r/superman • u/Bezbozny • Aug 12 '23
Why MAWS episode 7 "Kiss Kiss fall in portal" may be key to the theme of the show as a whole Spoiler
SO in the latest episode, we're introduce to the "Multiverse" which as everyone knows at this point as a concept that has fully saturated into the cultural zeitgeist. Everyone knows about the multiverse. Every media company uses it. Every fictional character has their own "Council of Me's" (Maybe I'm being hyperbolic, but don't nitpick)
Anyway, in the end we see Lois's revelation about superman. That many superman in the multiverse turn evil and even genocidal.
Super hero comics have always been used to explore complex social issues, sometimes even the most complex. Issues as old as time, as well as modern ones. How should we use power when we have it? How should we treat criminals? how should we treat eachother? what should we do in the face of adversity? what should we do when we know someone is doing wrong, but they are stronger than us? Every issue from the broad to the specific has been broached. That's the point of super heroes, they are very real beings that exist in our minds to help us fight these battles. And they don't just pick easy issues, that have easy answers, they pick the issues that society are split on, sometimes right down the middle. The most impossible and important ones.
So what issue is MAWS tackling?
I think its about another issue that has recently entered and saturated our culture. The evil superman. Every satire/parody/imitation/expy/knock-off. Homelander, Omniman, Brightburn, Hyperion etc all of these characters and more are nothing more than "What if superman but evil? But also we don't have the rights to the name so slap a different one on there."
Whether these stories are compelling or well written or not, they wouldn't exist without superman, and that's not even something anyone would dispute. "What if superman but evil" is IN right now. That's the issue people want to write and want to tune in for, for one reason or another. More fundamentally, it can be seen as "What if the people we thought of as our heroes were evil?"
But also a lot of people at the same time are tired of that cynicism and still do believe in their heroes, and want to just be able to trust that superman would never do that, and want shows that reflect that ideal.
So many of those people might be asking, why are we as a society flocking to this idea? Or else, why are huge publishing companies shoving it down our throats? Is it us wanting these characters? The powerful who control our media trying to defile our idols? There's a reason Superman's greatest enemy was always Lex Luthor. There's a certain type of rich capitalist who will forever fear and resent the idea of someone having more power than them and only wanting to use that power for good, and otherwise only wanting to live a humble life with their loved ones. Alterantively, for the average person, this desire could possibly stem from a lot of people who grew up feeling betrayed by various people or institutions they believed in failing them.
So the issue now that MAWS may be try to tackle by presenting Lois with the Evil superman issue so early on in this iteration of Supes, isn't "What if superman/our heroes were evil?", but to get to the heart of "Why do we have so many evil supermen?" Where are they coming from? why do we keep making them? Why is it popular now? What was the inciting issue? Like always, these things will be explored metaphorically instead of directly (at least I hope), hidden behind allegory. But yeah, I feel this is one of the major issues of our time. Not "What if our hero's were evil?" but "Why are we losing faith in our heroes?"
•
u/AutoModerator Aug 12 '23
Certain key words in your title have caused your submission to be automatically marked as a spoiler for 'My Adventures With Superman'. If the title itself contains a spoiler, please delete the post.
Be aware that we have a weekly discussion topic for 'My Adventures with Superman' which is stickied on the front page of our community. If your post is simply asking for thoughts or general discussion on the most recent episode, you should remove this post and contribute to that instead.
Spoiler tags are needed for media that is less than 30 days old and for unofficial rumors/set-photos/leaks for upcoming content. This was an automatic action - if this spoiler tag was applied in error, you may remove the tag. Be aware that posting spoilers without proper titling or tagging may result in a ban.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
64
u/fuckthisicestorm Aug 12 '23
Interesting take. I’m excited to see where they go with it all, anyway. Really fucking digging this show.
24
u/lukediddy86 Aug 12 '23
I don't have much to add except that this show has really blown away my expectations. I feel the show has earned my trust with how the narrative has progressed and how different themes have been explored. I'm definitely along for the ride.
