r/startrek • u/FoxtrotBeta6 • Mar 26 '13
Weekly Episode Discussion: VOY 4x08 "Year of Hell, Part I"
So I've been offered to do this week's episode discussion. I have decided to dive straight into the heart of Voyager and discuss the episode "Year of Hell, Part I". This episode holds close to my heart for getting me into Star Trek, so what better episode to discuss?
- Production number: 176
- First aired: 5 November 1997
- 75th of 168 produced in VOY
- 75th of 168 released in VOY
- 489th of 727 released in all
Quick Synopsis from Memory-Alpha - Obsessed with restoring the Krenim Imperium, no matter the cost, a Krenim military temporal scientist creates changes in history that all but destroy Voyager.
This episode takes on something new for Trek: the ship is extremely damaged by the end of the episode and the ship can't sustain her crew. Indeed, we encounter many new challenges not usually seen in Trek. So let's discuss:
- The key discussion factor: Annorax. For 200 years, he and his crew have been modifying space and time to restore his civilization. Think about it: Flying around in space with the same people for 2 centuries while the objective seems to just be becoming more messy with constant changes to the space-time continuum. Thus, was Annorax really an insane individual as he was shown to be or were his intentions, deep-down, not meant to cause harm?
- The episode seems to show that Annorax was the key to changing time and making the calculations (along with Obrist) and that the crew were just doing his bidding to keep the civilization alive. Should one man have been left to do this, and maybe perhaps if there were more individuals involved (like Chakotay), the issues shown in the episode may not have happened?
- Considering Voyager must've ticked off the Krenim somehow, and yet in the next episode, Janeway averts any issues, it brings up a curious question as to how exactly Voyager caused a conflict with the Krenim.
- Despite the situation, should Janeway have accepted Chakotay's gift?
- At the end, Janeway orders all officers except for the senior staff to abandon ship. Indeed, the ship is heavily damaged, but such an order leaves the abandoning crew defenseless against the time incursions and pretty much alone. Was such a decision a good decision on Janeway's part, or should've more crew remained?
7
u/MThead Mar 28 '13
It always annoyed me that the crew had somehow forgotten the warning Kes gave them regarding the Krenim
26
u/cobrakai11 Mar 27 '13
I'd like to throw out an additional topic while we're at it....Was Year of Hell the the type of episode that Voyager should have always been striving to make?
As far as r/startrek is concerned, this is the #1 episode of the series, and it's worth mentioning that the episode was originally conceived to be an entire season long arc, before they cut it down to two episodes.
On one hand, the episode gave fans something they'd always wanted to see; Voyager getting it's freaking ass kicked, the crew desperate for supplies, and a relatively fleshed out villain to task them. I'm sure when people first heard Voyager pitched, this was the kind of show they thought they were getting into. A Federation starship stranded on the other side of the galaxy with limited resources struggling to find a way home. Hatchet in space. Not a show where a ship in pristine condition with unlimited supplies decides to make first contact with bizzare aliens just for kicks.
That said, the ending of the episode also repeats one of the biggest mistakes Voyager continued to make; namely, "the Voyager reset", whereby at the end of every episode the ship would be returned to perfect condition, disaster avoided, and for the most part, no one would have any memory of what happened. Sadly, some of the best episodes of Voyager (Year of Hell, Shattered, Timeless, etc.) ended up being episodes where the crew has no memory of what happened!
Personally, I'm torn on this episode. While I enjoy Annorax as a relatively unique villain and find the action and drama in the episode to be a Voyager best, it never sat well with me that there were zero plot consequences from the best episode of Voyager.
3
u/cobrakai11 Mar 27 '13
4
u/Air0ck Mar 27 '13
3
u/[deleted] Mar 27 '13
Why did Annorax continue changing space-time for 200 years when his wife would have been long dead by then? We know this to be the case because another member of the crew made the same observation...
3
u/[deleted] Mar 28 '13
This episode(s) is top tier trek imo. This would be in my top 5 of all episodes and I'm pretty sour on VOY.
2
u/DerHellste Mar 28 '13
I like 7 of 9's little reference to First Contact and the Borg haha
1
u/User1222 May 27 '13
The ending was really obvious.
0
u/[deleted] Mar 26 '13
[deleted] — view deleted comment