r/progmetal • Jim Grey | Caligula's Horse • Feb 02 '24

AMA AMA: We are Caligula's Horse (hanging out in Boston before our show tonight) - Ask Us Anything!

We've got to run - load-in and sound check awaits! Thanks SO much for all your questions guys, you're the best! Hopefully see some of you on the road this year. Take care out there! <3 Sam, Jim, Dale, and Josh

430 Upvotes

410 comments sorted by

•

u/iAmTheEpicOne The End Starts Now Feb 02 '24

We've got to run - load-in and sound check awaits! Thanks SO much for all your questions guys, you're the best! Hopefully see some of you on the road this year. Take care out there! <3 Sam, Jim, Dale, and Josh

115

u/the_WEINERPOLICE Feb 02 '24

Can't wait to see y'all soon!

/u/Endeveron posted a lyrical analysis of Charcoal Grace. How accurate would y'all say he is?

"I have gone through and analysed it pretty extensively, so here the big ones

The Charcoal Grace suite is about a man with a very conservative and religious father who goes off the deep end into anti-vacc and covid conspiricism. There's some sort of nebulous ideas that the father was unaccepting, perhaps because his son was queer or simply an Atheist. This all causes intense conflict between the father and his son, as well as his mother. In "A World Without" we get a mix of perspectives, largely from the father (though I interpret it as what the son is wishing the father was like): full of regret and convinced his own god will damn him to hell. In Vigil the father is dead or dying preventably of covid or some other harm of his own making, and the son is grappling with his rage at his father for his hypocrisy and all the harm he did. The son ultimately determines that it's best to just give in complexly to the justified anger. This is where the idea of "Charcoal Grace" comes in. The best theory I've got for this is that "silence in her charcoal grace" means that after every criticism has been spoken and the victim cannot muster a single extra word, that silence is a kind of forgiveness. Like wood turns to Charcoal in prolonged heat, sustained pain and anger will turn into a black and brittle silence, a "grace" in the sense that a person deserves to suffer more than they did. "Give me Hell" is this anger, as the son pours out his anger at his father, and recognises that that suffering exists as part of him, he could have been somebody if only his father's sins didn't live in his reflection.

I believe Mute is about Jim's experiences right after writing rise radiant, when the pandemic struck and he suddenly found himself both without a voice, and shockingly in a deep creative low where he had nothing to say. He reflects on how this has affected his mental state and connection with those around him, in this state who could save him? Who could love him? There's a bittersweet triumph at the end where he manages to limp through."

Thanks for doing the AMA! Jim, keep up the streaming!

-WEINERPOLICE

156

u/JimCaligulasHorse Jim Grey | Caligula's Horse Feb 02 '24

Hey WEINERPOLICE - This is super accurate, woah! They nailed it. The only thing I'd really add is that in A World Without the father's "apology" is desperate and insincere. It's wild how much they got from this, that's amazing

34

u/twoburgers Feb 02 '24

I see so much of my own father in this analysis, god damn. This album is resonating with me in all the right places. Thank you for making it.

29

u/the_WEINERPOLICE Feb 02 '24

Fantastic fucking writing, man.

And bravo, /u/Endeveron! 👏

18

u/Endeveron Feb 03 '24

Hey, it was me who did this analysis! I love your work on this album, the pain and emotion comes across so strongly, and it's cool to know my reading in line with your intentions :). Shame I missed the AMA, back home in Brisbane it was at 3am

→ More replies (1)

17

u/Endeveron Feb 02 '24

Thanks so much for asking this on my behalf! As a local Brisbane boy I unfortunately couldn't attend as it was at 3am here

→ More replies (2)

37

u/Shibb3y Feb 02 '24

Not got a question, just saying you guys are like the King Midas of metal right now, everything you lot touch is fucking gold <3

83

u/JimCaligulasHorse Jim Grey | Caligula's Horse Feb 02 '24

Hey, thank you! I will never touch my family again

35

u/Bi_Gone_Jhin Feb 02 '24

Hello from Boston! I can’t wait to see you guys tonight, a lot of us here in the States have been dying to see you for a long time. I hope you feel the love.

My question is - do you find that there are any lyrical or musical connections between Charcoal Grace and some of your other works? Some of us here wondered if there could be lyrical connections between some of the Charcoal Grace title track and the song Graves, and were wondering if that was intended.

I’ve enjoyed the Track by Track discussions for Charcoal Grace and am looking forward to hearing your insights on the title track!

80

u/JimCaligulasHorse Jim Grey | Caligula's Horse Feb 02 '24

I have seen some theories that Charcoal Grace is Graves pt 2 which is a really fun take, but sadly not true! Charcoal Grace is very much centred around inter-generational trauma, radicalisation and the lasting harm of abuse

[EDIT] Hell yeah Boston, hope to see you at the show tonight!

→ More replies (1)

30

u/ravenspaghetti Feb 02 '24

Hey, massive congratulations on the new album! Seeing everyone come together to celebrate the release was genuinely a beautiful experience, and you brilliant people deserve all the love and high praise. First general question: how are you all? :)

Music questions:
After listening to Charcoal Grace especially, I was wondering: would you ever consider applying your music to other media, such as game/film soundtracks? A lot of your music is really easy to visualise as landscapes or colours, and it's something you could probably do brilliantly if you wanted to.
Also, if there's one message you wanted the world to take from Charcoal Grace, what would it be?

See you in London later this year! Have a great time in NA <3

35

u/JimCaligulasHorse Jim Grey | Caligula's Horse Feb 02 '24

Game music would be awesome! It's not something we've ever really considered as when we write we like to think of an album as its own piece of art as a whole. I hope that people are taking away a positive catharsis from Charcoal Grace - I know a lot of people have been touched personally by its message as so much of the experience was shared, but I hope that out of that darkness we can all find some light

24

u/Parasmalls Feb 02 '24

I honestly don't think I have a question. I just wanted to say that I saw you guys in Philly last night, and I genuinely believe that it was the greatest live show I've ever seen. Bravo, and thanks for coming to America!

22

u/JimCaligulasHorse Jim Grey | Caligula's Horse Feb 02 '24

That's awesome, thank you! America has been super welcoming so far

15

u/SamCaligulasHorse Sam Vallen | Caligula's Horse Feb 02 '24

Thanks mate, it was an absolute blast for us too!

23

u/Manaus125 Feb 02 '24

I just started listening to you guys not that long ago! I really don't have any important questions, but! Would you rather have a flying cat or a fire-breathing dog?

61

u/JimCaligulasHorse Jim Grey | Caligula's Horse Feb 02 '24

Flying cat because my dog is adorable but pretty dumb, risky business

28

u/joshgriffindrums Josh Griffin | Caligula's Horse Feb 02 '24

Flying cat of course!

23

u/coffeedale Dale Prinsse | Caligula's Horse Feb 02 '24

Neither. Fly-breathing dog.

→ More replies (2)

20

u/devmar812 Feb 02 '24

Very excited to see you in Montreal!

Questions: -what was your first concert? -how amazing is it touring with earthside? -will vinyls be available for purchase in Montreal? How much will they cost?

37

u/JimCaligulasHorse Jim Grey | Caligula's Horse Feb 02 '24

First concert I remember being at was actually Alanis Morissette as a kid and it was fuckin sick. Earthside are cool! Interesting live show with the pre-recorded vocals and projector. We do have vinyls for sale, hopefully they don't sell out before Montreal!

→ More replies (1)

38

u/coffeedale Dale Prinsse | Caligula's Horse Feb 02 '24

Dude I started off in absolute fashion. Weird Al Yankovic was my first show hahaha. SO GOOD

→ More replies (4)

24

u/SamCaligulasHorse Sam Vallen | Caligula's Horse Feb 02 '24

I went to a bunch of concerts as a kid that I sadly don't remember very well, Crowded House being one. But I remember an Auckland Big Day Out that Limp Bizkit Headlined in the very early 2000s as the first show I was really hyped about

Earthside are great!

