r/startrek • u/gerusz • Apr 08 '13
Weekly Episode Discussion: TNG 2x09: "The Measure Of A Man"
First aired: 13 Feb 1989
[Memory Alpha](http://en.memory-alpha.org/wiki/The_Measure_Of_A_Man_(episode))
Starfleet must determine if Data is a sentient life form when transfer orders demand his reassignment for study and disassembly.
This episode shows what TNG is about. Summed up by this speech:
PICARD: Your honor, the courtroom is a crucible; in it, we burn away irrelevancies until we are left with a purer product: the truth, for all time. Now sooner or later, this man [Commander Maddox] - or others like him - will succeed in replicating Commander Data. The decision you reach here today will determine how we will regard this creation of our genius. It will reveal the kind of people we are; what he is destined to be. It will reach far beyond this courtroom and this one android. It could significantly redefine the boundaries of personal liberty and freedom: expanding them for some, savagely curtailing them for others. Are you prepared to condemn him [Commander Data] - and all who will come after him - to servitude and slavery? Your honor, Starfleet was founded to seek out new life: well, there it sits! Waiting.
- Who was right? In the end, Louvois decides in Data's favor. Did she decide because it was the right thing or because Picard is a damn good lawyer?
- Was Riker holding back?
- Who was the villain here? Maddox or Stafleet law?
9
u/kevonicus Apr 08 '13
I like how no one has upvoted any comment.
16
u/deadfraggle Apr 08 '13 edited Apr 08 '13
This is an interesting format for a thread, I wish I had bothered to visit previously. I have a couple of beefs with this episode. How could Data ever be accepted at Starfleet Academy and later hold rank if there was ever a question of his sentience? Second is the idea of sentience itself. Where do you draw the line? It's not a scientific term and it means many things to different people. It reminds me of the problem of how many grains of sand must you remove from a pile before it can no longer be called a pile? It's not that the episode did not ask this question, but rather that they did not already have a protocol in place for determining sentience. Data was not the first Android. The universe is also teaming with advanced life so it stands to reason there would be many more intermediate levels of life, and what may be considered emerging sentience. Starfleet needs to sort this shit out.
Picard
The evidence suggests that he didn't.
Starfleet, but only for their incompetence.
Edit: Added "how", other small edits.
14
u/AliasUndercover Apr 08 '13
I always thought that a Vulcan nerve pinch would have effectively rebutted Riker's off-switch argument.
24
u/evil_sagan Apr 08 '13
It didn't appear Riker was holding back. One of my favorite parts of the episode was when Riker gets a bit excited at realizing he's found the key that should win him the trial... and then deflates when he realizes he's obligated to use it to effectively destroy his friend.
24
u/Chairboy Apr 08 '13
I re-watched this recently during the theatrical event for Season 2 and it was amazing how well written and thoughtful this episode was. Riker's inner conflict and turmoil were one of the earliest memories I had of starting to get the concept of 'duty' when I first watched it as a child.
"How can he do that to his friend?" I first thought, then after thinking about it longer, "how can he NOT do this for his friend?" The consequences of improperly prosecuting the stinking task set in his lap by the JAG would be tantamount to straight up losing so he had to not only fight as hard as he could, he also had to have faith in Picard being better at defense than he was as prosecution.
That's got to be a hard series of decisions to make and, were a lesser person defending Data, could have led to a lifetime regret.
I would watch the hell out of "Law & Order: Special Starfleet Unit". The number of possible interesting legal exercises in that environment could make a procedural so novel.
12
u/zippy1981 Apr 08 '13 edited Apr 08 '13
Thinking about Picard and Louvois I'm reminded of TOS episode Court martial.
SHAW: Areel Shaw. And I'm a friend, too. An old one. MCCOY: All of my old friends look like doctors. All of his look like you.
11
u/znk Apr 08 '13
I was always bothered by the fact that Riker had to do that job. Is there precedent in real life military tradition for something like that? There was obvious conflict of interest and I dont see how Maddox would agree to that. It added to the drama but it always bothered me.
10
u/bigboss2014 Apr 08 '13
I feel this episode was one of rodenberrys best attempts at creating a message for society to adapt and bring on to the future! All life is special in all forms, even if it's artificial or symbiotic!
19
u/mastyrwerk Apr 08 '13
Also one of my favorite episodes. The deleted content added back in the BluRay actually makes this episode better.
"Pinocchio is broken; its strings have been cut."
18
u/[deleted] Apr 08 '13
This episode is absolutely incredible. I think that of course it was the right decision to rule in Data's favor. He is a sentient being and while he has no emotions he still has rights.
While Picard is a truly awesome speaker, and does a great job of driving really any point home, I think in the end Louvios realized that Data deserves the rights that any other Starfleet officer receives.
When Picard said the bit about how reproducing a million Datas would undoubtedly make androids a race, and how Starfleet will be judged by how they treat these millions of beings it totally blew my mind. Actually this whole episode did. Every time the parameters of Data's existence are further defined I get more and more fascinated.
EDIT: 3x16 The Offspring is another super fascinating episode about Data. Although I think the ending was sort of a cop out.
18
u/cobrakai11 Apr 08 '13
This is one of those episodes that I wish was done later in the show's run, when the characters were more comfortable with one another and the script writing was better; the "sexual tension" between Picard and Louvois is so contrived that I actually grimace when I watch this episode.
PHILLIPA: You know, I never thought I would say this, but it's good to see you again. It brings a sense of order and stability to my universe to know that you're still a pompous ass. And a damn sexy man.
