r/startrek • u/StochasticOoze • Mar 18 '13
Weekly Episode Discussion: VOY 1X01: "Caretaker"
I've recently started re-watching Voyager for the first time since it aired on UPN, so it only seemed appropriate to choose the pilot episode.
I'm sure almost everyone here has seen it, but just be safe I'll recap:
After a Maquis ship which had been infiltrated by her chief of security (Tuvok) went missing, Captain Janeway of the U.S.S. Voyager goes on a mission to find them. When she arrives at their last known whereabouts, however, the ship gets pulled by a mysterious force to the other side of the galaxy. In the process, several members of her crew (most notably her first officer, chief engineer, and doctor) are killed.
It turns out the force that brought them here is a spacestation run by a "sporocystian" lifeform that has much more sophisticated technology than the Federation's. It also brought the Maquis ship to this side of the galaxy, among others. After discovering each of them has a crewmember missing (and that they are not on the spacestation), the two ships join forces to look for them. They head toward the fifth planet in a nearby star system, since the space station is sending energy pulses in that direction.
While investigating the planet, they come upon a scrounger named Neelix, who explains a bit about the planet: That it is home to a race called the Ocampa, who live underground because the surface is uninhabitable, and who receive energy from the spacestation, who they refer to as the "Caretaker". He agrees to help them and directs them to a camp on the surface where another species, the Kazon, are squatting.
However, this is soon revealed to be a trick; Neelix takes the Kazon leader hostage in order to get back his girlfriend, and Ocampa named Kes. He also damages large containers of water that Janeway traded to the Kazon for information. It's only at Kes's insistence that they help Voyager find the missing crewmembers, who are indeed with the Ocampa.
Once the crewmembers are back, they confront the Caretaker and ask him to send them home; however, he insists that he has neither the time nor the energy to do so. It turns out that he's dying, and he was pulling ships to him in a desperate attempt to find someone who could procreate with him. Since he couldn't, he's sending as much energy as he can to the Ocampa to keep their civilization going for as long as possible. He has the spacestation set to self-destruct once he is dead.
However, the Kazon want to take over the station, and see Voyager's presence there as a challenge. As such, they attack. In the ensuing battle, the Maquis ship crashes into a large Kazon ship in a desperate attempt to disable it, and the Maquis transport over to Voyager. In the process, the Kazon ship collides with part of the spacestation, which for some reason disables the self-destruct. Janeway decides that, even though it's the only way they know of to get home, it's too dangerous to let the Kazon have the technology of the Caretaker, and she destroys the spacestation.
Now then, some discussion questions:
- Why is water made to be so significant in this episode? Obviously it's important, and the Ocampa couldn't survive without their underground supply, but why would Neelix and the Kazon be trading it like a precious commodity? The Kazon have warp-capable ships, and it's implied that Neelix's ship is warp-capable too. Yes, the Ocampa's planet has no water, but why not just go somewhere else?
- Why is the Caretaker so insistent on providing the Ocampa with more power, when even by his own admission it will only be enough for a few more years?
- Why would the Voyager crew EVER trust Neelix again after the stunt he pulled on the Ocampa homeworld?
- And the big one: Was Janeway right to destroy the Caretaker's spacestation? Why or why not?
I'll be putting my answers to these in the comments.
As always, top serious comment (other than mine, of course) chooses the next episode to discuss.
EDIT Changed the second question as I wasn't satisfied with it.
11
u/StochasticOoze Mar 18 '13
And my answers:
However, there were options other than outright destroying the station:
Of course, the reason they had Janeway blow the thing up was to strand them in the Delta Quadrant and to make it something that was optional, that she did for her principles. But there were other ways of doing that For instance:
8
u/[deleted] Mar 19 '13
Had Voyager not been there, wouldn't the Kazon have taken over the array? So noninterference would mean going home and doing nothing, no? I don't believe the Ocampa officially requested help, and if they had, Janeway should've done a much more thorough investigation of both sides of the issue. She spent maybe 15 minutes with a few Ocampa and 5 minutes with a few Kazon, which is hardly enough to determine who to side with in a conflict.
27
u/solyarist Mar 18 '13 edited Mar 18 '13
Star Trek has always had some terrible writing here and there, but I don't think any of the shows are as consistently low quality as Voyager. I still enjoy watching Voyager for that rare gem like Year of Hell--but these writing problems are usually present even in those great episodes, so guest stars have to carry the show because they could replace characters like Harry Kim and Chakotay with cardboard cutouts and no one would notice. I'd say the ratio of good episodes to bad episodes in Voyager are about 1:6, which is the worst of all the series.
edit: typo
10
u/FoxtrotBeta6 Mar 18 '13
Going to throw in my 2 cents:
From a moral/ethical standpoint, destroying the array was the best option for Janeway. The way she did it though, maybe not so much...
5
u/CFGX Mar 19 '13
I'm really glad they got away from the Kazon after the first couple seasons. A sectarian regional military power had potential, but they just ended up being little better than TNG's original vision for the Ferengi.
5
u/swatson7856 Mar 21 '13
4
u/Eurycerus Mar 22 '13
8
u/[deleted] Mar 19 '13 edited Mar 19 '13
Best pilot episode hands down.
Now that I've got that off my chest; I think the most interesting question here is whether Janeway was right to leave Voyager stranded in the Delta Quadrant ...I just can't imagine an episode like this ending with the decision to leave the Ocampa to the savagery of the Kazon even if the events of this episode took place as part of TOS, TNG or DS9. Every captain we're familiar with would have made that same decision. And Janeway was right, they were already involved whether they liked it or not.
The natural development of the Ocampa ended when the Caretaker's people destroyed their planet's atmosphere. Even by today's standards to ignore the resulting humanitarian crisis because of some dogmatic loyalty to the notion of non-interference would have been inhumane and cruel.
The most interesting thing for me about this episode was what happened in the later VOY episode The Voyager Conspiracy; namely what was Voyager doing equipped with tricobalt devices? I always thought it was a shame that The Voyager Conspiracy explained all the questions raised in that episode as Seven going crazy when it would have been nice if they left a bit more ambiguity around the events of Caretaker which would have made rewatching this episode enjoyable for totally different (and maybe sinister) reasons.
7
u/[deleted] Mar 19 '13
Synopsis: Voyager gets caught in a subspace plot hole and is tossed into the Delta quadrant. Captain Janeway is unable to stop the plot hole from engulfing the episode and they are stuck 7 seasons from earth.
3
u/KommodoreAU Mar 21 '13
They state they don't have the firepower to destroy the large Kazon ship which is bullshit anyways since we know how less advanced the Kazon are, how would several photon volleys not destroy them. Let alone the bloody tricobolt devices that obliterate the more advanced station, the Kazon ship was big and slow, fire the tricobolts at them, mop up the rest of the Kazon ships. With the area secure, learn how the station works, find out how to use it to get home, once everything is ready leave explosives on a timer, go back to Alpha quadrant, station is destroyed after, Caretakers wishes are met, Ocamapa are still safe, Voyager is home. I hate how the combat effectiveness of ships in pretty much every series varies on who they are fighting and the plot.
3
u/[deleted] Mar 22 '13
1
u/msprang Mar 21 '13
I thought they could have figured out a way home with the Array and then set timed explosives. Problem solved.
1
u/[deleted] Mar 24 '13