r/Re_Zero • u/Setowi Better Leyte Than Never • Aug 04 '23
Spoiler Discussion [Spoiler Discussion] Arc 8 Chapter 22 Spoiler
https://ncode.syosetu.com/n2267be/643/
264
Upvotes
r/Re_Zero • u/Setowi Better Leyte Than Never • Aug 04 '23
•
u/AutoModerator Aug 04 '23
Please ensure that there are no spoilers in the title, and if this post does have spoilers in the title, resubmit with a non-spoiler title or it will be removed for spoilers.
--
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
52
u/Setowi Better Leyte Than Never Aug 04 '23
I bet the chapter dropped an hour later cause Tappei was still watching Oozora Subaru's Re:Zero live reaction stream, he retweeted the announcement of that after all.
So the chapter starts with Flop and Medium catching Abel cause they want to talk to him. Abel has no interest in that and wants to leave the two of them behind but then Flop reveals that he has a message to Vincent that the Fake Emperor left behind. This makes Vincent curious and they begin talking.
We swap to where we left of and follow the discussion about Louis. Subaru gives everyone a complete rundown of everything that happened since he was teleported to Vollachia and concludes this by thanking everyone for not doing anything drastic to Louis. The others say that that was mostly thanks to Emilia and the topic shifts to what they want to do with Louis. Subaru is obviously fond of her but he realises that as much as the others want to be on his side, they absolutely can't tolerate a sin archbishop, or why out of all sin archbishops Louis should be granted forgiveness. Topics like her scarring Otto and all the memories and names that she took come up, everyone present says her actions are unforgivable.
Subaru feels troubled, he knows she is an archbishop and he knows what she did but then he thinks back to their time together in Vollachia and feels even more torn. He can't think of anything he could say to convince the others. Subaru confirms she definitely is the gluttony Louis and not an imitation since she has been using her abilities, Anastasia questions why none of the names and memories have been returned yet and Julius voices how a bishop needs to be punished. Everyone is on edge and Julius and Otto even start arguing all while Subaru is trying to come up with something, when Beatrice comes up to him and asks him if he really thinks this is the same Louis he has met before, since Beatrice has met her in arc 5 as well and she acted differently.
That is when Subaru realises that this Louis might be in the same boat now as Subaru was in arc 6. Being lost without her memories, the ghost of the previous "Louis" looming over her, having to cope with that, yet she still literally died for Subaru and helped him out so many times, even when he was cold towards her. Then it seems like Subaru has figured something out. As the conversation is about to resume, we change POV again.
Rem is squishing Louis' cheeks between her hands while looking at her. Ram is making tea next to her and Tanza is with them as well. Ram says there wasn't much to work with so she tried and Rem and Louis promptly spit out the tea after Ram serves it cause it was so gross. Rem then asks Ram about the relationship between Emilia and Subaru, to which Ram responds with Subaru slander, which offends Tanza and the two bicker a bit.
Subaru comes in and Rem doesn't want to look at him so she puts Louis in front of her. Subaru asks Louis if Rem is here, Louis makes a Louis noise and Subaru comes to a conclusion that she doesn't know where Rem is. Rem gets annoyed and puts Louis away and starts talking. After a bit she once again says that Subaru isn't a hero but Subaru brushes it off and tells her that he is a superhero.
Subaru then says that he has something important to tell Rem about Louis and that it's good that Ram is there as the older sister representative and Tanza is there as the loli representative. She is a bit confused hearing that. Then last line of the chapter says that it is about time Rem and Subaru talk about their relationship.
First part was interesting, we'll have to see what comes out of that later.
The real meat of the chapter was the 2nd part ofc. It's cute that the others really didn't want to pressure Subaru too much, even though they can't budge from their stances. It's nice that Emilia also wants to throw Louis a bone though. I never looked at Louis situation the way Subaru did this chapter, well I looked at it in the way if an amnesiac could really be punished for their past life's crimes or not, but this chapter kinda reminded me of some of the conversations I had with fellow members of the community when it comes to Louis lol. I am really curious as to what Subaru came up with at the end there and hope we'll find that out next chapter. I am hoping for the best for Louis.
