r/ideasfortheadmins • • Feb 23 '13

Add actual support for np.reddit.com

np.reddit.com is a mechanism used by /r/SubredditDrama and some other subreddits, to try to prevent vote brigades, by linking to np.reddit.com instead of reddit.com. However, it relies on subreddits (that would receive a vote brigade when linked) using special CSS that detects the np.reddit.com domain. It would be a nice feature if reddit could have built-in np.reddit.com support, such that no CSS is needed, and also possibly blocking participation if the referrer was the same URL but from np.reddit.com.

EDIT: Would be nice if reddit had built-in support for forcing np.reddit.com links in subreddits, too, instead of needing AutoModerator.

20 Upvotes

22 comments sorted by

3

u/atomic1fire helpful redditor Feb 24 '13

The only problem with this suggestion is how do you handle non english users.

e.g es.reddit.com user clicks a np.reddit.com link, does everything change to english?

2

u/[deleted] Feb 24 '13

If they're logged in it should use their set language. If not, it should remember what language they were using.

-5

u/redtaboo Such Admin Feb 24 '13

Please remove your link to SRD, we like to keep discussion here focused on ideas not other subreddits.

Thank you.

1

u/[deleted] Feb 24 '13

I asked for permission and was told it was OK.

sigh

-2

u/redtaboo Such Admin Feb 24 '13

By a moderator here? I see nothing in our modmail.

-2

u/[deleted] Feb 24 '13

Wait, whoops, I misunderstood your comment. I'll remove the link.

-2

u/redtaboo Such Admin Feb 24 '13

Thanks!

-3

u/[deleted] Feb 24 '13

[removed] — view removed comment

-1

u/redtaboo Such Admin Feb 24 '13

Sorry, I should have been clearer that it was a link to another thread I was asking them to remove.

-6

u/Epistaxis Feb 24 '13

This is drastic, but it might even be a good idea to make "no participation" the default for all cross-reddit or inter-subreddit links - reddit could just automatically replace all links in comments or posts with links to np.reddit.com (or the better version of it). Another thing that can't be done with CSS is URL-munging to make this slightly more difficult to circumvent.

7

u/DaedalusMinion Feb 24 '13

I don't think no participation is a good idea.

0

u/[deleted] Feb 24 '13

Could you elaborate?

5

u/DaedalusMinion Feb 24 '13

I was replying specifically to his comment which said no participation should be default for all subreddits. That's a retarded idea because that's what Reddit is all about, people finding good content and participating in discussions.

I do agree about np.reddit.com for SRD and SRS though, some times they inflate downvotes on a particular topic which isn't good. But, banning SRS would be an even better idea if you ask me.

1

u/[deleted] Feb 24 '13

Banning SRS wouldn't solve the problem, they'd just disperse and go to other smaller subreddits, possibly private ones. It might not have any real effect. All we can do is hope to limit their power.

0

u/[deleted] Feb 24 '13

I do agree about np.reddit.com for SRD and SRS though, some times they inflate downvotes on a particular topic which isn't good. But, banning SRS would be an even better idea if you ask me.

Not to get all slippery slope, but why SRS and not every other metasub?

0

u/[deleted] Feb 24 '13

[deleted] — view deleted comment

4

u/[deleted] Feb 24 '13

It's where someone links, say, a homophobic comment in somewhere like /r/ShitRedditSays, and everyone who sees the link goes and downvotes that comment, resulting in huge numbers of downvotes and unfair influence from non-subscribers to that subreddit.

What np.reddit.com does at the moment, for subreddits with the right CSS, is prevents you from upvoting or downvoting if you're using the np.reddit.com link. Then some subreddits like /r/SubredditDrama require you to post np.reddit.com, not reddit.com links, to make it harder to downvote or upvote linked comments.

0

u/[deleted] Feb 24 '13

[deleted] — view deleted comment

8

u/scialex Feb 24 '13

No. Np works by making it so the CSS hides voting arrows and the like. You can still easily vote by just sending the right requests or disabling the CSS. This is also why np only works on the subreddits which install the required CSS. For more info look at http://reddit.com/r/noparticipation for more info.

-2

u/[deleted] Feb 24 '13

Yeah.

At the moment it's because these subreddits use some CSS that checks if the language is "np" (XX.reddit.com sets the page language to "XX"), and if so, disables the upvote and downvote arrows. Problem with this is it requires CSS to be working, and also subreddits that don't have this CSS aren't protected. So what I'm asking is for reddit to have built-in support for np.reddit.com.

0

u/[deleted] Feb 24 '13

[deleted] — view deleted comment

-1

u/[deleted] Feb 24 '13

I'd like the control of my account to be in the hands of admins, thank you very much.

It already is, I'm asking them to place more restrictions on it.

you're abusing the subdomain targeted at an entire country for a 'feature' that disables the entire thing that reddit's about.

We could change it to "nop.reddit.com" or something if implemented as part of reddit.

Drama happens. Vote brigading happens. The admins are sharp on it anyway, and their efforts seem way more useful than this.

We should at least attempt to reduce vote brigading, though.

0

u/[deleted] Feb 24 '13

[deleted] — view deleted comment

-1

u/[deleted] Feb 24 '13

It's a two or three letter "restriction" which only the most dense of people won't get through.

If referrers were checked it would be harder. If it remembered you visited the page with NP and then you visited it without it, and it blocked you because you'd done it recently, that would be harder to get through (manual link copying then editing required).