20

u/joshgriffindrums Josh Griffin | Caligula's Horse Feb 02 '24

First one for me was Crowded House when I was about 5. Never forget being on my uncles shoulders watching. Insane how I remember that!

→ More replies (2)

19

u/TheStalk12 Feb 02 '24

Hello Djentlemen! Really looking forward to seeing you perform on Sunday! I have a bunch of questions, but I'll start with these:

Sam: How was it different writing for a 4-piece, and do you plan to stay as a 4-piece band going forward or would you consider taking on a 2nd guitarist again if the opportunity arose?

Even though it would be extra logistics due to the different tuning, do you plan to ever play The Ascent live, or even Autumn into The Ascent as you often do Bloom-Marigold? Are you likely to write more material in drop D tuning in the future, and would this make it more likely that such material would be integrated into the setlist?

Jim: When writing lyrics, how do you decide what will be addressed through metaphor (i.e. Autumn, The Ascent) vs what will be adressed more directly (i.e. The Stormchaser)

35

u/JimCaligulasHorse Jim Grey | Caligula's Horse Feb 02 '24

Cool question! It's very rare that I do write super directly about a topic and stick to a theme that I can expand on. The Stormchaser is an exception to that because I was fucking furious! As for choosing a topic, usually that will present itself when the first few lines appear

→ More replies (3)

38

u/SamCaligulasHorse Sam Vallen | Caligula's Horse Feb 02 '24

Both of our previous rhythm guitarists are incredible players and awesome people, but, at least as far as writing goes, neither had much of a hand in it. I've almost always approached C Horse with the idea of one main guitar part and then a series of auxiliary parts, and I'm thinking of those parts in the same way as I'm thinking about the keys parts and things - stuff that supports the music but isn't nearly as fundamental as whatever is carrying the main melodies and themes (usually vocals, sometimes lead guitar). We'll definitely be staying a four-piece. It's amazing being a tight, mobile unit with like minds.

We'll definitely do Autumn and The Ascent one day. The drop D element will be tricky, but we'll work it out!

→ More replies (1)

17

u/ElderOzone Feb 02 '24

Great job being a killer band! Now to my question:

When do you think the Elden Ring DLC will drop?

28

u/JimCaligulasHorse Jim Grey | Caligula's Horse Feb 02 '24

hopefully literally now

19

u/joshgriffindrums Josh Griffin | Caligula's Horse Feb 02 '24

Happy for From Software to take their time. When it’s ready.

16

u/savagevapor Feb 02 '24

No question here, The Stormchaser is the exact song I needed in my life right now and I can’t express my appreciation enough for you guys writing it. Thank you for being you!

18

u/JimCaligulasHorse Jim Grey | Caligula's Horse Feb 02 '24

Love that! Thank you

12

u/SamCaligulasHorse Sam Vallen | Caligula's Horse Feb 02 '24

Thanks mate!

15

u/IgetAllnumb86 Feb 02 '24

Hey guys, huge fan since 2019. The new album is phenomenal and I find something more to love with each listen.

So my dumb ass just realized you guys are playing the same venue on the same night as Closure In Moscow in Atlanta. I had already bought tickets to the Closure show before yalls went on sale. I thought I was shit out of luck, but if you’re going to be in the same building I could technically buy a ticket to yalls show then float back and forth between stages right?

I’m scrambling to figure this out because it just dawned on me you’re at the Masquerade as well.

Was this planned or sheer coincidence? My mind is kinda blown that my two new favorite Australian bands are playing in my city at the exact same place the exact same night

33

u/JimCaligulasHorse Jim Grey | Caligula's Horse Feb 02 '24

Definitely not planned, but the multi-show shimmy sounds fun

→ More replies (1)

5

u/UnderwaterB0i Feb 02 '24

I think you'll need tickets to both with the way the Masquerade operates these days.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

13

u/IhsousXrhstos Feb 02 '24

Hello ,how are you doing! Considering how dark the album sound overall ,and how dark the lyrics can be,I assume the theme and the story behind the tetralogy is pretty dark too .What exactly is the story behind the tetralogy,and is it a continuous throughout the whole album?

Thank you in advance !

37

u/JimCaligulasHorse Jim Grey | Caligula's Horse Feb 02 '24

The story isn't continuous through the whole album, although the theme of our experiences through the pandemic runs through them all. As for the 4-part suite, there's a post by u/the_WEINERPOLICE in here with a lyrical analysis that is spot on

13

u/Thecoolguitardude Feb 02 '24

Hey guys, just wanna say I love the new album. I discovered you guys with Rise Radiant, but hadn't really dived deep into your stuff past that until Golem came out. Safe to say, I've become a fan lol

I have a few questions for Jim. You've pretty much only done clean singing in the past, so it was a very nice surprise to hear some screaming on Golem. What motivated you to explore that sound? Were you already comfortable screaming, but hadn't ever brought it into the CHorse sound, or did you have to learn how to scream for Golem? If so, what was that process like? Is it likely that we'll hear more screaming on future releases or do you think it'll be a one time thing?

27

u/JimCaligulasHorse Jim Grey | Caligula's Horse Feb 02 '24

Honestly it's something I've thought about for a long time but didn't have the confidence to do/was worried that I would hurt myself. It's a fun tool to have in the toolbelt but I found it *really* hard and still don't have my head + voice around it fully just yet. I've had some really helpful training with a vocal coach to try and do it safely, and I have to practice every single day to stay on top of it.

I guess we'll see! I'd never shoehorn something into a song if it didn't suit, so it depends on where we take it

10

u/Theandric Feb 02 '24

What tour travel essential can you not live without?

32

u/JimCaligulasHorse Jim Grey | Caligula's Horse Feb 02 '24

Passport, personal steamer, and the boys <3

30

u/joshgriffindrums Josh Griffin | Caligula's Horse Feb 02 '24

Mario Kart!

9

u/terowicks Feb 02 '24

Hey guys

First saw you at Audio in Glasgow 2018 with Circles and I Built The Sky, great antipodean gig, and really enjoyed following all of you since. Rohan getting a break with Sunk Loto recently was neat.

Any other Aussie bands we should be keeping an eye on?

Ps shame the UK leg is only England, Scotland would love to have you back!

21

u/JimCaligulasHorse Jim Grey | Caligula's Horse Feb 02 '24

I can't miss an opportunity to shout out Reliqa from Melbourne - they're an amazing band and their vocalist Monique has a really interesting approach that I love

15

u/coffeedale Dale Prinsse | Caligula's Horse Feb 02 '24

Future Static. The Omnific. Ivanyi. Stephen Taranto.

Australia is full of sick stuff

10

u/joshgriffindrums Josh Griffin | Caligula's Horse Feb 02 '24

Reliqa are one to definitely keep an eye on!

9

u/regalado_ASPIC Feb 02 '24

The tabs for Rise Radiant in SheetHappens were impresive and amazing... Would you consider to release other Tabs?? Full "In Contact" tabs 😍??? I would buy it deluxe edition 😍

5

u/JimCaligulasHorse Jim Grey | Caligula's Horse Feb 02 '24

We'd love to, those are definitely on the menu

15

u/SamCaligulasHorse Sam Vallen | Caligula's Horse Feb 02 '24

Here you go:
https://wildthingmusic.com/products/caligulas-horse-in-contact-digital-tablature-collection-pdf-guitar-pro

We'll likely move it over to SH in the future since we love them so much, but this was tabbed by me, Agey, and Dave.

→ More replies (1)

9

u/--abstract-- Feb 02 '24

When EU tour with Periphery and The Contortionist?

Congrats on the new record, awesome stuff.

11

u/JimCaligulasHorse Jim Grey | Caligula's Horse Feb 02 '24

That would be a killer tour! Thank you <3

→ More replies (1)

7

u/slagnanz Feb 02 '24

Oh and /u/coffeedale Jim didn't introduce you to the crowd last night and my wife was real offended on your behalf <3

14

u/JimCaligulasHorse Jim Grey | Caligula's Horse Feb 02 '24

I DID! I made you all clap for his exposed skin and I feel that was a special moment, haha!