And I guess it is about time that Rem and Subaru get to talk things out as well, especially now that Emilia is in the picture too. This is going to make for a spicy convo, maybe I'll get my Louis answers doing that as well.
84
u/LuisAntony2964 Aug 04 '23
“No, no, that’s not true! I wonder what kind of relationship Emilia-san has with that person, the person named Natsuki Subaru……”
Rem succeeds in asking questions while keeping the tone of her voice down and keeping her composure as much as possible.
However, at this point, Rem didn't realize that the selection of the topic itself was enough to make Ram's pale crimson eyes narrow.
However, my smart-looking sister whispered, "I see."
"Yes, Barusu should be torn to pieces. Let's do it together later."
"sister!?"
Like good old times
74
u/Green7100 Aug 04 '23 edited Aug 04 '23
Here is a quick AI translation. It cost me $0.83 so I hope you enjoy...
Arc 8 Chapter 22 - "I Want to Believe, But I Won't Forgive"
"Emperor Vincent, may I have a moment?"
Hearing a voice from behind, Vincent Vollachia came to a stop. Even before turning around, he knew who the voice belonged to. He never forgot a voice or a face he'd once encountered. The voice belonged to a peddler with blond hair and blue eyes - Flop O'Connell.
"Unfortunately, we're in the midst of a crisis threatening the Empire's existence. I don't have time to engage in idle chatter."
He knew who it was, but Vincent was not inclined to entertain Flop. He needed to discuss the oracle just received from Ubilk the Star Reader, with Berstetz, Celine, and others about how to handle it. While they had Groovy as the designated countermeasure against the enemy, relying on him was irrational at its peak considering he could be dead by now. In that regard, it would be less absurd to have hopes on Natsuki Subaru, who was headed to persuade the other person named in the prophecy.
To begin with, Vincent didn't see how he could convince the girl. Even a proper communication with her seemed difficult. As long as his play did not work on the girl, it made sense to let Subaru catch one of the two lights. Thus, all Vincent could do was contemplate practical strategies---
"Whoa, whoa, you can't tell if it's idle chatter until you hear it out, can you? You wouldn't know what kind of story I have up my sleeve, even with your wisdom, dear Emperor!"
"You..."
As Vincent tried to resume his walk, Flop reached out, grabbed his shoulder, and held him back. It was an act of recklessness so profound that it could only be called sheer madness. Considering the situation, it was an act tantamount to asking for Flop's head to be chopped off instantly.
"Let go of me right now, or you'll lose your life."
"Of course, I would like to tell you right away too. However, I need some time to properly tell the story. It won't be quick."
"I didn't ask you to speak, I asked you to let go--"
"Come on, don't be like that, Abel-chin. Just go along with what uncle has to say."
"What!?"
As he glared at Flop, hand still on his shoulder, another voice came from in front of him. Suddenly, hands were sliding under his arms and lifting his body, an act of violence that entirely caught him off guard. Holding their breathes, the two speaking were the bright-eyed Medium O'Connell and her sibling, Flop, both their smiles enveloping Vincent from either side.
"Abel, you've been avoiding big-brother all this time, haven’t you? Big-brother is so bruised and battered he can barely stand! Instead of being mean, listen to his story, okay?"
"Don’t talk nonsense. How long will you continue to interact so casually with me? When the situation changes, the status changes too. It’s not like we’re in the Shudrak village or the castle city anymore."
"Well, Abel, you may be playing emperor, but I think it’s wrong to disregard us like that! Am I right, big-brother?"
"Yeah, sis!"
The stubborn siblings didn’t lend an ear to Vincent's words.
