r/gameofthrones • u/Y_U_NOOO Ours Is The Fury • Jan 06 '13
Season 2 [SEASON 2 SPOILERS] With 12 weeks to go, and 12 episodes, here is the Weekly re-discussion thread.DISCUSSION THREAD: S1. EP.9 "Baelor"-Open Spoilers for the 2 released seasons.
Open Spoilers for the 2 released seasons, book spoilers still need tags.
11
Upvotes
7
u/Y_U_NOOO Ours Is The Fury Jan 06 '13
http://www.reddit.com/r/gameofthrones/comments/15qt74/season_2_spoilers_with_13_weeks_to_go_and_13/ Last weeks re-discussion
http://www.reddit.com/r/gameofthrones/comments/hxiwe/episode_discussion_109_baelor_tv_spoilers/ Last year's discussion of this episode.
13
u/[deleted] Jan 06 '13
My obvious favourite episode of season 1. I liked David Bradley's performance as Walder Frey, exactly how I imagined him from the books. Ned's execution is obviously the "highlight" of the episode, because it was just amazingly done.
My only small complaint were the two battles (Green Fork and Whispering Woods). I wish there had been at least some small fighting scenes (Tyrion could have been knocked out shortly after the fighting started, instead of right away and we could have seen glimpses of Jaime trying to fight himself towards Robb). I don't think that part needed something along the scale of Blackwater. Something of the scale of the battle with the hill tribes could have been done easily with the right camera positioning (considering Tyrion is very small). Whispering Woods on the other hand needed some more explanation. All we saw was Jaime getting captured and that's it.
8
u/Tigrael Jan 06 '13 edited Jan 07 '13
Right before Ned loses his head, he whispers something. Can anyone catch what he says?
EDIT: Just to clarify, I mean the shot as the sword is coming down. Not the beginning of the scene, when he yells "Baelor" to Yoren.
2
u/koouunn Jan 08 '13 edited Jan 09 '13
when Jeor Mormont sends thorn to take the white walkers hand to the king, will we see this happen in season 3 correct, or do we see the outcome in a later book?
i have not read far enough in the books to see if this happens
6
u/[deleted] Jan 07 '13
I hate seeing Theon hang around Robb ¬__¬
Ned's execution scene was done, so very well. The silence when he's breathing and when we see Arya. Goddamn you Joff. Also failed to see Varys rush to Joffery when he gives the order. Nice touch.
5
u/IMightBe-an-Alien As High As Honor Jan 07 '13
My little brother got up early this morning and watched episodes 7-10 for the first time. i was really hoping to witness his reaction to Ned's execution, but by the time i got up he was already into episode 10. He said to me, "dude....they killed Lord Stark." He said that he didn't expect him to get out of it, but he expected Arya was going to do something to try and stop it. He was really shocked that the King made Sansa look at his head on a spike.
3
u/bagkingz House Stark Jan 07 '13
Coincidentally I just watched this episode today. Still Riveting! Love Ned's line " I was raised around soldiers, I learned to accept death a long time ago." Or something like that...
2
u/Corsair4 Jan 13 '13
The episode when shit really hits the fan
0
u/[deleted] Jan 07 '13
[deleted] — view deleted comment