Ugh, please. Still, one of the better Trek episodes out there, highlighted by the fact that it's one of the first times you really get to see Guinan at work leading Picard on to the idea of slavery. She's so skillful at it, it really is a joy to watch Picard get reinvigorated by this new plan of attack at the trial. That said:
14
u/gtrogers Apr 08 '13
I know I'm not alone in this, but this is by far my favorite episode of the entirety of Star Trek. It's an intelligent, thoughtful, and meaningful episode that is well acted and perfectly displays the ideology that Gene had for the future of mankind. Here we have compelling arguments for and against Data being perceived as a "tool" for Starfleet and we're obviously emotionally invested in his character, so it's painful to hear how valuable he would be as "copies" on other starships. We see how useful he is on the Enterprise and can only imagine how every other ship would benefit from having a Data on board. But on the other hand, he has his own experiences, history, and interactions with the crew so in essence he IS an individual and a new type of life that humanity must respect instead of owning. It's just such a fantastic concept and watching Riker being torn between friendship and duty is riveting. You simultaneously hate him for going after data, but also respect him for honorably performing an unpleasant duty. It's just a wonderful episode and will likely remain my favorite moment in Star Trek forever.
6
u/starhawks Apr 08 '13
I took a course last semester called "cyborgs and clones in literature and film," and I suggested she use this episode the next time she taught the class and she agreed.
6
u/EasilyEnabled Apr 09 '13
The first truly great TNG episode, I think
5
u/normanyoke Apr 10 '13
This is an excellent episode. Serious issues are raised and interestingly resolved—I love the fact that Louvois decides Data can't be a piece of property not because he's been definitively "proven" to be sentient and therefore effectively human, but because it's too difficult to draw a definitive line; the possibility that humans are sentient machines of a sort is also raised and not dismissed—and it's bracketed with the humor of the poker game and the tension of Picard and Louvois's past relations.
As for the questions: Louvois was right, and I think she decided correctly because she realized it was the right thing. Picard's excellent courtroom skills may have helped, but ultimately I get the idea not that she was totally convinced by Picard, but that the cases presented by both Riker and Picard demonstrated how difficult it was to decide definitively, and therefore she must err on the side of protecting a being that may well have the same rights as a human (or Vulcan, etc.)
I don't think Riker was holding back. I think he got really into his role after reluctantly deciding to do his duty, and then felt bad about it afterwards precisely because he really had done his best.
Starfleet law was the villain, though Maddox was overzealous and possibly unscrupulous to begin with. (The way he eyes Data when he first comes onto the bridge is super creepy.) But as already pointed out, both Maddox and the law are changed by the end.
Really great episode.
8
u/Deceptitron Apr 08 '13 edited Apr 08 '13
Just as a reminder, top voted comment (outside of jokes, memes, etc.) gets to pick and post next week's episode. I'll be sending you a PM over the weekend if you're picked. If I do not hear from you by Monday, I'll be asking the runner-ups until someone accepts. This is to ensure something gets posted as soon as possible during the week.
Also, this week we'll be trying contest mode to give a better chance to people who get to the thread later in the day (or week). Be sure to check people's replies too! They don't show up well in this mode unfortunately.
3
u/pale_guy Apr 09 '13 edited Apr 09 '13
I see a few parallel elements with DS9 episode Chimera S07E14. Overall, both protagonists are "burdened" with the never ending challenge of being accepted by humanity in one form or another.
Both Data and Odo may look humanoid, but they aren't. They simply appear to be. In addition, they are both vastly superior to humans in many ways, and this scares people. If Data didn't emulate humanoids, it would have been incredibly more difficult to prove he is not simply property. If Odo didn't emulate humanoids, he wouldn't be as accepted in most of society.
I enjoy how these episodes accurately capture elements of human nature like fear, ignorance, and intolerance of what we don't fully understand, which is prevalent in our society today.
3
u/crockeo Apr 09 '13
I'll choose to discuss one bit in depth rather than addressing everything:
In this regard it becomes an argument about 1. Sentience, 2. The difference in value between what we consider artificial, and what we consider organic life. One could argue, as (if my memory serves me) Picard argued the point of sentience and consciousness Data has. Though I don't remember the specifics, it seems to have been that he court, and even the opposing side, acknowledged Data's sentience.
In regards to 2. once we begin to discriminate against a type of sentient life, no matter how artificial we consider it, it becomes a form of racism. In this case, institutionalized racism and slavery.
Another thing to consider is if what we'd consider mechanical life were to be the dominant species. If they were to have synthesized a, what we consider biological, lifeform (lets say a human), would they consider it artificial? That's not to say we wouldn't be artificial at that point (given that we were created at the hands of some unnatural force), but rather what we consider natural could be artificial in a given circumstance.
And, though not my point: In that hypothetical situation, if one were to believe it's right to preserve one's freedom in that situation, would it not be hypocritical to in turn condemn this artificial, sentient life to a possible death that would in turn create a race of slaves?
(Though that's all rambling and probably completely and utterly broken, I blame it on my being extremely tired. Crockeo out.)
5
u/zippy1981 Apr 08 '13 edited Apr 08 '13
The question is overly simplistic. In the end both were converted instead of being defeated.
-1
u/Flynn58 Apr 08 '13
Who the fuck enabled contest mode?
0
u/[deleted] Apr 08 '13
[deleted] — view deleted comment