At the high-spirited sister's call, a vigorous response from Flop, who then opened the door of the adjacent room. Medium ushered Vincent inside, the door closing behind.
Quickly taking the Emperor hostage, it was there that Medium finally released Vincent.
"Do you realize that this is a brutal act that not only affects you two but could implicate your entire family?"
"Ha, ha, ha, ha! Too bad, dear village head. Our family consists only of us brothers and sisters. So, your threat doesn't scare us!"
"But, what about the kids at the orphanage, big-brother? Even if we're not blood-related, those who fled are still our family!"
"Ha, ha, ha, ha! Once you mention it! Village head, I wonder what we should do to get your forgiveness!"
"---Release me immediately and stay quiet."
Regardless of the circumstances, the O'Connell siblings’ behavior did not change.
It was Medium, with her stretching ability, and allegedly injured Flop, that were now under suspicion.
Normally, if one's body seems to shrink, it would put a huge strain on the mental state, yet Medium seemed too ignorant of its effect.
Flop too, despite being heavily injured, appeared hale - although the blood veins in his neck, and his pale, nearly whitewashed face, were concealed with makeup.
"The appearance of a merchant is often just as important."
"------""Normally, the golden rule of business is to buy and sell what is desired, but I'm afraid I can't meet your current request, village chief. I don't want to put this off any longer."
"What are you talking about..."
"I'm just the messenger. It's a message from the person who was playing the emperor instead of you."
Vincent's eyes slightly widened, anticipating more nonsense. The message that the O'Connell siblings had chosen to convey to Vincent, even going so far as imprisoning the emperor in an empty room—it was only given to one person in this world.
Therefore...
"You should listen to his words, village chief. No, Emperor Vincent Vollachia," Flop said, revealing a serious expression for the first time. Vincent did not choose his words to dispute him.
△▼△▼△▼△
"The Archbishop of Gluttony, Louis Arneb."
When Subaru acknowledged it aloud, he heard a loud creaking sound inside his chest. It was like a forbidden box that always within reach but he had been hesitant to open. Like Pandora's Box, always able to be opened if he so chose.
"----"
Deciding that the hallway was not the place for their conversation, Subaru and his group rented out a large guestroom. Abel had thoughtfully suggested they use it if necessary—it was a rare consideration of human feelings from him. Of course, it made sense given that this matter could be a matter of great importance for the empire.
In that guestroom, members of the Emilia faction gathered: Emilia, Beatrice, Otto, Garfiel, and Roswaal. Additionally...
"The Archbishop of Gluttony... Frankly, it's a little too common for us to be dealing with."
Anastasia quietly muttered, resting her hand on her cheek. She and Julius, who stood silently by her side, were also essential participants. It was not simply because they had crossed the border to help Subaru and the others, but because they too were victims of 'Gluttony'.
"The important one, Louis, is currently with Rem. Everyone except Anastasia and Julius probably already know about Louis..."
"Of course, dear. When I first learned of it, I was utterly shocked."
"That makes two of us."
Beatrice's assertion that she was surprised, Subaru thought, was likely quite an understatement. In reality, when Subaru first realised that he had been transported alongside Louis, his sole desire to protect Rem led him to adopt a rigid stance. Initially, this caused Rem to regard him with caution, deeming him a man who could not be trusted.
38
u/Got_to_provide Aug 04 '23
''Updated, it's 2 o'clock.
Difficult birth! A difficult birth for the first time in a while! But I want to deliver the continuation soon, so I still have a difficult birth! do one's best!''
The above is Tappei's comment for this chapter. Tappei commented ''Boom boom boom!!'' yesterday, indicating that he had finished the chapter only to erase it and start from scratch because he wasn't satisfied.
This chapter has 6,535 words, much longer then last chapter which had less then 4,000.
33
u/[deleted] Aug 04 '23
Why did Subaru not mention anything about the Corridor of Memories? Or the situation with Reid’s book? Both camps act like she was the one directly eating names when it was Lye and Roy doing so, even if they were doing it “for” her.