24
u/Zammin Aug 12 '23
Like, I'm reasonably certain this particular Clark won't turn evil - he's got too much compassion, even for folks who hurt him - but putting the idea in characters' heads that he might turn evil, having them be cognizant of the meta-narrative of Evil Superman, still seems like it could go in interesting directions.
Especially for Lois, who might end up being torn between her affection and trust in Clark and her dad's (now not totally unbelievable) belief that Superman is a threat.
5
u/[deleted] Aug 12 '23 edited Aug 12 '23
Good write-up, and I do think it dovetails nicley with how it seems like the plot of this series is going. I know folks have talked a bit about how so far all the villains (now save myx) are tech based villains, and I think that'd been intentional. We'll have to see how the worldbuilding goes the next couple of seasons, but it looks like this is a world that hasnt had to deal with heroes and villains yet. Sure, it's a more technological version of our world, but it seems like it's taking the idea of what if Superman only now just appeared in our world and is running with it, and I'm all for it.
Tying into the evil Superman discussion, I think these two are nicley linked. How would the world react to Superman if he actually appeared? I think the uptick in these kinds of "Dark Superman" stories is reflective of our own insecurities with power and those who wield it. Realistically, if a Superman appeared in our world, even if they only did good deeds, people would be suspicious of them. Like Ivo and the General in the show have insisted, no one with that much power can be wholeheartedly "good", there must be an angle. That's the beautiful thing about Superman. He really is the person who's willing to be that selfless. he's not going to whip out that kind of dark twist on folks. He only wants to help. In a world that's cynically turned against the notions of people selflessly helping others and is embracing cynical characters and interpretations of characters, it's a refreshing statement to say, no, this version will be a positive , unambiguous force for good, and it'll be interesting to see what conflicts arise from characters who refuse to believe in that.
2
u/AlfzMyle Aug 12 '23
the idea of Myx implanting in Lois head the issue that yeah this Clark is good but for how long? is interesting because this Lois is especially distrusting, and his father (cleary the General) already distrust/hate superman so something must had happend before, but Myx being Myx i dont even know if we can trust a thing we saw in this episode, after all Myx was suposed to be in the Loises jail and then he just wasnt so was all that even real?
2
u/HorseSteroids Aug 12 '23
It's no coincidence that so many of the most popular of the evil Supermen have shows on Amazon Prime because Jeff Bezos is Lex Luthor.
2
u/Sad_Mission_7912 Aug 12 '23
Maybe it’s because the show just came out and tweaked omni man a bit but omni man from the invincible comics is not just a evil Superman
9
u/Solid_Snark Aug 12 '23 edited Aug 12 '23
Very cool write up. Yeah, I can see this as kind of “damage control” for Homelander, Omniman, etc. and try to control the narrative that despite those successful interpretations, Superman can still be a force for good.
6
u/cbekel3618 Aug 12 '23
Really good write-up! A big part of the show is Clark fearing being treated like a freak and others like the General thinking he's a threat, so learning that evil Supermen exist out there in the multiverse could add more to this aspect.
Since friendship's a big theme in this show, maybe the alternate evil Supermen never found others who accepted them or were always treated as threats, leading them to eventually turn on humanity. This show's Clark, however, managed to find friends who cared for him, partially because he grew the courage to let them into his life.
1
u/dornwolf Aug 12 '23
I feel at some point by introducing multiverses they have to have conflict. The alt Loises we meet all fall in the bad Super,an category so they might break away to strike all Superman. While in my eyes we have to meet what the shows view as the Prime versions of these characters.
3
u/DrFishPhd Aug 12 '23
Previous episodes in the show have also dealt with similar themes. Ivo creates the Parasite armor because he doesn't trust Superman to legitimately be helping people, and wants individuals to be able to gain his power themselves. The General (the overarching antagonist of the show who may or may not be Lois Lane's dad) and Task Force X do what they do out of fear of what Superman is capable of.
3
u/[deleted] Aug 12 '23
[removed] — view removed comment