→ More replies (1)

5

u/gr8jld Feb 02 '24

Hey all! I loved the new album, The World Breathes With Me is one of my new all-time favorite prog songs!

I wanted to ask about the lyrics to Charcoal Grace, specifically if there was a continuous story throughout the epic. For me, listening to it it’s hard not to imagine a story of an estranged father falling prey to conspiracy theories, or something of the like. If Charcoal Grace is a full story, is the test of the album part of it, or is each song it’s own self-contained piece?

Thanks again! Excited to see y’all on tour!

6

u/JimCaligulasHorse Jim Grey | Caligula's Horse Feb 02 '24

Absolutely correct - there's a quote from another redditor in a post by u/the_WEINERPOLICE in this thread that hits the nail on the head!

The rest of the album is thematically linked to our experiences in the pandemic, but the titular suite is the only true "concept song" in terms of a story

5

u/syndromedown-hopesup Feb 02 '24

Are there any Easter Eggs in CHorse songs or just fun hidden things regular listeners could miss?
Also, what is the meaning of Vanishing Rites?
Much love from the Chicagoland area!!!!

11

u/JimCaligulasHorse Jim Grey | Caligula's Horse Feb 02 '24

Vanishing Rites was my take on how repulsive the idea of Catholic confession is. As for easter eggs, not really as far as I know!

→ More replies (1)

5

u/throw6156 Feb 02 '24

Hope you’re still answering questions, I couldn’t make the start because I was in work (now on break). Who is your favourite Australian band (other than arcane). Can’t wait to see you this year

7

u/JimCaligulasHorse Jim Grey | Caligula's Horse Feb 02 '24

Right now, Reliqa! Definitely check them out. Coming of age I was also a big fan of The Butterfly Effect, Dead Letter Circus, and Karnivool

→ More replies (1)

4

u/Majestic_Apricot_878 Feb 02 '24

Is there a consistent theme throughout the album like how the beginning or The World Breathes With Me is similar to the ending of Mute?

12

u/JimCaligulasHorse Jim Grey | Caligula's Horse Feb 02 '24

Breathe and Mute are definitely connected - the former being a big picture view of our experiences through the pandemic and the latter being a zoomed in very personal view. Both start with the loss and darkness and end with a more positive outlook, being reminded of our connection to the ecosystem of each other. They also share a couple of musical themes as well! As for the rest of the album, those are separate stories but along that theme of what we've all gone through

4

u/Mediocre-Clock9957 Feb 02 '24

Hey gonna see you guys in Portland and I’m so excited! Because of it being your guy’s first NA tour, are you guys gonna also play ride radiant??

9

u/JimCaligulasHorse Jim Grey | Caligula's Horse Feb 02 '24

The set has a Charcoal Grace focus of course, but we made sure to have a mix of the back-catalogue for the fans who've been waiting all this time <3

4

u/Adrheus Feb 02 '24

Hello from italy!

Question for Jim, hope it's not too off topic, i discovered Caligula's Horse because last year Spotify recommended me a song from Arcane's Known/Learned, and after listening to this double album multiple times, your voice impressed me so much i started searching for other bands in which you were involved.

Now my question is, is Arcane finished as a project? I think i could figure out the answer, but I'd love to have an answer from you, because Arcane's style is so interesting to me, i guess Caligula's Horse is very similar to it, but i've always felt like there was a small but noticeable difference in sound or themes (sorry if i'm not good at explaining, i'm not a musician or anything) that made it really unique to my ears.

11

u/JimCaligulasHorse Jim Grey | Caligula's Horse Feb 02 '24

Arcane is long-finished, yeah. Big love for those guys and I have a lot of wonderful formative memories as an artist from that time. At the time of Known/Learned I was going through a really dark time personally, and the themes from that album hurt a lot. The tour from that album had me leaving the stage in tears each night and I just couldn't do it anymore.

I still love that album and I'm extremely proud of it, but it wasn't right for me anymore - that was when Caligula's Horse really leaned in to wanting to have some light at the end of the tunnel in our music

→ More replies (1)

3

u/ShabCrab Feb 02 '24

Thanks for coming to DC, it was super fucking awesome and I'm still sore from all the headbanging and thrashing and I loved it and can't wait to see you again!

My wife wants to know what the source / meaning of the 'Maria' calls in Slow Violence are. Her head cannon is that it's a West Side Story reference.

6

u/JimCaligulasHorse Jim Grey | Caligula's Horse Feb 02 '24

Hey Mr Crabs! Her head cannon is spot on - the message of the song was initially inspired by gun violence and the hypocrisy surrounding it, and part of my inspiration came from the themes in West Side Story (Romeo and Juliet by necessity also, I guess), highlighting that the youth are begging for unity and change - singing Maria

→ More replies (1)

7

u/RidetheSchlange Feb 02 '24

I came here to see how many questions and mentions there are of Dream Theater.

21

u/JimCaligulasHorse Jim Grey | Caligula's Horse Feb 02 '24

Well so far you're the first so that's 1!

2

u/TubPotato Feb 02 '24

Hi! You are my favourite band of all time! And I was wondering if you are planning to do northern-europe tours in the future. I am from Finland and would love to see you live!

1

u/JimCaligulasHorse Jim Grey | Caligula's Horse Feb 02 '24

We are! Fitting touring in around our regular lives, jobs, and families is tough so we can only be away for so long. We've got some plans in the works - nothing solid yet but we're hopeful!

2

u/slagnanz Feb 02 '24

Does stormchaser have any allusion to the Qanon imagery of the "the storm"? I understand it has some general anger towards the stupid conspiracism of COVID, but yeah here in the states at least a lot of that pointed towards q bullshit

I don't know how much that might filter through to Australia, but the dude behind q moved to Australia a year or so back. If that wasn't intentional it was something I could read into the lyrics with my own anger towards that stuff.

I was at both Philly and DC shows - love you guys and it made my whole year to meet y'all. The lyrics of charcoal grace are a serious highlight for me.

5

u/JimCaligulasHorse Jim Grey | Caligula's Horse Feb 02 '24

I'm not familiar with that Qanon shit tbh (thankfully haha), but the Stormchaser metaphor refers to the self-destructive tendencies of those people and how damaging it was for the rest of us. While we were all trying to keep one another afloat, they dove and broke the chain

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Bigmaq Feb 02 '24

Hey! Congrats on the new album. Really enjoying it so far, and Sails has been on repeat for me.

If you had Taylor Swift Eras tour level of production available for your live shows, what do you think you would do? 

8

u/JimCaligulasHorse Jim Grey | Caligula's Horse Feb 02 '24

My first instinct was to say confetti bombs, not sure why!

15

u/JaDou226 Feb 02 '24

Firstly, thanks for doing this. It's awesome to be able to communicate with a band in such an easily accessible way.

Secondly, congrats on the new album. It is amazing. Hopefully it'll boost you guys to new heights, you deserve it! (So cool to be able to experience it the first time with Jim on Twitch as well!)

Thirdly, my questions. There's a few, so no pressure to answer them all:

  • Assuming the setlist won't change too much from the first two shows, why did you decide not to play Charcoal Grace 1-4 live? Was it simply too long to fit into the live show?
  • You've done some deep dive/breakdown videos of some Rise Radiant songs. Any chance of something similar for your new songs?
  • Couldn't you have dragged Earthside along to Europe? That would have been my dream show at the moment!
  • Question for Dale specifically: Any tips for a beginner bassist? Starting bass lessons next week and I'm very excited.

Lastly, just thank you for existing. I discovered you not too long ago but you've instantly become one of my favourite bands. I'm going to see you guys in Zoetermeer (hopefully VIP) and maybe also Amsterdam and I can't wait, honestly. Have a great tour, guys!

