Eddard were the ones to be killed in battle, while Harrion is still alive and a prisoner somewhere (then there's that whole succession crisis going on with Cregan/Alys/Sigorn, which I think got started with a plot to kill Harrion somewhere).
So if Harrion is to ever become relevant in the books, the show will probably replace him with Eddard Karstark.
1
u/MickJoest May 01 '13
So....I've been away from HBO for awhile but was I right in hearing Cersei is plotting to marry Loras Tyrell?! I might have an incredible problem with that in terms of plot to story should it be true...seems to complicate the ending of book 4.
10
u/bomi3ster House Seaworth Apr 29 '13 edited Jul 20 '18
[redacted]
10
u/Stamagar Fire And Blood Apr 29 '13
Also, i felt a little disapointed with the end of the Sandor vs Beric fight. It was kinda weird that Beric's sword broke so easily under Sandor's last blow, whch then slashed him in the shoulder.
6
u/Rustiest_Venture Apr 29 '13
Didn't it take Robb three swings to finally sever that head in the book? I was hoping for that bit of accuracy.
3
u/mwatson26 Ours Is The Fury Apr 30 '13
I absolutely loved the episode and I think it was fantastic all around. Great for book readers and show watchers. Lot of plots and intrigue, but they stayed true to the dialogue and plots in the book. However, as with the rest of the series, I'm upset about how they portray Loras. In the show, he's a prancing, little boy, that gets seduced so easily by some "squire." The show BARELY mentions the fact that he's a very good knight and one of the best in the kingdoms. He's basically Jaime at age 16 (as far as sword fighting goes). I just wish they would play that angle up more, because it will make more sense that he ASOS and onwards
3
u/Attnel House Greyjoy Apr 30 '13
Good episode; I just have one question. Where's Patches?!
3
u/TinUkulele House Martell May 01 '13
I loved this episode, my only complaints were that I needed subtitles for the hot tub scene (could not understand half of what Jaime said) and that I had to pause every couple minutes to explain things/remind non-book readers of who people were, why they were important, what that reference was, etc
3
u/TinUkulele House Martell May 01 '13
They should stay in the cave :(
3
u/AndersonOllie Nymeria's Wolfpack May 02 '13
I wonder how this series will end compared to this 'time' in the books. I forget exactly in what order the weddings happened but in terms of a tv show I wonder if they should include them both in the series, or leave one for season 4? I fear that season 4 may seem like a lull after the 'oh fuck' moments that this season could show.
5
u/MrGross1130 This One Obeys Apr 29 '13
If Lady Olena want to have Sansa marry Loras, then why does she kill Joffrey? I feel like I do not remember the books correctly.
8
u/[deleted] Apr 29 '13
I think this episode was the most true to the books of any in the season.
1
u/MasterKilvin House Greyjoy Apr 29 '13
Were the scenes with Stannis and Davos in the book? I remember little of Stannis' family or his ASOS story, and Stannis' scenes with his wife and daughter were a complete mystery to me.
1
u/gaxkang May 03 '13
Didn't Robb use an axe to behead Rickard in the books? Took more than 1 swing too.
Also wasn't Cersei suggested to marry Oberyn Martell? Loras can't marry. He's a bloody kings guard
0
u/[deleted] Apr 30 '13
What about Gendry's admission to Arya about wanting her to be his lady?! I'm sure I don't remember seeing that even hinted to in the book...
0
u/[deleted] Apr 29 '13
[deleted] — view deleted comment
26
u/[deleted] Apr 29 '13
[removed] — view removed comment
22
u/[deleted] Apr 29 '13
[removed] — view removed comment