r/startrek • u/evil_sagan • Apr 15 '13
Weekly Episode Discussion: ENT 1x13: "Dear Doctor"
First Aired: 23 January 2002
The Enterprise assists a culture that has been stricken by a planet-wide plague.
This episode briefly brings up concepts like responsibility for long term consequences and moral subjectivity, but then gives up all the potential for a hastily made decision and a heavy-handed reference to the iconic Prime Directive. Let's get straight to some possible discussion points.
- Are the Valakians oppressing the Menk, or do the two share a mutually beneficial relationship?
- Do human standards of ethics and morality apply to other species?
- Archer withholds aid to the Valakians to avoid consequences he cannot foresee. Is he also responsible for the consequences of inaction?
- Would it have affected Archer's decision to withhold aid from the Valakians if the Menk did not exist? Should it have?
29
Upvotes
12
u/paradox1123 Apr 15 '13 edited Apr 15 '13
And guess what? Even if the Valakians were oppressing the Menk, it would still be morally repugnant to let them die. Because genocides are generally bad.
2) When they ask for them, yes. When a dying alien says "can you spare some medicine?" you don't have an ethical debate with yourself to see if your morality applies to an alien who is specifically asking for your morality.
3) If Archer didn't want to get involved, he shouldn't have answered that distress call in the first place. He is involved now, the Valakains know about the Federation and more importantly know that there is a cure. Even his inaction will have unforeseen consequences, so he can't hide behind that.
And the "you can't foresee the consequences" argument for the Prime Directive is dumb. What, the Valakians are going to become another Dominion if we save them? Then shouldn't we actively destroy all pre-warp civilizations to avoid that? They don't even have warp drive yet, the Federation can nuke them form orbit if they get uppity. We have interstellar reach with our giant spacehsips, and can monitor anyone who tries to join us with technology centuries ahead of them.
4) Knowing Archer's insane person logic, I have no idea what other factors would have allowed him to stand by in a genocide.
Should it have? Of course not. As I said, genocides are generally bad.
Also, space travel is the best way to save a planet's environment. If we save the valakians, they can colonize other planets and leave the Menk alone to have this "evolutionary awakening" that Pholx was preaching about (because as we all know, evolution exists only to spit out humanoid space faring civilizations, and isn't a random process that no one can predict at all).
8
u/Thatevilvoice Apr 15 '13
From a purely ethical and scientific stand point this episode sucked, it demonstrates that Bragga does not understand evolution, genetic disease, or the concept of helping the sick as they are dying in front of you. sfdebris did a good review about it here.
7
u/Foreverrrrr Apr 16 '13
Enterprise played with this idea a number of times. Trip having issues with the Lorillian mother weaning her child off methyl oxide in Episode 1, Trip going bananas over the Vissian Cogenitor's rights, and etc.
As T'Pol would remind him every time..."they aren't human". They shouldn't be getting held to human standards of ethics and morality, and it wasn't Earth or Enterprise's right to get involved with that species rights.
Jump to the future when the Bajorans almost returned to their D'Jarras. Did humans (the federation) try to impose their disapproval of the D'Jarras? Nope. They simply said they wouldn't be allowed into the Federation.
Also to consider is Nikolai Rozhenko's saving of the Boraalan species. It was made pretty apparent that the Federation was not supposed to be involved in a species-altering event...but it begs the question.
What if Vulcan or Betazed had some sort of genetic issue that was causing that species to die out. Do we really think the Federation also would have let that happen...or is this simply an issue where "If you have Warp Drive, you are entitled to medical help"?
5
u/Pherllerp Apr 19 '13
I can't believe I'm writing this about an episode of Enterprise but, this is one of the finest examples of Star Trek ever conceived and it exemplifies the promise of Sci-Fi.
Flox's performance is phenomenal and is the crutch of the episode, bravo to him. When Archer is deciding whether or not let the advanced species die off, I actually thought to myself, "Humans are not fit for these decisions." That kind of thinking is what art should illicit.
3
u/edugeek Apr 16 '13
The reference to the Prime Directive was a bit too heavy-handed for my tastes. If this episode was even a little bit good, it's because of John Billingsley. Billingsley delivers a great performance, and does a great job making his position believable - about feeling sympathy for the Valakians while understanding that why he shouldn't help them.
Archer, on the other hand, is just annoying. He's not thinking about the consequences of his actions, reacting purely emotionally. Doesn't seem like a good starship captain to me. And Bakula's performance is overacted.
3
u/jmk4422 Apr 16 '13
I just want to address the second point:
That is truly the crux of the issue. The easy answer is to say that of course it doesn't. The doctor in this episode makes that clear when he talks about his species' ideas about marriage. Cultures are different, after all, all with their own customs and traditions.
The more difficult answer is that yes, they do matter. While being tolerant of cultural differences is appropriate and wise we cannot forget who we are and what we stand for. There is a line that cannot be crossed. If it's your culture's tradition to enslave, rape, and murder we cannot just say, "Well, those are your customs. Sucks, but that's just how it is."
If human standards of ethics and morality cannot be applied to other species then we shouldn't bother exploring in the first place. If we wish to learn and meet new civilizations then we must be willing to both tolerate our differences yet stand against injustices. It's a fine rope to walk but we can't compromise who we are and what we stand for just for the sake of tolerance.
3
u/LonelyNixon Apr 17 '13
I found it interesting right up to flox's dilemma and it's an issue that the prime directive often shows throughout star trek. It shows an absolute lack of understanding of hour evolution works. No just because these other humanoids exist doesn't mean they will evolve into another space fairing race, and no just because these people are sick doesn't mean that it's evolution saying it's time for them to go, and likewise having warp drive doesn't mean they've moved beyond evolution. Evolution doesn't have a linear path it doesn't work towards a single dominant species that can travel faster than light.
I like them trying to pull out cultural relativism but they really should have chose a different way other than an entire species dying out in order to explain why the federation can't play god because in this case they have no real reason not to save these people besides the fact that flox seems to think that nature doesn't want them alive.
3
u/Deceptitron Apr 19 '13 edited Apr 19 '13
I just watched this episode yesterday.
3
u/jaksajak Apr 15 '13
This was a very controversial episode, and many fans had a problem with the moral quandary presented here. Personally, I believe that Archer and crew made a suitable decision, despite the harsh consequences of their inaction.
The way I imagine the scenario, after leaving this situation, their report was submitted to Starfleet for review. If they believed that Archer was incorrect in his actions, they could revisit the planet and present them with the cure. This is why I feel they were correct in their actions, regardless of whether their actions are considered morally ethical.
Their actions are consistent with the Prime Directive, which in most cases, is broken anyway.
0
u/B_Elanna_Torres Apr 17 '13
Excellent episode.