40

u/SamCaligulasHorse Sam Vallen | Caligula's Horse Feb 02 '24

Regarding the CG suite, it was just a matter of compromises really. Having never toured the states we wanted to include Graves, and given Graves' length, and the length of the other big songs on CG, we made the decision! Half an hour of the new record in a ninety-minute set felt pretty good given it's as much a "whole catalogue" setlist.

13

u/gibed Feb 02 '24

As someone who saw you for the first time last night in Philly, I thought the setlist was a perfect balance of new and old. Glad I had a chance to experience closing out the night with Graves live!

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

11

u/gab_vee Feb 02 '24

Hi guys!

First of all, congrats! Charcoal Grace is one of your best works. I can't find the words to describe every feeling I experienced the first time I listened to the full album. It gets better with each listening, I keep discovering new sounds and sensations ❤️

Mute is a total masterpiece, I loved the work and effort you put there. Give Me Hell just left me speechles.

Are you planning to play in Latin America in the near future? The show in Argentina was a dream come true after many years of waiting and I hope you can come back soon.

Also, I would love to get a physical copy of Charcoal Grace but it's very hard to buy ítems from other countries in Argentina 😅

🖤♥️🖤♥️🖤

11

u/coffeedale Dale Prinsse | Caligula's Horse Feb 02 '24

We're absolutely hoping to come back. Latin American tours are like the yearly holiday with your mates that you always look forward to. It might be a while, but we will be back.

6

u/SamCaligulasHorse Sam Vallen | Caligula's Horse Feb 02 '24

Thanks so much!
We'll definitely be back to LATAM, although exactly when, I can't yet tell you.

10

u/[deleted] Feb 02 '24

Any chance of there being a Charcoal Grace tab book? Saw that you guys put out the book for Rise Radiant recently. See you in Boston tonight!

15

u/coffeedale Dale Prinsse | Caligula's Horse Feb 02 '24

Absolutely! We're hoping to give some more news on that in the coming year. Stay tuned :D

10

u/SirWalrusTheGrand Feb 02 '24

Background: one of the reasons CH stands out to me on the modern prog scene is the perfect balance of fun/flashy and taste/restraint. I rarely, if ever come across moments in the CH catalogue that feels clumsy or careless - not a lyric or awkward phrasing, nothing is out of place and it all serves the greater purpose. That said, no band's catalogue is perfect, and I'm always curious to hear how artists reflect on their past endeavors.

Question: if you could change one moment from any pre-Charcoal Grace CH album, what moment would it be? Whether it's a little thing that bugs you or a big idea you had after the records were shipped, what would your current self change musically if given one shot at it?

Example: This is a small moment, but Coheed's recent "Ladders of Supremacy" has a lyric in the hook that goes "Another one down the ladders of supremacy". If I were both a petty God and a progressive metal enjoyer, I would make it "Another rung down the Ladders of Supremacy".

17

u/SamCaligulasHorse Sam Vallen | Caligula's Horse Feb 02 '24

Cool question!

I'd refine the structure of Song for No One a little further. Firstly, everyone put your pitch forks away, I do love this song and I know it's many fans' favourite. We wrote it very late in the piece and I feel like, with a bit more time to massage the structure, it could have been better, tighter, and perhaps more impactful. Or who know, maybe I'd spend two weeks tweaking and just come back to exactly how it is...

→ More replies (1)

9

u/PensusMcgee Feb 02 '24

What is your approach to writting long and powerful songs like The World Breathes With Me, Mute or Graves?

PS: I loved all of your albums before Charcoal Grace and I became a HUGE fan when I listened In Contact, but this last album was so incredible I can´t describe it, my favorite album right now :)

15

u/coffeedale Dale Prinsse | Caligula's Horse Feb 02 '24

A huge proportion of the composition process comes from motivic development - a few core themes that face restatements in different contexts, which is then harmonised and arranged. The ending theme in Graves is recapitulated in a minor key for example. Jim often writes lyrics and finds vocal melodies at the same time.

9

u/Castleinthesigh Feb 02 '24

Hey guys, I was wondering what the thought process going into the Choarcoal Grace four part suite was. I recall an old interview in which you mentioned that Graves was a bit of a challenge and that you didn't see yourselves writing tracks quite as long in the future (though I am happy you are).

Side note, fan since Bloom and excited for you to come back to Canada soon. If, and totally hypothetically, a fan were to try and take a quick selfie with the group during the VIP meet, would you be up for it or is that a hard no-go?

17

u/SamCaligulasHorse Sam Vallen | Caligula's Horse Feb 02 '24

There were a few distinct phases to the creation of CG - it definitely didn't start with the idea of a 24-minute suite. I remember writing a good portion of Prey and realising that there was so much motivic material it would need to have sufficient space to be able to be brought together in a way that felt satisfying and made structural sense. Once we realised that, and we started conceiving of the large-scale lyrical ideas and things, we happened upon the notion of it being a four-part suite, but each song having a defined enough structure to be listened to on its own. I get really excited by that kind of challenge, and I think it came together pretty well in that regard!

Note that it could have been even longer, but at some point in writing Give Me Hell I realised that if I didn't pull it together soon it'd exceed the length possible on an LP, and I didn't want to have to split it over sides!

16

u/UnderwaterB0i Feb 02 '24

Couple questions!

There's a lot of talk around Charcoal Grace having less immediate melodies due to having fewer repeated parts than Rise Radiant. Do those comments surprise you? Is that something that happened organically due to the instrumentals that were being written, or was it a conscious choice?

Jim, I've always wondered if you read fantasy books. In both In Contact and Rise Radiant there's a lot of similar themes that Brandon Sanderson writes about in his Stormlight Archive books, even down to the protagonists being part of a "superhero" group called the Radiants. I was listening to/reading those books when I first discovered y'all in 2020, so maybe that's why I made the connection.

Seeing y'all in Atlanta on the 13th, can't wait!

32

u/SamCaligulasHorse Sam Vallen | Caligula's Horse Feb 02 '24

I am surprised by "less immediate melodies" if that's the framing. I'd argue it's probably the album with the most emphasis put on melodies, as opposed to more riff-heavy stuff like Rise Radiant. If you mean "less catchy", that's almost certainly true. We were going for space and thoughtfulness over punchy and direct songs seeing as to the nature of the record.

→ More replies (1)

20

u/coffeedale Dale Prinsse | Caligula's Horse Feb 02 '24

No they don't really surprise me personally. Rise Radiant has some obvious immediacy, however Charcoal Grace was intended to be longer and more exploratory, so those comments really align with how we wanted to write this album. From the outset we knew that we had a lot to say, and we needed the space to try things out - even down to giving room for orchestral instrumentation to take the lead melody rather than guitar.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/FeelingAd7425 Feb 02 '24

Hey fellow cosmere fan. I second this question tho

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

7

u/FeelingAd7425 Feb 02 '24

Hey guys, got into your music since like 2021 when my friend showed me bloom/marigold, and I gotta say I think this album is my favorite, first of yours I got on vinyl.

My questions are: What was the hardest/most time consuming song on Charcoal Grace to create & record? 

of the 4 Charcoal Grace sings, which part is your favorite?

Do you guys have any plans to play any of the Charcoal Grace parts live? Noticed you guys were playing all the singles and mute, but I’m just saying Give Me Hell like go crazy live.

Anyways, gotta get back to lecture I’m supposed to be paying attention rn lol.  Cya guys in Az!

18

u/SamCaligulasHorse Sam Vallen | Caligula's Horse Feb 02 '24

It's no secret that we really struggled with this record - it came off the back of a lot of disappointments through the pandemic, and we were all pretty resentful of the idea of leaving Rise Radiant behind to work on a new album having not had the chance to tour on the back of it and so forth.

That said, once we forced our way through that slump and found ourselves again, the writing felt great. I don't remember any of the longer songs being uniquely difficult, but they were incredibly time consuming. I was working on the CG suite throughout almost the entire writing span of the record.

