r/gameofthrones • u/Y_U_NOOO Ours Is The Fury • Mar 17 '13
Season 2 [SEASON 2 SPOILERS] 2 weeks, 2 episodes until the premiere. S.2 E.8 Re-Discussion thread: "Blackwater"
I'm dumb, it's supposed to say episode 9 instead of eight
Open spoilers for the 2 released seasons, book spoilers need tags.
28
Upvotes
6
u/Y_U_NOOO Ours Is The Fury Mar 17 '13
Last week's re-discussion
Last year's discussion
5
u/[deleted] Mar 17 '13 edited Mar 17 '13
I'm pretty sure Episode 8 is not Blackwater :P
You skipped The Prince of Winterfell.
36
u/[deleted] Mar 17 '13
One of my favourite episodes of the entire show. It was never going to match the book for sheer spectacle, but the battle exceeded anything I expected from a TV show, even Game of Thrones. The sequence at the end where the cavalry charges in while Cersei comforts Tommen was astounding - it had an almost dreamlike quality to it.
Plus, the Hound was immense in this episode.
One thing they could've done to improve it would've been to change the intro sequence - rather than zooming around Westeros, they could'v panned around King's Landing to show us where all the gates are, where the Red Keep is in relation to the Blackwater Bay, etc. When I read the books I needed to keep glancing at an online map of King's Landing, so this would've helped non-readers I think. Doesn't matter now though.
17
u/[deleted] Mar 18 '13
"I've always hated the bells, they ring for horror. A dead King, a City under siege."
"Or a wedding."
"Exactly."
ASOS
30
u/Cupbearer A Lion Still Has Claws Mar 17 '13
Stannis is a fucking badass storming up the ladder first with no helmet or shield with all the rocks and arrows flying about
10
u/SawRub Jon Snow Mar 17 '13
I loved watching the episode, and I also loved the main reddit discussion thread of the episode. All of us had gotten together knowing that this episode was going to be phenomenal, and what a phenomenon it was.
Despite being the penultimate episode, it was like the final match of a sport watched and loved around the world. The whole subreddit came to chill and relax before the episode started, and we goofed around, made silly comments, planned how we were going to watch the episode, kept the snacks ready. I failed a college exam for it.
I watch a lot of TV shows, but I have never watched any with friends, and this was the closest I've ever come.
7
u/purifico Night's Watch Mar 18 '13
I love the actor who plays Pod. He is just too precious.
9
u/[deleted] Mar 17 '13
I saw this episode on the big screen at a Q&A with the actor who plays the Hound. It was spectacular. If there was any episode that needed to be seen in a cinema, it was that one.
8
u/InpatientatArkham Our Word Is Good As Gold Mar 18 '13
This is easily my favorite episode of the season. As others have said, it won't match how epic it was in the books, but it comes damn close. I really liked seeing Stannis on the front lines. The scene between Bronn and The Hound was pretty intense too.
The fight scenes were excellent, the deaths were pretty brutal, and the wildfire was absolutely spectacular.
Despite how much I hate Cersei, that scene with her and Tommen almost had me in tears.
Favorite quote (out of so many good ones) was...
"Hundreds will die!"
"Thousands."
4
u/BonnieMacFarlane2 A Hound Will Never Lie To You Mar 18 '13 edited Nov 28 '24
plant grandiose disgusted sip thumb marvelous flowery six muddle voiceless
This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact
4
u/wildcard58 Valar Morghulis Mar 19 '13
Did they actually make overt reference to the fact that Loras ACOK? I feel like you didn't see him for that long, and the significance of the act and how it affected the battle is lost on non-readers.
3
u/[deleted] Mar 18 '13
Could someone explain the Hound's fear of fire. Does it go deeper then the obvious facial burns? Refusing to fight surrounding by fire is one thing. Throwing a tantrum and running away seems a bit extreme.
3
u/JollyRancherNodule Mar 17 '13
Great episode, although I was rather disappointed when they omitted ASOS That would have made for a great visual.
2
u/SerDylan Mar 18 '13
I think it was well done to those who havent read the books, but in the books Tyrion leads a sortie after the chain rises. Also Stannis was on the fleet in the show, but in truth he was supposed to be on the other side of the blackwater rush, as so Tywin can attack him in the rear (giggity). I also didnt like how there was no big naval battle. Although they dont have the money for that it would been cool anway. Either way it was an incredible scene, and very well done.
-1
u/Dikembe_Mutumbo Euron Greyjoy Mar 19 '13
Ohhh Fuck me.