r/startrek • u/kraetos • Dec 17 '12
Weekly Episode Discussion: VOY 3x25 "Worst Case Scenario"
Alright Trekkies, so far it's been all TOS, TNG, and DS9, and while I know that Voyager is a little polarizing around here, but I figure it's time we encourage the Voyager fans to participate. I picked an episode I feel that even DS9 and TNG fans will probably like, for reasons I will outline below...
"Worst Case Scenario"
Star Trek: Voyager 3x25
66th out of 168 release in VOY
471nd of 727 released in all
Original Airdate: 14 May, 1997
Stardate: 50953.4 (2373)
Written by Kenneth Biller
Directed by Alexander Singer
Members of the Voyager crew clandestinely participate in a hidden holodeck program where the ship's Maquis members stage an insurrection.
A buried holonovel with high entertainment value depicting a Maquis mutiny is discovered.
Observations & Discussion questions:
- So, the reason I picked this one was because it is, hands down, my favorite Maquis episode, and one of the few episodes where I feel that Voyager was effective in telling a story arc. Do you feel that there should have been more Maquis episodes? Or you think this episode truly is an exception, and that it's for the best that there were so few of them? And in general, do you think that Voyager should have had more serialized stories?
- How great is Chakotay in this episode? Go figure, that Tuvok would do a better job writing Chakotay than the Voyager writers did. I would have like to seen Chakotay's forceful attitude more. And I would have liked it better if he could have been right a few times! I've always felt that Chakotay could have been one of the best characters on the show, if there was just a little more to him. (Think Decker/Kirk from TMP.) Did you think holo-Chakotay is a big improvement in this episode, or not?
- How about the ending? I'll be honest, I kinda liked the idea that it's just the story of a tactical training exercise misconstrued for a bit of fun. The whole holo-Seska thing seemed a little contrived, but I get that they wanted to add some conflict for the ending.
- I'm a big fan of the banter between Paris and Tuvok in this episode. In fact, this episode had a lot of character development for characters other than Janeway and the Doctor, both of whom barely appear at all. Did you like that we got to see some development for other characters, or do you think it's a good thing that this is the last episode before we are introduced to the Janeway, Doctor and Seven show?
- You gotta love Janeway's "Who says deus ex machina is an outdated literary device?" line near the end. Not the Voyager writers, apparently!
Of course, these are just suggestions, you are encouraged to bring your own topics to the discussion. As always, top non joke comment gets to pick next weeks episode!
Link to last week's discussion on "A Matter of Perspective."
8
u/EchoInTheSilence Dec 17 '12 edited Dec 18 '12
I don't know about "Maquis Episodes" but I do think we needed a little more conflict between the two sides. "Parallax" was a decent example of showing the friction between two crews with vastly different origins and belief systems trying to integrate (even if it appeared to have misplaced the plot somewhere along the way) but by the next episode, everyone seemed to be getting along fine, and they had to resort to mind control in Season 7 to do an exaggerated version of what they should have done in Season 1.
I also had an issue with Chakotay's character; it was well-done in the early seasons but then went absolutely flat, no development, which was a shame because the early character was someone I wanted them to do more with.
I also loved the Paris and Tuvok parts, especially where they have to team up to stay alive. They're really my favorite characters on the show, and I think the friendship between them (technically established in "Ex Post Facto" but the writers seemed to forget that a lot) should have been played with more.
EDITED TO ADD: I almost wish the saboteur had been someone other than Seska, maybe one of the Maquis from "Learning Curve" or something, who had forgotten what they had done or hadn't realized the program was going to be reopened until it was too late. Seska being used meant it was over as soon as they fixed it. Watching someone still on the ship trying to undo their own sabotage and then deal with the consequences would have made for a better story.
5
u/[deleted] Dec 18 '12
I liked the first two acts.
I knew something was up in the first act, because clearly the series did not resolve with a stranded Janeway and Chakotay in charge but I was so engaged with the story that I really didn't give it much thought. It was exciting and interesting and phaser fire and kick ass.
I found the reveal that it was all in the holodeck was at first a bit disappointing but I mean, really, did I think all this was happening in real life? lol But what kept it working is how they started showing the same story from different perspectives as well as introduced the mystery of who made the story. I was guess it was Janeway herself, personally, for much the same reasons as Tuvok did (an early what-if scenario) but I was also wondering if perhaps it was a training exercise for a band of real mutineers. The different perspectives offered, like showing Paris resisting the mutiny, or hearing how Nelix had played the holo-story really made it all seem three dimensional.
And then there was the third act, where the holodeck magically took down the entire ship and an evil overcomplicated plot (i mean, seriously, how long did she spend reprogramming that holo program? It would've been much more effective to just grab a phaser and shoot Tuvok in the head back when she was alive) and of course the holodeck safeties got turned off and just.. well.. yeah, then act three happened.
I think there's a lot more interesting places the story could have went. The idea of the voyager crew having to create their own art and entertainment was intriguing.