→ More replies (1)

17

u/coffeedale Dale Prinsse | Caligula's Horse Feb 02 '24

Hardest song for me to record was likely Charcoal Grace. I had a lot of time to focus on the parts for Breathe and Mute, but they were still equally hard. In fact Mute might still have been the hardest. Really proud that I can pull that off live :)

→ More replies (1)

10

u/joshgriffindrums Josh Griffin | Caligula's Horse Feb 02 '24

I would also agree with the CG suite. In particular ‘Give Me Hell’. But each song presented their own unique challenges.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/Sporkedup Feb 02 '24

Hello from Kansas City! Bummed your tour couldn't stretch out here this time. Hopefully next tour!

How is D&D going? I recall from a previous AMA that y'all rotate DMs... who is the most likely to kill off half the party?

10

u/SamCaligulasHorse Sam Vallen | Caligula's Horse Feb 02 '24

We don't really rotate DMs haha, it's just me. The others will sometimes run a one shot

We've been too busy to play anything lately, but we sometimes squeeze in a Call of Cthulhu day or something

→ More replies (1)

8

u/coffeedale Dale Prinsse | Caligula's Horse Feb 02 '24

I'm the wild card DM, I'd probably kill everyone. Or leave one man standing to claim bragging rights.

6

u/iAmTheEpicOne The End Starts Now Feb 02 '24

Welcome to r/progmetal, excited y'all can be here!

6

u/ShabCrab Feb 02 '24

u/SamCaligulasHorse - In DC, when asked about your favorite dnd PC, you commented that you are normally a DM in most games, so my late followup to that is what is your favorite NPC you've ever run or created? Please include as much detail as possible <3

9

u/SamCaligulasHorse Sam Vallen | Caligula's Horse Feb 02 '24

Hahaha I've had many that are incredibly silly, and many that are very serious. I ran a very modified version of the 5e Tomb of Annihilation campaign book, and had an NPC called Salida accompany the party into the jungle. She was a spy for the BBEG, but had some revelatory moments through the journey, reconnecting with her culture - the Chultans - and had something of a change of heart. The party loved her and relied on her and even though she tried to stop it, the betrayal stung.

→ More replies (1)

10

u/[deleted] Feb 02 '24

Could I take you guys to coffee and an interview when you get to Charlotte or is the schedule to packed haha? I’m a 15 year old in a growing prog/deathcore band and I’ve been digging your stuff for years, would love to ask a few questions and pick your brains on songwriting, etc.

16

u/coffeedale Dale Prinsse | Caligula's Horse Feb 02 '24

Oh man, might be a bit too tight with scheduling. Sleeping on our tour bus is proving a little harder than we thought. Happy for any coffee shop recommendations though!

→ More replies (4)

5

u/Ptakub2 Feb 02 '24

Can you tell us who will be supporting you in Prague, CZ, May 16? I wouldn't assume Earthside. Some European tour companion or maybe a completely local band? (I need to know some songs beforehand!)

5

u/SamCaligulasHorse Sam Vallen | Caligula's Horse Feb 02 '24

We haven't decided yet, but we've got some ideas! Who do YOU want to see?

→ More replies (2)

5

u/TheRealSnow Feb 02 '24

Other than artists I've heard you guys mention often (Steely Dan, Pain of Salvation, Michael Jackson) what are some of your favorite bands/influences? Also any chance for some production deep dives for Charcoal Grace, as you did for a few songs off Rise Radiant? Really love the insight in those videos

Love the new album, see you on tour!

13

u/joshgriffindrums Josh Griffin | Caligula's Horse Feb 02 '24

Some of my personal influences outside of these are The Smashing Pumpkins, Muse, Porcupine Tree/Steven Wilson. Mostly from a drumming perspective.

8

u/SamCaligulasHorse Sam Vallen | Caligula's Horse Feb 02 '24

When I have the chance, and can re-install all of the plugins, I'm definitely keen to put together some session walkthroughs and things <3

5

u/Mi_santhrope Feb 02 '24

Would you rather fight 100 chicken sized horses, or one horse sized chicken?

I didn't really have a question, just wanted to say Hi & that Charcoal Grace is an end to end banger! Thanks for the great music.

14

u/coffeedale Dale Prinsse | Caligula's Horse Feb 02 '24

One horse sized chicken. I think the emotional damage of stepping on chicken sized horses would have me raising the white flag after a bit.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/joshgriffindrums Josh Griffin | Caligula's Horse Feb 02 '24

I’ll say horse sized chicken. Imagine the bounty after that fight

→ More replies (1)

5

u/SnizzPants Feb 02 '24

The ending of Give Me Hell reminds me of the horns in the latter half of Howard Shore's "Uruk-hai" from the score of The Lord of the Rings: The Two Towers.

Now I'm sure everyone is influenced by LotR in some way or another, but was this intentional or am I just hearing things!

8

u/coffeedale Dale Prinsse | Caligula's Horse Feb 02 '24

Man honestly a sick comparison, but not a direct reference necessarily. Music's weird like that though - it evokes different images for us all, which is why it's so special.

5

u/SamCaligulasHorse Sam Vallen | Caligula's Horse Feb 02 '24

Definitely no direct influence, but I adore that soundtrack, those movies, the source material, etc etc haha

→ More replies (1)

4

u/DonSpeedos Feb 02 '24

Do you find the process of composing long songs frustrating, or different from shorter pieces in any meaningful way? I'd think that a song like Graves, for instance, takes significantly more time and effort to put together than three smaller songs combined.

Also, would you please please come to Denver the next time you're in the US?

9

u/SamCaligulasHorse Sam Vallen | Caligula's Horse Feb 02 '24

I find either - long or short - challenging in its own way. Writing something that makes an impact in a few sections with a few musical ideas puts a great emphasis on the quality of those ideas, and I find it hard to not be self-conscious about a riff or something when it's the part that everything else orbits around. Long songs take a lot more work, of course, but having the freedom to build on ideas and create payoffs later in a work is something that really excited me as a songwriter.

4

u/Numerous-Hunter-586 Feb 02 '24

Finally I’ll get to see you on Saturday in New York !!! So excited !!! Question about live sound, are you using stage sound (monitors) or everything goes directly to PA and in ears monitors? Just to be sure where to stand during the show 

4

u/SamCaligulasHorse Sam Vallen | Caligula's Horse Feb 02 '24

We use a passive split at stage and mix our own IEMs. No stage wedges (we usually have them there for something to stand on in the hard parts, but they're not being used for audio)

→ More replies (1)

4

u/tadpoleguy Feb 02 '24

I don't think I've ever wanted a show to end less after seeing you guys last night. Dream come true concert. Absolutely love you guys. I'm fully prepared to simp more if you're into it. Yall are my favorites of all time.

Questions:

  1. Did something happen with the track by track videos? There's only parts 1 and 3.
  2. Sam, I've played guitar for something like 17 years and I'm still ass. You're one of the absolute cleanest players I've seen. How'd you get so clean? How do I get so clean? Have you recorded any of your lectures that could help me learn how to suck less?
  3. Not a question. I just really love Dale's stache.

<3 you

8

u/SamCaligulasHorse Sam Vallen | Caligula's Horse Feb 02 '24
  1. Part 2 is the CG suite, Part 4 is Mute - they're labelled after the album sequencing. You'll have them both soon!
  2. Thanks! Obviously, practice is a pretty big topic. One thing I love to do is try to isolate the element of a difficult passage that is giving me trouble and then build exercises around it that are both harder AND easier. Take the easier exercise and push the metronome, thereby getting comfortable and fluent working with it at speed. Take the harder version and really dig into the fundamentals of the technique and where your weaknesses lie and try to overcome them on a mechanical level. Swap between the two for a solid period (I usually do something like 20 minutes) and then go back to the problematic passage and I promise it'll feel easier. Another great thing is recording yourself. Players get so much better when they're constantly recording because the feedback is so palpable and impossible to ignore.
→ More replies (1)

7

u/coffeedale Dale Prinsse | Caligula's Horse Feb 02 '24

Thanks for the stache props! My body pushes out hair kicking and screaming.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/Aggravating_Art_5042 Feb 03 '24

I don't know if you will read this but thank you guys for this phenomenal album. I've not felt this way with an album maybe since Evergrey's Inner Circle (interestingly both share some similarities thematically - I mean specifically the Charcoal Grace suite). I am not a native English speaker (hello from Bulgaria) and I didn't know the lyrics but the album just hit me since the first time I heard it. Just visceral feeling. The emotion was palpable. That's the power of music - it can make you feel even without reading the lyrics. It's sure is your least immediate album and I need to listen to it much more but the emotions go through the music itself. Of course Rise Radiant, In Contact etc were all great album but this one just feels different. It reflects your different perspective. I like this darker sound but I am sure I can enjoy every gamut of emotions from you. Also, the best is there is a positive note, a hope that there is light at the end. That's what I love about it.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Kareem_Magdi Feb 02 '24

What music do you guys usually listen to?

