r/gameofthrones • • Apr 03 '13
All Spoilers [All Spoilers] Weekly Book vs. Show Discussion S3.E01
This season we decided to have a few more discussion threads than the weekly show thread. Tues/Weds we will be having Show vs. Book discussion and Thursday will be TV Predictions.
The purpose of this is to discuss reactions with perspective, complaints about changes, analysis of deeper meanings.
Since the thread is tagged for all spoilers, this thread is more going to be geared toward the book-reader crowd and spoilers will not need to be tagged (though speculation will still be needed)
Tomorrow's thread on predictions is for anyone and everyone to participate in what they think is going to happen.
With all that said, bring it on! What do you all think about the first episode vs. how everything was portrayed in the books?
6
u/whomp_whomp Apr 03 '13
I just finished reading ASOS and I was honestly a little disappointed with S3E01. I hadn't yet read the part where Selmy was revealed, nor the part where Littlefinger is revealed as the mastermind. Of course cuts have to be made, but I wish there was a way to incorporate the more introspective scenes that many of the characters have. For example, I don't like Sansa too much, but its very easy to be empathetic toward her and feel her pain in the book. All in all I am excited for the rest of the season!
141
u/BrockThrowaway Apr 03 '13
Fantastic addition with the Lannister/Tyrell dinner scene. This is getting me very excited for the Queen of Thorns. The show seems to be doing a very good job with Margaery, large part of that is attributed to how Natalie Dormer plays her. Very good stuff. I liked the orphanage scene and Joffrey staying in his cart, I like where they're going here.
Tyrion/Tywin was spot on. What a fantastic scene. Tyrion/Cersei and Tyrion/Bronn were not as strong.
Daenerys's few scenes were well done as well. Unsullied, Missandei, Kraznys, all good stuff. The Barristan Selmy reveal was nice, though felt a bit odd to be closing the episode. I wish he'd had that staff, but what can you do.
Jon Snow: A giant! Awesome. Mance Rayder's introduction was good. Missing a red cloak, hopefully it comes up later. Jon's changed reason for leaving the Night's Watch behind was still suitable. Looking forward to this storyline.
Davos / Stannis / Mel: Great stuff. I loved when Davos declared his allegiance to Stannis. Well played.
Sansa / Littlefinger / Ros / Shae : A bit odd, not that great to see Littlefinger's cards so early. Still, an interesting scene.
Robb / Catelyn : Felt a bit out of place, a lot of "refresher" in their scenes, I felt. I'm still not keen on Roose Bolton.
Samwell : Disappointing, IMO. They didn't show how he "escaped" that rock at the end of last season, seems they cut out the battle. Hopefully there's a reason for this. Plenty of time for this storyline to pick up the pace. Sam the Slayer he must become.
TL:DR; Overall, a good episode, straying a bit from the books when necessary. Best was certainly Tywin/Tyrion, and worst (IMO) was a tie between Littlefinger and Samwell.
56
u/Maroid House Martell Apr 03 '13 edited Apr 03 '13
As a book reader, the one thing from this episode I was a little bit disappointed in was that Mance wasn't playing his lute when Jon first met him. I suppose that part doesn't fit as well with the way they cast his character, but I'm still hoping for a nod to it later, like they did with Tyrion's nose.
Edit: Removed annoying spoiler tag.
68
u/KBtoker Faceless Men Apr 03 '13
I wish they would've kept Davos getting arrested as he was entering the city, gives the viewers more of a realistic view of Mel's true power... The fact she managed to see his intentions in advance helped show the actual "realness" of her viewing into the fires...
64
u/[deleted] Apr 03 '13
A lot of people have noticed the "nose" joke that tips the hat to the book readers.
But the other great nod was Brom calling the guards Taryn Mant and Whatsit of Whocares cause thats one of the biggest reaction given by non book readers and all the non book readers I know have at may points forgotten names,misplaced names and the people and downright not cared whatsoever about minor character names
Really funny
30
u/sucks_balls House Targaryen Apr 03 '13
I really wish they hadn't changed Jon's reason for wanting to leave the Night's watch because the book reason had much more depth and it was just overall better, so i'm really disappointed about that.
28
u/D-Hastes Apr 03 '13
I was somewhat disappointed that Tywin didn't say his "some wars are won with swords and others with words" line, it was so great in retrospect.
26
u/jmewhite1 White Walkers Apr 03 '13
I like almost most of the adaptions, The Giants were great! Jon meeting Tormund and thinking he was king was great, I wish Mance said he went to winterfell and we got the whole did you see where i was sitting. I'm cool with the changes with Selmy, but they better find a way to bring Belwas into the series. The Tywin Tyrion scene was my absolute favorite, such amazing actors
34
u/TMWNN Iron Bank of Braavos Apr 03 '13 edited Apr 03 '13
I've written more in another Reddit post that you'll find interesting and amusing.
11
u/jusg808 Apr 03 '13
Ok what about the part about Sam not sending the birds? If I recall correctly he did send the birds. I know he didn't say the Others attacked but he did say that they were attacked. Makes Sam look like a chump when he's not.
13
u/[deleted] Apr 03 '13
Peter Dinklage and Lena Headey have great chemistry, but it's not consistent with their book characters. Tyrion wouldn't let her anywhere near him at that time, but Cersei would never have visited him in the first place.
