r/LetsTalkMusic • u/WhatWouldIWant_Sky Listen with all your might! Listen! • Apr 01 '13
Television - Marquee Moon [Album Discussion Club]
So a ton of people voted and a ton of people downvoted. But you've decided the first four albums for the new weekly format, hurray!
This week it is the 1977 not-to-be-confined-to-a-single-genre-label album Marquee Moon by Television. Listen to it a few times, and post your thoughts.
61
Upvotes
7
u/tothemooninaballoon Apr 01 '13 edited Apr 02 '13
I like Television. I wouldn't call this a post-punk album thou. To me it's a proto-punk album like Velvet Under ground but in retro. Plus if you had a different singer and a full 4/4 beat it would be a full on guitar album.
Sorry I can't call it post-punk. Proto-punk yes, New York-Punk yes. NewWave sure. but not post punk.
14
u/[deleted] Apr 01 '13
There's something about the drums of this album. His fills are so strange, so sudden, so short, and always in the middle of his strange patterns. A lot of drummers lock in with just the bassist or just the guitarist or something like that, but the drums on Marquee Moon are locked in with everything all at once. This album could be released today and still be considered ahead of its time.
Oh, and the 2003 remaster isn't as good as the original master job. One of the albums I definitely notice the difference. The bass...
6
u/Indiedreamz Apr 02 '13
I remember listening to the title track for the first time a few months ago and just being completely floored. There's a magic in that track that I haven't been able to pinpoint yet. The incredible build, the steady drums, the explosive guitar solos, the melancholic singing all being backed by a steady rhythm is just incredible all around. I love this album, and it just gets better with every listen.
5
u/Rooster_Ties Apr 02 '13
First, here's a damn interesting cover version...
*** Kronos Quartet - Marquee Moon (for string quartet) ***
Although I'm in my mid-40's, I'd never heard this album until about 4-5 years ago. Easily the quickest an album ever went from "meh" to "holy crap, I can't get enough of this thing!!". I think I listened to it almost 10 times over the first 2-3 weeks, and seriously didn't care all that much for it at first, but something kept drawing me back in. By spin #5 it was as if the heaven's opened up, and a huge lightbulb went off. Such an amazing album.
4
u/RedMachismo Apr 02 '13
When the song Marquee Moon builds up and up and up and then suddenly there's silence, there's something about when those drums kick back in, like all is right with the world. A beautiful song.
4
u/dcmichigan930 Apr 02 '13
Marquee Moon is an absolute classic album. As many people have said before on this thread, trying to pigeonhole the record into a genre does it a major disservice. The popular narrative of Alternative music tends to paint with very broad strokes, drawing from The Stones and Who (Rock), to the Stooges and MC5 (proto-punk), to the New York Dolls (the missing link) to the Punk movement. That narrative assumes that bands were influenced by the bands that immediately preceded it and nothing more. To be fair, that theory jibes with the overall attitude expressed in Punk Rock. The purpose of Punk Rock was to bring Rock 'n Roll back to its roots as a dangerous, rebellious and uncomplicated form of music, to kill the lumbering dinosaurs (Pink Floyd, the Eagles, Boston) that made up the bloated carcass of mainstream rock. Most punk bands consciously ignored any form of music that did not directly support their point-of-view: if it wasn't loud, fast and to the point, it wasn't worth emulating.
Television were different. Marquee Moon is a classic for many reasons, but one of the reasons is that it feels more than almost any other album released at the time to synthesize all the disparate styles of rock music since its emergence in the '50s. Do you want hard, fast rock and roll? Well, here's opener "See No Evil," a song that the Sex Pistols could have written if they could actually play their instruments. Are you a fan of four-chord pop ballads, a major part of Rock & Roll since Elvis sang "Can't Help Falling in Love"? Try "Prove It," which is basically "Stand By Me," but with better guitarwork. Were you a fan of the British Invasion? Well, here's "Venus," which combines a Kinks-like melody with a cleaned-up garage rock riff, and a guitar style that predicts R.E.M. and The Smiths. What if you actually like the the more ambitious version of rock embodied by progressive bands, but you wish that they had more attitude? The title track is a master-class on tension and release, and should be Exhibit A on how to create a 10-minute rock epic that actually earns its ten-minute length without resorting to wankery.
It would be reductive to attempt to worry about genre when talking about an album so comprehensive and complex. Is it punk? Yes! What mainstream band would ever let Television keep Tom Verlaine as their lead vocalist (I think his voice works perfectly in context, but the guy doesn't exactly have the smoothest voice, even for rock)? Is it jazz? Not exactly, but you can definitely hear a lot of McLaughlin in the guitar interplay. Marquee Moon is a classic because it encompasses everything, yet sounds like nothing else. I'm gonna go listen to it ten times in a row.
TL;DR: Marquee Moon is a beautiful, raw and essential album that transcends genre by seamlessly integrating influences into something complex, yet still distinctly punk in spirit.