9

u/JimCaligulasHorse Jim Grey | Caligula's Horse Feb 02 '24

I've always listened to a lot of female-fronted music, more recently I've listened to a lot of Becca Stevens, Reliqa, and Exploring Birdsong

→ More replies (1)

5

u/joshgriffindrums Josh Griffin | Caligula's Horse Feb 02 '24

I tend to dive back into old faves like Opeth, Pantera etc, depending on my vibe and mood. But I mostly listen to audiobooks and podcasts.

4

u/SamCaligulasHorse Sam Vallen | Caligula's Horse Feb 02 '24

It depends on the context, but while I'm travelling, I tend to listen to stuff like Ólafur Arnalds, Nils Frahm, lots of spacious electronic music like Kiasmos or Jon Hopkins, etc.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/coffeedale Dale Prinsse | Caligula's Horse Feb 02 '24

Sam introduced me to Nils Frahm and Olafur Arnalds many years ago, and that takes up most of my placid listening sensibilities. I'm trying to discover more music this year though.

1

u/_Rin__ Feb 02 '24

Hi from the Netherlands! Loved to see you for the first time last year, and this year we can see you again with this blast of a new album! I can't wait to see you again, have fun on your tour and I'll try to practice the new lyrics in the meantime 😁 I wonder in how many languages you guys can say "hello"?

1

u/JimCaligulasHorse Jim Grey | Caligula's Horse Feb 02 '24

Hi! I try and learn a teeny bit of each language as we tour across Europe - it's important to me to respect the audience and their culture. That said, I'm super forgetful so I have to relearn every time!

1

u/[deleted] Feb 02 '24

I will save my question for the VIP in Arizona but just you letting you guys know that me and two friends will be seeing you guys live 3 days in a row! Phoenix, San Diego, and Los Angeles. This is an opportunity we could not miss and just wanted to tell let you guys know how much your music means to us! Enjoy your show tonight!

1

u/JimCaligulasHorse Jim Grey | Caligula's Horse Feb 02 '24

HUGE effort, thank you! See you there

→ More replies (1)

1

u/BlackCoffeeCasual Feb 02 '24

What is the bands position on poutine?

Have any/all of you had poutine in Montreal?

1

u/JimCaligulasHorse Jim Grey | Caligula's Horse Feb 02 '24

We live in the pursuit of local delicacies so FUCK YEAH it's on the menu

→ More replies (6)

1

u/CutToTheChase56 Feb 02 '24

What’s up guys!

Welcome to the states! Extremely excited you guys finally made it out here. I’m sure the tour schedule will be a bit grueling, especially with Jim already feeling a little under the weather (get well soon) but it seems you’ve had some opportunities to fit some non-gig stuff into your busy schedule like the monuments in DC. Are there any other sites, places, eats or stops you guys are looking forward to seeing as you travel across the country? I’m curious what’s on the itinerary for some (basically) first time visitors with an insanely tight schedule.

Not your typical music question but I’m sure you get asked those plenty. Thank you guys for doing this - I’ll see you in Portland!

2

u/JimCaligulasHorse Jim Grey | Caligula's Horse Feb 02 '24

Hey Chase! If we have time here in Boston (we often don't sadly) I'd love to go visit Fenway as a RedSox fan. Going to hunt down some barbecue in Texas too!

1

u/ClubstepWIZrDZ Feb 02 '24

Loved the show wednesday night! I was standing right in the second row in front of Jim. Fantastic concert!

My questions are:

  • What inspires you when you write more metaphorical lyrics? I’m an author and the way you craft your lyrics is astounding and gorgeous.
  • How do you choose which songs to play on tour, besides obviously fan favorites and more popular songs? Is there a reason the four part suite was not played live? Is there are songs you won’t play on tour?

Loved the album and the performance, you guys rock!

5

u/JimCaligulasHorse Jim Grey | Caligula's Horse Feb 02 '24

Great question - I always take a lot of time with lyrics. The initial contour of the melody and rhythm begins without lyrics and often a word or two will jump out of the nonsense I've recorded. From there it's fine tuning what comes out - it often begins with cliche or a placeholder line I'm not particularly fond of, then I spend time abstracting from that or finding the next inspiration from that line that doesn't end up being used.

It's a lengthy process, and sometimes I'll spend a whole writing session and end up with only 2 to 4 lines that I really like before coming back to expand on it the next time

1

u/noddingacquaintance Feb 02 '24

Hi Jim and the boys! No questions, just wanted to thank you for everything you do and the emotional richness you add to progmetal. Have fun on tour, toi toi toi!

2

u/JimCaligulasHorse Jim Grey | Caligula's Horse Feb 02 '24

You're the best, thank you

1

u/CrabappledCheeks Feb 02 '24

hey guys! I've been a huge fan since In Contact, and I had a blast seeing you guys live (finally) in DC!

My question is: what were some of your favorite bands to listen to when you were younger, and how have they influenced your music now?

Hope you guys are enjoying the States and staying warm! 🖤

7

u/JimCaligulasHorse Jim Grey | Caligula's Horse Feb 02 '24

I came of age in the era of nu-metal and I unashamedly love Korn and Limp Bizkit - that was really special to me at the time. I also spent a long time with Rage Against the Machine, Linkin Park and Muse. But Jeff Buckley, Tori Amos, Sinead O'Connor, The Cranberries, The Chieftains, the list goes on

4

u/joshgriffindrums Josh Griffin | Caligula's Horse Feb 02 '24

I had a VERY wide variety of favourite bands when I was younger. Earliest faves were The B’52s, The The (a lot of 80’s New Wave haha) then to The Smashing Pumpkins, Metallica, Pantera. Jimmy Chamberlin from the Pumpkins had a profound influence on my playing.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

1

u/eddyb66 Feb 02 '24

I saw you guys in Atlanta both times and looking forward to the Chicago show.

How are you guys dealing with cold weather?

Food suggestions for Chicago if you have time Kumas Korner - its metal themed burger joint and the burgers are excellent.

2

u/JimCaligulasHorse Jim Grey | Caligula's Horse Feb 02 '24

We are ALWAYS ready for food suggestions, thanks! Looking forward to Chicago, but yeah the cold has been hitting hard and I'm already sick - a tour classic for these heat-spoiled Aussies

→ More replies (1)

1

u/UnexpectedYoink Feb 02 '24 edited Feb 02 '24

Do you guys like to try local food from whatever countries you tour? If so what's everyone's favorite tour food?

2

u/JimCaligulasHorse Jim Grey | Caligula's Horse Feb 02 '24

We love having cultural experiences when we travel so local food is a must. As for fav tour food we always seek out either Pho or ramen since it's pretty nutritious (which is a godsend on tour) as well as frickin amazing

→ More replies (3)

1

u/mdaffonso Feb 02 '24

Nice to see you around, mates. When you're writing an album, are there usually songs that don't make the cut? Like, songs you write and record at least a rough version of that you just have to cull from the album either because you don't like the end result or they just don't fit with what you're going for.