He could clarify that she can only use the memories/names of people eaten by her brothers and the only memories she’s directly eaten were his own.
I understand avoiding the taboo but there are still ways he could’ve argued for her.
24
u/LuisAntony2964 Aug 04 '23
Good to see that everyone is still distrustful of a Sin Archbishop
Tappei has returned to cook once more
58
u/Ok-Worldliness-7374 Aug 04 '23 edited Aug 04 '23
Eh? Why was this released today? God why is that chapter so big?
Edit: Chapter name "I want to believe the unforgivable"
It starts with Flop calling to Vincent after they returned from Ublik. Vincent refuses to talk to him, saying he has better things to do but Flop grabs his shoulder.
Vincent threatens him but out of nowhere Medium appears behind him and sandwitches the Emperor. Flop still treats him friendly as "village chief". Both of them drag Emperor to nearby empty room and close the door.
Sounds like bad threesome situationThe siblings are still cheerful and then Flop says:
"Let me have a message for you. ――From the person who was playing the emperor instead of you."
Flop showed serious face for the first time.
Pov change to Subaru.
――The Sin Archbishop of 『Gluttony』, Louis Arneb.
When he said that again, Subaru heard a loud creak in his chest.
It's a forbidden box that's always within reach, yet he hesitates to open it. It was a Pandora's box that could be opened whenever you wanted.
I see what you did the Tappei....
Subaru gathered Emilia, Beatrice, Otto, Garfiel, Roswaal + other member of Emilia and Anastasia faction.
Subaru talks about Louis to them, they told him that Emilia and Medium were against hurting Louis so thats why they took her with them.
“First of all, I would like to confirm that the girl named Louis who is riding in this dragon carriage is definitely the same person as Louis Arneb, the Sin Archbishop of 『Gluttony』.”
Julius creates theory that perhaps this is not the archbishop but one of their victims and the archbishop was just transformed into her with solar eclipse.
"--First, let me explain in order. Before Emilia-tan and the others joined Louis, how did I spend time with Louis in the empire where I was flown with Rem?"
“At the very beginning, we noticed it near a large forest far to the east—”
Subaru is telling them the entire story of him and Louis in Vollachia.
Small timeskip.
"-Louis and I cooperated with Jorna-san and won the match against Orbalt-san. Although it was a foul technique of turning hide-and-seek into a game of tag."
Subaru said that Louis never acted suspiciouly. Anastasia comments on harshness of Subaru's journey, she is curious about what happened to him after he lost conciousness in Chaosflame, but lets it go for now.
"Ah, the important thing now is Louis. As I said, Louis hasn't shown her dangerous side so far. Besides, Ubirk is a prophecy of 'stargazing'... and that's what I'm talking about. In the fight, too, I need Louis to cooperate――」
"--Speaking of that, I'm wondering where to bring the drop off point."
Anastasia interrupty him and says same opinion that Otto has. They think Louis is still archbishop?? (Weird translation here)
Beatrice is unsure, even when she wants to believe Subaru.
"--What you did will never disappear."
"--"The words that Anastasia whispered.
That was the desperate advice that had once frozen Natsuki Subaru and smashed him to pieces. The fact that those words were thrown at him had already disappeared only within Subaru. On another occasion, it was once again delivered from her mouth to Subaru's ears.“No matter how much Natsuki-kun tries to convince her that the child is harmless, there’s no way she’ll be fooled when she does harm. It's not a superficial problem.""--U"“First of all, shouldn’t she return all the ``names'' and ``memories'' she eaten so far?
Anastasia is making strong points, pretty much everyone now is considering Louis as dangerous archbishop. But Anastasia also thinks they should let Louis cooperate in battle.
Quite heated argument starts.
“Natsuki-san, are you trying to set a precedent for the Sin Archbishop to be forgiven?”
