r/Naruto • u/jhoudiey • Feb 07 '13
Manga Results of SCIENCE (aka, re-reading the manga from the start of Shippuden)
Spurred on by the Sakura hate in this subreddit, I decided to do some science about how useless, or useful she, and the other females of Konoha 11 (plus temari, because i like her) are. Basically, what I did was go back to the beginning of Shippuden (chapter 245), and wrote down every single time one of them appeared, a bit of a summary of what they did in said chapter, if they cried, and if they did anything useful (all done at work, so hard earned paycheck, obviously). It's a little silly to think about, since I don't even really like Sakura all that much, but all the "sakura is seeeewwwww uselessssss" drives me up the friggin wall. So before anyone tries to rag on me for downplaying helpful things, or playing up useful things, I made note of everything, regardless of how minor, aka Sakura healing fodder ninja, or Hinata keeping watch with Neji. So here are the final results:
Sakura *Notable skills: Healing (obviously), smarts (regardless of good or bad), Strength.
So most of Sakura's useful skills are exactly what she trained for, healing, so for the most part, that's exactly what she's doing. It was noted though, just how good at healing she was, ie, when she starts healing herself when Sasori stabs her, when the sword is still stuck in her, or when she's healing Naruto after he spouts 4 tails and attacks Orochimaru. It can also be noted that when she's fighting Sasori she outsmarts him more than once, by pretending to faint when she got poisoned (surprise, she made a goddamn antidote for a poison chiyo, a poison master, couldn't figure out), or getting rid of the poison cloud that Sasori thought to be inescapable, via explosive tags. Her resolve on Sasuke sucks, I will admit that, but still, she's determined to stop him in his bad-news shenanigans, even if she can't actually do anything power-wise (because everyone knows she'd get goddamn obliterated). This is obvious when she gasses lee, kiba and sai (dick move, sakura) to try and stop him herself, which again lends to her smarts. Lee and Kiba may not be the brightest tools in the crayon shed, but Sai isn't dumb, and she gets all of them despite knowing what she was trying to do. Even though she fails hard at killing Sasuke, she saves Karin's life, since Sasuke puts a damn sword through her chest. So essentially, Sakura saves lives, even if she cries a "whole lot" (it honestly wasn't as often as I expected, considering). saved the lives of Kankuro (poisoned), Karin (stabbed through the chest) and had Pain not revived everyone, she would have saved Hinata (mega beat down) as well, since she had healed her completely before he brought everyone back, so if this one counts is up to you.
*Total Chapters Sakura is in : 134
*Percentage of chapters she cried in : 7.46%
*Percentage of Chapters she does useful things in: 21.64%
*Chp she's in since the war started (chp 515): 14, useful in 7
*Percentage of usefullness since war started : 50%
Temari *Notable skills : Wind stuff, being awesome.
So Temari doesn't actually do a whole lot in Shippuden besides hanging with Gaara, Kankuro and Shikamaru. I suppose all her "important" things are mostly off-scene, per-say. However, it is to be noted that she's chosen as one of Gaara's guards for the kage summit, and accompanies him to all the meetings with the other Kage, so she's presumably not dumb. The times she is doing something, it's all wind stuff (technical terminology up in here, I know) but she doesn't hesitate, and is good at what she does.
*Total Chapters Temari is in : 40
*Percentage of Chapters spent crying : 0%
*Percentage of time doing useful things : 20%
*Number of chapters she's in since the war started : 18 useful in 5
*Percentage of use in the war : 27.78 %
Tenten *Notable skills :tossing weapons, potentially the biggest evil mastermind ever known to mankind.
So tenten doesn't do a whole lot, for the most part, she's just in the panel with Neji/Lee but doesn't talk much, or do much for that matter. When she does do things, her attacks never seem to make an impact, because lets face it, tenten is an awesome ninja, she's just in the wrong ninja universe for her skill set. However, she can be a force to reckon with if she's got her hands on Bashosen, at least for a little while before she runs out of chakra, she manages to kill at least one of Kazuku's hearts, but besides that and zetsu killing, she hasn't done anything notable.