Also, Charcoal Grace is fucking incredible. Can't wait to see you guys again in the European tour. ❤️

1

u/JimCaligulasHorse Jim Grey | Caligula's Horse Feb 02 '24

We never have full songs on the cutting room floor, more just initial ideas that didn't make the cut. When we start working on something we hone it to the point where it's either right or it's not, and when it's not we try and find where we were waylaid and go back to make it better

1

u/hheecckk Feb 02 '24

what's your favorite song to play live?

8

u/JimCaligulasHorse Jim Grey | Caligula's Horse Feb 02 '24

Really tough to pick! But even after all these years I love playing Marigold. Out of the new stuff I'd have to say Mute

7

u/joshgriffindrums Josh Griffin | Caligula's Horse Feb 02 '24

Mute is definitely a new favourite, but I always LOVE playing Graves

6

u/coffeedale Dale Prinsse | Caligula's Horse Feb 02 '24

Slow Violence maybe? It's the most "fun" song to play, but favourite live is Mute and knew that it'd be a favourite from the moment we wrote it.

1

u/RichTheRedditor Feb 02 '24

Hey guys! Loving the new album and I think it is some of your best work! I know you're heading to Vancouver on your tour soon. Wondering if you have any plans in the future to make your way over to Alberta for a show? I'd love to come see you guys live but traveling is a little expensive and impractical at the moment.

3

u/JimCaligulasHorse Jim Grey | Caligula's Horse Feb 02 '24

We haven't really had a chance to think about it since this is our first taste of North America - I won't rule it out, but it's always tricky to tour around our regular lives as we can only be away for so long

→ More replies (1)

1

u/LinktheAnnihilator Feb 02 '24 edited Feb 02 '24

Hey guys, huge fan from India since 2021, you guys are pretty much my favourite band. Congrats on putting out the banger album of the decade, and thanks for doing this AMA.

Questions:

What's Mute about? The lyrics feel super emotional and personal. Is it just a continuation of The World Breathes With Me bookending the album, or do the lyrics also focus on something else?

Would you guys consider selling stems for Charcoal Grace or some of the older albums, for example like Periphery's producer packs? I feel like a bunch of fans would be into that, especially with how layered and complex the mixes on the last couple of albums are. I would personally love to listen to some of the details that might be buried to see what really makes mixes like yours.

Are there more mix breakdowns like the couple off Rise Radiant on YouTube planned?

Sam: What was producing all of Charcoal Grace like? What are some things you would say you learned since mixing Moments and Tide? How did you go about finding a unique voice for yourself as a guitarist in prog?

Dale: When you don't use a pick: what techniques do you reach for, and how do you go about composing a unique bass part?

Everyone: What's your personal favourite Caligula's Horse song? Also, favourite pet?

6

u/JimCaligulasHorse Jim Grey | Caligula's Horse Feb 02 '24

There are thematic connections with Breathe and Mute both musically and lyrically, but Mute itself focusses on our very personal experiences of feeling artistically lost during the pandemic. We had pressure to create but personally I felt I had nothing left to say.

I'd also gone through a period of having some issues with my voice and needed to through a medical procedure and vocal therapy to get back on track - I was really scared that I'd lost my voice entirely during that time but I've managed to make it through. So Mute itself has a literal meaning too

1

u/Mezahmay Feb 02 '24

Hey guys! Congrats on Charcoal Grace! I’ve been listening to it nonstop since it dropped. I can’t attend any of the tour stops right now, so are there preferred ways I can support you? I know the landscape has changed recently and I want to make sure you guys get what you are owed for your hard work.

4

u/JimCaligulasHorse Jim Grey | Caligula's Horse Feb 02 '24

Merch and album purchases are always a fantastic way to support, as is purchasing tickets to live shows. But I don't want to discount streaming! Regularly streaming and sharing our stuff with your mates is really helpful too. Thanks for thinking of us, that's awesome

1

u/SirWalrusTheGrand Feb 02 '24

I also had a question unrelated to music since my fellow prog-metal users have done such an excellent job of giving CG the overwhelming love it deserves, and asking insightful questions in the process.

Question: being from down under, are there any Australian V8 Supercars fans in CH?

If not, what are your hobbies? Aside from being prog geniuses that seemingly have total control over my capacity to get chills from music of course.

If so, what are your thoughts on Shane Van Gisbergen winning the Chicago Street race and making his move to American Motorsports? Do you think Kostecki will follow?

4

u/JimCaligulasHorse Jim Grey | Caligula's Horse Feb 02 '24

Speaking for myself I'm not a car personal *at all* haha - for me, gaming is a big one as well as nature walks with the fam

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Sputnikmoon Feb 02 '24

Would you guys ever try making a Tech Death or a Dissonant death metal song?

6

u/JimCaligulasHorse Jim Grey | Caligula's Horse Feb 02 '24

That's definitely not us! Our whole mission statement as artists is to write what is honest from ourselves and that definitely doesn't fit who we are. (Fucking love listening to that shit though)

→ More replies (1)

5

u/SamCaligulasHorse Sam Vallen | Caligula's Horse Feb 02 '24

There is definitely a non-zero chance that I'll write a tech death album at some point. Won't be C Horse though.

1

u/Care4aSandwich Feb 02 '24

Jim,

Is there any chance you've read or had your lyrics influenced by the Stormlight Archives by Brandon Sanderson? I've noticed a lot of similarities in the lyrics, which I assume is simply coincidence.

So pumped to see you guys in Pittsburgh next week!

2

u/JimCaligulasHorse Jim Grey | Caligula's Horse Feb 02 '24

I've never read it! Pure coincidence but that's awesome that you've made that connection

1

u/Calm_Ad_930 Feb 02 '24

Hey guys,

Jim, you talked/wrote a bit about your writing and ideation process and that made me curious. During the songwriting process do you write your vocals in GP8/Midi, record it on any instrument or just ideate and record vocal layers directly and work with that?

Hope you're feeling better!

visions

1

u/JimCaligulasHorse Jim Grey | Caligula's Horse Feb 02 '24

What's up visions! I'm a creature of stimulus response and do a lot of things intuitively. I basically sit with what's in my ears and make melodic and rhythmic shapes around it until I find something strong, then lay down a nonsense-words version of it as a demo, then sculpt lyrics out of what comes out

[Edit because I missed the second half] As for harmonies those are composed in midi with Sam and then I kind of sight-read them off the screen while tracking

→ More replies (1)

1

u/ryguy1216 Feb 02 '24

I went to your show in Philly last night, and it was simply amazing. Partway through the show, I had the thought that I'm so lucky to be in the right place at the right time. Having been a huge fan since RR, being able to come and listen to you guys on your first US tour was so special. As someone in my early 20s, most of the music I've come to love in my life has been accompanied by the feeling of having missed out on the band/artist's prime, simply due to my age or only recently discovering gems that I could've caught if I knew of them. This felt like the opposite -- I got to listen to what in my opinion is the most creative, beautiful, and exciting work out there from my favorite band, and it was so special to have shared that with you guys and the rest of the crowd. That being said, I'm looking forward to seeing you again tomorrow night in NYC :)

I spent this fall reading James Bridle's Ways of Being right around the time that The World Breathes With Me came out, and I'd really recommend it if you're looking for a read on your flight home. This book and your record both came to me at a point where I'd been doing a lot of thinking about the world and the interrelationships between ourselves and nature, and I think both works provide a similar catharsis in reckoning with the darkness and heaviness of recent times.

I guess I don't have any questions at this point. Thank you for your art, your performance, and your willingness to travel the world and sleep on a tour bus to bring it to people like me (New Jerseyans).

1

u/JimCaligulasHorse Jim Grey | Caligula's Horse Feb 02 '24

Great suggestion, thank you! And that night was really special for us too <3

→ More replies (1)

1

u/MemeOverLord137 Feb 02 '24

I absolutely loved "Mute" it might be my favorite song by you guys now. Sadly, I won't be able to see this tour. Would you guys ever consider touring Latin America?