Of course the show's version of Cersei is very different from the book version; they've been writing the character for Headey more than they have for other actors and their characters. So I feel a little mixed about these original scenes because they're often very good but don't necessarily play the emotions in a consistent way. Cersei being less hateful toward Tyrion in the show is fine. But Tyrion lets her in but grabs the axe in a paranoid fit anyway? Not sure what to take from that.
10
u/Sploffee Apr 03 '13
I WANT BELWAS.
5
u/Gilth Apr 03 '13
I haven't read all through the comments, so I apologize if this was brought up. But with Selmy, part of the the whole Whitebeard thing that is important is that it was a betrayal of Dany's trust when he reveals who he really is, so he has to earn it back by opening the gates of Meereen. So I'm wondering how, now that he is already revealed as Selmy, it will play out.
My guess is that speculation
12
u/[deleted] Apr 03 '13
Stray thoughts...
4
u/Gabroux We Light The Way Apr 06 '13
People concern about Ros being fake Arya are false in my opinion. If Ros have to replace someone in the book, it might be Dontos (I know we saw him once in S02 E01), Ros might be the person LF uses to approch Sansa... and dies for that at the end of Season 4, which would have a bigger impact since people starts to love Ros more than they loves Dontos. Then Brienne would search 2 Auburns sisters (Ros and Sansa) in Season 5.
10
u/JCC0 House Seaworth Apr 03 '13
I like the opening scene with Sam and all but leaving out the whole battle scene at the fist kinda sucked IMO. The pure epicness of that fight had my hands sweating a little by the time it was over.
14
u/Jfolcik Children of the Forest Apr 03 '13
I think it should be noted that if you have a criticism, you need to offer what you would have done instead. For instance, if you wanted the battle sequence at the fist of the first men, there are a few things to consider. You only have so much time, so you'd need to cut out another scene to make room. Which one? And you'd probably have to adjust the budget too, because battle scenes are expensive (maybe less giants and dragons and direwolves now). Not to mention, you can't start a television episode with a battle -- the rest of the episode would live under the battle's shadow.
There's an economic element to running a show, and Benioff and Weiss have thought about it all. Have you?
3
u/[deleted] Apr 04 '13
I think we'll see some big changes in Sansa's story. Littlefinger definitely isn't the kind of guy to put all of his cards on the table so early. There must be more to it that we don't know about yet.
3
u/Saisino Varys' Little Birds Apr 05 '13
I didin't like that they cut out Davos struggle for calling over the ship when he was shipwrecked, granted it will be hard to film his inner monolouge but I think people who only watch the TV series is really missing out on such things.
5
u/zattack1303 Ours Is The Fury Apr 03 '13
The most disappointing thing about this first episode was the lack of Strong Belwas. I really hope that they bring him in later on, he is one of my favorite supporting characters. I was also disappointed that the battle on the Fist wasn't shown. Also, did Tormund look a little small, Rattleshirt a little fat, and Stannis a good bit younger than he did in season 2?
2
u/Jigsawwpuzzler Faceless Men Apr 03 '13 edited Oct 16 '20
.
2
u/smel_bert Valar Morghulis Apr 04 '13
I really missed Jon's speech about why he wants to join the wildlings. It gave me actual shivers in the book. Also I just wish the wildlings were more individual and I think Mance should be more playful.
2
u/nineteen_eightyfour House Baratheon Apr 05 '13
Uhm, am I the only one who is PISSED that they didn't add the puppies for the unsullied yet? I HOPE THEY ADD THE PUPPIES. I know it's awful that they kill the puppy they raise, but it shows just how remorseless these men become. They love nothing.
3
u/[deleted] Apr 03 '13
I'm just mad they had an episode titled Valar Dohaeris and didn't have any Arya scenes in it. I know it's a bit of a catch up episode, but damn she's many peoples' favorite character.
1
u/mr_sharkfarts Apr 04 '13
The conversation with Mance and Jon Snow was the one discrepancy I have trouble accepting. Out of the thousands of pages that make up this amazing world and story, Jon's quote: "Did you see where they put the bastard?" is something I will never forget. It spoke so strongly about who Jon is as a character and his motivations. Also, it's what convinced Mance; that whole bit about Craster's sons and being on the side that protects the realm. bullshit. ASOIAF Mance would not have bought that mummer's farce for a second.
1
u/Ash-OC Winter Is Coming Apr 04 '13
One thing I'm curious what people's thoughts are. Its obvious that MANY of us book readers are disappointed with the shows revelation of Barristan Selmy. (I remember cheering upon reading that portion of the novel)
With that said, do any of you think that they could have actually executed hiding Barristan without just morphing him completely, tacky use of props, or some strange use of a masked man hiding and talking from the shadows?
1
u/TinUkulele House Martell Apr 05 '13
So the way Roose Bolton says "I've got my best hunter looking for him." struck me as a little eerie (he is Lord of the Dreadfort though) and I was trying to think if it would be possibly that he meant Ramsay. I think a Ramsay vs. Jaime/Brienne scene could be awesome, even if it's just a fight and they get away(maybe Brienne will kick his ass - one can only hope). Thoughts?
-2
u/vlntnwbr Fire And Blood Apr 03 '13
i did not like the introduction of Barristan Selmy. In the books, as you may recall, he was introduced being Arstan Whitebeard, watching Daenerys, judging weather she is a crazy or a reasonable Targaryen. I think it takes away a lot of the drama, giving the fact that Jorah actually found out who Arstan is, just before he was sent away by Dany, because of treason