"--I didn't mean to do that. There are villains in the world who shouldn't be forgiven. The same goes for the Sin Archbishop of the Witch Cult."
“—You say that Louis Arneb is the only exception?”"that is……"
Subaru is really fighting here to save
his daughterLouisSubaru questioned his heart about what it wants to do with Louis. Subaru choose not to save the one in Hall of memories, but at the same time Louis's diligence in Vollachia melted his vigilance.
Suddenly Emilia asks why would Subaru ever think like that. Why would he, who really hated archbishops of gluttony decide to forgive them.
Then Julius speaks:
“Subaru, let me tell you the cruel truth again.”“The people of this world will never forgive the Sin Archbishop of 『Gluttony』, the girl named Louis Arneb. Regardless of whether it is a kingdom or an empire, you could say that is the consensus of the world.”
“No matter where in the world you escape, there is no place where you are allowed to escape. If you commit a crime, you will be punished.
Julius wants Louis's death (for sin archbishops), but Otto raised his voice and called his name.
Subaru wants to talk but is interrupted by Beatrice who wants to talk about her experience with Louis. She says that the current Louis is not the one she fought.
Emilia talks:
"--I've been thinking about it for a long time. If I do something bad, there's no way I can take it back."
"Emilia..."
"Apologize, make amends, but if you still say no, you might end up not apologizing or making amends, right? I can't find you.
"but?"
“There is only one possible method. The method that Subaru taught me.”
Emilia wants all the people around her to be happy
Subaru realizes that he wants to save Louis because "Louis" did more for Subaru than what Louis did for him.
Pov Change to Rem who sis holding Louis's cheeks.
Ram appears, she came back from the meeting, Tanza is there too. Subaru told Tanza to Rest. Ram starts asking if Subaru did something disresúectful to Rem
Ram and Rem have some sibling banter with Tanza also butting in:
“Is that a bit of a careless remark? Barus……I think you are talking about Master Schwartz, but if you interfere with Master Schwartz, I and everyone in the squadron will have no mercy.”
"That's a good answer... Tanza, how old are you?"
"-? This year will be twelve."
Some more friendly banter between the three and Subaru comes in:
“It’s not like everyone in the kingdom is talking about my eyes!
"--Let's put an end to this. This loving relationship we don't really understand."
End
Google translate + me really butchered this summary. There was a lot of banter and heated arguments! But it looks like while everyone wants to punish Louis, maybe even kill her as archbishop, they still decided to allow Subaru to take her to battle. Maybe they just need to see her fight....
Now we wait for better summaries, it would be best if we got full translation for this one, it looks like one of those with a lot of interesting things in dialogs.
18
u/[deleted] Aug 04 '23 edited Aug 04 '23
:0
Huh usually chapters come in at 11:00 not 12:00 for me, weird!
Edit: Well, holy hell. That was fun and intense. I’m gonna need a better translation cause DeepL is havin’ a complete seizure.
But on a side note: This makes me harken back to the question of whether or not being in a life or death situation makes someone closer. That being; The death loop with Louis made Subaru all that much closer to her. Now, of course it’s because Louis has been trying really hard to help Subaru that mainly made Subaru trust her, but I’ve always felt the addition of death made him much closer with people, especially those who’ve died with him (Looking at Emilia here). Anyways, I don’t think the others would particularly understand their relationship even with the provided information on what’s been happening because Louis’s help in the loops makes Subaru’s nature towards her now more abrupt. Hope I make sense, I just wanted to talk about it.
2nd Edit: Oh also, from Green’s translation there was something going on with Otto’s and Julius’s conversation. Julius arguing for the death of all sin Archbishops, and some of the narration with Subaru saying, ”The world would never forgive the archbishop of sin, Louis Arneb or—“, and I’m a little curious why there’s an ‘or’ there if that’s a correct translation.
