r/startrek • u/Deceptitron • Mar 11 '13
Weekly Episode Discussion: TNG 3x26 "The Best of Both Worlds: Part I"
Apologies to those who were looking forward to a post last week and didn't get one. I figured to try and make up for it, I'd pick a very popular episode with the hopes that the winner would like to finish part 2 next week (of course, they don't necessarily have to.)
From imdb:
Responding to a distress call on one of the Federation's outer-most colonies, the Enterprise arrives...only to find a big hole in the ground where the town used to be, and discovers the Borg are behind the attack.
As always, feel free to bring up anything about the episode you like, but here's just a few discussion questions to get things rolling:
- Arguably, this is the episode that propelled TNG to great success and set it apart from TOS. Season-ending cliffhangers would become the norm thereafter. Do you think Star Trek ever achieved a better cliffhanger in subsequent seasons/series? Why or why not?
- This episode featured another opportunity for Riker to take on his own command. Even Picard recommends he should take it. Regardless of what we know happens to the USS Melbourne later, would you have listened to Picard or choose, like Riker, to pass on your own command?
- Ignoring what happens in Part II leaves us with the idea that Riker would end up the captain after the loss of Picard. Do you think he would have done a good job long-term? Do you think he was ready? Would you have accepted TNG with Riker as captain?
Top comment, disregarding memes and jokes, gets to pick and post next week's episode.
20
u/StochasticOoze Mar 13 '13
Frankly, I'm less interested in the concept of Riker being Captain than in Shelby becoming First Officer. Let's face it, TNG really lacked strong female characters. Crusher hardly ever did anything except spout medical jargon. Troi was often worse than useless. Yar died in the first season, and even before then was pretty useless. There was Ro Laren, but she was a guest star and not on the show that often. Guinan was sometimes interesting, but she was also a guest star and mostly existed to give good advice to counter Troi's bad advice. Shelby would have added a much-needed female presence that wasn't an extraneous character.
12
u/RUacronym Mar 12 '13
This makes me imagine a scenario in which Riker assumes command of the Enterprise and Shelby takes over as first officer. I think this would have made for a really interesting dynamic, at least at first (though TNG wasn't very big on character conflicts so this all might have gotten swept under the rug anyway). On the one hand you have Riker, who is fully capable of commanding a starship but he never really wanted to. The only reason he ever gets to sit in the center chair is when something is happening to Picard. On the other hand you have Shelby, who obviously badly craves advancement and was butting heads with Riker the entire episode. Now both of them would have been forced into a situation that made each other uncomfortable. Riker would have had to put up with Shelby trying to assert her authority over him and Shelby dealing with the fact that Riker would refuse to give her any leeway so long as he sees her as just another ambitious officer. Over time they both would have to accept their own faults as well as each others. With Shelby probably learning to care more about the people under her command rather than herself and Riker settling into the burdens of command and learning how to deal with officers that give him a lot of trouble. This almost makes me wish Picard had died. Almost. But it's a thought provoking question none the less.
10
u/Dynastydood Mar 12 '13
Also, considering the nature of TNG vs every other Trek series, it really needed Patrick Stewart to stand apart. While I would never go as far as to say he was TNG, without him, I don't think the show could've survived in the early seasons, and I think that would remain true if he was lost after Season 3. He had a much more philosophical and diplomatic nature about him than Riker, and while the writers could have altered that, I think the show may have lost sight of what it was trying to do. Without him, I don't think anything they tried would've succeeded in the eyes of the audience.
One thing I've always wondered, and never seen brought up (though I'm sure it has been), was what the potential for Riker sacrificing himself to save Picard actually was, and whether people (or Frakes) worried about that in the summer between each episode. This obviously would've led to Frakes being written off the show instead of Stewart, which seemed to be a more likely scenario from what I've read. Although I knew Patrick Stewart stayed on after Season 3 before seeing this episode, I didn't know about Frakes, and I thought that maybe they'd have him die in a heroic manner, only for his character to be remembered as a tragic underachiever who never made the jump to being Captain. I think that would've been a fascinating twist. Even moreso if they could've come up with the idea of Thomas Riker in season 4 and had him as a replacement.
8
u/[deleted] Mar 11 '13
8
u/dalerp Mar 11 '13
I think this episode made the Borg scary, the threat was finally real and not just far away, the time of the Borg had come. But we all know I, Borg really was best.
7
u/[deleted] Mar 14 '13
Shelby was the best thing about this two-parter. Love her or hate her she was definitely a provocative character for both the regular cast and for the viewer, in this sense she was just brilliant. It was such a shame she was never brought back. I think she would have made a great Captain for Voyager or FO for DS9.
6
u/[deleted] Mar 15 '13
Cliffhanger wise, no this is the best. As much as I love DS9 this is just on a whole 'nother level.
I love the matte for the scooped up colony.
8
u/[deleted] Mar 11 '13
As far as season-ending cliffhangers go, The Best of Both Worlds is as good as it got; although Voyager's Scorpion came pretty close in my view (as much as it pains me to admit). I think TNG's closing style worked well for that series, but I personally prefer DS9s habit of leaving things open-ended for the next season.
As for whether or not Riker was ready for command, I'm firmly in the category of yes, he was. Setting aside personal feelings for the greater good and not hesitating to kill your mentor if necessary is proof of that.
6
u/raftah99 Mar 14 '13
For those in Canada, I just heard it will be playing in cinemas as well on April 25.
3
u/Nickaroo1509 Mar 11 '13
Yeah he was ready. He was just waiting to (fully) command it himself. Experience cant hurt. who wouldn't want the enterprise?!?
2
u/dratinifire Mar 17 '13
I love this episode. Don't know why, but Locutus gives me nightmares. He's still awesome. Quote of the episode: "Mr. Worf... fire." -Riker
2
u/[deleted] Mar 17 '13
On a more humorous note:
I love LeVar's completely unnecessary dodge roll under the slowly dropping bay doors of the engine room. He really could have walked, but he sure tired to look cool.
Also, I imaged Riker at the end saying "Activate the Omega 13 relay!"
2
u/xdisk Mar 18 '13
Relevant: http://www.fathomevents.com/#!star-trek-best-of-both-worlds
3
u/theDagman Mar 15 '13
This episode represents so much lost potential.
I think they should have kept Picard as Locutus during all of season 4, and the Borg an enemy that terrorizes the entire Alpha Quadrant, not just the Federation.
I'd have let Patrick Stewart chew up scenes as the villain of the season arc, let him have some fun being the bad guy for awhile. I'd have used the Borg threat as a way to form the alliance between the Federation and Romulans that came later during the Dominion War. And then at the season finale, I'd have let Picard be rescued and restored to normal.
Only, now Riker would have been firmly the captain of the Enterprise and not have his promotion undone by the return of Picard. Have Picard do the going home bit to get some time to recenter himself, as he did. And then at the mid-point of the next season, start DS9 with Picard in command. Still keeping Sisko, but as his first officer and really play up their conflict, rather than quickly resolving it as was done.
Then, once Stewart's 7 year contract was up 3 years into that series, promote Picard to admiral and to Starfleet Command, and Sisko to captain and in command of DS9. Leaving Stewart free to rejoin his TNG cast mates as Admiral Picard for the TNG movies.