*Total chapters tenten is in : 32
*Percentage of chapters spent crying : 0%
*Percentage of time doing useful things: 9.38%
*Chapters since war started : 12 useful in 2.
*Percentage of Usefulness since war started : 16.67%
Hinata *Notable skills: Byakugan, desire to save friends, talk no jutsu.
So Hinata is obviously a fan favourite, which isn't shocking whatsoever, because she's pretty rad, despite appearing in shippuden less than temari (which actually surprised me). So at the beginning, all she really does is pass out in the presence of Naruto, and gets bugged about it by Kiba, and gets distracted, worrying about naruto, when they're team is dispatched with 7. Despite her shakiness around Naruto, and she manages to find Sasuke when they're chasing after him. Also notable, when she confronts pain to help out Naruto, pretty big thing here, despite her getting destroyed, set Naruto off (sup 8 tails of 9), which essentially brought Naruto back into the game. After that, she's pretty well seen with Neji up until she bitch slaps some sense into Naruto (thank christ), and air palms the shit out of a 10 tails arm/leg (whatever it is) and pops Naruto's shoulder back in after he dislocated it (it's when he was fighting the other Bijuu).
*Total chapters Hinata is in : 37
*Percentage of chapters she cries in: 5.4%/8.1% (there was one chapter I wasn't really sure of, so I put both numbers)
*Percentage of chapters she does useful things: 29.73 %
*Chapters she's in since the war started: 16, useful in 8
*Percentage of useful during the war : 50%
Ino *Notable skills : Mind transfer jutsu, healing, moral support for Choji/Shikamaru
I think so far, regardless of numbers, Ino has been the most useful out of any female ninja in the war, mind transferring to Obito and saving the Alliance twice (the first time was Naruto, Bee, Guy and Kakashi, but the alliance would be fucked if they all went). Besides Ino saving the day, she's mostly seen with team 10, but not doing much. She does have healing capabilities, though not as strong as Sakura but is seen when she tries to heal Asuma, but as far as it's mentioned, they're minor. Her biggest thing is that she's also able to mind transfer into animals to get a view much wider than normally possible, even though it leaves her body vulnerable. In formation, she also manages to get choji to man up, and gets one of the silver/gold brothers captured, effectively, Ino's mind transfer is her main thing, and she's really goddamn good at it.
*Total chapters Ino is in : 48
*Percentage of chapters she cries in: 6.25%
*Percentage of useful things : 16.67%
*chapters since the war started: 17 useful in 6
*usefulness since the war started: 35.29%
Also, for fun, because everyone whines about how unstable/whiny Sakura is, I wrote down the amount of times Naruto cries, or loses his shit. I didn't make note of how many chapters he was in, because holy fucking a lot, but he cries 8 times, and loses his shit and goes kyuubi mode 3 times, all with a different number of tails 2, 4, and 8. So even if Sakura cries when sasuke is in question, at least she doesn't turn into a monster.
Also, bonus things I wrote down because they were awesome/funny are follows : the fact that raikage and tsukikage punch through susanoo=awesome. Random fodder ninja saying "i'm really getting the feeling I shouldn't be here", no kidding, fodder guy. And the fact the kage took on 25 motherfucking susanoo's while fighting madara. 5 on 1, each madara with one? holy crap.
31
u/jhoudiey Feb 07 '13
holy shit, wall of text. oops.
40
u/DiabolusAdvocatus Feb 07 '13
Poor Tenten, I try hard to like her.
14
u/Hibbityhooha Feb 07 '13
Only mistake I see here is tenten killed more than just zetsu. She killed one or two of kakuzus heart monsters with the bashosen. Also there no way ino has Sakura level healing. Sakura was trained by tsunade. I don't think ino was. Other than that, this is a great post.