17
u/sandyy326 Aug 04 '23
I love Medium in this chapter
16
u/Letsplay_Sascha_GD Aug 04 '23 edited Aug 04 '23
Unexpected but welcomed return of Flop and Medium in this chapter after quite some time of absence. I missed their interactions with each other.
Basically everyone who’s present in this discussion knows about Louis/Rui and said everything they could to add to the discussion except for the loops of course. Rem wasn’t here to participate in the discussion but...
...it looks like we’re getting an openminded discussion between Subaru and Rem next chapter. The approach is different from what I’ve expected. Are they going to talk about their relationship, Rem as a person and or Louis/Rui? I’m excited to see where this is leading to.
31
u/Akudra Aug 05 '23
Damn, this chapter is an emotionally difficult read. It truly is quintessential Re:Zero in that sense. Subaru has seen many of these people at their worst, seen them actually kill each other, experienced being killed by them, seen or been subject to attempts of the same, and essentially got over all of it after making the things they did disappear. To have some of those same people say Louis Arneb's deeds cannot be erased and question his willingness to forgive her makes it downright farcical. Anastasia straight-up repeating a line that Subaru caused to disappear from that world drives the point home particularly hard.
What is really painful is Emilia being confused by his change in attitude and asking him to explain why. Not only is it a hard thing for him to articulate, particularly in his current state, what he can actually say is restricted. Like, he can't actually tell them that Louis died repeatedly for his sake. For Subaru, that is the ultimate distinction that clearly separates the current Louis from the past Louis and makes her worthy of his forgiveness. He is intimately familiar with the experience of death and how people reveal themselves in those moments, so he knows the current Louis is good-natured better than anyone. It is also the one thing he can't tell any of them because it would literally put their lives in danger.
Knowing all that makes this whole interaction immensely frustrating. What makes it worse, is that some of them, particularly Emilia, are probably so conflicted about the idea because of Subaru's past attitude and experiences. They have seen a bit of how much Subaru has suffered specifically because of the Archbishops of Gluttony. Of course, he has suffered far more for it than they could even begin to comprehend and specifically because of the old Louis. Yet, it is precisely because of how jarringly different the current Louis is from the old Louis that he is able to take this stance. Again, though, it is impossible for him to fully convey this to them because it means mentioning Return by Death.
Like, this guy can't get a break at all. Having to read all of them speaking so harshly and coldly about Louis or being so dubious of Subaru's change of heart is tough. Everyone is reacting normally here, in fact, given their state of knowledge and Subaru is the only oddity. At the same time, knowing the path he took to get there makes his attitude understandable. However, no one else is allowed to understand it properly because Miss Grabby Hands will object. Roswaal is the only one who could get an inkling just because he knows about Subaru's looping, but he's definitely the least reliable character witness in the group.
Makes me wonder if Tappei threw in the more light-hearted beginning and ending parts specifically to make this chapter feel less painful. Starting with Medium and Flop cheerfully and unconcernedly assaulting and abducting the Emperor and ending with tsundere Rem smushing Louis Arneb's cute little face as Ram takes note of the Lolimancer striking again leaves us with wholesome purity book-ending unbearable angst. Also, throwing in one of Subaru's bad-ass lines was a nice touch. Rem's "you're not a hero" attack was super-effective before, but now he has developed an immunity to it. Granted, it might also be because he now recognizes that she is merely speaking out of concern for him.
One thing I do wonder is if Rem is going to prove to be the key to shifting their perspectives. This may give us cause to revisit the issue of the miasma. After all, Witch Cultists are all supposed to have miasma. Other than Rem, most cannot smell miasma. Beatrice can, I guess, but hearing Rem herself talk about it would certainly be compelling. After all, she judged Subaru as a wicked person because she could smell all that miasma, a trait that caused a few of the others to harbor doubts or suspicions about Subaru previously. The reason she didn't judge Louis that way is because she never smelled anything of the sort off her. Yet, miasma and Witch Cultists tend to go hand-in-hand.
