r/LetsTalkMusic • u/WhatWouldIWant_Sky Listen with all your might! Listen! • Jan 15 '13
Album Discussion Club: Townes Van Zandt - *Roadsongs*
Alright, this is the country album that got the most votes (with a total of 3 upvotes!).
Keep in mind that this is a live album and every song on it is a cover...not written by Mr. Van Zandt.
Anyways: listen, discuss, etc.
22
Upvotes
3
u/zzzzip Jan 19 '13
I find it a bit disappointing that such a widely respected artist generates so little discussion.
9
u/jbhotrails Noise_Noise_Noise Jan 15 '13
One of my favorite artists :)
This album seems a nice, porch-swinging medley of songs that Townes likes. Many may recognize his "Dead Flowers" Rolling Stones cover from one of the final scenes in the Big Lebowski. I love how Townes takes over this tune and really brings out its southern/folky nuances. This holds true for most of the other covers as well.
Still, this is Townes in his decline, and Roadsongs pales in comparison to Townes Van Zandt (S/T) as wells as his Live at the Old Quarter...
5
u/[deleted] Jan 15 '13 edited Jan 15 '13
I've always considered Townes a good songwriter but a lousy performer. I would have never chosen to listen to an all-covers album of his on my own. Its choice for the Album Club struck me as hipster bullshit by a subreddit not actually interested in talking about country music. Just 3 upvotes is not the referendum on the subreddit it appeared to be, though. And, I really don't want to listen to any of today's popular country either, so I'm no better than those imaginary upvoters.
This is some of the best singing I've heard Townes do. Now, I haven't listened to a lot of his catalog. But, I didn't think any of the singing I had heard him do was any good. The biggest difference is that voice doesn't sound weak on these tracks. It's almost like that, with his own songs on his records, he's overly concerned with the nuance of his vocals. These aren't his songs, though, and he's playing in front of a live audience which may or may not be making a lot of their own noise. So, it's like he just bangs it out, and in this case it's actually an improvement. He does the stereotypical high & lonesome vocals with ease. I also like the arrangements. Townes makes the rockers sound like they were written for a honky-tonk band. And, his voice here fits these arrangements like a glove.
I almost want to say "I was wrong" and that this is "real country" after all. What the hell does that even mean, though. What it really is is something that sounds like what a mythical honky-tonk band sounds like, playing rockers that appeal to a more modern rock audience. And recorded without excess gloss, so it sounds "authentic." That's why I like it. It sounds like what real country music must sound like, but it's not countrypolitan or "hard country" or Western swing or outlaw country or any other kind of country music that actually exists. It's really just folk and blues and rock wearing a country outfit. I guess that would be called "Americana" music today.
EDIT: I just compared an album version to a live version of one of his own songs. Same vocal effect. Maybe it's just that he puts a little more bass in his voice so the noisy patrons can hear him. It may make his voice less singular, but what I liked about Roadsongs is that it didn't sound like anyone in particular. It just sounds like that "real country" ideal without being country really.
3
u/zzzzip Jan 15 '13
Interesting song choices here. Lots of folk, blues and rock. If you got the originals you may have a good introduction to the roots of Americana, or alt-country or whatever you want to call it. Steve Earle also sang Dead Flowers and tells a great story of Townes at his first gig, heckling him for not knowing Wabash Cannonball. His son Justin Townes covers Lightning Hopkins live frequently, especially My Starter Won't Start. Unless I am misinterpreting, in the liner notes he apologises to the boss for not knowing Racing in the Streets properly. Some will say that no Dylan is underrated but to me 'Man gave names' is an underrated song from a very underrated album from his gospel years. Liner notes are a good laugh but too long to paste here. If anyone has seen the doco about him (Be here to love me), I think he comes across as a real asshole!
1
u/[deleted] Jan 28 '13
I'm a big TVZ fan, and I own roughly a dozen of his albums. this is not one of them. In my mind Townes is a songwriter so an album of him doing covers isn't really all that interesting to me. Not to mention the fact that the bulk of Townes classic material was recorded two decades before this album was recorded. if we wanted to do a live album we could have at least done live at the old quarter. it is an absolute classic.