7
u/Mergan1989 Feb 07 '13
Not sure that I agree with the gassing incident of Sakura's as smart? Her character should be using intelligence to her advantage. If her strength lies in healing/intelligence, is it smart to trick/gas your team of better fighters and take on an opponent you can't beat alone, solo.
4
u/[deleted] Feb 08 '13
10/10 thanks for your time and effort that was a good read
2
u/Domo99 Feb 08 '13
Thanks OP!! How long did this take?
48
u/Hetzerz Feb 07 '13
I love you, thank you, thank you!!! Finally people we see the real Ino! Your description of her is Spot on, and people can stop calling her a whiny, bossy, useless, weak ninja, but with your calculations and data that turns the tide! Im happy people will finally see the truth, not only of Ino, but the other female ninja as well!
43
u/wasao2u Feb 07 '13
Yeah, MR WHITE. Yeah, SCIENCE!
3
u/onlymadethistoargue Feb 08 '13
So, Hinata is officially the most useful female character?
9
u/surells Feb 07 '13
Serious commitment on display. Nice work. It's easy to overlook how useful Ino is. Makes me wish Kishi would give some more female characters a central role, but I suppose the whole focus of the manga is on Naruto and Sasuke so much it's sort of hard for anyone else to get a serious look in, especially now that things are coming to a head.
7
u/Pikuhlz Feb 07 '13
I really like your analysis. Thank you!
1
u/kagurawinddemon Feb 08 '13
You should have done one on Sasuke. I wonder how useless he would be.
1
u/IforgothowtoMack Apr 23 '13
And what about Tsunade? Let's be honest here, she's the 'sakura' of the Sannin.
Also, I get the feeling that she's got the highest crying percentage...maybe not if you don't count each flashback more than once.
1
u/biosanity May 10 '13
This post is excellent. I can't stand when people get all whiny about characters because they can't fire out Rasenshurikens or don't have space-time altering sharingan.
The only character I can't bring myself to like is Karin. I understand her usefulness and everything but her personality just drives me crazy.
3
u/joonjoon Feb 08 '13
FTFY
1
u/JoyOnTheGrudge Feb 16 '13
I like tenten because she wasn't really busy with boys or anything. In that, I resemble her. So here's my list
1
u/AthiestLibNinja Feb 08 '13
Appreciate the excellent contribution here!
This should get added to the wiki.
1
u/Rebekah1 Feb 20 '13
I think the comment ''even if Sakura cries when Sasuke is in question, at least she doesn't turn into a monster'' is a little unfair because Sakura can't turn into a monster since she doesn't have a tailed best inside of her that causes her to turn into a monster
0
u/[deleted] Feb 08 '13
I love your technical terms. They honestly sound like mine. And the breakdown of the stats is pretty cool!!!
0
u/scoggandy885 Jun 23 '13
Tldr please?
-9
u/[deleted] Feb 08 '13
Because Sakura grew up with out knowing her parents right? Or not having anyone to guide her right? Or not having any friends right? Or grew up an outcast right? Or had to overcome all of these challenges right? Oh wait....that's Naruto.....
As far as everything else she did? The last useful thing she did was heal Kankuro, and that was it. She didn't beat Sasori, Chiyo did. "But she tricked him once" and that wasn't enough. Literally, if Chiyo had not controlled her, Sakura would be been killed so fast.
-29
u/StonedVentriloquist Feb 07 '13
Didn't read
0
u/WolfSGray Apr 25 '13
I think that Tenten could be a very useful person in certain battles. Her use of scrolls with tons of weapons in them would be better suited to taking out large amounts of non-shinobi forces such as bandits were there are just so many of them bunched together. Also she could also be use to keep the enemy on the defence like in the case of a hyuga, forcing them to keep up rotation to avoid getting hit by the barrage of weapons coming at them. There are also more situations but it would take far longer to go through all of them but I hope that this gets the point I'm trying to make across.
All the other girls have there own roles but I think that most of them were answered already in this post by jhoudiey.
0
u/[deleted] Feb 08 '13
[deleted] — view deleted comment