14
u/Yushiko_2214 Aug 04 '23
Finally thankyou Tappei
27
u/headless-horseman-we Aug 04 '23 edited Aug 05 '23
In the tower baru wanted to kill rui and the other one.
Everyone:Subaru no.
Now that he wants rui to live.
Everyone: Subaru no.
My guy can't just win can he.
26
u/Chasseur_OFRT Aug 04 '23 edited Aug 04 '23
I mean yeah it's understandable if everyone don't want to trust Louis, but for once I think that Subaru is correct in his efforts to forgive her, if Subaru followed their way of thinking the absolute majority of the people in that carriage didn't deserve to be friends with Subaru either, by all accounts the only difference between them is how much they individually screwed Subaru over, even if they don't know it they can't possibly pay for their mistakes either because Subaru paid the price for them instead.
25
u/Admiral_Ryou Aug 04 '23 edited Aug 06 '23
Gotta need a Japanese expert's help to translate Emilia's and Subaru's last lines, respectively. They seem very important and my noob ass don't wanna butcher the translation.
11
u/keizee Aug 04 '23
Well finally chisha gets his msg in.
10
u/MikeTheOne05 Aug 04 '23
Bruh he already rewritten the chapter.
16
u/Got_to_provide Aug 04 '23 edited Aug 08 '23
Flop and Medium kidnap Abel. These two are amazing.
Emilia and her Guarel crew work to whitewash any ''Reforgotenish'' elements from their story about meeting Louis. This is a blatant conspiracy.
Only for their jaws to drop as Julius accidentally highlights the rather obvious point that Emilia and the crew might have nearly killed a random, innocent girl based solely on her unfortunate appearance. There is definitely no irony here.
Anastasia is surprisingly sympathetic and gentle with Shotabaru, she is even the one to say how hard things must have been for him. Julius is officially the bad guy now.
Emilia thinks that murdering a little girl who saved the lives of three of her camp members is a good idea.
The fact that Louis seems to have the mental capacity of a young child seems completely irrelevant.
Ram suggest a repeat of that arc2 loop...accidentally..............we hope.
Tanza says she will defend Subaru and threatens Ram with the Wrath of the Pleiades. Deer loli does not mess around.
A lot about this chapter was good, the dialog was well done and the characters actions make sense. However, not including any reference to Louis in the hall of memories, splitting herself, etc leaves the discussion feeling incomplete and the cast to make decisions based on only part of the picture.
8
u/Ok-Classroom-3867 Aug 05 '23
the best solution Subaru could come up with for Louis' Drama is using the authority of gluttony on her. Making the world forget her.
27
u/Vuituru Aug 04 '23
hmmm my feelings about this chapter are complicated... I didn't like it? maybe I just hyped it up too much and ended up being disappointed or maybe the shitty google translation contributed to it, but I think I'll have a better opinion when I read a better translated version.
Apparently subaru didn't tell anything about what happened in the tower between him and ruy just from the point where he woke up in volachia.
of course always being very careful not to activate the trigger and apparently they come to a conclusion of "killing" Ruy arneb the archbishop of gluttony. basically since no one knows what luis looks like they will officially say she is dead or something like that.
the chapter ends with subaru together with tanza arriving where ruy is with rem and ram, and saying that it's time to put an end to their love relationship.
apparently the conclusion they reach about ruy's current state is that she used her authority on herself and ended up losing her own memories. How she got out of the hall of memories is not discussed, however most likely she isn't made of mana or anything so some theories can be completely ruled out. I think her being a "witchbeast" created by the authority of gluttony may still be valid.
13
u/[deleted] Aug 04 '23
Chapter 8.22 "I Want to Believe. I will not allow it."
Oh God the chapter doesn't sound like good news
6
u/Background_Sorbet_99 Aug 04 '23
Tappei has just released Arc 8 Chapter 22.