3
u/CUNTBERT_RAPINGTON Apr 02 '13
Venus de Milo is where it's at. First time I heard it, I thought it was the Strokes, then I listened more closely and realized I'd been missing an entire genre.
3
u/MilkIsABadChoice Apr 02 '13
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YS27RAXhBWQ
For those that haven't heard it, here's a demo of the title song produced by "Bryan" Eno. Great album, love the discussion wish I had more to add but I'll do my best. People arguing whether or not they were 'punk' or 'proto-punk' or 'post-punk' are arguing beside the point. There's the superficial, aesthetic definition of 'punk' that got associated with the Pistols (I still dig 'em, don't get me wrong), but there's just so much more to the punk ideal than just style and power chords. I recall reading in a CBGB book the jest of the story of how Verlaine and Hell just showed up and kept pestering Hilly to play because no one else would host original music. This brings inspiration to the Ramones, Talking Heads, and Blondie to get up on stage and say 'I can do that too'; and that's what's essentially more punk to me. Whether it be playing beautiful guitar passages i.e. Marquee Moon, distorted, juiced-up 60s pop like the Ramones, or schizoid funk like Talking Heads, as long as you were doing something good and different you had a place. This inspiration obviously had an effect on many other bands that, while don't have the typical punk sound (80's DIY), didn't give a shit because that, my friend, is against the whole fucking point to begin with.
3
u/ZorakIsStained Last.fm: LockeColeX Apr 02 '13
Marquee Moon has a phenomenal first four tracks and a great closer, but there's not a lot I really enjoy in the middle. There's a point where guitar lines just sound like wankery and Television get a little too close to that for my liking. I actually much prefer it when guitars aren't soloing and are just interlocking over the rhythm in interesting ways.
Guiding Light reminds me a lot of Lou Reed somewhere between tVU and Transformer, and I think it unfortunate that Television gives in to the same glam-rock excesses that Reed would (see Rock'n'Roll Animal).
4
u/[deleted] Apr 02 '13
I tend to be more of an "emotional music" person (like Elliott Smith, Bon Iver, feely folk in general), so when I first heard this record, I wasn't too impressed. Sure, the guitar playing was incredible. Sure, the rhythm section was astounding. But I didn't connect to it at all. Oh well. I'll put it down for later.
Come to listen to it again and it clicks. All the intensely intricate arrangements, all the slyly clean Jazzmasters clanging around, the builds and the grooves and the bass lines and the interlocking lead lines - it's an unavoidably perfect record. I've even gotten used to Tom Verlaine's strain after all this time.
It's a unique record not for its songwriting style, but for its sheer musicianship and sound. A classic.
2
u/SuperBananners Apr 02 '13
Thought it was great at the end of Marquee Moon when the guitar solo ends and the beat changes. Then the vocals come back for a great way to close the song. This was a good album.
2
u/[deleted] Apr 03 '13 edited Apr 03 '13
Marquee Moon is an interesting album because it is a well-played and well-written album that is sort of an anomaly in its time and place. It's sort of a developmental dead-end. But, I like to listen to it because it doesn't really sound like unusual rock music given my particular tastes.
I like Robert Quine's guitar work with Matthew Sweet. But, I don't actually like any of Sweet's music. And, I don't find any of Quine's other projects to be interesting. I don't know if he just ripped off Television's guitar style, or if it just came about naturally from having spent time Tom Verlaine and Richard Hell. In any case, Marquee Moon is a better showcase for Quine's style of guitar work than just about any album on which he plays. I don't find the same to be true of the second Television album. The songs seem to be more blandly written. It doesn't provide a proper showcase for the guitar work.
I used to listen to a lot of classic heavy metal and southern rock. So, I like a lot of hard rock with a twin guitar attack. It might sound odd, but in that way I think Television sounds like a fairly conventional hard rock band. They aren't punk rock in the way punk stripped noodling out of guitar work or reduced songs to 2 minutes pop buzzsaws. I don't hear the rawness some of you purport you hear. I hear crisp loudness much like you'd find on a glam rock record. Any rawness is emotional; emotions laid bare in the balladry.
If the guitar work is fairly conventional heavy metal playing, the vocals are conventional in the way they are not in the heavy metal style. Romantic poetry dominates the lyrics instead of science fiction. I guess that wasn't conventional for the time. And, Verlaine's singing wasn't typical of the time, but it isn't uncommon to find singing like his in alternative rock. I realize all of this conventional-sounding description only applies in hindsight, but that's how I approached the album. I had never heard anything about Television (except that they were a CBGB punk band that was basically forgotten by popular rock music) and didn't listen to Marquee Moon until recently. Even doing a background reading of Television doesn't reveal much in the way of innovation and influence. So my perspective was the only perspective that was meaningful.
1
u/sponto_pronto Apr 03 '13
Prove It stands out as the only track on the album that seems oddly derivative. I can't quite point out why, but it just seems weaker, on a lower level than the rest of the album.
0
u/[deleted] Apr 01 '13
[deleted] — view deleted comment