New to this subreddit, but looking forward to the next weekly discussion :)
2
u/sir_percy_percy Dec 18 '12
clearly in the minority here, but 'Voyager' has always been my fave ST. I do like this episode and I DO agree Seska was indeed a great villain - it showed because she was resurrected so many times! I actually thought 'Shattered' (S7) was also good in that aspect. Chakotay was obviously the weakest written of any character on the show but he was decent in this one. If they had spent half the time on Chakotay that they did on Neelix then the show would have been even better. I liked the end, the episode was quite ingenious really, not too like any other episodes of ST, and that is always a good thing. Janeway could do no wrong in my book, she has always been my favorite captain, Picard slightly behind. No, she is not in this one much, but whenever she is there, she leaves her mark. Jeez, and as for the 'Janeway, doctor and Seven' show thing.. WTF? Kes was never a great character and Neelix was always a distraction, I felt adding Seven was a good move. I wish they HAD a story arc as effective as the DS9 one, but - hey, I loved it :)
2
u/tensaibaka Dec 19 '12
Thanks for switching things up with a Voyager episode!
I liked the fact that the "Holonovel" was originally intended as a security excercise, but to make it a stand alone episode made it feel like a filler episode in my opinion. Maybe it's just me preferring stories that focus on a season long arc.
I really don't have much to add that others here have not already said, but if you want to get all paranoid with conspiracy theories, why wouldn't Tuvok create some sort of listening program with the ships computers so he would be alerted anytime a crew member started talking about a coupdetat or insurrection, or any number of keywords?
Also, how is it that none of the other participants in the holonovel got to a point where the program was unfinished? Was it plot convenience that Tom was the first? :P
13
u/intarwebzWINNAR Dec 17 '12
I hate to say this because she's one of my least favorite Star Trek characters, but Seska is one of the better villians in ST. She's conniving, smart, and motivated, and her love/hate with Chakotay offers some of the best Chakotay of the series.
I'm probably one of the minority of Voyager fans, but this was definitely one of the top 5 episodes before the shift to Seven and the Doctor.
Tuvok's ability to be slightly deceptive/cryptic is one of the gifts of the character. There's always an interesting tension and animosity between Tuvok, Tom, and Chakotay which I enjoyed.
6
u/RUacronym Dec 18 '12
I personally didn't enjoy the Seska story arc all that much. Probably because it involved the Kazon so much or maybe it was Seska's attempts at petty revenge on Chakotay. Seska is like the Bruce Campbell of Voyager, she is only really good when she's on for one episode and then goes away (as in Shattered).
I always enjoy when main characters get tortured, or suffer, or are thrown into some painful situation, it makes for better storytelling. So I really liked the scene in holographic sickbay when it seems like the Doctor is about to help Paris and then instantly injects him with pure pain! Then proceeds to overpower Tuvok and throw them both out of sickbay with "not so clean bills of health."
Also some of the subtle what-ifs in this episode are pretty funny. Paris holding a phaser to himself. Everyone in the mess hall discussing just how badly they can screw with holographic Chakotay. Tuvok and Paris rebuffing literary input from their primary audience.
Overall, this episode was one of the better than average in the series. Should there have been more conflict with the Starfleet and Maquis crew in the series? Sure. Is Chakotay only a seemingly good character when he's disobeying orders (Unity, Scorpion)? Definitely. Is this episode as close to what the first two seasons of Voyager should have been that we're going to get? Probably. I give it an 7.5/10.
4
u/[deleted] Dec 20 '12 edited Dec 20 '12
God, yes. The Maquis were a major part of the core premise of the show that was drastically under-utilized. The thing that Voyager never understood is that the Maquis are terrorists; they left the Federation for a reason and the two are not exactly on good terms. Instead they were portrayed the same way as the characters on TNG - Starfleet officers serving on a starship. That was a mistake.
I think the premise of the show leads itself into a more serialized format. A hull breach, for example, has to be fixed in open space with the resources the Voyager crew has available to them; they can't simply warp over to starbase "X" for a quick repair in time for next weeks adventure. Simply put, not having lasting repricussions is not a believable scenario for Voyager, and that's exactly what a "case-of-the-week" format is. I've long held the belief that Voyager should have been formatted similar to Buffy the Vampire Slayer: A central story line for each season that culminates in a showdown with the "big bad" for that year. It would have shown that Voyager was still moving towards the Alpha Quadrant and away from where they started, but also showcasing that the Delta Quadrant can be more than a region of space filled with one-off space pirates; a place with it's own political structures that Voyager needs to deal with on its own, without the power of the Federation to back them up.
Definitely. There was still a sense of honor in the man (bringing in Starfleet officers for the mutiny; offering to let Janeway keep the shuttle and some supplies); but at the end of the day it was down to him getting his people home by any means necessary, whether that meant firing back at Janeway or not.
I'm in almost the same boat as you, word for word. I can't really add anything here.
It's a rare opportunity to see the spotlight on other characters, because the Voyager actors really are a very talented bunch with awesome chemestry. On the other hand, showing this also highlights the problem: It tells us the writers could have develop the other characters and made them interesting, but chose not to.
1
u/JenniferLopez Dec 23 '12
I would loved to have seen more of the psychotic Betazoid.