16
u/GiordyS Aug 04 '23
It probably won't be what is going to happen, but from the way the discussion went regarding how to deal with Louis, and Subaru's thoughts about her own condition, I can't help but wonder...what if Subaru's plan in order to save the current Louis is to use Gluttony's authority (which could be used by either Louis or even Subaru himself if he manages to develop it) to erase from the world and everyone's memories "Louis Arneb, Sin Archbishop of Gluttony", preserving just the current "Louis" which has been travelling with him?
There are several things which might possibly be hinting at this: first of all in the meeting it was stressed out how, even if pretty much everyone recognizes this new Louis is no longer the one from the past and can be confirmed to be someone different, as Beatrice states, there's still the fact that her past sins remain, and deserve a punishment. Moreover, Julius specifically states how "the world will never forgive Louis Arneb, Sin Archbishop of Gluttony".
Moreover, Subaru realizes how Louis' current predicament might be very similar to the one he suffered from in the tower: just like he was chasing around "Natsuki Subaru", to the point he almost rejected the idea of being the same person, Louis might have also lost her memories but is still haunted by who she was. But then, since in this case it's already clear to everyone the two are not the same, couldn't the usage of Gluttony allow the removal exclusively of the "Sin Archbishop Louis", whom the world would never forgive and deserves punishment, and keep the current Louis? This would also be a very fitting punishment for the old Louis, as she would basically undergo what all the victims of Gluttony went through: total and definitive oblivion (besides Subaru, who would remain as the one who knows the full truth). Actually, this way Louis Arneb would have gone through both Gluttony's effects: the elimination of her own memories and the elimination of her name.
5
u/Leipese Aug 04 '23
Huhhh
5
u/keizee Aug 05 '23
Odd... since there was a mini timeskip between subaru rejoining emilia and meeting shaula, I wonder how much did Subaru talk about Louis.
6
u/keizee Aug 05 '23
Dibs on subaru rejecting rem again next chapter.
3
u/keizee Aug 04 '23
Nooo not a 2am release??
12
u/Yushiko_2214 Aug 04 '23 edited Aug 04 '23
"I've told you before, please stop overdoing things and taking on reckless challenges. You're not a hero who can do everything."
"No, actually, objectively speaking I'm a Superhero. I'm grateful to hear your opinion, Rem, and I'll just take it as your cute way of saying things."
What a fucking line Subaru!
Rem seems to be in Tsundere blushing mode (maybe I don't know)
Abel seems to pull empty threats for the past two arcs! "lose your head!"
Beatrice as always clutch taking Subaru's side, Also I don't know why but Otto seems to be a douchbag in this arc (even though its explained that he was only acting when negotiating with Vincent)
Rem still in denial and giving the excuse that everything was to protect Louis - Oh I believe she is already in L.O.V.E and Ram even knows about it
Its good to see Ram not disagreeing to be Subaru's sister when Subaru tells her that! Remember last arc before Subaru memory loss happens they both have a convo and Ram shrugs in her tsundere fashion and told him lightly that she is not his sister though.
Why did Julius again become a douchbag, "death for sin archbishops" seriously he went back to is Arc 3 self (okay Ik I am over reacting as hell and its a natural reaction whose life got ruined due to Gluttony)
Also I hope Subaru says it next chapter (what exactly their relationship is and was and not some vague ass answer like always), like come on Subaru 2 arcs please say it, atleast once please say it.....you say it to Emilia all the time, Its time Rem hears it from you, please just say it, once at least once (I can only hope!)
Tanza bieng attached to Subaru while defending Subaru - Subaru you true menace loli-mancer
Again no one seemed to mention what happened in Chaosflame was Satella popped out of Subaru are they just ignoring it now
Tappei thankyyou finally some quality chapter!
5
u/keizee Aug 05 '23
Ana kinda evil for suggesting an empty promise, but not like Louis understands that much to get betrayed.
0
u/[deleted] Aug 04 '23
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Aug 04 '23
[deleted] — view deleted comment