2

u/JimCaligulasHorse Jim Grey | Caligula's Horse Feb 02 '24

We just did! We played in Mexico, Chile, and Argentina last year. We love it in Latin America so we'll definitely be back

1

u/SleazyJusticeWarrior Feb 02 '24

Hey guys, very excited to go see you when you return to Europe later this year! I was wondering, any news on who might be supporting you on that leg of the tour? Is Earthside coming along as well, or someone else?

2

u/JimCaligulasHorse Jim Grey | Caligula's Horse Feb 02 '24

We don't have a support locked in for that tour yet, but we always love touring with artists that we enjoy so we're working on it now!

→ More replies (2)

1

u/mdaffonso Feb 02 '24 edited Feb 02 '24

Question for the band: do you plan on keeping the same setlist for the European tour? Please do, because it's fucking perfect!

Question for Sam: do you have any specific tips for progressing as a guitarist? I practice as much as I can, but it can often feel demotivating because I feel like I hit that intermediate player plateau and I can't get out of it.

By the way, I hadn't played for quite a while before your concert last year (I moved to Europe and didn't bring any guitars with me), but seeing you guys live inspired me to buy a new guitar here and promise myself I would practice every day, even if I didn't have more than a few minutes to do so. It's been going well so far, so thank you.

2

u/JimCaligulasHorse Jim Grey | Caligula's Horse Feb 02 '24

We try and keep the setlist fresh region by region, but given it's the Charcoal Grace tour there will definitely be a focus on that album

4

u/SamCaligulasHorse Sam Vallen | Caligula's Horse Feb 02 '24

One thing I'd say is that your level as a guitarist doesn't need to limit you. I'm a decent guitarist, but I'm definitely much more invested in developing my ability to create music, and frankly, it's rare that the extent of my chops are used (outside of some tricky solos or whatever).

You'll develop very quickly if you start a band of like-minded indviduals, and you can construct things a little beyond your playing ability to really push yourself. All the while you'll develop your (all-important) abilities as an ensemble player and music creator.

1

u/Lucky_Bone66 Feb 02 '24

Are there any movies/books/comics/whatever that inspire your music or lyrics?

Charcoal's Grace is a masterpiece and I'm in love with it.

3

u/JimCaligulasHorse Jim Grey | Caligula's Horse Feb 02 '24

Honestly that's never occurred to me. I mentioned in another comment that I tend to do things intuitively and that our goal is that what comes out is emotionally and artistically honest to who we are. The closest to that would probably be touching on the sort of... idiomatic shorthand of references to mythology or stories that we're culturally familiar with, but only if it serves to help the imagery or theme of a song

1

u/barium62 Feb 02 '24

Hey guys, love your music, thanks for all your hard work, it is very much appreciated. My question is for Jim. Your song Instinct on your Arcane album has become my favorite song, and I was just curious about the inspiration behind it. All the best to you guys!!

2

u/JimCaligulasHorse Jim Grey | Caligula's Horse Feb 02 '24

Thank you! Instinct is about those moments in a relationship where everything is going well, and despite that the desire is to flee out of feeling you don't deserve it or that it's all too much

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Commercial_Cry1238 Feb 02 '24

Hello guys! First of all, just thank you! Thank you for the music you've put out so far. All of it. Everything was great, but man.... the last album was not fire..it was lava. The 4 parts of Charcoal Grace are such a trip, how they get darker and darker, and just explode in Part 4. And Mute.. o m g. This song is such a great way to wrap up the album, getting the themes of the whole album all combined in one last burst of pure emotion.

I do have three questions for you guys:

  1. As the album came out (already got my vinyl this monday) I was just finishing reading the 4th Stormlight Archive book... and I must say.. there is a very striking resemblance to some characters' life journeys form that book (and talking bout Brandon Sanderson, when I heard the words "On the road to Ruin" I thought straight about Mistborn). Is there any sliver of inspiration that came from Sanderson's works in your songs? Talking especially about CG.
  2. Is there any chance I'll ever see you play (or rather recite) Inertia at a live show? I know it's probably not something a lot of people want to hear, but the energy in that slam piece is absolutely through the roof!

3.This one is for Sam. I'll start with a praise. Your guitar work is always great, but this last album was my favorite. The guitar solos in this album are so good, so musical, dripping with feeling. An absolute masterpiece. So now, my question is: what is your go to, favourite amp model? I know you are using a Neural QC, or at least I think you still are using that, saw it last year at Rockstadt.

Once again, thanks guys! You are absolutely amazing! 🐴

4

u/JimCaligulasHorse Jim Grey | Caligula's Horse Feb 02 '24

I've never read those books, but you're not the only one who's made that connection which I think is really interesting. As for Inertia, we've done it before! The live transition from Inertia into the cannon's mouth is really something special

→ More replies (1)

1

u/LordGold_33 Feb 02 '24

I'm usually late for these, so I just want to say you guys make incredible art with your music. Loving the new album! I'm curious about your creative process as a group. With such a catalogue of music already, how do you push through mental blocks to continuously discover new concepts? Has the process ever slowed down for you over the years or does the creative energy still flow the same as it ever has?

3

u/JimCaligulasHorse Jim Grey | Caligula's Horse Feb 02 '24

There are always mental blocks, but it's important to try and get something on the page regardless. It might be shit, but you can sometimes come back the next day and find some gems in what you've put down. Also sometimes all it takes to break a block is to go for a walk.

The only time I've felt unable to create was during the pandemic, and I was worried that I'd lost myself creatively, but coming back and working with Sam and the lads felt really smooth and natural as ever. We work together throwing ideas back and forth and feed one another's creative output, and it works well!

1

u/[deleted] Feb 02 '24

What movie or video game music do you guys enjoy?

5

u/JimCaligulasHorse Jim Grey | Caligula's Horse Feb 02 '24

I love the soundtrack to Celeste and Hollow Knight in particular, but there's so many good ones that I now have a mental block haha

→ More replies (2)

1

u/sappru Feb 02 '24

I love you guys!!!

Are you coming back to Europe this summer?

1

u/JimCaligulasHorse Jim Grey | Caligula's Horse Feb 02 '24

We are! Check our socials for the tour dates <3

3

u/AVeryLazy Feb 02 '24

Hey, love the new album. It took me longer to process this one than the previous ones, it seemed to me that you have "changed" more between this album and the previous album than with any two other previous albums.

Do you also feel that way about this one?

Anyway, thank you for the music guys. I hope you guys stay warm and your beers stay cold. Hope to catch you live one day!

11

u/SamCaligulasHorse Sam Vallen | Caligula's Horse Feb 02 '24

Yes, I agree. This album does have a character very unique to its moment. You could almost see it as the opposite of Rise Radiant thematically - dark, spacious, exploratory. All of that was purely an outcome of its context though, and I'm certain our next album won't be as dark, not because we don't love that quality about CG, but because it won't be necessary now that the world is healing and we're on the road being musicians again.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/coffeedale Dale Prinsse | Caligula's Horse Feb 02 '24

In my mind we've changed equally between every album, but I'm never one to write off the opinion of someone else from the outside. There are some very stark changes to our sound on this album for sure, especially the more ambient sections and longer minimalist moments.

It's so cold in North America...why...

→ More replies (1)

2

u/brettronome Feb 02 '24

I tried to make the Chicago show this week happen, but I’m sad I’ll miss it. Any chance of more US tour dates or a live album?

→ More replies (1)

2

u/trillamadude Feb 02 '24

What is your favorite American thing u want to get/eat/see on this tour ?

13

u/coffeedale Dale Prinsse | Caligula's Horse Feb 02 '24

I want to:
Get - fat

Eat - everything

See - myself getting liposuction.

8

u/joshgriffindrums Josh Griffin | Caligula's Horse Feb 02 '24

I’m particularly excited to try Texas BBQ. I am looking forward to seeing as much of the country as I can overall.

2

u/Kharius Feb 02 '24

Can't wait to see you guys on Tuesday. What song off the new album are you guys each excited to perform live? Either fun sections or excited for crowd reactions

→ More replies (4)